Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheLegendOfLizzieBorden

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' originally aired on {{Creator/ABC}} on February 10, 1975. Creator/FionnulaFlanagan plays Bridget, the Bordens' Irish maid. Creator/KatherineHelmond plays Lizzie's older sister Emma, who's got an ironclad alibi (being out of town). Creator/GloriaStuart of future ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' fame has a small role as a customer in a shop.

to:

''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' originally aired on {{Creator/ABC}} {{Creator/ABC|US}} on February 10, 1975. Creator/FionnulaFlanagan plays Bridget, the Bordens' Irish maid. Creator/KatherineHelmond plays Lizzie's older sister Emma, who's got an ironclad alibi (being out of town). Creator/GloriaStuart of future ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' fame has a small role as a customer in a shop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs out from the home of wealthy banker Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.

to:

The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs out from the home of wealthy banker Andrew Borden. A doctor next door neighbor arrives and finds him Borden dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's the bloodied corpse of Andrew Borden’s wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: John Morse, Lizzie and Emma’s maternal uncle who was visiting the Bordens at the time of the murders and was one of the early suspects, is omitted entirely in this dramatization. This is rather significant as it was his staying in the guest room was the reason why Abby went in there to clean up.

to:

* AdaptedOut: John Morse, Lizzie and Emma’s maternal uncle who was visiting the Bordens at the time of the murders and was one of the early suspects, is omitted entirely in this dramatization. This is rather significant as it was significant, since his staying in the guest room was bedroom the reason why night before is what prompted Abby went in there to clean up.the room that morning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' originally aired on {{Creator/ABC}} on February 10, 1975. Creator/FionnulaFlanagan plays Bridget, the Bordens' Irish maid. Creator/KatherineHelmond plays Lizzie's older sister Emma, who has an ironclad alibi, being out of town. Creator/GloriaStuart of future ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' fame has a small role as a customer in a shop.

to:

''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' originally aired on {{Creator/ABC}} on February 10, 1975. Creator/FionnulaFlanagan plays Bridget, the Bordens' Irish maid. Creator/KatherineHelmond plays Lizzie's older sister Emma, who has who's got an ironclad alibi, being alibi (being out of town.town). Creator/GloriaStuart of future ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' fame has a small role as a customer in a shop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BloodIsTheNewBlack: Due to Lizzie taking her clothes off beforehand and how brutally she hacked up her parents, she is covered in their blood head to toe.

Added: 180

Removed: 123

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BloodIsThicker: Emma lies on the stand in an effort to protect Lizzie, who is the only family she has left at this point.


Added DiffLines:

* PsychoStrings: Used when Lizzie kills her stepmother.


Added DiffLines:

* ThickerThanWater: Emma lies on the stand in an effort to protect Lizzie, who is the only family she has left at this point.

Added: 123

Changed: 114

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: John Morse, Lizzie and Emma’s maternal uncle who was visiting the Bordens at the time of the murders and was one of the early suspects, is omitted entirely in this dramatization.

to:

* AdaptedOut: John Morse, Lizzie and Emma’s maternal uncle who was visiting the Bordens at the time of the murders and was one of the early suspects, is omitted entirely in this dramatization. This is rather significant as it was his staying in the guest room was the reason why Abby went in there to clean up.


Added DiffLines:

* BloodIsThicker: Emma lies on the stand in an effort to protect Lizzie, who is the only family she has left at this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FlashbackWithinAFlashback: [[spoiler:The whole time that murders are shown it's within a flashback, while the the individual chops are intersped with more flashbacks to the various fights Lizzie had with her parents or even childhood memories.]]


Added DiffLines:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: [[spoiler: Lizzie is visibly upset after she murders her father, as opposed to her stepmother.]]

Added: 284

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CensorShadow: [[spoiler:When Lizzie undresses to kill her stepmother, she's covered with shadow when she reaches under her bed to grab the hatchet.]]



* EvilLaugh: [[spoiler:Lizzie giggles at the sight of her stepmother's corpse, right as Bridgette struggles to open the front door.]]



* ILoveTheDead: If Andrew Borden weren't profoundly creepy enough with the hinted incest with Lizzie, there's another scene that hints at this. Andrew, who once worked as a mortician, is shown pulling back a sheet and taking a long look at the face of a DropDeadGorgeous woman. He then pulls the sheet back over her face, and then ''feels her breasts through the sheet''. Lizzie watches all of this through a window. There is another scene where Andrew shows Lizzie a corpse and insists that Lizzie touch it, describing the flesh as "smooth" and "cool to the touch". This freaks Lizzie out.

to:

* ILoveTheDead: If Andrew Borden weren't profoundly creepy enough with the hinted incest with Lizzie, there's another scene that hints at this. Andrew, who once worked as a mortician, is shown pulling back a sheet and taking a long look at the face of a DropDeadGorgeous woman. He then pulls the sheet back over her face, and then ''feels her breasts through the sheet''. Lizzie watches all of this through a window. There is another scene where Andrew shows Lizzie a the corpse and insists that Lizzie touch it, describing the flesh as "smooth" and "cool to the touch". This freaks Lizzie out.

Added: 248

Removed: 254

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merged tropes


* ChristmasCake: Unlike other dramatizations that portray Lizzie as a PsychoLesbian, here she appears as a frustrated heterosexual woman who missed the narrow Victorian "marriage window" due to her father's stinginess and negative reputation around town.


Added DiffLines:

* OldMaid: Unlike other dramatizations that portray Lizzie as a PsychoLesbian, here she appears as a frustrated heterosexual woman who missed the narrow Victorian "marriage window" due to her father's stinginess and negative reputation around town.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BackfireOnTheWitnessStand: Hosea's case is already not going that well what with Lizzie's extremely incriminating testimony at the inquest having been ruled inadmissible. But things get worse when Hosea rushes an expert witness on the stand without vetting him, and the expert proceeds to testify that what minor bloodstains were found on Lizzie's clothes were "menstrual blood". Lizzie's acquittal follows soon after.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSuffragette: A group of suffragettes can be seen picketing the courthouse in support of Lizzie once the trial becomes nationwide media circus.

to:

* TheSuffragette: A group of suffragettes can be seen picketing the courthouse in support of Lizzie once the trial becomes a nationwide media circus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSuffragette: A group of suffragettes can be seen picketing the courthouse in support of Lizzie once the trial becomes nationwide MediaCircus.

to:

* TheSuffragette: A group of suffragettes can be seen picketing the courthouse in support of Lizzie once the trial becomes nationwide MediaCircus.media circus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheSuffragette: A group of suffragettes can be seen picketing the courthouse in support of Lizzie once the trial becomes nationwide MediaCircus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs from the home of wealthy banker Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.

to:

The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs out from the home of wealthy banker Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs from the home of wealthy townsman Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.

to:

The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs from the home of wealthy townsman banker Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Suspicion soon focuses on Lizzie (Montogomery), Andrew's daughter and Abby's stepdaughter, who was one of only two other people in the house at the time, the other being Bridget the maid. Lizzie is oddly calm and undisturbed, and details of her story don't match up. Soon, she is on trial for murder. But could a prim, well-bred upper-class lady really have taken a hatchet and chopped two people to death?

to:

Suspicion soon focuses on Lizzie (Montogomery), Andrew's daughter and Abby's stepdaughter, who was one of only two other people in the house at the time, the other being Bridget the maid. Lizzie is oddly calm and undisturbed, and details of her story don't match up. Soon, she is on trial for murder. But could a prim, well-bred well-bred, upper-class lady young woman really have taken a hatchet and chopped two people her parents to death?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs from the home of wealthy resident Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.

to:

The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts is shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs from the home of wealthy resident townsman Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' is a 1975 TV movie directed by Paul Wendkos. If there's a definitive screen version of the UsefulNotes/LizzieBorden story, it's probably this MadeForTVMovie from TheSeventies. [[LostInImitation It's certainly the one that subsequent versions are copying.]]

The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts, is ruined on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs out of the home of wealthy Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds Andrew dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.

Suspicion soon focuses on Andrew's daughter and Abby's stepdaughter Lizzie (Creator/ElizabethMontgomery, in a big PlayingAgainstType role just a few years after the end of her wholesome sitcom ''Series/{{Bewitched}}''). Lizzie was one of only two other people in the house at the time, the other being Bridget the maid. Lizzie is oddly calm and undisturbed, and details of her story don't match up. Soon, she is on trial for murder. But could a prim, well-bred upper-class lady really have taken a hatchet and chopped two people to death?

to:

''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' is a 1975 TV movie MadeForTVMovie directed by Paul Wendkos. Wendkos and starring Creator/ElizabethMontgomery (in a big PlayingAgainstType role, just a few years after the end of her wholesome sitcom ''Series/{{Bewitched}}''). If there's a definitive screen version of the UsefulNotes/LizzieBorden story, it's probably this MadeForTVMovie from TheSeventies.one. [[LostInImitation It's certainly the one that subsequent versions are copying.]]

]]

The peace of quiet Fall River, Massachusetts, Massachusetts is ruined shattered on August 4, 1892, when a panicked maid runs out of from the home of wealthy resident Andrew Borden. A doctor arrives and finds Andrew him dead, having been gruesomely murdered with a hatchet. People at the scene are still reeling from the shock of this when Andrew's wife Abby is also discovered upstairs, also dead, also killed with a hatchet.

Suspicion soon focuses on Lizzie (Montogomery), Andrew's daughter and Abby's stepdaughter Lizzie (Creator/ElizabethMontgomery, in a big PlayingAgainstType role just a few years after the end of her wholesome sitcom ''Series/{{Bewitched}}''). Lizzie stepdaughter, who was one of only two other people in the house at the time, the other being Bridget the maid. Lizzie is oddly calm and undisturbed, and details of her story don't match up. Soon, she is on trial for murder. But could a prim, well-bred upper-class lady really have taken a hatchet and chopped two people to death?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SympathyForTheDevil: Invoked by Sylvia Knowlton before the denouement when she admits she empathizes with Lizzie and understands what could potentially drive a woman like her to murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
murdering one's parents is not making an argument


* VillainHasAPoint: Invoked by Sylvia Knowlton before the denouement when she admits she empathizes with Lizzie and understands what could potentially drive a woman like her to murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' is a 1975 TV movie directed by Paul Moskos. If there's a definitive screen version of the UsefulNotes/LizzieBorden story, it's probably this MadeForTVMovie from TheSeventies. [[LostInImitation It's certainly the one that subsequent versions are copying.]]

to:

''The Legend of Lizzie Borden'' is a 1975 TV movie directed by Paul Moskos.Wendkos. If there's a definitive screen version of the UsefulNotes/LizzieBorden story, it's probably this MadeForTVMovie from TheSeventies. [[LostInImitation It's certainly the one that subsequent versions are copying.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GilliganCut: When Bridget testifies that she never saw any quarreling at the Borden household, it immediately cuts to a flashback of Bridget witnessing a particularly ugly argument between Lizzie, Andrew, and Abby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}}: Lizzie was seen burning a dress, but Hosea dismisses that, saying that Lizzie would not have been so stupid as to burn her blood-spattered murder dress in front of two witnesses and with a cop standing just outside an open door. But then he wonders, "What **did** she wear?" This film's answer was that [[FullFrontalAssault she was wearing nothing]].

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: Lizzie was seen burning a dress, but Hosea dismisses that, saying that Lizzie would not have been so stupid as to burn her blood-spattered murder dress in front of two witnesses and with a cop standing just outside an open door. But then he wonders, "What **did** ''did'' she wear?" This film's answer was that [[FullFrontalAssault she was wearing nothing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HiddenDepths: The frigid and repressed Lizzie Borden loves animals and cares deeply for her pet pigeons. This is a case of TruthInTelevision, as historical Lizzie Borden had several pets and later in life became an avid animal rights activist who helped establish the first animal humane society in Fall River and bequeathed most of her estate to a local animal shelter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: Elizabeth Montgomery's nipples are briefly visible during the scene where Lizzie chops her father up. One can only assume that ABC censors missed this, since there's no way in the world it would have been allowed under American network television standards either then or decades later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While in reality, Lizzie was acquitted of the murders and her guilt has never been definitively established, the film adds a fictionalized denouement that shows her actually killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet.

to:

** While in reality, reality Lizzie was acquitted of the murders and her guilt has never been definitively established, the film adds a fictionalized denouement that shows her actually killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
** While in reality, Lizzie was acquitted of the murders and her guilt has never been definitively established, the film adds a fictionalized denouement that shows her actually killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet.
** The film also portrays Lizzie having an extremely confrontational and antagonistic relationship with Abby Borden, while her sister Emma mostly acts passively towards her. According to historical record, it was the other way around.

Added: 538

Removed: 268

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There is nothing in the film that specifies this.


* InheritanceMurder: Although Lizzie had plenty of motive, what with her father's years of verbal and emotional abuse towards her, and the strongly implied sexual abuse, and her stepmother basically being a royal bitch, this is the immediate motive for the killings. Lizzie overhears a conversation in which Abby is strong-arming Andrew into making her the beneficiary of his will instead of his daughters. A furious Lizzie rages to her sister that she won't go begging to "that sow" and that Andrew can't be allowed to make a new will.



* PragmaticVillainy: [[spoiler: Lizzie decides to murder Abby first, because her property would automatically transfer to her husband Andrew immediately upon death. Thus, when she kills Andrew, she would also inherit Abby's estate along with her father's by default.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: Elizabeth Montgomery's nipples are briefly visible during the scene where Lizzie chops her father up. One can only assume that ABC censors missed this, since there's no way in the world it would have been allowed under American network television standards either then or decades later.

Top