Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheForeigner2017

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FromCamouflageToCriminal: Hennessy’s nephew Sean is a former Irish Ranger and Special Forces soldier who served two tours in Iraq. Now he’s an operative for the IRA.

Added: 2523

Changed: 1642

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Foreigner'' is an 2017 British-Chinese action thriller movie directed by Creator/MartinCampbell starring Creator/JackieChan in his first film to receive a wide Western release since ''Film/TheKarateKid2010''. This is based on the novel ''The Chinaman'', written by Stephen Leather, which was written in 1992.

to:

''The Foreigner'' is an 2017 British-Chinese action thriller movie directed by Creator/MartinCampbell starring Creator/JackieChan in his first film to receive a wide Western release since ''Film/TheKarateKid2010''. This is based on the novel ''The Chinaman'', written by Stephen Leather, Creator/StephenLeather, which was written in 1992.



* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene: While there is not quite a full-blown war, the film unflinchingly portrays morality ranging from grey to black on all three sides: TheProtagonist, and the two sides he is caught in the middle of. The trope example comes in when government forces torture a terrorist off-screen, and then--after getting the information they need--summarily execute that terrorist ''on'' screen.



* PinballProtagonist: Other than kicking ass, Quan doesn't really do much to impact the plot. Hennessy was already investigating the bombing before Quan got involved. Hennessy got the list of the bombers and sent it to the UK government before Quan even got the list himself. [[spoiler:And the London police were already about to interrogate and/or kill the bombers when Quan snuck in and did it himself. Quan didn't even find out anything about the laptop bomb.]] Arguably the only thing Quan did that impacted the plot was [[spoiler:taking pictures of Hennessy and his mistress and getting them posted online.]] But any consequences of that would be after the movie ends.

to:

* PinballProtagonist: PinballProtagonist:
**
Other than kicking ass, Quan doesn't really do much to impact the plot. Hennessy was already investigating the bombing before Quan got involved. Hennessy got the list of the bombers and sent it to the UK government before Quan even got the list himself. [[spoiler:And the London police were already about to interrogate and/or kill the bombers when Quan snuck in and did it himself. Quan didn't even find out anything about the laptop bomb.]] Arguably the only thing Quan did that impacted the plot was [[spoiler:taking pictures of Hennessy and his mistress and getting them posted online.]] But any consequences of that would be after the movie ends.



* PostCoitalCollapse: We hear a [[TheGruntingOrgasm a grunt]] as a man collapses into bed, sweaty and panting quickly followed by his lover Maggie. While he goes to the bathroom to clean up, she [[spoiler:quickly searches his room, revealing she is actually [[HoneyTrap a terrorist that seduced him]] for being a journalist that had info she needed to further a bombing plot.]]



** Quan is ex-special forces.

to:

** Quan is ex-special forces.forces that retired to be a restaurant owner... until his daughter is killed in a terrorist attack.



* SpeedSex: Maggie mocks her journalist lover for being a "three seconds wonder".



* ToplessnessFromTheBack: Maggie's bare back in seen when she gets out of bed, before she quickly throws a shirt on.



* TwoDecadesBehind: A ZigZaggingTrope. The film is set in 2017, yet Irish terrorists blowing up British streets haven't been an issue for over 20 years due to the peace accords signed in 1998 and the IRA disarming in 2005. The main reason is due to the fact that the novel the film is adapting, ''The Chinaman'', was originally published in 1992 when the Provisional IRA's bombing campaign was in full swing. Yet at the same time, the UK is facing massive security threats from Islamic terrorists, both foreign infiltrators and homegrown jihadists. At the time of the movie's release in October 2017, the UK had already suffered almost half a dozen major terrorist attacks that same year, including a bombing at an Music/ArianaGrande concert in Manchester that killed 22. The odd conclusion is that while the movie's politics and perpetrators are out of place, the overall plot is very current and applicable.

to:

* TwoDecadesBehind: TwoDecadesBehind:
**
A ZigZaggingTrope. The film is set in 2017, yet Irish terrorists blowing up British streets haven't been an issue for over 20 years due to the peace accords signed in 1998 and the IRA disarming in 2005. The main reason is due to the fact that the novel the film is adapting, ''The Chinaman'', was originally published in 1992 when the Provisional IRA's bombing campaign was in full swing. Yet at the same time, the UK is facing massive security threats from Islamic terrorists, both foreign infiltrators and homegrown jihadists. At the time of the movie's release in October 2017, the UK had already suffered almost half a dozen major terrorist attacks that same year, including a bombing at an Music/ArianaGrande concert in Manchester that killed 22. The odd conclusion is that while the movie's politics and perpetrators are out of place, the overall plot is very current and applicable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadassGrandpa: At age 63, Jackie is still quite a convincing ass kicker.
** Pierce Brosnan shares his age and his character has no trouble putting the hurt to people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotBloodSiblings: Sean is having an affair with his aunt Mary, his uncle Liam's wife.


Added DiffLines:

* RenegadeSplinterFaction: The Authentic IRA is a faction of the real-life IRA.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a trope, not sure if it's accurate to the trope itself tho.

Added DiffLines:

* OffscreenMomentofAwesome: [[spoiler: When the police begin to interrogate Maggie, she is absolutely defiant in giving them any information, going so far as to state that there's only "9 minutes left" (before the bomb went off). Cue the interrogator walking in with a car battery and a pair of clamps, which then cuts directly to a scene of him calling his superiors about the location of the bomb. Considering that the police were able to organize a search and isolate the bomb, the interrogator must have been able to extract the information ''within 5-6 minutes.'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StealthHiBye: Quan disappears suddenly when he is talking with Lam in his flat.

to:

* StealthHiBye: Quan disappears tells Lam that he decided to give her his restaurant. Lam tells him that she will stay with him tonight and sleep on the couch. When she turns around, Quan has suddenly when he is talking with Lam in his flat.disappeared.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StealthHiBye: Quan disappears suddenly when he is talking with Lam in his flat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Lampshaded in the movie: When the news reporters learn of the attack their editor immediately rattles off a list of Middle Eastern terrorist groups to look for rather than any IRA splinter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
correct trope name


* HandshakeConfusion: When Quan and Hennessy first meet, the former goes for a bow and the latter a handshake.

to:

* HandshakeConfusion: GreetingGestureConfusion: When Quan and Hennessy first meet, the former goes for a bow and the latter a handshake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* HandshakeConfusion: When Quan and Hennessy first meet, the former goes for a bow and the latter a handshake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: The rogue IRA and Maggie who caught a stray-bullet, tortured by the police and then executed as a loose end. Considering that she's the one responsible for bombing civilians which sets the plot in motion.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwoDecadesBehind: A ZigZaggingTrope. The film is set in 2017, yet Irish terrorists blowing up British streets haven't been an issue for over 20 years due to the peace accords signed in 1998 and the IRA disarming in 2005. The main reason is due to the fact that the novel the film is adapting, ''The Chinaman'', was originally published in 1992 when the Provisional IRA's bombing campaign was in full swing. Yet at the same time, the UK is facing massive security threats from Islamic terrorists, both foreign infiltrators and homegrown jihadists. At the time of the movie's release in October 2017, the UK had already suffered almost half a dozen major terrorist attacks that same year, including a bombing at an Creator/ArianaGrande concert in Manchester that killed 22. The odd conclusion is that while the movie's politics and perpetrators are out of place, the overall plot is very current and applicable.

to:

* TwoDecadesBehind: A ZigZaggingTrope. The film is set in 2017, yet Irish terrorists blowing up British streets haven't been an issue for over 20 years due to the peace accords signed in 1998 and the IRA disarming in 2005. The main reason is due to the fact that the novel the film is adapting, ''The Chinaman'', was originally published in 1992 when the Provisional IRA's bombing campaign was in full swing. Yet at the same time, the UK is facing massive security threats from Islamic terrorists, both foreign infiltrators and homegrown jihadists. At the time of the movie's release in October 2017, the UK had already suffered almost half a dozen major terrorist attacks that same year, including a bombing at an Creator/ArianaGrande Music/ArianaGrande concert in Manchester that killed 22. The odd conclusion is that while the movie's politics and perpetrators are out of place, the overall plot is very current and applicable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBad: The film doesn't have a dedicated central antagonist; the bombers are largely characterized as having the same level of authority, [[spoiler:Hennessy set the plan in motion but didn't intend for people to die]], and [[spoiler:Mary]] acts on a combination of LetNoCrisisGoToWaste and being a ManipulativeBastard. By the trope's definition as the one who instigates the plot, however, there's [[spoiler:Hugh]]. Though it wasn't his plan, he's the one that contributed the explosives, he organizes the bombers, and he was the one who took the plan off track to suit his own agenda (thus making an enemy of Quan).

to:

* BigBad: BigBadEnsemble: The film doesn't have a dedicated central antagonist; the bombers are largely characterized as having the same level of authority, [[spoiler:Hennessy set the plan in motion but didn't intend for people to die]], and [[spoiler:Mary]] acts on a combination of LetNoCrisisGoToWaste and being a ManipulativeBastard. By the trope's definition as the one who instigates the plot, however, there's [[spoiler:Hugh]]. Though it wasn't his plan, he's the one that contributed the explosives, he organizes the bombers, and he was the one who took the plan off track to suit his own agenda (thus making an enemy of Quan).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwfulWeddedLife: Liam and Mary Hennessy can't stand each other and apparently haven't been able to for years. [[spoiler:For good reason: Mary blames Liam for getting her IRA brother killed. Mary is eventually assassinated on Liam's orders after he finds out she betrayed him in multiple ways.]]
* BadassBoast: Duelling ones from Hennessy and Quan

to:

* AwfulWeddedLife: Liam and Mary Hennessy can't stand each other and apparently haven't been able to for years. [[spoiler:For good reason: Mary blames is angry at Liam for getting not having her IRA brother brother's murderers killed. Mary is eventually assassinated on Liam's orders after he finds out she betrayed him in multiple ways.]]
* BadassBoast: Duelling ones from Hennessy and QuanQuan.



* CultureClash: Quan offers twenty thousand pounds in cash to what appears to be a high ranking police officer for the names of the bombers only to be told: "That's not how we do things here."

to:

* CultureClash: Quan offers twenty thousand pounds in cash to what appears to be a high ranking high-ranking police officer for the names of the bombers bombers, only to be told: told "That's not how we do things here."



* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Quan is a former special forces soldier trained by the Americans who served in Vietnam. Liam's nephew Sean is former British Special Forces

to:

* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Quan is a former special forces soldier trained by the Americans who served in Vietnam. Liam's nephew Sean is former British Special ForcesForces and served in Iraq.



** When he infiltrates Hennessy's house Henessey finds his dog on the floor and accuses Quan of killing him. Quan says he only knocked him unconscious and sure enough the dog is up and fine in the next scene. [[spoiler: In the novel the movie was based on, [[SparedByTheAdaptation he did kill the dog.]]]]

to:

** When he infiltrates Hennessy's house Henessey finds his dog on the floor and accuses Quan of killing him. Quan says he he's only "sleeping" (drugged or knocked him unconscious unconscious) and sure enough the dog is up and fine in the next scene. [[spoiler: In the novel the movie was based on, [[SparedByTheAdaptation he did kill the dog.]]]]



** The British police officers who [[spoiler:arrest Maggie torture her for information on her group's latest bomb plot and then execute her in cold blood.]]

to:

** The British police officers who [[spoiler:arrest Maggie torture her for information on her group's latest bomb plot plot, and then execute her in cold blood.]]



* MistakenNationality: Everyone believes Quan is Chinese - he's South Vietnamese, and possibly half-Chinese, but it doesn't stop people from referring to him as "the Chinaman".

to:

* MistakenNationality: Everyone believes Quan is Chinese - he's South Vietnamese, and possibly half-Chinese, of an ethnic Chinese minority group, but it doesn't stop people from referring to him as "the Chinaman".



** Though Quan argues against Hennessy's comparison he does feel a similar connection to Sean when they fight. Sean gives him one of the hardest matches in the film [[spoiler:and the names of the bombers]] and after that he and Quan have a calm chat. Quan subtly notes the similarities between them, Sean was a soldier in Afghanistan serving the British whilst he himself was Irish much like how Quan was in Vietnam serving the Americans.

to:

** Though Quan argues against Hennessy's comparison comparison, he does feel a similar connection to Sean when they fight. Sean gives him one of the hardest matches in the film [[spoiler:and the names of the bombers]] bombers]], and after that he and Quan have a calm chat. Quan subtly notes the similarities between them, Sean was a soldier in Afghanistan Iraq serving with the British whilst he himself was Irish Irish, much like how Quan was in Vietnam Vietnamese serving the Americans.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted. Sean is the name of Hennessy's [[TheDragon Dragon]], and also one of his men. This is Ireland, of course, so the aversion is {{justified}}.
* PetTheDog: When Quan infiltrates Hennessy's farm the first time he assaults and knocks out 2 guards. He makes a point to check their pulse afterwards and when he leaves them tied up he keeps them out of range of the bomb he sets.
* PinballProtagonist: Other than kicking ass, Quan doesn't really do much to impact the plot. Hennessy was already investigating the bombing before Quan got involved. Hennessy got the list of the bombers and sent it to the UK government before Quan even got the list himself. [[spoiler:And the London police were already about the interrogate and/or kill the bombers when Quan snuck in and did it himself. Quan didn't even find out anything about the laptop bomb.]] Arguably the only thing Quan did that impacted the plot was [[spoiler:taking pictures of Hennessy and his mistress and getting them posted online.]] But any consequences of that would be after the movie ends.

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted. Sean is the name of Hennessy's [[TheDragon Dragon]], and also one of his men. This is Ireland, of course, so the aversion is {{justified}}.
[[JustifiedTrope justified]].
* PetTheDog: When Quan infiltrates Hennessy's farm the first time he assaults and knocks out 2 guards. He makes a point to check their pulse afterwards pulses afterwards, and when he leaves them tied up he keeps them out of range of the bomb he sets.
* PinballProtagonist: Other than kicking ass, Quan doesn't really do much to impact the plot. Hennessy was already investigating the bombing before Quan got involved. Hennessy got the list of the bombers and sent it to the UK government before Quan even got the list himself. [[spoiler:And the London police were already about the to interrogate and/or kill the bombers when Quan snuck in and did it himself. Quan didn't even find out anything about the laptop bomb.]] Arguably the only thing Quan did that impacted the plot was [[spoiler:taking pictures of Hennessy and his mistress and getting them posted online.]] But any consequences of that would be after the movie ends.



* RightHandVersusLeftHand: The police want to catch the terrorists. Liam wants to take care of them internally so that they don't

to:

* RightHandVersusLeftHand: The police want to catch the terrorists. Liam wants to take care of them internally so that they don't don't.



* WesternTerrorists: The terrorists are Irish.

to:

* WesternTerrorists: The terrorists are Irish.Irish, specifically IRA extremists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
mention that awesome cop at the end.

Added DiffLines:

* BadassBystander: A random, unnamed cop grabs the last bomb and sprints through an airport carrying it, knowing it's about to go off, throwing it down a jetbridge just in time. ''Badass''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Quan is a former special forces soldier trained by the Americans who served in Vietnam. Liam's cousin Sean is former British Special Forces

to:

* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Quan is a former special forces soldier trained by the Americans who served in Vietnam. Liam's cousin nephew Sean is former British Special Forces

Added: 419

Changed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: The movie is fairly faithful to the novel overall, but despite its grim tone it considerably lightens the [[DownerEnding book's ending]]. [[spoiler: Namely, in the novel, Quan's character dies before he gets his revenge and the terrorists actually succeed in bringing down the passenger jet, which motivates the government to assassinate various IRA figures including Hennessy and Sean.]]



** When he infiltrates Hennessy's house Henessey finds his dog on the floor and accuses Quan of killing him. Quan says he only knocked him unconscious and sure enough the dog is up and fine in the next scene.

to:

** When he infiltrates Hennessy's house Henessey finds his dog on the floor and accuses Quan of killing him. Quan says he only knocked him unconscious and sure enough the dog is up and fine in the next scene. [[spoiler: In the novel the movie was based on, [[SparedByTheAdaptation he did kill the dog.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OneSteveLimit: Averted. Sean is the name of Hennessy's [[TheDragon Dragon]], and also one of his men. This is Ireland, of course, so the aversion is {{justified}}).

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted. Sean is the name of Hennessy's [[TheDragon Dragon]], and also one of his men. This is Ireland, of course, so the aversion is {{justified}}).{{justified}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Someone correct me on which relative of Mary's was killed?


* AwfulWeddedLife: Liam and Mary Hennessy can't stand each other and apparently haven't been able to for years. [[spoiler:Mary is eventually assassinated on Liam's orders after he finds out she betrayed him in multiple ways.]]

to:

* AwfulWeddedLife: Liam and Mary Hennessy can't stand each other and apparently haven't been able to for years. [[spoiler:Mary [[spoiler:For good reason: Mary blames Liam for getting her IRA brother killed. Mary is eventually assassinated on Liam's orders after he finds out she betrayed him in multiple ways.]]

Added: 176

Changed: 188

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Quan's cause is just, but his methods are downright frightening.

to:

** Quan's cause is just, but his methods are downright frightening.involve bombing, maiming, and blackmailing those he believes responsible.



* MistakenNationality: Everyone believes Quan is Chinese - he's South Vietnamese, and possibly half-Chinese, but it doesn't stop people from referring to him as "the Chinaman".



* RightForTheWrongReasons: [[spoiler:At the end, Quan assumes that because he identified one of the bombers as Hennessy's mistress, he must have been behind the whole thing. As it turns out, Hennessy ''was'' the one who planned to use bombings to leverage pardons for his fellow IRA members out of the British government, he just never intended for them to target innocents. But even so, he had no idea who any of the bombers were, and his mistress got with him solely so that the extremists would be able to blackmail him if he turned on them.]]

to:

* RightForTheWrongReasons: [[spoiler:At the end, Quan assumes that because he identified one of the bombers as Hennessy's mistress, he must have been behind the whole thing. As it turns out, Hennessy ''was'' the one who planned to use bombings to leverage pardons for his fellow IRA members out of the British government, he just never intended for them to target innocents. innocents or do any real damage. But even so, he had no idea who any of the bombers were, were (he doesn't even suspect the guy he trusted with carrying out the original plan), and his mistress got with him solely so that the extremists would be able to blackmail him if he turned on them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigBad: The film doesn't have a dedicated central antagonist; the bombers are largely characterized as having the same level of authority, [[spoiler:Hennessy set the plan in motion but didn't intend for people to die]], and [[spoiler:Mary]] acts on a combination of LetNoCrisisGoToWaste and being a ManipulativeBastard. By the trope's definition as the one who instigates the plot, however, there's [[spoiler:Hugh]]. Though it wasn't his plan, he's the one that contributed the explosives, he organizes the bombers, and he was the one who took the plan off track to suit his own agenda (thus making an enemy of Quan).

Added: 653

Changed: 212

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NotSoDifferent: Both Quan and Hennessy have much in common. Both were fighters in a past war that resulted in the deaths of many of their loved ones, resulting in them doing whatever they can to keep their remaining family safe.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferent:
**
Both Quan and Hennessy have much in common. Both were fighters in a past war that resulted in the deaths of many of their loved ones, resulting in them doing whatever they can to keep their remaining family safe.safe.
** Though Quan argues against Hennessy's comparison he does feel a similar connection to Sean when they fight. Sean gives him one of the hardest matches in the film [[spoiler:and the names of the bombers]] and after that he and Quan have a calm chat. Quan subtly notes the similarities between them, Sean was a soldier in Afghanistan serving the British whilst he himself was Irish much like how Quan was in Vietnam serving the Americans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoDragons: Hennessy has two main enforcers. Sean, his main agent in the field and the one who's sent out to do his wet-work operations. Jim, his main enforcer within his local forces and his right hand. At different points in the film both are sent after Quan directly and tend to give him more of a fight than the other mooks.

to:

* CoDragons: Hennessy has two main enforcers.2nd in commands. Sean, his main agent in the field and the one who's sent out to do his wet-work operations. Jim, his main enforcer within his local forces and his right hand. At different points in the film both are sent after Quan directly and tend to give him more of a fight than the other mooks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CoDragons: Hennessy has two main enforcers. Sean, his main agent in the field and the one who's sent out to do his wet-work operations. Jim, his main enforcer within his local forces and his right hand. At different points in the film both are sent after Quan directly and tend to give him more of a fight than the other mooks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EveryoneHasStandards: A big reason that Quan stays an AntiHero rather than a full on VillainProtagonist.
** When harassing Hennessy Quan makes a point to pull his punches and takes his men down non-lethally. Sometimes they end up maimed, but they're explicitly said to have survived.
** When he infiltrates Hennessy's house Henessey finds his dog on the floor and accuses Quan of killing him. Quan says he only knocked him unconscious and sure enough the dog is up and fine in the next scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PetTheDog: When Quan infiltrates Hennessy's farm the first time he assaults and knocks out 2 guards. He makes a point to check their pulse afterwards and when he leaves them tied up he keeps them out of range of the bomb he sets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNationality: In the novel, the titular "China Man", Nguyen Ngoc Minh, is actually Vietnamese who gets mistaken for Chinese and has served with the Viet Cong before defecting to the US side. In the movie, Jackie's character, Ngoc Minh Quan, is [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoa_people Chinese Nuang]] who served with the US Special Forces during the Vietnam War.

to:

* AdaptationalNationality: In the novel, the titular "China Man", Nguyen Ngoc Minh, is actually Vietnamese who gets mistaken for Chinese and has served with the Viet Cong before defecting to the US side. In the movie, Jackie's character, Ngoc Minh Quan, is [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoa_people Chinese Nuang]] who served with the US Special Forces during the Vietnam War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OlderHeroVsYoungerVillain: The 60-year old Quan vs the Authentic IRA cell that is made up of terrorists in their 20's and 30's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Pierce Brosnan shares his age and his character has no trouble putting the hurt to people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Quan is a former special forces soldier trained by the Americans who served in Vietnam.

to:

* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Quan is a former special forces soldier trained by the Americans who served in Vietnam. Liam's cousin Sean is former British Special Forces

Top