Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / LostHorizon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNationality: Father Perrault was from Luxembourg in the novel but it's changed to Belgium here. Also the novel's Lo-Tsen, who's Chinese, becomes the film's Maria, who's Russian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptedOut: Miss Brinklow, a Christian missionary, is a member of the group who goes to Shangri-La in the book but doesn't appear here. Ross Hunter reportedly wanted to reinstate the character for the 1973 version with Creator/BarbaraStanwyck in the role, but she said no, so Brinklow didn't appear there either.


Added DiffLines:

* CanonForeigner: Lovett, Gloria and Sondra aren't in the book.


Added DiffLines:

* RelatedInTheAdaptation: Conway's aide Mallinson from the book becomes his brother George here.


Added DiffLines:

* SecondaryAdaptation: While it's officially credited as an adaptation of the novel, it's self-evidently a musical remake of the 1937 film, right down to importing the [[CanonForeigner Canon Foreigners]] from there.

Changed: 100

Removed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UsefulNotes/TheBechdelTest: A rare instance of a film passing because of a musical sequence ("The Things I Will Not Miss").



* DuetOfDifferences: "The Things I Will Not Miss" crosses this trope with IWantSong for Sally and Maria, who agree to disagree about what they want out of life. The chorus even features the phrase "Different people look at life from different points of view".

to:

* DuetOfDifferences: "The Things I Will Not Miss" crosses this trope with IWantSong for Sally and Maria, who agree to disagree about what they want out of life. The chorus even features the phrase "Different people look at life from different points of view". Interestingly, the film passes UsefulNotes/TheBechdelTest because of this song.



* MoodWhiplash: Basically the film's main problem, as we'll go from a scene that's an okay (if a bit slavish) modernization of the original film, then without much warning into a musical number patterned after ''Film/TheSoundOfMusic'' or ''{{Theatre/Camelot}}'', totally breaking up the film's flow.

to:

* MoodWhiplash: Basically the film's main problem, as we'll go from a scene that's an okay (if a bit slavish) modernization of the original film, then without much warning into a musical number patterned after ''Film/TheSoundOfMusic'' or ''{{Theatre/Camelot}}'', ''Theatre/TheKingAndI'', totally breaking up the film's flow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UsefulNotes/TheBechdelTest: A rare instance of a film passing because of a musical sequence ("The Things I Will Not Miss").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllMusicalsAreAdaptations

to:

* AllMusicalsAreAdaptationsAllMusicalsAreAdaptations: In fact, the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shangri-La_(musical) second attempt]] at a ''Lost Horizon'' musical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoodWhiplash: Basically the film's main problem, as we'll go from a scene that's an okay (if a bit slavish) modernization of the original film, then without much warning into a musical number patterned after ''Film/TheSoundOfMusic'' or ''{{Theatre/Camelot}}'', totally breaking up the film's flow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShotForShotRemake: The first half-hour is tight re-enactment of the opening scenes of the Capra film, right down to the way some specific shots are framed. Even after they get to Shangri-La and the musical numbers start up, it still doesn't stray all that much from the original.

to:

* ShotForShotRemake: The first half-hour is a tight re-enactment of the opening scenes of the Capra film, right down to the way some specific shots are framed. Even after they get to Shangri-La and the musical numbers start up, it still doesn't stray all that much from the original.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShotForShotRemake: The first half-hour is tight re-enactment of the opening scenes of the Capra film, right down to the way some specific shots are framed. Even after they get to Shangri-La and the musical numbers start up, it still doesn't stray all that much from the original.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeterosexualLifePartners: Lovett and Barnard don't even know each other at the start of the film but quickly become VitriolicBestBuds and seem well on their way to becoming this.


Added DiffLines:

* IceCreamKoan: Surprisingly averts this. The High Lama is philosophical but straightforward in his way of expressing things. Chang is very cagey but that's mainly because he knows that it takes a while for everyone to understand what's happening in Shangri-La.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by Creator/FrankCapra, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''Film/GoodbyeMrChips'' fame).

to:

''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by Creator/FrankCapra, starring Creator/RonaldColman, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''Film/GoodbyeMrChips'' fame).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HairTriggerAvalanche: Both versions have this in the final stretch as Richard, George and Maria try to return to TheOutsideWorld.
** In the 1937 film, it is caused by the porters playfully fooling around with the brothers' guns and shooting them off.
** In the 1973 film, because they're busy helping Maria, who is too weak to walk (in hindsight, she's RapidAging) the brothers fall behind the porters and call out to them to stop. ''Oops.''



----

to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DuetOfDifferences: "The Things I Will Not Miss" crosses this trope with IWantSong for Sally and Maria, who agree to disagree about what they want out of life. The chorus even features the phrase "Different people look at life from different points of view".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GrassIsGreener: Inverted for Maria, who wants to leave peaceful, contented, simple Shangri-La for the glamorous, exciting [[TheOutsideWorld outside world]] (this is thanks in part to her conversations with George). Sally warns her that though there are some nice things out there, there's also war, corruption, etc.; this leads into "The Things I Will Not Miss".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DarkAndTroubledPast: Sam isn't upfront about who he is to his fellow travelers. After some time in Shangri-La he admits to Sally that he was, once, a notorious corporate bigwig whose business dealings eventually collapsed around him. He's spent his life as a fugitive since his downfall, no longer having any purpose in his life except perhaps rebuilding his fortune. With Sally's encouragement and love, however, he turns his original talent for engineering towards improving life for the people of Shangri-La (he designs an irrigation system for their crops), and finds true fulfillment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrowdSong: Several -- "The World Is a Circle", "Living Together, Growing Together", and "Question Me an Answer" once the kids join in.

Added: 199

Changed: 5

Removed: 248

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doesn\'t quite fit the trope


* MusicalWorldHypotheses: Mostly Alternate Universe. Not counting the TitleThemeTune performed by an offscreen singer, there are no musical numbers in the opening and closing stretches of the film, which are set in TheOutsideWorld. Only in Shangri-La do characters sing. There are two Diegetic numbers in Shangri-La, "Share the Joy" and "Living Together, Growing Together".

to:

* MusicalWorldHypotheses: Mostly Alternate Universe. Not counting the TitleThemeTune performed by an offscreen singer, there are no musical numbers in the opening and closing stretches of the film, which are set in TheOutsideWorld. Only in Shangri-La do characters sing. There are also two Diegetic numbers in Shangri-La, "Share the Joy" and "Living Together, Growing Together".Together".
* PluckyComicRelief: Harry, an unsuccessful nightclub entertainer, serves as this among the five travelers. His happy ending is finding a receptive audience for his hijinks in Shangri-La's children.



* WorthlessYellowRocks: There's gold in the streams of Shangri-La that's gone long untouched because it's valueless to the residents. Sam considers taking it for himself and leaving Shangri-La, but the now-enlightened Sally convinces him otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BetaCouple: Sam and Sally have a much easier time falling and being in love than Richard and Catherine -- while the former couple is content to stay in Shangri-La forever, Richard keeps being urged by his brother to leave, which would mean leaving Catherine behind.


Added DiffLines:

* InterruptedSuicide: Sally (this film's equivalent to Gloria) is a depressed, drug-addicted journalist whose state of mind is not improved by the events of the first act. As everyone is settling into Shangri-La, she reaches a DespairEventHorizon and prepares to jump out of a window into the chasm below, only to be interrupted by Chang, who talks her down. With the lamas' help, she gradually gets better from here.


Added DiffLines:

* WorthlessYellowRocks: There's gold in the streams of Shangri-La that's gone long untouched because it's valueless to the residents. Sam considers taking it for himself and leaving Shangri-La, but the now-enlightened Sally convinces him otherwise.

Added: 427

Changed: 75

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Passengers aboard a small airplane discover that they have been kidnapped by someone posing as their assigned pilot. The plane crashes in the Himalayan mountain range along the border of China. The dying pilot's last words indicate there is a lamasery near by at Shangi-La and they will find help there. The passengers go to the lamasery and uncover a mystery.

to:

Passengers aboard a small airplane discover that they have been kidnapped by someone posing as their assigned pilot. The plane crashes in the Himalayan mountain range along the border of China. The dying pilot's last words indicate there is a lamasery near by at Shangi-La Shangri-La and they will find help there. The passengers go to the lamasery and uncover a mystery.



When the negative was restored in TheSeventies, it was decayed so badly that [[DeletedScene seven minutes could not be salvaged]]. However, an intact soundtrack was found. The film as it exists today uses still pictures along with dialogue to illustrated those extra seven minutes.

to:

When the negative of the 1937 film was restored in TheSeventies, it was decayed so badly that [[DeletedScene seven minutes could not be salvaged]]. However, an intact soundtrack was found. The film as it exists today uses still pictures along with dialogue to illustrated illustrate those extra seven minutes.



* TheOutsideWorld: Shangri La is hidden from the rest of the world in the Himalayan mountains. Visitors can come and go (though due to its location very few visit) but natives face a terrible price for leaving.

to:

* TheOutsideWorld: Shangri La Shangri-La is hidden from the rest of the world in the Himalayan mountains. Visitors can come and go (though due to its location very few visit) but natives face a terrible price for leaving.



* StockFootage: The 1937 film borrowed a few shots of snowy mountain peaks from a documentary to make it more realistic.

to:

* StockFootage: The 1937 film borrowed a A few shots of snowy mountain peaks from a documentary were used to make it this film more realistic.



* IWantSong: "The Things I Will Not Miss". Sally wants to stay in Shangri-La while Maria wants to see TheOutsideWorld; each is tired of the very things the other wants.



* SettingUpdate: To TheSeventies, which was ThePresentDay at the time. One of the problems that critics had with this version was that merely updating the setting only emphasized ValuesDissonance (such as the MightyWhitey nature of Shangri-La's leadership).



* WelcomeSong: "Share the Joy", the first in-story musical number.

to:

* WelcomeSong: WelcomingSong: "Share the Joy", the first in-story musical number.

Added: 643

Changed: 137

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

** In the 1973 film, Chang is played by another Brit, Sir John Gielgud. (The producer wanted Toshiro Mifune, but he turned it down.)

!!The 1973 film adds the following tropes:
* AllMusicalsAreAdaptations
* BookEnds: The TitleThemeTune opens and closes the film.
* MusicalWorldHypotheses: Mostly Alternate Universe. Not counting the TitleThemeTune performed by an offscreen singer, there are no musical numbers in the opening and closing stretches of the film, which are set in TheOutsideWorld. Only in Shangri-La do characters sing. There are two Diegetic numbers in Shangri-La, "Share the Joy" and "Living Together, Growing Together".
* TitleThemeTune: The only song in the film's opening quarter, to boot.
* WelcomeSong: "Share the Joy", the first in-story musical number.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Using an ampersand instead of the word \"and\" outside titles or direct quotes just looks lazy.


* TheOutsideWorld: Shangri La is hidden from the rest of the world in the Himalayan mountains. Visitors can come & go (though due to its location very few visit) but natives face a terrible price for leaving.

to:

* TheOutsideWorld: Shangri La is hidden from the rest of the world in the Himalayan mountains. Visitors can come & and go (though due to its location very few visit) but natives face a terrible price for leaving.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Shamgri La is now The Shangri La. Bad examples are being removed, and \"fake\" examples being reported.


* ShamgriLa: Shangri-La fits the description perfectly, a mysterious yet idyllic village nestled in the Himalayas tended to by people who have cast off the stresses and strains of the world beyond, accessible only with the help of insiders.

to:

* ShamgriLa: TheShangriLa: Shangri-La fits the description perfectly, a mysterious yet idyllic village nestled in the Himalayas tended to by people who have cast off the stresses and strains of the world beyond, accessible only with the help of insiders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheOutsideWorld: Shangri La is hidden from the rest of the world in the Himalayan mountains. Visitors can come & go (though due to its location very few visit) but natives face a terrible price for leaving.

Added: 283

Removed: 479

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When the negative was restored in TheSeventies, it was decayed so badly that [[DeletedScene seven minutes could not be salvaged]]. However, an intact soundtrack was found. The film as it exists today uses still pictures along with dialogue to illustrated those extra seven minutes.



* DevelopmentHell: More like post-production Hell - the production went swimmingly but it turned out to be six hours long. Eventually it was cut down to feature-length after several test screenings.



* MissingEpisode: The film had a running time of 132 minutes in its first release. When restored in 1973, only 125 minutes of film could be found, but they did have the entire soundtrack. The restored version shows publicity photos and stills in place of the missing film elements.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MightyWhitey: Featuring a modern MightyWhitey in the 1930s, when the old-fashioned version was still in vogue. The mostly Chinese and Tibetan monks there prove themselves to be wise, intelligent, competent, and well-rounded characters. However, the white Conway turns out to be better at being a monk than the best of the Tibetans, and it turns out that [[spoiler:the founder and leader of the monastery is a European who arrived in the 15th century]].

to:

* MightyWhitey: Featuring a modern MightyWhitey in the 1930s, when the old-fashioned version was still in vogue. The mostly Chinese and Tibetan monks there prove themselves to be wise, intelligent, competent, and well-rounded characters. However, the white Conway turns out to be better at being a monk than the best of the Tibetans, and it turns out that [[spoiler:the the founder and leader of the monastery is a European who arrived in the 15th century]].century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IncurableCoughOfDeath: Subverted, in that Gloria's incurable cough of death actually is cured by the magic of Shangri-La.
* LostWorld: The high mountains all around mean that no one ever goes to Shangri-La except the porters that visit once every few years.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Skinnydipping}}: Including a rather daring scene for 1937, in which Jane Wyatt's body double actually leaves the pool while nude. Shot from a considerable distance away, but still.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Yellowface}}: The very British H.B. Warner plays Chang, the #2 man at Shangri-La.

Added: 717

Changed: 42

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DespairEventHorizon: George charges over it after seeing Maria age half a century and die in a matter of hours after leaving Shangri-La, and runs headlong over a cliff to his death.
* {{Determinator}}: When Conway is rescued, he is absolutely determined to return to Shangri-La, and in the film's pentultimate scene, Lord Gainsford tells the members of the Embassy Club in London the stories he has heard of Conway learning to fly and stealing an Army plane, making six attempts to cross a supposedly uncrossable mountain pass, fighting off six guards to escape from a Tibetan jail after being imprisoned for stealing food and clothing, and leading the local military on a wild goose chase through their own country.



* RapidAging: Implied to happen to Maria when the Conway brothers take her with them as they attempt to return to the outside world. As they trek through the mountains after their porters have been buried in an avalanche, a horrified George screams, "Bob! Bob, look at her face!", and we see a lifeless, wrinkled old woman's face.

to:

* RapidAging: Implied to happen Happens to Maria when the Conway brothers take her with them as they attempt to return to the outside world. As they trek through the mountains after their porters have been buried in an avalanche, a horrified George screams, "Bob! Bob, look at her face! Her face, look at her face!", and we see a lifeless, wrinkled old woman's face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Also removing redundant pothole.


''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by Creator/FrankCapra, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''[[Film/GoodbyeMrChips Goodbye, Mr. Chips]]'' fame).

to:

''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by Creator/FrankCapra, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''[[Film/GoodbyeMrChips Goodbye, Mr. Chips]]'' ''Film/GoodbyeMrChips'' fame).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Some of these entries use the characters\' names from the book, not the film. Also fleshing out Zero Context Examples.


* TheChosenOne: Conway was specially selected to go to Shangri-La, and the other passengers were considered wonderful, accidental additions to the lamasery who all (excepting Mallinson) found reasons to be happy there.

to:

* TheChosenOne: Conway was specially selected to go to Shangri-La, and the other passengers were considered wonderful, accidental additions to the lamasery who all (excepting Mallinson) Conway's brother George) found reasons to be happy there.



* HiddenElfVillage: Shangri-La
* HurtingHero: Conway the protagonist
* MacGuffinLocation

to:

* HiddenElfVillage: Shangri-La
The people of Shangri-La are not exactly disdainful of the outside world, but their attitude can rather succinctly be summed up as smiling, shaking their heads, and saying, "What silly people."
* HurtingHero: Robert Conway, though he is professionally successful, admits to feeling a great emptiness in his life, and the fact that this comes through in his writing is what leads the higher-ups at Shangri-La to bring him there.
* MacGuffinLocation: Shangri-La may be the setting of most of the film and the ultimate goal of most of the characters, especially Conway, but the film is more about how Shangri-La affects the characters (such as Gloria recovering from her tuberculosis, Lovett learning to relax and enjoy himself, and especially
Conway finding a sense of purpose in life) than about the protagonist
* MacGuffinLocation
place itself.



* NoImmortalInertia
* RapidAging: [[spoiler:This may be Lo-Tsen's fate.]]
* ShamgriLa

to:

* NoImmortalInertia
NoImmortalInertia: The inhabitants of Shangri-La do age, but much more slowly there than they would do in the outside world. As Maria demonstrates, if they leave the village, they quickly advance to the age they would be if they had never been to Shangri-La.
* RapidAging: [[spoiler:This may be Lo-Tsen's fate.]]
Implied to happen to Maria when the Conway brothers take her with them as they attempt to return to the outside world. As they trek through the mountains after their porters have been buried in an avalanche, a horrified George screams, "Bob! Bob, look at her face!", and we see a lifeless, wrinkled old woman's face.
* ShamgriLaShamgriLa: Shangri-La fits the description perfectly, a mysterious yet idyllic village nestled in the Himalayas tended to by people who have cast off the stresses and strains of the world beyond, accessible only with the help of insiders.



* {{Utopia}}: Shangri-La

to:

* {{Utopia}}: Shangri-LaShangri-La. Through moderation in all things moral and material, the inhabitants are all (with one or two exceptions), to quote Chang, "more than moderately happy."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by FrankCapra, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''GoodbyeMrChips'' fame).

to:

''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by FrankCapra, Creator/FrankCapra, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''GoodbyeMrChips'' ''[[Film/GoodbyeMrChips Goodbye, Mr. Chips]]'' fame).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:280:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Lost_Horizon_1124.png]]

''Lost Horizon'' is a 1937 film by FrankCapra, based on [[Literature/LostHorizon the novel of the same name]] by British author James Hilton (of ''GoodbyeMrChips'' fame).

Passengers aboard a small airplane discover that they have been kidnapped by someone posing as their assigned pilot. The plane crashes in the Himalayan mountain range along the border of China. The dying pilot's last words indicate there is a lamasery near by at Shangi-La and they will find help there. The passengers go to the lamasery and uncover a mystery.

The novel was filmed again in 1973 as a spectacular star-studded musical flop.

!!The 1937 film provides examples of:

* AgeWithoutYouth: Averted - you live long and age proportionately in Shangri-La.
* TheChosenOne: Conway was specially selected to go to Shangri-La, and the other passengers were considered wonderful, accidental additions to the lamasery who all (excepting Mallinson) found reasons to be happy there.
* DevelopmentHell: More like post-production Hell - the production went swimmingly but it turned out to be six hours long. Eventually it was cut down to feature-length after several test screenings.
* HiddenElfVillage: Shangri-La
* HurtingHero: Conway the protagonist
* MacGuffinLocation
* MightyWhitey: Featuring a modern MightyWhitey in the 1930s, when the old-fashioned version was still in vogue. The mostly Chinese and Tibetan monks there prove themselves to be wise, intelligent, competent, and well-rounded characters. However, the white Conway turns out to be better at being a monk than the best of the Tibetans, and it turns out that [[spoiler:the founder and leader of the monastery is a European who arrived in the 15th century]].
* MissingEpisode: The film had a running time of 132 minutes in its first release. When restored in 1973, only 125 minutes of film could be found, but they did have the entire soundtrack. The restored version shows publicity photos and stills in place of the missing film elements.
* NoImmortalInertia
* RapidAging: [[spoiler:This may be Lo-Tsen's fate.]]
* ShamgriLa
* StockFootage: The 1937 film borrowed a few shots of snowy mountain peaks from a documentary to make it more realistic.
* {{Utopia}}: Shangri-La
----

Top