Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Circle

Go To

OR

Added: 549

Changed: 769

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Despite being critical to the main thrust of the plot, the Little Girl barely says anything throughout the film and mostly just cries, because she's ten years old and in a terrifying situation.
** All the bigoted rants that end up getting people killed. People crack under pressure, and tend to lash out against those who they see as inferior. That's also the reason they don't start early on, but after the game have been going on for a bit and there is a lack of easy target. Similarly, while not bigoted, the atheist end up in a similar situation when the pressure leads him to slip an unfortunate choice of word, and is sadly killed before he can correct himself (unless, as speculated, he was looking to die out of guilt).

to:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome:
**
Despite being critical to the main thrust of the plot, the Little Girl barely says anything throughout the film and mostly just cries, because she's ten years old and in a terrifying situation.
** All the bigoted rants that end up getting people killed. People crack under pressure, and tend to lash out against those who they see as inferior. That's also the reason they don't start early on, but after the game have has been going on for a bit and there is a lack of easy target. Similarly, while not bigoted, the atheist end ends up in a similar situation when the pressure leads him to slip an unfortunate choice of word, and is sadly killed before he can correct himself (unless, as speculated, [[DeathSeeker he was looking to die out of guilt).guilt]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** With just two minutes between each death, there is no time for a group to organize a cohesive strategy, particularly not one started later in the game. [[spoiler: The Fake Husband and Fake Wife's plan works because they decide it early on, while they are still calm, and doesn't require them to do anything, while Eric and the Bearded Guy manipulate others but elaborate a secret strategy themselves, making them more effective than the other members of either group, with Eric coming out on top due to his better observation skills.]]

Added: 2651

Changed: 469

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: Ends up being the undoing of the pragmatist group: they have a common goal in general, but not a real strategy or ranks, leading to their demise. Also, while the group is focused on the fact that eliminating the Kid and Pregnant Woman gives all of them a chance, only the Bearded Guy thinks further ahead realizing that still only ''one'' of them can make it, and are caught out of guard when they end up being sacrificed for that goal.
** Ironically, while being the cleverer of the group, the Bearded Guy is the one that falls for it the most: he assumes the votes in his favor without actually counting them, and when Eric suddenly reveals himself willing to go along with his plan he sees it as a victory, not considering Eric might have a plan of his own. [[spoiler: This first leads to his whole group being wiped out, but after that he trusts Eric ''again'', this time leading to his own demise.]]



** When everyone tries to vote for themselves to force a universal tie, one unnamed survivor secretly switches his vote to the Young Pregnant Lady in an attempt to eliminate her. Eric notices this and switches his own vote. In the subsequent runoff everyone votes to save the Young Pregnant Lady, eliminating the other survivor.

to:

** The Bearded Guy cheers after four people are eliminated, even if two were members of his faction, since lower numbers means less people to control. [[spoiler: This inspires Eric to offer a trade, knowing that the Bearded Guy will jump at the chance, using it as a trap to kill the Fake Wife.]]
** When everyone tries to vote for themselves to force a universal tie, one unnamed survivor secretly switches his vote to the Young Pregnant Lady in an attempt to eliminate her. Eric notices this and switches his own vote. In the the subsequent runoff everyone votes to save the Young Pregnant Lady, eliminating the other survivor.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: All the members of the pragmatism group end up eliminated for pragmatic reasons. [[spoiler: In their defense, though, this is also due to Eric being actually the craftiest and most pragmatic of them all.]]
** The Rich Banker makes himself hated by the majority before revealing his reasons, ending up in a tie with one of the people he wanted to eliminate. It's also very likely that the Bearded Guy saw it as the chance to take control of the group.
** The Black Guy is killed by the opposing faction when they realize he is the easy one to identify, and they can vote all against him too fast for the other group to counteract that.
** The Lesbian and the Pretty Girl end up in a tie with the Soldier and Cancer Survivor Lady. Rather than try to save one of them and risk the survival of either Soldier and Cancer Survivor Lady, the Wife and Bearded Guy let them die to cull the number of both groups, thinking it will turn the tide to their advantage.
** The Wife is quickly given up when Eric offers the Bearded Guy the chance to sacrifice her, but also kill the Pregnant Lady. [[spoiler: It also ends up being for nothing, since thanks to Eric's plan the Pregnant Lady survives anyway.]]
** Lastly, the Bearded Guy is disposed of [[spoiler: since both Eric and the Pregnant Lady realize they have the majority, and he is more dangerous to keep around than the Silent Man.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** All the bigoted rants that end up getting people killed. People crack under pressure, and tend to lash out against those who they see as inferior. That's also the reason they don't start early on, but after the game have been going on for a bit and there is a lack of easy target. Similarly, while not bigoted, the atheist end up in a similar situation when the pressure leads him to slip an unfortunate choice of word, and is sadly killed before he can correct himself (unless, as speculated, he was looking to die out of guilt).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RuleOfDrama: It's established that if votes are tied, a run-off results, while if no one votes, the machine selects a person randomly. [[spoiler:Therefore, when it's down to just Eric and the Pregnant Woman's unborn child, one of them should have simply been picked right away without a tie resulting since neither of them voted, but this would have removed the dramatic impact of The Reveal.]] This may be a special rule to prevent [[spoiler:the final two people abstaining from voting and leaving it entirely to chance. It's 50-50 by that point.]]

to:

* RuleOfDrama: It's established that if votes are tied, a run-off results, while if no one votes, the machine selects a person randomly. [[spoiler:Therefore, when it's down to just Eric and the Pregnant Woman's unborn child, one of them should have simply been picked right away without a tie resulting since neither of them voted, but this would have removed the dramatic impact of The Reveal.]] This may be The baby itself also never counted as a special rule to prevent [[spoiler:the final two people abstaining from voting and leaving it entirely to chance. It's 50-50 by player up until that point.]] Then again, all the "rules" of the game are deduced as event unfolds, but never stated, nor is ever actually stated that there are rules being followed. As one of the characters points out, after all, the very situation they find themselves in is intrinsically unfair. [[spoiler: It's entirely possible that the aliens changed the rules to invoke that trope.]]

Added: 740

Changed: 463

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DevelopersForesight: In-universe, the creators of the elimination game planned for every contingency. Try to leave? You die. No one votes? A random person is killed. The vote is tied? Everyone in the tie dies unless someone changes their vote.

to:

* DevelopersForesight: In-universe, the creators of the elimination game planned for every contingency. Try to leave? You die. No one votes? A random person is killed. The vote is tied? Everyone in the tie dies unless someone changes their vote. Of course, this is assuming the game is fully automated, they might actually just be watching and adapting on the fly to ensure the deaths. After all, no actual rule is ever officially presented, they are only deduced by the context, and we actually see them being changed in at least one occasion [[spoiler:((when the unborn child is suddenly treated as another player at the end, something that wouldn't have worked with the votes and ties previously shown)]].


Added DiffLines:

** Actually averted, however: purely heroic characters are shown sacrificing themselves for others, some of them are never actually seen voting, and one is acknowledged never having voted at all, and some people are shown with loving bonds not broken even in that situation. The ending shows the circle we followed to have been mostly an exception, with pregnant women and children being more often than not chose as the survivor, and even in the titular circle the first attempts are to find a way for everyone to live, only starting turning on each other once all methods are proven ineffective.


Added DiffLines:

** When the people force the two lovers in a tie, they decide to go both together rather than one being responsible for the death of the other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The most noticeable example would be bad: she is agreeable enough to start telling her life's story, which seems fine, though there is nothing impressive. And then she is killed because ''the others didn't find that story justified keeping her alive''. Mind you, she is killed before openly racist or bigoted characters, or others actively antagonizing the characters, and isn't even killed because of something she did or to some calculation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAesop: The moral about humanity turning on itself is compromised by the fact that the situation is rigged in the first. Starting from how the people aren't even aware of the rules and of what's going on (several characters are killed at the very beginning completely by chance). The group actually tries several ways to ensure the survival of everyone, or not to kill people, but all methods actually get shut down. When an all-powerful force kills people one by one no matter what, the greatest threat is said all-powerful force, not the nature of humanity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Rich Banker also advocated how his side was about treating other people "equally", yet he finds very filmsy pretenses to consider some people being worth less than others and deserving to be killed.


Added DiffLines:

** On a similar not, the Black Man might be rude about it, but several of the characters there express racists or general bigoted reasoning to deem people "unworthy", so he had a reason to look out for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Rude Atheist claims that the Attractive Blonde Woman next to him is actually an ex-pornstar, which she denies. It's probably an intentional ploy by the Rude Atheist to be as much of a {{Jerkass}} as possible to get voted out, but we don't find out if he was outright lying. She might have been and just [[OldShame didn't want to be associated with her past career]], or he was just making it up from whole cloth.

to:

** The Rude Atheist claims that the Attractive Blonde Woman next to him is actually an ex-pornstar, which she denies. It's probably an intentional ploy by the Rude Atheist to be as much of a {{Jerkass}} as possible to get voted out, but we don't find out if he was outright lying. She might have been and just [[OldShame didn't want to be associated with her past career]], or (probably wisely, if that's the case) didn't want to risk exposing herself to social stigma cosnidering the triviality of the reasons that lead to some of the victims being chosen. Or maybe he was just making it up from whole cloth.cloth. It's even possible he just mistook her for someone who looked like her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
index wick removal


* AcceptableTargets: [[invoked]] Deconstructed. Choosing based on ethnic stereotypes, class divisions or any other divisive topic gets innocent (and not-so-innocent) people killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The script for ''Circle'' was reportedly inspired by ''Film/TwelveAngryMen''. Another film many have compared this film to is ''Film/{{Cube}}''; to that end, a producer on the film stated that in comparison, ''Circle'' provides more answers and has a more definitive ending.

to:

The script for ''Circle'' was reportedly inspired by ''Film/TwelveAngryMen''. Another It has also fielded many comparisons to the film many have compared this film to is ''Film/{{Cube}}''; to that end, a producer on the film stated that in comparison, ''Circle'' stated that in comparison, this film provides more answers and has a more definitive ending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


The script for ''Circle'' was reportedly inspired by ''Film/TwelveAngryMen''. Another film many have compared this film to is ''Film/{{Cube}}''; to that end, a producer on the film stated that in comparison, ''Circle'' provides more answers and has a more definitive ending.

The film premiered at the Seattle International Film Festival on May 28, 2015, and was later released on video-on-demand on October 16.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambig redirect


Not to be confused with works titled ''TheCircle''.

Added: 492

Changed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: [[invoked]] Deconstructed. Choosing based on ethnic stereotypes or class divisions or any other divisive topic gets innocent (and not-so-innocent) people killed.
* AnAesop: The greatest danger to humanity, is [[HisOwnWorstEnemy itself.]]

to:

* AcceptableTargets: [[invoked]] Deconstructed. Choosing based on ethnic stereotypes or stereotypes, class divisions or any other divisive topic gets innocent (and not-so-innocent) people killed.
* AnAesop: The greatest danger to humanity, is [[HisOwnWorstEnemy itself.]]itself]].



* AliensAreBastards: [[spoiler: The aliens are forcing the characters to kill each other either ForScience or ForTheEvulz]].

to:

* AliensAreBastards: [[spoiler: The aliens are forcing the characters to kill each other either ForScience or ForTheEvulz]].ForTheEvulz.]]



* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Eric tricks the Little Girl into killing herself for the baby while he votes for the Pregnant Woman at the last second. Then he and the unborn fetus are the only survivors left. Eric votes for the baby and is returned to Earth. The ending at first seems like a downer ending because the master manipulator survives, but we gain much more faith in mankind when Eric finds the survivors of other circles and we see that almost half of them are children and pregnant women, meaning that in many other ships, everyone else willingly died in order to do the right thing and save those more vulnerable than themselves.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Eric tricks the Little Girl into killing herself for the baby while he votes for the Pregnant Woman at the last second. Then he He and the unborn fetus are the only survivors left. Eric votes for left, and he returns to Earth after voting to kill the baby and is returned to Earth. The baby. At first, this ending at first seems like a downer ending {{downer|Ending}} because the master manipulator survives, character revealed to be the most [[TheSociopath cold-blooded]] and {{manipulative|Bastard}} of them all ends up surviving, but we gain much more faith in mankind when Eric then finds the survivors of other circles circles, and we see that almost half of them are children and pregnant women, meaning women. This means that in many other ships, everyone else willingly died in order to do the right thing and save those more vulnerable than themselves.themselves, which can restore some of a viewer's faith in mankind.]]



* GoryDiscretionShot: Occasionally, we won't even see when the orb zaps someone to death--which makes it all the more shocking when someone unexpected dies.

to:

* GoryDiscretionShot: Occasionally, we won't even see when the orb zaps someone to death--which death -- which makes it all the more shocking when someone unexpected dies.



** The Rich Man, whose [[TheSocialDarwinist Social Darwinist]] views, DirtyCoward rationale and ItsAllAboutMe attitude is absolutely ''vile''.
** The Lawyer deliberately mispronounces the name of a teenage boy who sacrificed himself to buy the others time. He then goes on a homophobic tirade against the Lesbian until finally being eliminated.

to:

** The Rich Man, whose [[TheSocialDarwinist Social Darwinist]] views, DirtyCoward rationale and ItsAllAboutMe attitude is are absolutely ''vile''.
** The Lawyer deliberately mispronounces the name of a teenage boy who sacrificed himself to buy the others time. He then goes on a homophobic tirade against the Lesbian until finally being eliminated.Lesbian, [[spoiler:which promptly gets him eliminated]].



** Several times, one character [[ReasonYouSuckSpeech argues heatedly]] for why another particular character deserves to die next -- only to find that everyone else is so disgusted by their hateful rant that they are the next one to die instead.
** After emerging as the leader of the pragmatist faction the Bearded Man assumes the silent man is on his side. [[spoiler:This turns out to be a fatal mistake.]]

to:

** Several times, one character [[ReasonYouSuckSpeech [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech argues heatedly]] for why another particular character deserves to die next -- only to find that everyone else is so disgusted by their hateful rant that they are the next one to die instead.
** After emerging as the leader of the pragmatist faction faction, the Bearded Man assumes the silent man is on his side. [[spoiler:This turns out to be a fatal mistake.]]



* LeaningOnTheFourthWall: [[spoiler:Eric]]'s rant to those running the Circle after [[spoiler:he survives at the end]], when [[spoiler:another countdown starts and it seems like he's going to be killed regardless]]. It could just as well be directed at the audience, who have also spectated the full process of characters killing each other, especially with [[spoiler:Eric noting that he's probably not "the one that you wanted" to have survived]]. (See YouBastard below for the full speech.)



** When the Rude Atheist managed to turn half of the circle onto him, he tries to make the Beautiful Blonde Woman next to him a target by insinuating she's a porn star and ends up making her cry. [[spoiler: This earned him the ire of everyone in the circle, and he's the next to die.]]

to:

** When the Rude Atheist managed manages to turn half of the circle onto against him, he tries to make the Beautiful Blonde Woman next to him a target by insinuating she's a porn star and ends up making her cry. [[spoiler: This earned earns him the ire of everyone in the circle, and he's the next to die.]]



--->'''Lesbian''': "So she's never heard of birth control she gets to live?"

to:

--->'''Lesbian''': "So So she's never heard of birth control control, she gets to live?"live?



* TheSociopath: [[spoiler: Eric. He seems like a nice person, but he's actually a ''ruthless'' ManipulativeBastard who plays everyone against each other and remorselessly kills a little girl and a pregnant woman (and her child). He is the quickest to assess the situation from a cold and logical perspective and he doesn't lose his cool like a normal person in such a stressful situation. Other characters may or may not be sociopaths also, but Eric is a classic and archetypal example of one.]]

to:

* TheSociopath: [[spoiler: Eric. He seems like a nice person, but he's actually a ''ruthless'' ManipulativeBastard who plays pits everyone against each other and remorselessly kills a little girl and a pregnant woman (and her child). He is the quickest to assess the situation from a cold and logical perspective perspective, and he doesn't lose his cool like a normal person in such a stressful situation. Other characters may or may not be sociopaths also, but Eric is a classic and archetypal example of one.]]



* TokenReligiousTeammate: The Minister...shocking right?
* TooDumbToLive: It's discovered pretty early on that the elimination is based on popular vote, but rather than keeping their mouth shut or outright lying for sympathy (as several smarter characters attempt), some of the people in the room behave like massive jerkasses, which almost always gets them killed. Special mention goes to the Rude Atheist, who acts like a massive jerk only for someone else to get eliminated. Then ''moments later'' he starts bullying the Pretty Girl and accusing her of being a porn actress, causing the survivors to finally eliminate him.

to:

* TokenReligiousTeammate: The Minister...shocking shocking, right?
* TooDumbToLive: It's discovered pretty early on that the elimination is based on popular vote, but rather than keeping their mouth shut or outright lying for sympathy (as several smarter characters attempt), some of the people in the room behave like massive jerkasses, which almost always gets them killed. Special mention goes to the [[spoiler:the Rude Atheist, who acts like a massive jerk this way only for someone else to get eliminated. Then Then, ''moments later'' later'', he starts bullying the Pretty Girl and accusing her of being a porn actress, causing the survivors to finally eliminate him.him]].



** [[spoiler: Near the end of the film the players are split into two groups. The protectors: a group of individuals who want to protect the Little Girl and the Young Pregnant Woman. The pragmatists: a group of individuals who want to kill the Little Girl and the Young Pregnant Woman in order to give everyone in the circle a better chance at survival.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Near the end of the film film, the players are split into two groups. The protectors: a group of individuals who want to protect the Little Girl and the Young Pregnant Woman. The pragmatists: a group of individuals who want to kill the Little Girl and the Young Pregnant Woman in order to give everyone in the circle a better chance at survival.]]



** The Pregnant Lady actively refuses to target the Little Girl. Not even to save her OWN child!

to:

** The Pregnant Lady actively refuses to target the Little Girl. Not Girl -- not even to save her OWN child!



* YouBastard: [[spoiler:Eric's rant at the aliens, including a defense of his actions, when he thinks he's going to be killed regardless]] could just as well be directed at the audience, who have enjoyed 90 minutes of characters killing each other via mass vote.
-->'''[[spoiler:Eric]]:''' [[spoiler:Of course. All that... all that for nothing? All that. What's the matter, huh? What? I'm not good enough for you? What? I'm not the one that you wanted? I'm exactly the same as everybody else in here! They all got to make their own choices! They chose to kill each other. That's what you wanted to see, right, huh? Well, there you go, congratulations. We're assholes. F--- you!]]

to:

* YouBastard: [[spoiler:Eric's rant at the aliens, including aliens (including a defense of his actions, actions), when he thinks he's going to be killed regardless]] regardless,]] could just as well [[LeaningOnTheFourthWall be directed at the audience, audience]], who have enjoyed 90 minutes of characters killing each other via mass vote.
-->'''[[spoiler:Eric]]:''' [[spoiler:Of course. All that... all that for nothing? All that. What's the matter, huh? What? I'm not good enough for you? What? I'm not the one that you wanted? I'm exactly the same as everybody else in here! They all got to make their own choices! They chose to kill each other. That's what you wanted to see, right, huh? Well, there you go, congratulations. We're assholes. F--- Fuck you!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TokenReligiousTeammate: The Minister...shocking right?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: While the Lawyer's sincerity is debatable, the Rich Man actually does seem show a moment of decency to teenage Shaun when he offers himself to die next.

to:

* PetTheDog: While the Lawyer's sincerity is debatable, the Rich Man actually does seem to show a moment of decency to teenage Shaun when he offers himself to die next.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PetTheDog: While the Lawyer's sincerity is debatable, the Rich Man actually does seem show a moment of decency to teenage Shaun when he offers himself to die next.

Added: 429

Changed: 330

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WouldntHurtAChild: Despite the Fake Husband and Fake Wife initially voting with the pragmatists to tie a vote between the Little Girl and the Rich Banker, the Fake Wife doesn't vote on the runoff so that only the Rich Banker dies. She admits that she couldn't bring herself to do it. The Rich Banker [[{{Jerkass}} being who he was]] probably helped.

to:

* WouldntHurtAChild: WouldntHurtAChild:
** The Pregnant Lady actively refuses to target the Little Girl. Not even to save her OWN child!
**
Despite the Fake Husband and Fake Wife initially voting with the pragmatists to tie a vote between the Little Girl and the Rich Banker, the Fake Wife doesn't vote on the runoff so that only the Rich Banker dies. She admits that she couldn't bring herself to do it. The Rich Banker [[{{Jerkass}} being who he was]] probably helped.

Added: 749

Changed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCorrupter: One can make a case for the Bearded Man, since he's able to pressure the Lesbian and Pretty Girl into actively trying to kill a pregnant woman and a ten year old girl by playing on them not wanting to die themselves.



* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: Asian Kid is more in line with the pragmatic group, but he's usually the first to call out other people's biases. He mocks the Rich Guy's idea of saving people based on class, and defends the Lesbian against the Lawyer.

to:

* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: JerkWithAHeartOfGold:
**
Asian Kid is more in line with the pragmatic group, but he's usually the first to call out other people's biases. He mocks the Rich Guy's idea of saving people based on class, and defends the Lesbian against the Lawyer.Lawyer.
** The Lesbian ultimately sides with the pragmatic group but only after being pressured by the Bearded Man and out of a desire to see her wife and daughter again. Despite somewhat slut-shaming the Pregnant Woman the Lesbian later defends her from the Rich Guy's antagonistic line of questioning.

Added: 843

Changed: 1350

Removed: 1108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForgettableCharacter: When the atheist ties with a woman, who tries to save herself by pointing out she didn't say anything wrong, he yells: "Who the f is this?!" Justified in that the audience probably didn't notice her either.

to:

* ForgettableCharacter: ForgettableCharacter:
**
When the atheist ties with a woman, who tries to save herself by pointing out she didn't say anything wrong, he yells: "Who the f is this?!" Justified in that the audience probably didn't notice her either.



** Another character does invoke a downplayed version of this: [[spoiler: Eric. While he becomes the ringleader of the protectors, he's also careful to restrict any emotional outbursts he has to ''only'' them and doesn't say or do anything else to draw unnecessary attention to himself. The result is that he makes it to the end, [[FromNobodyToNightmare and suddenly he isn't so forgettable anymore]].]]



** The Bearded Man is silent for the first act of the film. But when the group begins to divide, he quickly emerges as the leader of the pragmatists, persuading others to vote along with him and coordinating who should die next.

to:

** The Bearded Man is silent for the first act of the film. But when the group begins to divide, he quickly emerges as the leader of the pragmatists, persuading others to vote along with him and coordinating who should die next.next, becoming the primary antagonist to the more sympathetic protector faction.



** The Rich Man, whose [[TheSocialDarwinist views]], DirtyCoward rationale and ItsAllAboutMe attitude is absolutely ''vile''.

to:

** The Rich Man, whose [[TheSocialDarwinist views]], Social Darwinist]] views, DirtyCoward rationale and ItsAllAboutMe attitude is absolutely ''vile''.



** When everyone tries to vote for themselves to force a universal tie one unnamed survivor secretly switches his vote to the Young Pregnant Lady in an attempt to eliminate her. Eric notices this and switches his own vote. In the subsequent runoff everyone votes to save the Young Pregnant Lady, eliminating the other survivor.

to:

** When everyone tries to vote for themselves to force a universal tie tie, one unnamed survivor secretly switches his vote to the Young Pregnant Lady in an attempt to eliminate her. Eric notices this and switches his own vote. In the subsequent runoff everyone votes to save the Young Pregnant Lady, eliminating the other survivor.



* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler: Eric gets off scot-free for killing Pregnant Woman's baby and convincing the Little Girl to kill herself. Additionally,]] the aliens who conducted this experiment presumably get away with it.

to:

* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler: Eric gets off scot-free for killing Pregnant Woman's baby and convincing the Little Girl to kill herself. Additionally,]] the aliens who conducted this experiment presumably get away with it. herself]].



** The people who volunteered about halfway through are also nice people.
** [[spoiler: Katie sacrifices herself to save the pregnant lady. The pregnant lady also refuses to vote for Katie, a little bit before that, even when she is pressured to do so to save herself.]]
* NominalImportance: Averted in that several characters are named but still die just as easily as everyone else. [[spoiler:Then subverted when Eric becomes the only survivor.]]



* SadisticChoice: The whole movie is full of those, but the main one is about either let the child or the Pregnant Woman be killed. The Bearded Man tries to force Eric to choose between the two of them, [[spoiler:only for Eric to realize that the Silent Man has never voted and uses him to break the tie, allowing him to regain the majority by killing the Fake Wife.]]

to:

* SadisticChoice: SadisticChoice:
**
The whole movie is full of those, but the main one is about either let the child or the Pregnant Woman be killed. The Bearded Man tries to force Eric to choose between the two of them, [[spoiler:only for Eric to realize that the Silent Man has never voted and uses him to break the tie, allowing him to regain the majority by killing the Fake Wife.]]



* SenselessSacrifice: While the volunteers all count as such, since they're only delaying the inevitable, of particular note is [[spoiler:the Little Girl. She offers to give her life to save the Pregnant Woman, only for Eric to use the distraction to take out the Pregnant Woman at the same moment]].

to:

* SenselessSacrifice: SenselessSacrifice:
**
While the volunteers all count as such, since they're only delaying the inevitable, of particular note is [[spoiler:the Little Girl. She offers to give her life to save the Pregnant Woman, only for Eric to use the distraction to take out the Pregnant Woman at the same moment]].



* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: It stands to reason that a faction of pragmatists who want to ensure their own survival would all turn on each other. [[spoiler:Which Eric was banking on from the beginning by pitting the pragmatists and protectors against each other.]]
** The Little Girl barely says anything throughout the film and mostly just cries, because she's ten years old in a terrifying situation and a bunch of adults she's never met are debating whether or not to kill her so one of them has a chance to live instead.

to:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: It stands Despite being critical to reason that a faction of pragmatists who want to ensure their own survival would all turn on each other. [[spoiler:Which Eric was banking on from the beginning by pitting main thrust of the pragmatists and protectors against each other.]]
** The
plot, the Little Girl barely says anything throughout the film and mostly just cries, because she's ten years old and in a terrifying situation and a bunch of adults she's never met are debating whether or not to kill her so one of them has a chance to live instead.situation.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Deconstructed and heavily debated throughout the film, as a lot of characters point out that while no one ''really'' wants to sentence a child or a pregnant woman to death, every single one of them is in the same unfair situation and they all have lives they want to return to. [[spoiler: In the end, the one who does make it out alive is the one who sets those standards aside...at least for the group we follow, since we see multiple women and children among the survivors at the end.]]

to:

** Deconstructed and heavily debated throughout the film, as a lot of characters point out film. The pragmatists argue that while no one ''really'' wants they don't ''want'' to sentence a child or a kill children and pregnant woman to death, every single one of them is in the same unfair situation and women, they all have lives they want deserve to return to. [[spoiler: In the end, the one who does make it out alive is the one who sets those standards aside...at least for the group we follow, since we see multiple women and children among the survivors at the end.]]vote according to their self interest in this unfair circumstance.


* TooDumbToLive: It's discovered pretty early on that the elimination is based on popular vote, but rather than keeping their mouth shut or outright lying for sympathy (as several smarter characters attempt), some of the people in the room behave like massive jerkasses, which almost always gets them killed. Special mention goes to the Rude Atheist, who acts like a massive jerk only for someone else to get eliminated. Then ''moments later'' he starts bullying the Pretty Girl and accusing her of being a porn actress, causing the survivors to finally eliminate him. Although, this final move may not have been stupidity so much as him knowingly [[DeathSeeker trying to die]].

to:

* TooDumbToLive: It's discovered pretty early on that the elimination is based on popular vote, but rather than keeping their mouth shut or outright lying for sympathy (as several smarter characters attempt), some of the people in the room behave like massive jerkasses, which almost always gets them killed. Special mention goes to the Rude Atheist, who acts like a massive jerk only for someone else to get eliminated. Then ''moments later'' he starts bullying the Pretty Girl and accusing her of being a porn actress, causing the survivors to finally eliminate him. Although, this final move may not have been stupidity so much as him knowingly [[DeathSeeker trying to die]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At one point in a tie between the Little Girl and the Rich Banker, the Fake Wife can't bring herself to kill the Little Girl and doesn't vote, resulting in the Rich Banker's death.
** The Pregnant Woman also can't bring herself to vote for the Little Girl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FailedASpotCheck: Only one person ever notices that the Silent Man doesn't vote. [[spoiler: This has fatal consequences for the Bearded Man when he simply assumes the Silent Man is on his side.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooDumbToLive: It's discovered pretty early on that the elimination is based on popular vote, but rather than keeping their mouth shut or outright lying for sympathy (as several smarter characters attempt), some of the people in the room behave like massive jerkasses, which almost always gets them killed. Special mention goes to the Rude Atheist, who acts like a massive jerk only for someone else to get eliminated. Then ''moments later'' he starts bullying the Pretty Girl and accusing her of being a porn actress, causing the survivors to finally eliminate him.

to:

* TooDumbToLive: It's discovered pretty early on that the elimination is based on popular vote, but rather than keeping their mouth shut or outright lying for sympathy (as several smarter characters attempt), some of the people in the room behave like massive jerkasses, which almost always gets them killed. Special mention goes to the Rude Atheist, who acts like a massive jerk only for someone else to get eliminated. Then ''moments later'' he starts bullying the Pretty Girl and accusing her of being a porn actress, causing the survivors to finally eliminate him. Although, this final move may not have been stupidity so much as him knowingly [[DeathSeeker trying to die]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
formatting


** Another character does invoke a downplayed version of this: [[spoiler: Eric. While he becomes the ringleader of the protectors, he's also careful to restrict any emotional outbursts he has to ''only'' them and doesn't say or do anything else to draw unnecessary attention to himself. The result is that he makes it to the end, [[FromNobodyToNightmare and suddenly he isn't so forgettable anymore.]]

to:

** Another character does invoke a downplayed version of this: [[spoiler: Eric. While he becomes the ringleader of the protectors, he's also careful to restrict any emotional outbursts he has to ''only'' them and doesn't say or do anything else to draw unnecessary attention to himself. The result is that he makes it to the end, [[FromNobodyToNightmare and suddenly he isn't so forgettable anymore.anymore]].]]

Added: 892

Changed: 128

Removed: 484

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CheatersNeverProsper: Trying to rig the game never works out as intended. Refuse to vote, the game picks a victim at random. Try to force a tie? It's actually the fastest way to eliminate everyone, especially if nobody changes their vote.

to:

* CheatersNeverProsper: Trying to rig the game never works out as intended. Refuse to vote, the vote? The game picks a victim at random. Try to force a tie? It's actually the fastest way to eliminate everyone, especially if nobody Either someone changes their vote.vote in the run-off or everyone involved in the tie dies.



* TheChessmaster: [[spoiler: Eric notices the one guy trying to vote for the pregnant lady and eliminates him. Then, by explaning that the pregnant lady and the kid will probably last until the end, he actually paints a target on their back for the other ones who want to survive at all costs. He signals to the pregnant lady to vote for the bearded man, taking the last of the pragmatists out. Finally, he manipulates Katie into sacrificing herself and then killing the pregnant lady by a last moment twist of the wrist. During the whole thing, he stays away from any ideological discussions or emotional outbursts, making sure nobody feels any strong hostility towards him]].

to:

* TheChessmaster: [[spoiler: Eric notices the one guy trying to vote for the pregnant lady and eliminates him. Then, by explaning explaining that the pregnant lady and the kid will probably last until the end, he actually paints a target on their back for the other ones who want to survive at all costs. He signals to the pregnant lady to vote for the bearded man, taking the last of the pragmatists out. Finally, he manipulates Katie into sacrificing herself and then killing the pregnant lady by a last moment twist of the wrist. During the whole thing, he stays away from any ideological discussions or emotional outbursts, making sure nobody feels any strong hostility towards him]].



** Deconstructed and heavily debated throughout the film, as a lot of characters point out that while no one ''really'' wants to sentence a child or a pregnant woman to death, every single one of them is in the same unfair situation and they all have lives they want to return to. [[spoiler: In the end, the one who does make it out alive is the one who sets those standards aside...at least for the group we follow, since we see multiple women and children among the survivors at the end.]]



** Also deconstructed and heavily debated throughout the film, as a lot of characters point out that while no one ''really'' wants to sentence a child or a pregnant woman to death, every single one of them is in the same unfair situation and they all want a chance to live. [[spoiler: In the end, the one who does make it out alive is the one who sets those standards aside...at least for the group we follow, since we see multiple women and children among the survivors at the end.]]



** Another character does invoke a downplayed version of this: [[spoiler: Eric. While he becomes the ringleader of the protectors, he's also careful to restrict any emotional outbursts he has to ''only'' them and doesn't say or do anything else to draw unnecessary attention to himself. The result is that he makes it to the end, [[FromNobodyToNightmare and suddenly he isn't so forgettable anymore.]]






* YouBastard: [[spoiler:Eric's rant at the aliens, including a defence of his actions, when he thinks he's going to be killed regardless]] could just as well be directed at the audience, who have enjoyed 90 minutes of characters killing each other via mass vote.

to:

* YouBastard: [[spoiler:Eric's rant at the aliens, including a defence defense of his actions, when he thinks he's going to be killed regardless]] could just as well be directed at the audience, who have enjoyed 90 minutes of characters killing each other via mass vote.

Added: 1833

Changed: 362

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DevelopersForesight: In-universe, the creators of the elimination game planned for every contingency. Try to leave, you die. No one votes, a random person is killed. Tied votes kill all involved if no one changes their vote.

to:

* DevelopersForesight: In-universe, the creators of the elimination game planned for every contingency. Try to leave, you leave? You die. No one votes, a votes? A random person is killed. Tied votes kill all involved if no one The vote is tied? Everyone in the tie dies unless someone changes their vote.



* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler:The Minister quietly asks God for forgiveness before stepping off his platform and dying.]]

to:

* DrivenToSuicide: Several people "volunteer" to die by stepping off their platforms for various reasons. [[spoiler:The Minister quietly asks God for forgiveness before stepping off his platform and dying.]]



** Also deconstructed and heavily debated throughout the film, as a lot of characters point out that while no one ''really'' wants to sentence a child or a pregnant woman to death, every single one of them is in the same unfair situation and they all want a chance to live. [[spoiler: In the end, the one who does make it out alive is the one who sets those standards aside...at least for the group we follow, since we see multiple women and children among the survivors at the end.]]



* FiveSecondForeshadowing: [[spoiler: As the final timer is running down, Eric suddenly shouts at the Little Girl to walk off the platform, despite talking to her kindly beforehand. This is because if she doesn't step off the platform in time, the end result will almost certainly be a tie and Eric's plan will have failed.]]



** The Silent Man, who might be invoking this as a strategy; he never votes or says a word, and as such no one takes much notice of him. [[spoiler: He makes it all the way to the final six before anyone even acknowledges that he's there, and Eric is seemingly the only one to take note of him beforehand.]]



* GoodShepherd: The Minister, who tries to comfort some of the others, and is part of the group dedicated to saving Katie or the Pregnant woman.

to:

* GoodShepherd: The Minister, who tries to comfort some of the others, and is part of the group dedicated to saving Katie or the Pregnant woman.Woman.



* HopeSpot: [[spoiler: When it's just Eric, the Little Girl, and the Pregnant Woman left the audience is relieved that one of the two innocents is going to survive. However, Eric was faking his kindness the whole time and killed both of them]].

to:

* HopeSpot: [[spoiler: When it's just Eric, the Little Girl, and the Pregnant Woman left left, the audience is relieved that one of the two innocents is going to survive. However, Eric was faking his kindness the whole time and killed both of them]].



* IDidWhatIHadToDo: Comes down to this in many cases. The Husband says this word-for-word when he switches sides to prevent his wife from being killed next. [[spoiler:Only, it's not his wife, they were both just pretending to be married for sympathy and increase their chances of survival, and he had to switch his allegiance simply to keep up the pretense.]]

to:

* IDidWhatIHadToDo: Comes down to this in many cases. The Husband says this word-for-word when he switches sides to prevent his wife from being killed next. [[spoiler:Only, [[spoiler:Only it's not his wife, they were both just pretending to be married for sympathy and increase their chances of survival, and he had to switch his allegiance simply to keep up the pretense.]]



** [[spoiler: Katie sacrifices herself to save the pregnant lady. The pregnant lady also refuses to vote for Katie, a little bit before that, even when she is pressured to do so to save herself]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Katie sacrifices herself to save the pregnant lady. The pregnant lady also refuses to vote for Katie, a little bit before that, even when she is pressured to do so to save herself]]herself.]]



* NoNameGiven: Only a handful of the characters have names, and in the credits the others are described by phrases like Cancer Survivor, Pretty Girl, Cop, and so on.

to:

* NoNameGiven: Only a handful of the characters have names, and in the credits the others are described by phrases like Cancer Survivor, Pretty Girl, Cop, and so on. Justified in that they don't really have any time to get to know each other, and at least one survivor argues that knowing each other's name only makes what they're doing harder.



* SadisticChoice: The whole movie is full of those, but the main one is about either let the child or the pregnant woman be killed. The Bearded Man tries to force Eric to choose between the two of them, [[spoiler:only for Eric to realize that the Silent Man has never voted and uses him to break the tie, allowing him to regain the majority by killing the Fake Wife.]]

to:

* SadisticChoice: The whole movie is full of those, but the main one is about either let the child or the pregnant woman Pregnant Woman be killed. The Bearded Man tries to force Eric to choose between the two of them, [[spoiler:only for Eric to realize that the Silent Man has never voted and uses him to break the tie, allowing him to regain the majority by killing the Fake Wife.]]
** The Pregnant Woman has one herself eventually: [[spoiler: kill both herself and her unborn child to save a little girl, or allow the little girl to commit suicide for her? She refuses to vote for the little girl when pressed, but simply breaks down sobbing when the little girl volunteers herself.
]]



** Another one to note is the man who sacrifices himself so that Shaun won't have to, only for Shaun to immediately sacrifice himself the next round anyway.



** [[spoiler:The black man and woman who had an affair decide to step off the platform at the same time.]]
* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: It stands to reason that a faction of pragmatists who want to ensure their own survival would all turn on each other. [[spoiler:Which Eric was banking on from the beginning by pitting the pragmatists and protectors against each other.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:The black man and woman who had an affair decide to step off the platform at the same time.time when they tie.]]
* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: It stands to reason that a faction of pragmatists who want to ensure their own survival would all turn on each other. [[spoiler:Which Eric was banking on from the beginning by pitting the pragmatists and protectors against each other.]] ]]
** The Little Girl barely says anything throughout the film and mostly just cries, because she's ten years old in a terrifying situation and a bunch of adults she's never met are debating whether or not to kill her so one of them has a chance to live instead.



* WinsByDoingAbsolutelyNothing: The Silent Man survives for an impressive length of time simply by saying and doing nothing. [[spoiler:Eric is the only one to even notice this, using it to outwit another player. The Silent Man is then killed next round.]]

to:

* WinsByDoingAbsolutelyNothing: The Silent Man survives for an impressive length of time simply by saying and doing nothing. [[spoiler:Eric is the only one to even notice this, using it to outwit another player. The Silent Man is then killed in the next round.]]

Top