Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / ThievesCanBeHeroes

Go To

OR

Added: 168

Changed: 265

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyBirdCameo: [[spoiler:Futaba looks on longingly at Izuku and Inko through one of her monitors in Chapter 17, saying that it "must be nice" to have a loving mom.]]



* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use to emulate the fact that in the game, using a Persona that's way too strong for you to handle will cause it to take a great chunk of health with each use. It is also a CallBack to the recoil effect Izuku experienced while using One for All. in canon. For reference, using Virginia Smash ''once'' was enough to leave him barely able to stay up on one knee. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones from this.]]

to:

* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use to emulate the fact that in the game, using a Persona that's way too strong for you to handle will cause it to take a great chunk of health with each use. It is also a CallBack to the recoil effect Izuku experienced while using One for All. All in canon. For reference, using Virginia Smash ''once'' was enough to leave him barely able to stay up on one knee. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones from this.]]



* OxymoronicBeing: Izuku's status as a Phantom Thief is discussed as this. Heroes are widely popular, recognized, and accepted in society. So his desire to become a Hero acting as his rebellious catalyst to become a Phantom Thief seems contradictory. But it's explained that it's his desire to become a Hero in spite of the odds and obstacles placed before that makes the dream rebellious enough to make his Persona manifest.
* PintSizedPowerhouse: Izuku is the holder of the Fool Arcana but is only a first-year high school student versus his teammates' status as second and third-year students. As a result, he's shorter than most of them, but is still acknowledged as the most capable and powerful overall.

to:

* OxymoronicBeing: Izuku's status as a Phantom Thief is discussed as this. Heroes are widely popular, recognized, and accepted in society. So his desire to become a Hero acting as his rebellious catalyst to become a Phantom Thief seems contradictory. But it's explained that it's his desire to become a Hero in spite of the odds and obstacles placed before him that would tell him that he can't is what makes the dream rebellious enough to make his Persona manifest.
* PintSizedPowerhouse: Izuku is the holder of the Fool Arcana but is only a first-year high school student versus his teammates' status as second and third-year students. As a result, he's shorter than most of them, but them (but is still taller than Makoto). He's also acknowledged as the most capable and powerful member of the Thieves overall.



** It pops up again when [[spoiler:Izuku tells Makoto the truth and they get into an argument over the ethics of the situation and what might happen if he's ever caught.]]

to:

** It pops up again when [[spoiler:Izuku tells Makoto the truth and they get into an argument over the ethics of the situation and what might happen if he's ever caught. He knows it's wrong and he never wanted to operate this way, but if there are people suffering that he can help and other Heroes can't, he's willing to take that risk.]]

Added: 1664

Changed: 280

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassCape: Carter wears a flowing red one that he dramatically shows off upon being summoned for the first time.

to:

** Sae also calls Izuku "Little Izu" due to their past history, while he calls her "Sae-oneechan" (literally Big Sister Sae) out of respect.
* BadassCape: Carter wears a flowing red one that he dramatically shows off flourishes upon being summoned for the first time.



* ChildhoodFriend: Although she's significantly older than Izuku, Makoto was a good friend of his when they were younger and the only girl he could comfortably talk to. She is also implied to have been a MoralityPet for Bakugou, whose behavior worsened after she moved away.

to:

* ChildhoodFriend: Although she's significantly older than Izuku, Makoto was a good friend of his when they were younger and the only girl he could comfortably talk to. [[spoiler:This is what made her rejection of the Thieves' activities especially painful for Izuku.]] She is also implied to have been a MoralityPet for Bakugou, whose behavior worsened after she moved away.



* GargleBlaster: The concoction Tae has Izuku drink to test his bravery was designed to release an odor comparable to [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surströmming Surströmming]], the world's worst smelling food, upon making contact with stomach acid. The horrid smell that it produces is enough to put Izuku in a coma for several hours and cause him to repeatedly fade in and out of consciousness. The taste wasn't much better, since it was an eye-opening mix of bitter and sour that Izuku only barely managed to get down.

to:

* GargleBlaster: The concoction Tae has Izuku drink to test his bravery was designed to release an odor comparable to [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surströmming Surströmming]], the world's worst smelling food, upon making contact with stomach acid. The horrid smell that stench it produces is enough to put Izuku in a coma for several hours and cause him to repeatedly fade in and out of consciousness. The taste wasn't much better, since it was an eye-opening mix of bitter and sour that Izuku only barely managed to get down.


Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:Izuku spills the beans to her in Chapter 17. While it initially goes well, the conversation ends on a sour note due to the ProtagonistCenteredMorality aspect of the Thieves' BrainwashingForTheGreaterGood and their mutual admiration of Heroes.]]


Added DiffLines:

** It pops up again when [[spoiler:Izuku tells Makoto the truth and they get into an argument over the ethics of the situation and what might happen if he's ever caught.]]
-->'''Izuku:''' Because even if heroes save people, they can't save everyone! Especially those who are suffering in silence! We… what we did… we helped so many students from having to keep suffering. [[spoiler:Suzui-sempai]] was able to get the justice she deserved. But seeing how much students were suffering and nothing was being done about it... it makes me wonder how many more are suffering like that. How many people are at the mercy of egomaniacs like Kamoshida? There are people who are afraid to speak up, or even when they do they're silenced... I... I didn't want to be a hero who operated like this, but... but if we can help more people who are suffering like that, then I want to keep fighting. Even if the world calls us villains or vigilantes, I'm... I'm okay with it.
* SecretKeeper: [[spoiler:Izuku feels bad about keeping Makoto LockedOutOfTheLoop and ends up telling her everything. While she's understanding at first, she balks when he explains that he's considering doing it again to help more people, reluctantly agreeing to keep his secret when she realizes that she won't be able to stop him.]]

Added: 132

Changed: 366

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[UsefulNotes/AmericanAccents Dixie Accent]]: Carter speaks with a slight Southern drawl due to his past as a Confederate soldier.



* ThouShaltNotKill: No matter how vile the target is, Izuku refuses to do anything that could potentially kill them, causing his hesitation when faced with the fact that running rampant in Kamoshida's psyche could potentially kill the man.

to:

* ThouShaltNotKill: No matter how vile the target is, Izuku refuses to do anything that could potentially kill them, result in AccidentalMurder, causing his hesitation him to hesitate when faced with given the fact that running rampant option to perform BrainwashingForTheGreaterGood out of fear of killing Kamoshida. Even Shadows aren't totally exempt from Izuku's no-kill rule, since he's happy to let Shadows he can negotiate go if they don't have any money or items to provide and are no longer a threat, frequently trying to recruit them in Kamoshida's psyche could potentially kill the man.process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Carter:''' Never regret! Never surrender! Never doubt! If society chains you for being a hero... then rip those chains off and save them, whether they want you to or not!

to:

-->'''Carter:''' Never '''''Never regret! Never surrender! Never doubt! If society chains you for being a hero... then rip those chains off and save them, whether they want you to or not!not!'''''



* LightIsGood: As the embodiment of Izuku's dream of becoming a hero, the Bless-attribute Carter is an unambiguously good LargeHam who can use the Kouha line of spells. Further emphasized by his rousing summoning speech, which stands in contrast to Arsene's promise to provide power even if Ren ended up chained down to hell.
-->'''Carter:''' From the sea of your soul, I come forth! I am the rebel hero of your soul, your power to save others in this foreign land! I am Carter! ''[flourishes his cape]'' If you ask, I will give you the power to break forth and save yourself from this mess!\\

to:

* LightIsGood: As the embodiment of Izuku's dream of becoming a hero, the Bless-attribute Carter is an unambiguously good LargeHam who can use the Kouha line of spells. spells and encourages Izuku when he's feeling down. Further emphasized by his Carter's rousing summoning speech, speech which involves breaking the chains that hold Izuku down, which stands in contrast to Arsene's promise to provide power even if Ren ended up chained down to hell.
-->'''Carter:''' From '''''From the sea of your soul, I come forth! I am the rebel hero of your soul, your power to save others in this foreign land! I am Carter! Carter!''''' ''[flourishes his cape]'' If '''''If you ask, I will give you the power to break forth and save yourself from this mess!\\mess!'''''\\



'''Carter:''' Then consider it done, kid! Let's show 'em that you can be a hero!

to:

'''Carter:''' Then '''''Then consider it done, kid! Let's show 'em that you can be a hero!hero!'''''



-->'''Carter:''' ''[booming, echoing voice]'' Come on, kid. You gon' give up that easily?\\

to:

-->'''Carter:''' ''[booming, echoing voice]'' Come '''''Come on, kid. You gon' give up that easily?\\easily?'''''\\



'''Carter:''' You proved yer resolve when you jumped to save the blond. Even now, I can feel that you never regretted yer choice in savin' that woman, either. Actin' and doin' right without thinkin'... and yet, society's tellin' you that you're a criminal. A piece of scum for havin' the guts to do right by yer fellow man... what do you think? Or was that all just some act?\\

to:

'''Carter:''' You '''''You proved yer resolve when you jumped to save the blond. Even now, I can feel that you never regretted yer choice in savin' that woman, either. Actin' and doin' right without thinkin'... and yet, society's tellin' you that you're a criminal. A piece of scum for havin' the guts to do right by yer fellow man... what do you think? Or was that all just some act?\\act?'''''\\



'''Carter:''' Well said, my boy! We are at agreement! Now then, let's seal our contract with a vow! I am thou... thou art I... I shall grant you the power to enact justice on this world! Never regret! Never surrender! Never doubt! If society chains you for being a hero... then rip those chains off and save them, whether they want you to or not!

to:

'''Carter:''' Well '''''Well said, my boy! We are at agreement! Now then, let's seal our contract with a vow! I am thou... thou art I... I shall grant you the power to enact justice on this world! Never regret! Never surrender! Never doubt! If society chains you for being a hero... then rip those chains off and save them, whether they want you to or not!not!'''''



* SimpleStaff: In contrast to Ren Amamiya's status as a KnifeNut, Izuku prefers to use a staff alongside a revolver sidearm. But his Persona, Carter, is very much a case of HeroesPreferSwords.

to:

* SimpleStaff: In contrast to Ren Amamiya's status as a KnifeNut, Izuku prefers to use a staff alongside a revolver sidearm.sidearm, reflecting his ThouShaltNotKill ideology. But his Persona, Carter, is very much a case of HeroesPreferSwords.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use to emulate the fact that in the game, using a Persona that's way too strong for you to handle will cause it to take a great chunk of health with each use as well as the blowback of One for All. Using Virginia Smash ''once'' was enough to leave him barely able to stay up on one knee. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones from this.]]

to:

* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use to emulate the fact that in the game, using a Persona that's way too strong for you to handle will cause it to take a great chunk of health with each use as well as use. It is also a CallBack to the blowback of recoil effect Izuku experienced while using One for All. Using in canon. For reference, using Virginia Smash ''once'' was enough to leave him barely able to stay up on one knee. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones from this.]]

Added: 621

Changed: 198

Removed: 239

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It can be read [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12533988/1/Thieves-Can-Be-Heroes here.]]

to:

It can be read on [[Website/FanfictionDotNet Fanfiction.net]] [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12533988/1/Thieves-Can-Be-Heroes here.]]
here]] or on Website/SpaceBattlesDotCom [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/thieves-can-be-heroes-my-hero-academia-persona-5-crossover.536773/ here]].

Beware of unmarked spoilers.



* ThemeNaming: Izuku names [[spoiler:his Smash techniques, Quantico Smash[[note]]Referring to the name of [[https://www.bustle.com/articles/112649-is-quantico-a-real-place-this-isnt-the-first-time-a-tv-show-has-been-set the U.S. Navy's headquarters]][[/note]] and Virginia Smash, in the same vein as the signature moves of his lifelong idol, All Might.]]
* ThouShaltNotKill: No matter how vile the target is, Izuku refuses to do anything that could potentially kill them, causing his hesitation when faced with the fact that running rampant in Kamoshida's psyche could potentially kill the man.



* ThouShaltNotKill: No matter how vile the target is, Izuku refuses to do anything that could potentially kill them, causing his hesitation when faced with the fact that running rampant in Kamoshida's psyche could potentially kill the man.

Added: 1120

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Ann:''' If it makes you feel better, there's now way I can see you as being as bad as all that. If anything, you're almost... the opposite of what I expected after hearing all the rumors.\\

to:

-->'''Ann:''' If it makes you feel better, there's now no way I can see you as being as bad as all that. If anything, you're almost... the opposite of what I expected after hearing all the rumors.\\


Added DiffLines:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Izuku refuses to drag Makoto into his mess, leaving her in the dark about his activities as a Phantom Thief. Unbeknownst to him, this causes Makoto to feel useless and that Izuku doesn't want her help, even though he desperately does but wants to keep her safe at the same time.


Added DiffLines:

* ShrinkingViolet: Izuku is just as sweet as he is in canon but also just as shy and it takes him a while to open up to others unless Heroes are involved. His reputation as someone with an assault charge against him also takes everyone who meets him by surprise, which is lampshaded by everyone he meets.
-->'''Izuku:''' ''[bowing respectfully]'' I-I'm sorry to burden you, Kawakami-sensei. Please take care of me.\\
'''Kawakami:''' Are you... sure this is the kid with a criminal record? He looks like he could barely hurt a fly.


Added DiffLines:

* StrongFamilyResemblance: Izuku is described as the spitting image of his mother, which is exactly how it is in canon.


Added DiffLines:

* TragicDream: Izuku continues to cling to his dream of becoming a Hero even when he knows that it's all but impossible for him now thanks to being Quirkless AND a criminal.

Added: 1297

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GetAHoldOfYourselfMan: Ann does this to [[spoiler:Shiho after she wakes up from having attempted suicide.]]
-->'''[[spoiler:Shiho:]]''' A-am I supposed to walk through that school again, [[NothingIsTheSameAnymore expecting everything]] to go back to normal?! All of those eyes of disgust and pity watching me every single day! I can't take that! I can't- ''[gets slapped]''\\
'''Ann:''' You don't know any of that. You don't know what any of the students will think! And no matter what, you won't be alone anymore! I don't want you to give up on us. I want you to see for yourself that you still have a place to go back to. And once this is all over, you can walk through Shujin with your head held high! Alright?!



* ICouldaBeenAContender: Izuku feels this way about his decision to try to save that woman, resulting in his criminal record and effectively being permanently barred from pursuing his dream of becoming a Hero. Subverted when he realizes that he doesn't regret what he did even with the ultimate consequences, which allows him to form his contract with Carter.



* ItsAllMyFault: Izuku blames himself for [[spoiler:letting Shiho jump off the building even as he nearly broke his fingers trying to get to her. When Shiho wakes up, she acknowledges this to Ann and feels guilty about it.]]



* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku's criminal record underscores this, since he can barely speak with anyone without them judging him for having an assault charge on his record even as he tries to treat everyone around him nicely. His tendency to stutter also makes him far less threatening when attempting to negotiate with Shadows. At the same time, his status as the Wild Card means that he also has to be TheSocialExpert to make the most of his abilities. Naturally, HilarityEnsues.

to:

* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku's criminal record underscores this, since he can barely speak with anyone without them judging him for having an assault charge on his record even as he tries to treat everyone around him nicely. His tendency to stutter (even when texting) also makes him far less threatening when attempting to negotiate with Shadows. At the same time, his status as the Wild Card means that he also has to be TheSocialExpert to make the most of his abilities. Naturally, HilarityEnsues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InSpiteOfANail: Izuku ends up working out regularly in hopes of passing the U.A. Entrance Exam even without meeting All Might. He gives up after moving to Tokyo and the realization that he'll never be a hero sinks in, but he picks it back up again after becoming a Phantom Thief.

to:

* InSpiteOfANail: Izuku ends up jogging and working out regularly in hopes of passing the U.A. Entrance Exam even without meeting All Might. He gives up after moving to Tokyo and the realization that he'll never be a hero sinks in, but he picks it back up again after becoming a Phantom Thief. He eventually ends up being running partners with Ryuji.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[after Izuku wakes up from the several-hour-long coma the drink put him in]'' Are you out of your mind? We've only met twice before this and you just accept some strange medicine from me? Only an idiot would drink that...

to:

''[after Izuku wakes up from the several-hour-long coma the drink put him in]'' Are you out of your mind? We've only met twice before this and you just accept some strange medicine from me? Only an idiot would drink that...that...
* WalkingShirtlessScene: Carter, as per the [[Literature/JohnCarterOfMars source material]], amply showing off his rippling muscles.

Added: 118

Changed: 297

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl even with the confidence boost he gets in the Metaverse. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows. Tae loves abusing this for a quick laugh.

to:

* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting melts when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl even with the confidence boost he gets in the Metaverse. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows. Tae loves abusing this for a quick laugh.



* ClassicalAntiHero: Izuku is constantly doubting himself and his abilities and beats himself up when things go wrong.



* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones.]]

to:

* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use. use to emulate the fact that in the game, using a Persona that's way too strong for you to handle will cause it to take a great chunk of health with each use as well as the blowback of One for All. Using Virginia Smash ''once'' was enough to leave him barely able to stay up on one knee. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones.bones from this.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroicRROD: [[spoiler:Izuku's Smash techniques can deal tremendous damage but take a considerable amount of his stamina and wracks his body with pain with each use. Luckily, he doesn't get broken bones.]]

Added: 186

Changed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallingYourAttacks: Necessary when using magic.

to:

* CallingYourAttacks: Necessary when using magic. [[spoiler:Izuku also does this when having Carter replicate All Might's various Smash attacks.]]



* EmotionalBruiser: Izuku is the strongest member of the Phantom Thieves overall and also the most prone to TenderTears.



* MagneticHero: His sheer niceness ends up drawing the Phantom Thieves to him on top of his status as a Wild Card. Then there's the Shadows who become his Personas.

to:

* MagneticHero: His Izuku's sheer niceness ends up drawing the Phantom Thieves to him on top of his status as a Wild Card. Then there's the Shadows who become his Personas.


Added DiffLines:

* RedOniBlueOni: Izuku is the more demure Blue Oni to Ryuji's Red.

Added: 122

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShockAndAwe: Aside from his canon affinity for the Zio line, Ryuji's Quirk allows him to charge himself up with electricity to run extra first for a short duration, though he admits that it was a lot more useful before he broke his leg.

to:

* ShockAndAwe: Aside from his canon affinity for the Zio line, Ryuji's Quirk allows him to charge himself up with electricity to run extra first fast for a short duration, though he admits that it was a lot more useful before he broke his leg.


Added DiffLines:

* TenderTears: Izuku is frequently crying both tears of regret and tears of joy, though he always tries to wipe them away.

Added: 2135

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffectionateNickname: Makoto calls Izuku "Midori" for short while he calls her the more formal but still friendly "Koto-san", having met in the past. Makoto also refers to Bakugou "Baka-chan" as both a sign of affection and an insult.

to:

* AffectionateNickname: Makoto calls Izuku "Midori" for short while he calls her the more formal but still friendly "Koto-san", having met in the past. Makoto also refers to Bakugou "Baka-chan" as both a sign of affection and an insult. Carter also affectionately refers to Izuku as "kid".
* BadassCape: Carter wears a flowing red one that he dramatically shows off upon being summoned for the first time.
* BadassLongcoat: Izuku has the same trenchcoat worn by Ren in addition to the rest of his thief outfit, which is a black and red version of his second hero costume in canon.
* BadassCreed: Carter has one as part of his RousingSpeech to Izuku.
-->'''Carter:''' Never regret! Never surrender! Never doubt! If society chains you for being a hero... then rip those chains off and save them, whether they want you to or not!


Added DiffLines:

* CallBack: Carter tells Izuku that he can be a hero, much like All Might would have in another time and another place.
* CallingYourAttacks: Necessary when using magic.


Added DiffLines:

* InSpiteOfANail: Izuku ends up working out regularly in hopes of passing the U.A. Entrance Exam even without meeting All Might. He gives up after moving to Tokyo and the realization that he'll never be a hero sinks in, but he picks it back up again after becoming a Phantom Thief.


Added DiffLines:

* LightIsGood: As the embodiment of Izuku's dream of becoming a hero, the Bless-attribute Carter is an unambiguously good LargeHam who can use the Kouha line of spells. Further emphasized by his rousing summoning speech, which stands in contrast to Arsene's promise to provide power even if Ren ended up chained down to hell.
-->'''Carter:''' From the sea of your soul, I come forth! I am the rebel hero of your soul, your power to save others in this foreign land! I am Carter! ''[flourishes his cape]'' If you ask, I will give you the power to break forth and save yourself from this mess!\\
'''Izuku:''' Please, give me the power I need! Carter!\\
'''Carter:''' Then consider it done, kid! Let's show 'em that you can be a hero!


Added DiffLines:

* OxymoronicBeing: Izuku's status as a Phantom Thief is discussed as this. Heroes are widely popular, recognized, and accepted in society. So his desire to become a Hero acting as his rebellious catalyst to become a Phantom Thief seems contradictory. But it's explained that it's his desire to become a Hero in spite of the odds and obstacles placed before that makes the dream rebellious enough to make his Persona manifest.

Added: 1067

Changed: 50

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalSuperpowerChange: Izuku is still Quirkless, but he instead has the power of the Fool Arcana this time around. In addition, his superheroic tendencies have given him Carter for a Persona rather than Arsene.

to:

* AdaptationalSuperpowerChange: Izuku is still Quirkless, but he instead of One for All he has the power of the Fool Arcana this time around. In addition, his superheroic tendencies have given him Carter [[Literature/JohnCarterOfMars Carter]] for a Persona rather than Arsene.


Added DiffLines:

* RousingSpeech: Carter gives one to Izuku as he seals their contract.
-->'''Carter:''' ''[booming, echoing voice]'' Come on, kid. You gon' give up that easily?\\
'''Izuku:''' Wh-what?\\
'''Carter:''' You proved yer resolve when you jumped to save the blond. Even now, I can feel that you never regretted yer choice in savin' that woman, either. Actin' and doin' right without thinkin'... and yet, society's tellin' you that you're a criminal. A piece of scum for havin' the guts to do right by yer fellow man... what do you think? Or was that all just some act?\\
'''Izuku:''' ''[internally]'' Would I take back what I did? No! S-she called for help! There was no way I would ever ignore that! Not then, and not '''now!'''\\
'''Carter:''' Well said, my boy! We are at agreement! Now then, let's seal our contract with a vow! I am thou... thou art I... I shall grant you the power to enact justice on this world! Never regret! Never surrender! Never doubt! If society chains you for being a hero... then rip those chains off and save them, whether they want you to or not!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku's criminal record underscores this, since he can barely speak with anyone without them judging him for having an assault charge on his record even as he tries to treat everyone around him nicely. His tendency to stutter also makes him far less threatening when attempting to negotiate with Shadows.

to:

* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku's criminal record underscores this, since he can barely speak with anyone without them judging him for having an assault charge on his record even as he tries to treat everyone around him nicely. His tendency to stutter also makes him far less threatening when attempting to negotiate with Shadows. At the same time, his status as the Wild Card means that he also has to be TheSocialExpert to make the most of his abilities. Naturally, HilarityEnsues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoSell: Carter is immune to Bless attacks and resistant to Curse attacks. Later on, Carter's own Bless attacks get {{No Sell}}ed by a Shadow in Kamoshida's Palace.

Added: 274

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffectionateNickname: Makoto calls Izuku "Midori" for short while he calls her the more formal but still friendly "Koto-san", having met in the past.

to:

* AffectionateNickname: Makoto calls Izuku "Midori" for short while he calls her the more formal but still friendly "Koto-san", having met in the past. Makoto also refers to Bakugou "Baka-chan" as both a sign of affection and an insult.


Added DiffLines:

* ChildhoodFriend: Although she's significantly older than Izuku, Makoto was a good friend of his when they were younger and the only girl he could comfortably talk to. She is also implied to have been a MoralityPet for Bakugou, whose behavior worsened after she moved away.

Added: 347

Changed: 69

Removed: 259

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Izuku:''' ''[threatening Pixie]'' A-Alright! G-Give me whatever you have! Money or items... please...?\\
'''Pixie:''' ''[all fear of death gone]'' ...Was that really the best you could do?\\
'''Morgana:''' We really need to work on your execution, Hero...



* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows. Tae loves abusing this for a quick laugh.

to:

* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl.girl even with the confidence boost he gets in the Metaverse. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows. Tae loves abusing this for a quick laugh.



* GrinOfAudacity: Izuku flashes a smile to rival All Might's upon awakening his Persona.



* ThreatBackfire: Izuku's lack of confidence and sheer niceness means that most Shadows are hardly impressed with his attempts to perform a Hold Up until Ryuji steps in to pick up the slack.

to:

* ThreatBackfire: Izuku's lack of confidence and sheer niceness means that most Shadows are hardly impressed with his attempts to perform a Hold Up until Ryuji steps and Morgana step in to pick up the slack.slack.
-->'''Izuku:''' ''[threatening Pixie]'' A-Alright! G-Give me whatever you have! Money or items... please...?\\
'''Pixie:''' ''[all fear of death gone]'' ...Was that really the best you could do?\\
'''Morgana:''' We really need to work on your execution, Hero...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Izuku:''' ''[blanching while trying to push Ann out of the Metaverse to safety]'' S-s-sorry, Takamaki-senpai! ''[internally]'' This is for her own good, this is for her own good! D-don't think J-Just pull her along to safety!\\
'''Ann:''' ''[to Ryuji]'' H-Hey! Where did you just touch me?!\\
'''Ryuji:''' O-oh, s-sorry! I was-y-you were struggling too much and-that's not important! I-Izuku! Get a better hold on her!\\
'''Izuku:''' ''[face red-hot with sweat pouring down his face]'' I-I can't... I'm at my limit... ''[internally]'' I-I'm actually touching a girl! Thi-this is..! Th-think of it like Koto-san, think of it like Koto-san!\\
'''Ryuji:''' ''[as Izuku faints in and out]'' Dude, focus!


Added DiffLines:

-->'''Ann:''' If it makes you feel better, there's now way I can see you as being as bad as all that. If anything, you're almost... the opposite of what I expected after hearing all the rumors.\\
'''Izuku:''' ''[sheepish chuckle]'' Y-yeah, I've gotten that a few times...

Added: 675

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceGuy: Even after everything that's happened to him, Izuku refuses to let it affect how he treats others and continues to be an extremely kind and empathetic young man. He doesn't judge Ryuji for his appearance, is quick to help Morgana out of his cage, and gives Ann someone to talk to about her troubles with Kamoshida. This works against him in his work as a thief, since he's decidedly non-threatening compared to his teammates, but it does make Pixie join him and neither she nor Bicorn hold it against him when he selects them for fusion and thus execution. She even lampshades the fact.
-->'''Pixie:''' I guess you're the type who tries to be nice to everyone, huh?



* SamaritanSyndrome: Izuku is initially hesitant to steal the treasure of Kamoshida's heart due to questioning the morality of HeelFaceBrainwashing and being terrified of the thought of killing the man by accident. [[spoiler:He changes his tune after Shiho attempts to leap to her death, though he still insists on ThouShaltNotKill and plans to turn himself and shoulder all the blame for Kamoshida's murder if they accidentally kill him because he feels that [[IfYouKillHimYoullBejustLikeHim he'll be no better]] than a [[TheseHandsHaveKilled Villain if he doesn't.]]]]

to:

* SamaritanSyndrome: Izuku is initially hesitant to steal the treasure of Kamoshida's heart due to questioning the morality of HeelFaceBrainwashing and being terrified of the thought of killing the man by accident. [[spoiler:He changes his tune after Shiho attempts to leap to her death, though he still insists on ThouShaltNotKill and plans to turn himself and shoulder all the blame for Kamoshida's murder if they accidentally kill him because he feels that [[IfYouKillHimYoullBejustLikeHim [[IfYouKillHimYouWillBeJustLikeHim he'll be no better]] than a [[TheseHandsHaveKilled Villain if he doesn't.]]]]

Added: 433

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: Much like the source material, the Phantom Thieves are all people who are ostracized in a society that has wronged them and turns a blind eye to their pain and suffering.



* ThouShaltNotKill: No matter how vile the target is, Izuku refuses to do anything that could potentially kill them, causing his hesitation when faced with the fact that running rampant in Kamoshida's psyche could potentially kill the man.



''[after Izuku wakes up from the several-hour-long coma the drink put him in]'' Are you out of your mind? We've only met twice before this and you just accept some strange medicine from me? Only an idiot would rink that...

to:

''[after Izuku wakes up from the several-hour-long coma the drink put him in]'' Are you out of your mind? We've only met twice before this and you just accept some strange medicine from me? Only an idiot would rink drink that...

Added: 341

Changed: 107

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChronicHeroSyndrome: Deconstructed as per its source material. Izuku's thoughtless attempts to help a woman in trouble ends with him getting on the bad side of a man with connections in the government that let him easily rig a trial so that he walks away scot-free while Izuku is left with a year's parole and a permanent assault charge on his record.

to:

* ChronicHeroSyndrome: Deconstructed as per its source material. Izuku's thoughtless attempts to help a woman in trouble ends with him getting on the bad side of a man with connections in the government that let him easily rig government. The encounter ends with a rigged trial so that he walks away scot-free while Izuku is left with a year's parole and a permanent assault charge on his record.record on top of missing the U.A. Entrance Exam because of said trial.
* ClarkKentOutfit: Even without All Might to guide him, Izuku ends up getting into a routine of jogging and working out in preparation for the U.A. Entrance Exam, continuing this routine even after the trial. While he looks "fairly average" with his clothes on, he's also described as "quite well built" when seen shirtless or in a tank-top.

Added: 1611

Changed: 258

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Izuku:''' ''[threatening Pixie]'' A-Alright! G-Give me whatever you have! Money or items... please...?\\
'''Pixie:''' ''[all fear of death gone]'' ...Was that really the best you could do?\\
'''Morgana:''' We really need to work on your execution, Hero...



* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows.

to:

* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows. Tae loves abusing this for a quick laugh.



* HeroWorshipper: Izuku still looks up to All Might and the other Heroes even after reality sinks in as he realizes that he'll never be able to be like them. Even his Persona, Carter, wears a necklace with All Might's smiling face on it.



* TheLeader: Even though he's the youngest among them, Izuku's raw capability leads Ann, Morgana, and Ryuji to name Izuku the leader, taking aspects of the Levelheaded (his role as TheStrategist and being generally clear-headed), Headstrong (his ChronicHeroSyndrome), and Charistmatic (his ability to bring people together through his sheer niceness as his status a a Wild Card) types.



* MovieSuperheroesWearBlack: Izuku's Phantom Thief outfit is a black and red version of the second version of his canon costume with the addition of Ren's BadassLongcoat.

to:

* MagneticHero: His sheer niceness ends up drawing the Phantom Thieves to him on top of his status as a Wild Card. Then there's the Shadows who become his Personas.
* MovieSuperheroesWearBlack: Izuku's Phantom Thief outfit is a black and red version of the second version of his canon costume with the addition of Ren's BadassLongcoat.BadassLongcoat and All Might-like attachments to his mask.


Added DiffLines:

* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku's criminal record underscores this, since he can barely speak with anyone without them judging him for having an assault charge on his record even as he tries to treat everyone around him nicely. His tendency to stutter also makes him far less threatening when attempting to negotiate with Shadows.
* ThreatBackfire: Izuku's lack of confidence and sheer niceness means that most Shadows are hardly impressed with his attempts to perform a Hold Up until Ryuji steps in to pick up the slack.

Added: 808

Changed: 617

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SamaritanSyndrome: Izuku is initially hesitant to steal the treasure of Kamoshida's heart due questioning the morality of HeelFaceBrainwashing and being terrified of the thought of killing the man by accident. [[spoiler:He changes his tune after Shiho attempts to leap to her death, though he still insists on ThouShaltNotKill and plans to turn himself and shoulder all the blame for Kamoshida's murder if they accidentally kill him because he feels that [[IfYouKillHimYoullBejustLikeHim he'll be no better]] than a [[TheseHandsHaveKilledVillain if he doesn't.]]]]

to:

* RighteousRabbit: The Shadows mistake the parts of Izuku's mask shaped like All Might's hair for rabbit ears, causing an imp to refer to him as "bunny ears" as everyone else begins to take notice.
* SamaritanSyndrome: Izuku is initially hesitant to steal the treasure of Kamoshida's heart due to questioning the morality of HeelFaceBrainwashing and being terrified of the thought of killing the man by accident. [[spoiler:He changes his tune after Shiho attempts to leap to her death, though he still insists on ThouShaltNotKill and plans to turn himself and shoulder all the blame for Kamoshida's murder if they accidentally kill him because he feels that [[IfYouKillHimYoullBejustLikeHim he'll be no better]] than a [[TheseHandsHaveKilledVillain [[TheseHandsHaveKilled Villain if he doesn't.]]]]


Added DiffLines:

* ShockAndAwe: Aside from his canon affinity for the Zio line, Ryuji's Quirk allows him to charge himself up with electricity to run extra first for a short duration, though he admits that it was a lot more useful before he broke his leg.

Added: 682

Changed: 871

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl.

to:

* ButtMonkey: Izuku is on the receiving end of much of the story's verbal and physical slapstick, whether it's getting a chop on the head from Makoto after worrying her, getting teased for his Hero obsession by Morgana, or knocking himself out with the horrid potion cooked up by Tae.
* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl. The only girl he's remotely comfortable with at first is Makoto and he constantly has to talk himself into acting like she's there whenever he's conversing with a girl he only barely knows.
* CharacterTics: Izuku's mumble storms are still in full force, causing everyone to lampshade and point it out to him.



* GargleBlaster: The concoction Tae has Izuku drink to test his bravery was designed to release an odor comparable to [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surstr%C3%B6mming Surstr%C3%B6mming]], the world's worst smelling food, upon making contact with stomach acid. The horrid smell that it produces is enough to put Izuku in a coma for several hours and cause him to repeatedly fade in and out of consciousness. The taste wasn't much better, since it was an eye-opening mix of bitter and sour that Izuku only barely managed to get down.
* InelegantBlubbering: Izuku breaks down into inelegant tears, snot, and drool after [[spoiler:he fails to stop Shiho from attempting suicide.]]

to:

* GargleBlaster: The concoction Tae has Izuku drink to test his bravery was designed to release an odor comparable to [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surstr%C3%B6mming Surstr%C3%B6mming]], org/wiki/Surströmming Surströmming]], the world's worst smelling food, upon making contact with stomach acid. The horrid smell that it produces is enough to put Izuku in a coma for several hours and cause him to repeatedly fade in and out of consciousness. The taste wasn't much better, since it was an eye-opening mix of bitter and sour that Izuku only barely managed to get down.
* HeroWithBadPublicity: Izuku is probably the single nicest person you'll ever meet, but his criminal record means that people jump to conclusions about him without getting to know him or even asking for the context behind the assault charge. Because of this, the Phantom Thieves and Makoto are his only friends. Ann even lampshades this, telling him that he was the exact opposite of what she expected after slowing down and having a one-on-one conversation with him.
* InelegantBlubbering: Izuku breaks down into inelegant and lets the tears, snot, and drool fall after [[spoiler:he fails to stop Shiho from attempting suicide.]]

Added: 1036

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffectionateNickname: Makoto calls Izuku "Midori" for short while he calls her the more formal but still friendly "Koto-san", having met in the past.



* ExtremeOmnivore: Ann's Quirk allows her to bite through nearly anything, much to her embarrassment, as she's chewed through at least four forks and countless chopsticks in the past.
* GargleBlaster: The concoction Tae has Izuku drink to test his bravery was designed to release an odor comparable to [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surstr%C3%B6mming Surstr%C3%B6mming]], the world's worst smelling food, upon making contact with stomach acid. The horrid smell that it produces is enough to put Izuku in a coma for several hours and cause him to repeatedly fade in and out of consciousness. The taste wasn't much better, since it was an eye-opening mix of bitter and sour that Izuku only barely managed to get down.



* MovieSuperheroesWearBlack: Izuku's Phantom Thief outfit is a black and red version of the second version of his canon costume with the addition of Ren's BadassLongcoat.



* SimpleStaff: In contrast to Ren Amamiya's status as a KnifeNut, Izuku prefers to use a staff alongside a revolver sidearm. His Persona, Carter, is very much a case of HeroesPreferSwords.

to:

* SimpleStaff: In contrast to Ren Amamiya's status as a KnifeNut, Izuku prefers to use a staff alongside a revolver sidearm. His But his Persona, Carter, is very much a case of HeroesPreferSwords.

Added: 2730

Changed: 353

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNameChange: Due to his long-held dream of becoming a Hero, Ryuji decides that "Joker" simply doesn't fit Izuku as a CodeName, prompting him to call Izuku "Hero" while acting as a Phantom Thief.



* InelegantBlubbering: Izuku breaks down into inelegant tears, snot, and drool after [[spoiler:he fails to stop Shiho from attempting suicide.]]
* JapanesePoliteness: Izuku struggles to use anything other than proper Japanese honorifics to refer to others, constantly stumbling over his own words when Ryuji tells him to just call him by his given name, eventually settling on the only somewhat informal "Ryuji-senpai".



* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Two-fold here. On top of the social stigma that comes with having a criminal record, Izuku is burdened with the fact that he'll ''never'' be able to enroll at a Hero school or find a job at a Hero office with that assault label on his record, which brings him to tears on multiple occasions.

to:

* LuminescentBlush: Frequently out of embarrassment, whether he's talking to a girl or if Morgana is teasing him by revealing something he'd rather keep hidden.
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Two-fold here. On top of the social stigma that comes with having a criminal record, Izuku is burdened with the fact that he'll ''never'' be able to enroll at a Hero school or find a job at a Hero office with that assault label on his record, which brings him to tears on multiple occasions.occasions.
* PintSizedPowerhouse: Izuku is the holder of the Fool Arcana but is only a first-year high school student versus his teammates' status as second and third-year students. As a result, he's shorter than most of them, but is still acknowledged as the most capable and powerful overall.
* SamaritanSyndrome: Izuku is initially hesitant to steal the treasure of Kamoshida's heart due questioning the morality of HeelFaceBrainwashing and being terrified of the thought of killing the man by accident. [[spoiler:He changes his tune after Shiho attempts to leap to her death, though he still insists on ThouShaltNotKill and plans to turn himself and shoulder all the blame for Kamoshida's murder if they accidentally kill him because he feels that [[IfYouKillHimYoullBejustLikeHim he'll be no better]] than a [[TheseHandsHaveKilledVillain if he doesn't.]]]]
* SherlockScan: The Third Eye, as per the source material, allows Izuku to do this.
* SimpleStaff: In contrast to Ren Amamiya's status as a KnifeNut, Izuku prefers to use a staff alongside a revolver sidearm. His Persona, Carter, is very much a case of HeroesPreferSwords.
* TooDumbToLive: Tae accuses Izuku of being this when he agrees to down an unknown concoction from a woman he's only met twice if it means getting a part-time job and discounts on potentially life-saving (but barely legal) medicine for the Phantom Thieves.
-->'''Tae:''' Okay... wow. You actually drank it... color me impressed because I honestly didn't think you had the guts to do it. You're definitely braver than I thought... or dumber...\\
''[after Izuku wakes up from the several-hour-long coma the drink put him in]'' Are you out of your mind? We've only met twice before this and you just accept some strange medicine from me? Only an idiot would rink that...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/thieves_can_be_heroes.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:"If they are the heroes of the seen, we can be the heroes of the unseen."[[note]][[https://luffyfan1.deviantart.com/art/Thieves-Can-Be-Heroes-Cover-700055549 All credit for the image goes to its original owners]][[/note]]]]

Izuku Midoriya thought he was doing the right thing when he ran down that alleyway to save a woman who was being molested by a drunken man. After all, what kind of Hero could ignore a cry for help? But that man had connections, and the would-be hero soon found himself charged with assault and sentenced to parole in Tokyo for his "violent" act.

It's one thing to become a Hero when you're Quirkless, it's another thing entirely when you also have a criminal record.

With his hopes of achieving his lifelong dream dashed, Izuku gets shipped off to live with a family friend while attending Shujin Academy and serving out his parole, seemingly destined to be forever branded a thug for what he thought would be an act of heroism.

But the gears of fate turn in strange ways. After getting lost on his way to his new high school, the Quirkless teen is soon sucked into the Metaverse, where he would have been killed if not for the awakening of a strange power within him called a "Persona". Now dealing with forces far beyond the world of Heroes and Villains, the once powerless boy soon finds that even Phantom Thieves can be heroes in their own right.

''Thieves Can Be Heroes!'' is a ''Manga/MyHeroAcademia'' and ''VideoGame/Persona5'' FusionFic written by [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/3205666/Mugiwara-N0-Luffy Mugiwara N0 Luffy]]. With a Quirkless Izuku taking the place of Persona 5's protagonist, it follows his journey towards becoming a Phantom Thief and using his newfound abilities to unravel the mysteries and conspiracies in Tokyo while doing as much good as he can along the way.

It can be read [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12533988/1/Thieves-Can-Be-Heroes here.]]

!Thieves Can Be Heroes provides examples of:
* AdaptationalSuperpowerChange: Izuku is still Quirkless, but he instead has the power of the Fool Arcana this time around. In addition, his superheroic tendencies have given him Carter for a Persona rather than Arsene.
* {{Adorkable}}: Even with the confidence and power boost he gets while using his Persona, Izuku is still a quintessential NiceGuy who can't even threaten Shadows properly while negotiating with them, frequently stamping on a "please" at the end while making demands. Then there's the fact that he CannotTalkToWomen and his easy-to-fluster nature.
* CannotTalkToWomen: Izuku's inability to speak to girls his age is highlighted in particular here, becoming flustered around any new girl he meets and practically melting when he's asked to trade phone numbers or touch a girl.
* ChronicHeroSyndrome: Deconstructed as per its source material. Izuku's thoughtless attempts to help a woman in trouble ends with him getting on the bad side of a man with connections in the government that let him easily rig a trial so that he walks away scot-free while Izuku is left with a year's parole and a permanent assault charge on his record.
* LightEmUp: Carter is able to able to throw balls of light imbued with the Bless-attribute in contrast to Arsene's Curse-attribute.
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Two-fold here. On top of the social stigma that comes with having a criminal record, Izuku is burdened with the fact that he'll ''never'' be able to enroll at a Hero school or find a job at a Hero office with that assault label on his record, which brings him to tears on multiple occasions.

Top