Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / TheAlternityParadox

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Chained sinkholes.


* [[OurMonstersAreWeird Our Shadows Are Weirder]]: Some of the new Shadows introduced in the fic can be kind of...freaky, to say the least. Examples are the [[GiantSpider Mother]] [[DemonicSpider Spider]], her [[SpiderSwarm child]][[WaveOfBabies ren]], and the [[CatsAreMean Ice Behemoth]].

to:

* [[OurMonstersAreWeird Our Shadows Are Weirder]]: OurMonstersAreWeird: Some of the new Shadows introduced in the fic can be kind of...freaky, to say the least. Examples are the [[GiantSpider Mother]] [[DemonicSpider Mother Spider]], her [[SpiderSwarm child]][[WaveOfBabies ren]], children]], and the [[CatsAreMean Ice Behemoth]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hurting Hero is a disambiguation


* CharacterDevelopment: Yuka's gone from a [[PluckyGirl cheerful and snarky]] GenkiGirl whose antics manage to annoy even [[TheStoic Makoto Yuki]], to a [[HurtingHero rather downbeat]] and [[BrokenBird much less happy]] yet much more mature ActionGirl.

to:

* CharacterDevelopment: Yuka's gone from a [[PluckyGirl cheerful and snarky]] GenkiGirl whose antics manage to annoy even [[TheStoic Makoto Yuki]], to a [[HurtingHero rather downbeat]] downbeat and [[BrokenBird much less happy]] yet much more mature ActionGirl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was made YMMV and renamed to Diagnosed By The Audience. Removing for not fitting the new definition.


* AmbiguousDisorder: Makoto...tends to swing back and forth repeatedly between being a neutral-faced NiceGuy to a violent and murderous BloodKnight rather easily.
** He actually ''does'' display some traits of borderline personality disorder ([[HatesBeingAlone extreme reactions to abandonment]], [[MoodSwinger intense and highly changeable moods]], and problems with controlling anger).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[OriginalCharacters Satoshi Himuro and Tomoya Kitamura]] are Nice Guys, too. [[spoiler: And then it turns out they're Time Gods...]]

to:

** [[OriginalCharacters [[OriginalCharacter Satoshi Himuro and Tomoya Kitamura]] are Nice Guys, too. [[spoiler: And then it turns out they're Time Gods...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope has been disambiguated.


** He actually ''does'' display some traits of borderline personality disorder ([[HatesBeingAlone extreme reactions to abandonment]], [[MoodSwinger intense and highly changeable moods]], and [[{{Wrath}} problems with controlling anger]]).

to:

** He actually ''does'' display some traits of borderline personality disorder ([[HatesBeingAlone extreme reactions to abandonment]], [[MoodSwinger intense and highly changeable moods]], and [[{{Wrath}} problems with controlling anger]]).anger).



* [[spoiler: FakeMemories: Turns out Death implanted these into Makoto's head to prevent him from finding out the truth of the night everything began. So every {{Flashback}} Makoto's had of his past is now put into question]].
* FatalFlaw --> {{Wrath}}: Makoto's lived a life where everybody pretty much mistreated him after his family died, and he's now living a life where the beings responsible for his family's death torment him every chance they get. Makoto's [[{{Understatement}} not pleased at all with this]], but his rage in many a situation has led to some pretty deep divisions between him and his friends, who often get freaked out by how utterly '''angry''' he can become despite his stoic facade.

to:

* [[spoiler: FakeMemories: Turns [[spoiler:Turns out Death implanted these into Makoto's head to prevent him from finding out the truth of the night everything began. So every {{Flashback}} Makoto's had of his past is now put into question]].
* FatalFlaw --> {{Wrath}}: FatalFlaw: Makoto's lived a life where everybody pretty much mistreated him after his family died, and he's now living a life where the beings responsible for his family's death torment him every chance they get. Makoto's [[{{Understatement}} not pleased at all with this]], but his rage in many a situation has led to some pretty deep divisions between him and his friends, who often get freaked out by how utterly '''angry''' he can become despite his stoic facade.



* {{Griefer}}: '''''THE SHADOWS.'''''

to:

* %%* {{Griefer}}: '''''THE SHADOWS.'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking per TRS decision.


* BiTheWay: Yuka and [[TeenIdol Rise]] are the OfficialCouple of the fic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackAndGrayMorality: Makoto is unquestioningly on the side of good, but there are multiple occasions wherein he becomes pretty morally grey, and it's especially shown in how ruthless he is in battle. Opposite him are the Shadows, EldritchAbominations that are either AlwaysChaoticEvil and FauxAffablyEvil.

to:

* BlackAndGrayMorality: Makoto is unquestioningly on the side of good, but there are multiple occasions wherein he becomes pretty morally grey, and it's especially shown in how ruthless he is in battle. Opposite him are the Shadows, EldritchAbominations [[EldritchAbomination EldritchAbominations]] that are either AlwaysChaoticEvil and FauxAffablyEvil.

Added: 308

Removed: 309

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackAndGrayMorality: Makoto is unquestioningly on the side of good, but there are multiple occasions wherein he becomes pretty morally grey, and it's especially shown in how ruthless he is in battle. Opposite him are the Shadows, EldritchAbominations that are either AlwaysChaoticEvil and FauxAffablyEvil.



* GreyAndBlackMorality: Makoto is unquestioningly on the side of good, but there are multiple occasions wherein he becomes pretty morally grey, and it's especially shown in how ruthless he is in battle. Opposite him are the Shadows, Eldritch Abominations that are either AlwaysChaoticEvil and FauxAffablyEvil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The author is also making an official sequel to ''The Alternity Paradox'' titled ''Persona – The Answer to Life and Death'', based ([[CaptainObvious of course]]), on the epilogue to the original game titled, ''The Answer''. There is also a Crossover with the Alternity Universe and the universe of fellow fanfic writer mentioned above, Emiya2004, titled ''Persona Q: Shadows of the Heart''.

to:

The author is also making an official sequel to ''The Alternity Paradox'' titled ''Persona – The Answer to Life and Death'', based ([[CaptainObvious of course]]), on the epilogue to the original game titled, ''The Answer''. There is also a Crossover with the Alternity Universe and the universe of fellow fanfic writer mentioned above, Emiya2004, titled ''Persona Q: Shadows of the Heart''.

Added: 809

Changed: 85

Removed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Better to Reign in Hell]]
* AndNowForSomeoneCompletelyDifferent: [[spoiler: Akira is ''not'' the Wild Card this time around. [[IronLady Makoto]] is]]. [[spoiler: She]] also shares the position of [[spoiler: main protagonist]].

to:

[[folder:Better to [[folder:To Reign in Hell]]
* AndNowForSomeoneCompletelyDifferent: [[spoiler: Akira is ''not'' the Wild Card this time around. [[IronLady Makoto]] is]]. [[spoiler: She]] also shares the position of [[spoiler: main protagonist]].



* {{Deuteragonist}}: Makoto Niijima is the secondary POV character of the story; while it still maintains a first person POV centered largely around Akira himself, it shifts to third-person for Makoto.
* DownerBeginning
* NominalHero: Instead of being a suave AntiHero as in the original game, Akira's more or less a SociopathicHero whose goals more have to do with him deriving satisfaction from stealing the hearts of people worse than himself, rather than actually working to protect others.
* PettheDog: It's made clear that Akira has little to no sympathy or concern towards other people--outside those who've managed to worm their ways into his heart. His relationship with Kana establishes that yes, despite his stoic nature and his apathy to the world around him, he is capable of kindness and even love.



* VillainProtagonist: Going by the description, Akira will become this.

Added: 200

Changed: 88

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/{{Persona 5}}'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12503158/1/Persona-5-The-Wings-of-Rebellion The Wings of Rebellion]]

to:

* ''VideoGame/{{Persona 5}}'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12503158/1/Persona-5-The-Wings-of-Rebellion The Wings of Rebellion]]
net/s/12503158/1/Persona-5-Better-to-Reign-in-Hell Better to Reign in Hell]]



[[folder:The Sad Clown]]

to:

[[folder:The Sad Clown]][[folder:Better to Reign in Hell]]
* AndNowForSomeoneCompletelyDifferent: [[spoiler: Akira is ''not'' the Wild Card this time around. [[IronLady Makoto]] is]]. [[spoiler: She]] also shares the position of [[spoiler: main protagonist]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:The Wings of Rebellion]]

to:

[[folder:The Wings of Rebellion]]Sad Clown]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The author stated that the story is the first in a series of three fanfics he dubs the Alternity Universe. The two other fics in the series are:

to:

The author stated that the story is the first in a series of three fanfics he dubs the Alternity Universe. The two other fics in the series are:

Changed: 1608

Removed: 2610

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/{{Persona 5}}'' fics:
** ''Persona 5'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10779858/1/Persona-5-The-Fight-for-Emancipation-Route-I-The-Other-Prisoner The Fight for Emancipation, Route I: The Other Prisoner]]
** ''Persona 5'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10966977/1/Persona-5-The-Fight-for-Emancipation-Route-II-The-True-Prisoner The Fight for Emancipation, Route II: The True Prisoner]]

to:

* ''VideoGame/{{Persona 5}}'' fics:
** ''Persona 5'':
5}}'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10779858/1/Persona-5-The-Fight-for-Emancipation-Route-I-The-Other-Prisoner net/s/12503158/1/Persona-5-The-Wings-of-Rebellion The Fight for Emancipation, Route I: The Other Prisoner]]
** ''Persona 5'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10966977/1/Persona-5-The-Fight-for-Emancipation-Route-II-The-True-Prisoner The Fight for Emancipation, Route II: The True Prisoner]]
Wings of Rebellion]]



[[folder:The Fight for Emancipation]]
* AdaptationalWimp: Instead of being the stylish thief the ''Persona 5'' trailer makes him out to be, Akira starts off as an ExtremeDoormat completely trapped under the whims of his father. He refuses to stand up for himself or what he believes is right for fear of rejection, and as such is prone to fits of anger. But by the end of the prologue, he's become more bitter and cynical, but also much more assertive.
** AdaptationalAngstUpgrade
* BrokenBird: The main character, Akira Kanzaki, as opposed to the suave and cool PhantomThief as shown in the trailers for ''Persona 5'' is depicted as a teenager who's got ''way'' too much emotional baggage to handle on his own. [[spoiler: Kana herself turns out to be this as well]].
* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Averted. Akira's dad is, yes, very controlling. But the reason he keeps on grooming Akira to be a businessman and disregard any other job opportunities for him is because he truly thinks being the head of the Kanzaki Corporation is what's best for him.
* CouldHaveAvoidedThisPlot: The moral of the first chapter is '''TALK TO SOMEBODY ABOUT YOUR PROBLEMS'''.
* DarkerAndEdgier: ''Garden of Souls'' provided some much-needed happiness into this universe. So, obviously, the logical thing to do is make things miserable again!
* DarkAndTroubledPast: The prologue is basically Akira's.
* DownerBeginning: The prologue is over 12,000 words of torment for our main character.
* HeroicBSOD: Akira falls into a major one at the end of the '''prologue'''.
* IJustWantToBeFree: Freedom, like the original game, is a major theme within the fic. Kana imparts the importance of being free to make your own decisions to Akira, who is initially completely under the whims of his well-meaning but iron-fisted father. [[spoiler: It's all deconstructed. Because of how important freedom is to Kana, she refuses to be a burden on those she cares about: and as such, she doesn't even try to talk to anyone about her problems because she doesn't want to drag them down. It gets her killed]]. Eventually, [[spoiler: Akira himself adopts the desire to make his own decisions, but at the point he does, he's pretty much lost his closest friend, his love for his father, and his girlfriend]].
* LoveHurts: [[spoiler: Akira and Kana were so young...unfortunately, Kana died young, too]].
* TheLostLenore: [[spoiler: Kana is Akira's]].
* ManicPixieDreamGirl: Tragically deconstructed. [[spoiler: Kana turns out to be kinda messed up]].
* MisanthropeSupreme: It's implied Akira becomes this at the end of the prologue.
* MoodWhiplash: Yay! Akira finds a really good friend in his complete opposite, Kana! And then [[spoiler: Kana's mom dies]].
* PluckyGirl: Kana [[spoiler: acts like she]] is a spunky, snarky, and cheerful young girl who greatly values her own independence. [[spoiler: But then she's revealed to be ''very'' emotionally troubled, and she values independence to such a degree that she refuses to burden others with her problems: which leads to her death]].
* PyrrhicVictory: [[spoiler: So, Akira finally gets the guts to stand up to his dad and make his own decisions. If only he hadn't lost everything else along the way]].
* SanitySlippage: [[spoiler: Losing his girlfriend to a [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil sick rapist]] is a ''pretty good reason'' for this happening to Akira]].
* StartOfDarkness: [[spoiler: Akira [[EyeScream presses his thumbs into his father's eyes]] before beating him down and reducing him to a whimpering mess on the floor]]. '''Low.'''
* StepfordSmiler: [[spoiler: Kana is a HUGE one.]]

to:

[[folder:The Fight for Emancipation]]
* AdaptationalWimp: Instead
Wings of being the stylish thief the ''Persona 5'' trailer makes him out to be, Akira starts off as an ExtremeDoormat completely trapped under the whims of his father. He refuses to stand up for himself or what he believes is right for fear of rejection, and as such is prone to fits of anger. But by the end of the prologue, he's become more bitter and cynical, but also much more assertive.
** AdaptationalAngstUpgrade
* BrokenBird: The main character, Akira Kanzaki, as opposed to the suave and cool PhantomThief as shown in the trailers for ''Persona 5'' is depicted as a teenager who's got ''way'' too much emotional baggage to handle on his own. [[spoiler: Kana herself turns out to be this as well]].
* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Averted. Akira's dad is, yes, very controlling. But the reason he keeps on grooming Akira to be a businessman and disregard any other job opportunities for him is because he truly thinks being the head of the Kanzaki Corporation is what's best for him.
* CouldHaveAvoidedThisPlot: The moral of the first chapter is '''TALK TO SOMEBODY ABOUT YOUR PROBLEMS'''.
Rebellion]]
* DarkerAndEdgier: ''Garden Compared to ''[[LighterAndSofter Garden of Souls'' provided some much-needed happiness into Souls]]'', it will most likely end up this universe. So, obviously, the logical thing to do is make things miserable again!
* DarkAndTroubledPast: The prologue is basically Akira's.
* DownerBeginning: The prologue is over 12,000 words of torment for our main character.
* HeroicBSOD: Akira falls into
way. ''By a major one at the end of the '''prologue'''.
* IJustWantToBeFree: Freedom, like the original game, is a major theme within the fic. Kana imparts the importance of being free to make your own decisions to Akira, who is initially completely under the whims of his well-meaning but iron-fisted father. [[spoiler: It's all deconstructed. Because of how important freedom is to Kana, she refuses to be a burden on those she cares about: and as such, she doesn't even try to talk to anyone about her problems because she doesn't want to drag them down. It gets her killed]]. Eventually, [[spoiler: Akira himself adopts the desire to make his own decisions, but at the point he does, he's pretty much lost his closest friend, his love for his father, and his girlfriend]].
* LoveHurts: [[spoiler: Akira and Kana were so young...unfortunately, Kana died young, too]].
* TheLostLenore: [[spoiler: Kana is Akira's]].
* ManicPixieDreamGirl: Tragically deconstructed. [[spoiler: Kana turns out to be kinda messed up]].
* MisanthropeSupreme: It's implied Akira becomes this at the end of the prologue.
* MoodWhiplash: Yay! Akira finds a really good friend in his complete opposite, Kana! And then [[spoiler: Kana's mom dies]].
lot''
* PluckyGirl: Kana [[spoiler: Kohaku. She is rather chipper in comparison to our [[TheStoic protagonist]] here.
* TheStoic: Akira doesn't emote that much in front of other people. Though Kana was able to elicit a reaction from him.
* {{Troll}}: Kana certainly
acts like she]] is a spunky, snarky, one; dropping Akira's books and cheerful young girl who greatly values her own independence. [[spoiler: But then she's revealed kicking one of them away from him when he goes to be ''very'' emotionally troubled, and she values independence to such a degree that she refuses to burden others pick them up. All with a smile on her problems: which leads to her death]].
face.
* PyrrhicVictory: [[spoiler: So, VillainProtagonist: Going by the description, Akira finally gets the guts to stand up to his dad and make his own decisions. If only he hadn't lost everything else along the way]].
* SanitySlippage: [[spoiler: Losing his girlfriend to a [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil sick rapist]] is a ''pretty good reason'' for this happening to Akira]].
* StartOfDarkness: [[spoiler: Akira [[EyeScream presses his thumbs into his father's eyes]] before beating him down and reducing him to a whimpering mess on the floor]]. '''Low.'''
* StepfordSmiler: [[spoiler: Kana is a HUGE one.]]
will become this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9513507/1/Persona-3-The-Alternity-Paradox Persona 3: The Alternity Paradox]] is a ''{{Persona 3}}'' fanfiction detailing the journey of the Protagonist in his quest to find out the truth behind the deaths of his parents and his sister, by returning to the city where they had died: his hometown, Iwatodai. That, and he experiences a twenty-fifth hour of the day where the sky turns green, all sources of liquid turn into blood, and people turn into coffins. It's pretty much an AU retelling of the original story which takes a ''ton'' of liberties to the plot, but not enough such that it deviates completely from the original themes and messages of the original game.

to:

[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9513507/1/Persona-3-The-Alternity-Paradox Persona 3: The Alternity Paradox]] is a ''{{Persona 3}}'' ''VideoGame/Persona3'' fanfiction detailing the journey of the Protagonist in his quest to find out the truth behind the deaths of his parents and his sister, by returning to the city where they had died: his hometown, Iwatodai. That, and he experiences a twenty-fifth hour of the day where the sky turns green, all sources of liquid turn into blood, and people turn into coffins. It's pretty much an AU retelling of the original story which takes a ''ton'' of liberties to the plot, but not enough such that it deviates completely from the original themes and messages of the original game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsAllAboutMe: [[spoiler:It's revealed, when The Umbra confronts Makoto for the third time, that Makoto's desires to protect his friends are not necessarily because he cares for them ''as people'', but rather because they both serve as a tether to his own humanity and are there to help him through a rough patch when he needs them.]]

Added: 326

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharacterDevelopment – Like the game, ''everyone'' gets this. But in ''very'' [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation different]] ways as depicted in the game.

to:

* CharacterDevelopment – CharacterDevelopment: Like the game, ''everyone'' gets this. But in ''very'' [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation different]] ways as depicted in the game.ways.


Added DiffLines:

* HeroKiller: [[spoiler:Theodore kills Elizabeth and Hidetoshi with Armageddon.]]


Added DiffLines:

* {{Reconstruction}}: In strict opposition to the bleak and dour tone of the preceding story, ''Garden'' brings back the magic and the joy of the ''Persona'' series in full force while still being a story about personal growth and companionship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnyoneCanDie: Part II's fourth chapter ends with [[spoiler:Hidetoshi and Elizabeth]] dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/{{Persona 4}}'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10145685/1/Persona-4-Book-of-Souls Book of Souls]], written by the author's friend, [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/5001474/Emiya-2004 Emiya2004]].

to:

* ''VideoGame/{{Persona 4}}'': [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10145685/1/Persona-4-Book-of-Souls Book net/s/10145685/1/Persona-4-Garden-of-Souls Garden of Souls]], written by the author's friend, [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/5001474/Emiya-2004 Emiya2004]].



** If anything, a lot of Makoto’s failures are [[FailureHero really of his own doing]]. Numerous confrontations he has with the Shadows ultimately end up so chaotic because he doesn’t go all-out on them. Even in situations where he does go all out, it doesn’t necessarily prove helpful in the long run. There are even times when his violent side ends up making the situation ''worse''.

to:

** If anything, a lot of Makoto’s Makoto’s failures are [[FailureHero really of his own doing]]. Numerous confrontations he has with the Shadows ultimately end up so chaotic because he doesn’t go all-out on them. Even in situations where he does go all out, it doesn’t necessarily prove helpful in the long run. There are even times when his violent side ends up making the situation ''worse''.



[[folder: Book of Souls]]

to:

[[folder: Book Garden of Souls]]



* GenreShift: While ''The Alternity Paradox'' is a cynical and harsh Deconstruction of the ''Persona'' series as a whole, ''Book of Souls'' Reconstructs the universe by adding much more fantastical elements. If ''Alternity Paradox'' focused on the darker aspects of the ''SMT'' games, ''Book of Souls'' certainly focuses on the more extravagant side.

to:

* GenreShift: While ''The Alternity Paradox'' is a cynical and harsh Deconstruction of the ''Persona'' series as a whole, ''Book ''Garden of Souls'' Reconstructs the universe by adding much more fantastical elements. If ''Alternity Paradox'' focused on the darker aspects of the ''SMT'' games, ''Book ''Garden of Souls'' certainly focuses on the more extravagant side.



* SpellBook: ''Grimoire Animus'', the Persona Compendium Yuka used in ''The Alternity Paradox'' comes back here, and is the titular Book of Souls.

to:

* SpellBook: ''Grimoire Animus'', the Persona Compendium Yuka used in ''The Alternity Paradox'' comes back here, and is the titular Book of Souls.here.



* TakingUpTheMantle: Yuka's taken up the role as protagonist, now...and she's not taking any prisoners.

to:

* TakingUpTheMantle: Yuka's taken up the role as protagonist, protagonist now...and she's not taking any prisoners.



* DarkerAndEdgier: ''Book of Souls'' provided some much-needed happiness into this universe. So, obviously, the logical thing to do is make things miserable again!

to:

* DarkerAndEdgier: ''Book ''Garden of Souls'' provided some much-needed happiness into this universe. So, obviously, the logical thing to do is make things miserable again!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenreShift: While ''The Alternity Paradox'' is a cynical and harsh Deconstruction of the ''Persona'' series as a whole, ''Book of Souls'' Reconstructs the universe by adding much more fantastical elements. If ''Alternity Paradox'' focused on the darker aspects of the ''SMT'' games, ''Book of Souls'' certainly focuses on the more extravagant side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Top