Follow TV Tropes

Following

History CriticalExistenceFailure / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Changed: 907

Removed: 2846

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the original ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|1978}}'', battlestars and base ships showed no damage after many hits (because they didn't have spare models to damage), until they exploded. Particularly obvious was a combination of this with overused stock footage. A scene filmed for one episode showed missiles striking a base ship, causing a rapid chain reaction of explosions and then causing the ship to explode. It happened so fast that the explosions didn't have time to fade away, which would have shown that they didn't actually blow up a model. Still, it looked convincing enough... until they reused the footage in another episode. This was their only shot of a missile hit on a base ship. But this time, they had to show a ship hit and not destroyed. So they used the hit shot - and cut away before the final explosion. And, of course, the next shot with the base ship showed no damage.
** ''Extremely'' averted in the [[Series/BattlestarGalactica2003 reimagined series]]. The Galactica looks as beat up as you would think, and grows worse and worse as the series goes on.
* Also seen in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' and ''[[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]]''. The show's budget wasn't high enough to damage and repair the ship models for episodes so we occasionally saw things like the Borg tearing up the Enterprise with cutting beams in an episode, and there would be nary a scratch on the ship after the battle.
** Averted with later series. An entire episode of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' is devoted to damage sustained from flying into a Romulan minefield in the previous episode. Also, when the ship takes damage fighting the Xindi in season 3, the damage remains in place until the ship returns to Earth and can be repaired.
** Used rather JustForFun/{{egregious}}ly in ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. With the exception of the "Year of Hell" two-parter, any damage ''Voyager'' ever sustains is repaired by the next episode, even though they're stuck tens of thousands of light-years from any shipyard capable of handling a Federation capital ship (see also InfiniteSupplies). And they didn't have the "no budget to damage the models" excuse either, since the series used CGI.
** Egregiously doesn't come close to how TNG handled radiation exposure. While the Enterprise [crew] was subject to radiation, T-1 second and no effects whatsoever (not even a mention to show up to sickbay). T+1 second of exposure and presumably everybody was dead. Oddly enough, Star Trek II (Wrath of Khan) was mentioned in one of this editor's physics textbooks as "a fairly accurate portrayal of death by extreme radiation".
* The way angels and demons in ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' die is an interesting example. They can be nicked, sliced, and tortured using their respective [[AchillesHeel magic knives]] for seemingly forever until they get stabbed once with it in the heart or gut and then they die rather spectacularly. One is left to wonder what property it is exactly of the knife that's doing the killing. Lots of monsters on the show work the same way, able to take a seemingly unlimited amount of damage from whatever weapon it is that is supposed to kill them until you stab them in the right place and then they die all at once.
* ''Series/KamenRiderExAid'': the Rider's uniforms have a [[LifeMeter Rider Gauge]] that determines how much damage they are able to endure. The moment the gauge becomes empty, their bodies will begin to vanish. Until then, however, they are perfectly capable of continuing to fight. Most Riders' [[TransformationTrinket Game Drivers]] have a failsafe installed that automatically terminates their transformation if their Rider Gauge starts to run low, so as to prevent potential death.
----

to:

* In the original ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|1978}}'', battlestars and base ships showed no damage after many hits (because they didn't have spare models to damage), until they exploded. Particularly obvious was a combination of this with overused stock footage. A scene filmed for one episode showed missiles striking a base ship, causing a rapid chain reaction of explosions and then causing the ship to explode. It happened so fast that the explosions didn't have time to fade away, which would have shown that they didn't actually blow up a model. Still, it looked convincing enough... until they reused the footage in another episode. This was their only shot of a missile hit on a base ship. But this time, they had to show a ship hit and not destroyed. So they used the hit shot - and cut away before the final explosion. And, of course, the next shot with the base ship showed no damage.
** ''Extremely'' averted in the [[Series/BattlestarGalactica2003 reimagined series]]. The Galactica looks as beat up as you would think, and grows worse and worse as the series goes on.
* Also seen in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' and ''[[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]]''. The show's budget wasn't high enough to damage and repair the ship models for episodes so we occasionally saw things like the Borg tearing up the Enterprise with cutting beams in an episode, and there would be nary a scratch on the ship after the battle.
** Averted with later series. An entire episode of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' is devoted to damage sustained from flying into a Romulan minefield in the previous episode. Also, when the ship takes damage fighting the Xindi in season 3, the damage remains in place until the ship returns to Earth and can be repaired.
** Used rather JustForFun/{{egregious}}ly in ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. With the exception of the "Year of Hell" two-parter, any damage ''Voyager'' ever sustains is repaired by the next episode, even though they're stuck tens of thousands of light-years from any shipyard capable of handling a Federation capital ship (see also InfiniteSupplies). And they didn't have the "no budget to damage the models" excuse either, since the series used CGI.
** Egregiously doesn't come close to how TNG handled radiation exposure. While the Enterprise [crew] was subject to radiation, T-1 second and no effects whatsoever (not even a mention to show up to sickbay). T+1 second of exposure and presumably everybody was dead. Oddly enough, Star Trek II (Wrath of Khan) was mentioned in one of this editor's physics textbooks as "a fairly accurate portrayal of death by extreme radiation".
* The way angels and demons in ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' die is an interesting example. They can be nicked, sliced, and tortured using their respective [[AchillesHeel magic knives]] for seemingly forever until they get stabbed once with it in the heart or gut and then they die rather spectacularly. One is left to wonder what property it is exactly of the knife that's doing the killing. Lots of monsters on the show work the same way, able to take a seemingly unlimited amount of damage from whatever weapon it is that is supposed to kill them until you stab them in the right place and then they die all at once.
* ''Series/KamenRiderExAid'': the Rider's uniforms have a [[LifeMeter Rider Gauge]] that determines how much damage they are able to endure. The moment the gauge becomes empty, their bodies will begin to vanish. Until then, however, they are perfectly capable of continuing to fight. Most Riders' [[TransformationTrinket Game Drivers]] have a failsafe installed that automatically terminates their transformation if their Rider Gauge starts to run low, so as to prevent potential death.
----
[[redirect:CriticalExistenceFailure]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Used rather {{egregious}}ly in ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. With the exception of the "Year of Hell" two-parter, any damage ''Voyager'' ever sustains is repaired by the next episode, even though they're stuck tens of thousands of light-years from any shipyard capable of handling a Federation capital ship (see also InfiniteSupplies). And they didn't have the "no budget to damage the models" excuse either, since the series used CGI.

to:

** Used rather {{egregious}}ly JustForFun/{{egregious}}ly in ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. With the exception of the "Year of Hell" two-parter, any damage ''Voyager'' ever sustains is repaired by the next episode, even though they're stuck tens of thousands of light-years from any shipyard capable of handling a Federation capital ship (see also InfiniteSupplies). And they didn't have the "no budget to damage the models" excuse either, since the series used CGI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/KamenRiderExAid'': the Rider's uniforms have a [[LifeMeter Rider Gauge]] that determines how much damage they are able to endure. The moment the gauge becomes empty, their bodies will begin to vanish. Until then, however, they are perfectly capable of continuing to fight. Most Riders' [[TransformationTrinket Game Drivers]] have a failsafe installed that automatically terminates their transformation if their Rider Gauge starts to run low, so as to prevent potential death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Egregiously doesn't come close to how TNG handled radiation exposure. While the Enterprise [crew] was subject to radiation, T-1 second and no effects whatsoever (not even a mention to show up to sickbay). T+1 second of exposure and presumably everybody was dead. Oddly enough, Star Trek II (Wrath of Khan) was mentioned in one of this editor's physics textbooks as "a fairly accurate portrayal of death by extreme radiation".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the original ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|Classic}}'', battlestars and base ships showed no damage after many hits (because they didn't have spare models to damage), until they exploded. Particularly obvious was a combination of this with overused stock footage. A scene filmed for one episode showed missiles striking a base ship, causing a rapid chain reaction of explosions and then causing the ship to explode. It happened so fast that the explosions didn't have time to fade away, which would have shown that they didn't actually blow up a model. Still, it looked convincing enough... until they reused the footage in another episode. This was their only shot of a missile hit on a base ship. But this time, they had to show a ship hit and not destroyed. So they used the hit shot - and cut away before the final explosion. And, of course, the next shot with the base ship showed no damage.
** ''Extremely'' averted in the [[Series/BattlestarGalacticaReimagined reimagined series]]. The Galactica looks as beat up as you would think, and grows worse and worse as the series goes on.

to:

* In the original ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|Classic}}'', Galactica|1978}}'', battlestars and base ships showed no damage after many hits (because they didn't have spare models to damage), until they exploded. Particularly obvious was a combination of this with overused stock footage. A scene filmed for one episode showed missiles striking a base ship, causing a rapid chain reaction of explosions and then causing the ship to explode. It happened so fast that the explosions didn't have time to fade away, which would have shown that they didn't actually blow up a model. Still, it looked convincing enough... until they reused the footage in another episode. This was their only shot of a missile hit on a base ship. But this time, they had to show a ship hit and not destroyed. So they used the hit shot - and cut away before the final explosion. And, of course, the next shot with the base ship showed no damage.
** ''Extremely'' averted in the [[Series/BattlestarGalacticaReimagined [[Series/BattlestarGalactica2003 reimagined series]]. The Galactica looks as beat up as you would think, and grows worse and worse as the series goes on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added an example from Supernatural, because there aren\'t a lot of those on this wiki




Added DiffLines:

*The way angels and demons in ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' die is an interesting example. They can be nicked, sliced, and tortured using their respective [[AchillesHeel magic knives]] for seemingly forever until they get stabbed once with it in the heart or gut and then they die rather spectacularly. One is left to wonder what property it is exactly of the knife that's doing the killing. Lots of monsters on the show work the same way, able to take a seemingly unlimited amount of damage from whatever weapon it is that is supposed to kill them until you stab them in the right place and then they die all at once.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





** Averted with later series. An entire episode of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' is devoted to damage sustained from flying into a Romulan minefield in the previous episode.

to:

** Averted with later series. An entire episode of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' is devoted to damage sustained from flying into a Romulan minefield in the previous episode. Also, when the ship takes damage fighting the Xindi in season 3, the damage remains in place until the ship returns to Earth and can be repaired.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



* In the original ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|Classic}}'', battlestars and base ships showed no damage after many hits (because they didn't have spare models to damage), until they exploded. Particularly obvious was a combination of this with overused stock footage. A scene filmed for one episode showed missiles striking a base ship, causing a rapid chain reaction of explosions and then causing the ship to explode. It happened so fast that the explosions didn't have time to fade away, which would have shown that they didn't actually blow up a model. Still, it looked convincing enough... until they reused the footage in another episode. This was their only shot of a missile hit on a base ship. But this time, they had to show a ship hit and not destroyed. So they used the hit shot - and cut away before the final explosion. And, of course, the next shot with the base ship showed no damage.
** ''Extremely'' averted in the [[Series/BattlestarGalacticaReimagined reimagined series]]. The Galactica looks as beat up as you would think, and grows worse and worse as the series goes on.
* Also seen in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' and ''[[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]]''. The show's budget wasn't high enough to damage and repair the ship models for episodes so we occasionally saw things like the Borg tearing up the Enterprise with cutting beams in an episode, and there would be nary a scratch on the ship after the battle.
** Averted with later series. An entire episode of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' is devoted to damage sustained from flying into a Romulan minefield in the previous episode.
** Used rather {{egregious}}ly in ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. With the exception of the "Year of Hell" two-parter, any damage ''Voyager'' ever sustains is repaired by the next episode, even though they're stuck tens of thousands of light-years from any shipyard capable of handling a Federation capital ship (see also InfiniteSupplies). And they didn't have the "no budget to damage the models" excuse either, since the series used CGI.
----

Top