Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / SurviveBlockIsland

Go To

OR

Added: 1171

Changed: 533

Removed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 1. Orchestrates (or attempts as much) the eliminations of several players, openly backstabs and burns bridges with the rest of the cast (including Joe, his number one ally), and generally being quite the thorn in everyone's side.

to:

* BigBadDuumvirate: With Barbara, as the main antagonists for season 1.
**
BigBad: The main antagonist Between the two, however, Alfredo is the more openly antagonistic and villainous of Season 1. Orchestrates the two. He orchestrates (or attempts as much) the eliminations of several players, openly backstabs and burns bridges with the rest of the cast (including Joe, his number one ally), and generally being is quite the thorn in everyone's side.



* BigBadDuumvirate: With Alfredo, as the main antagonists for season 1.
** LesserOfTwoEvils: While she may have worked with Alfredo throughout the game, between the two she was much more openly friendly to rest of the cast. These stronger bonds were part of what allowed her to win over the jury.



* LesserOfTwoEvils: While she may have worked with Alfredo throughout the game, between the two she was much more openly friendly to rest of the cast. These stronger bonds were part of what allowed her to win over the jury.



* BigBadDuumvirate: With Michael, as the main antagonists of season 2.
** FinalBoss: And he's ultimately upgraded to the final threat to the remaining players in the finale once Michael gets eliminated.



->'''Occupation(s):''' Trying to Be Nice; A United

to:

->'''Occupation(s):''' Trying to Be Nice; A UnitedNice



* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 2. Blatantly and openly antagonizes those around him, team and alliance alike, uses intimidation and unpredictability to keep people guessing, and happily galavants across the chaos he spurs for no other reason than for a good laugh.

to:

* BigBadDuumvirate: With Blizz, as the main antagonists of season 2.
**
BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 2. Blatantly Though there's no real debate that between the two, Michael's much more malicious with his gameplay. He blatantly and openly antagonizes those around him, team and alliance alike, uses intimidation and unpredictability to keep people guessing, and happily galavants across the chaos he spurs for no other reason than for a good laugh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeadpanSnarker: The single most actively sarcastic, wisecracking player across ''both'' seasons. Nearly ''all'' of his confessionals contain at last a ''little'' bit of snark at someone's expense.

Added: 3236

Changed: 1940

Removed: 1628

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[FailureHero Failure Team]]: Never won a single pre-swap challenge, leaving to over half of them getting knocked out of the game immediately. They only started to pick up steam after the swap.



* FlawlessVictory: Absolutely ''dominate'' the Ice Team- they never lose a ''single'' challenge across the entire pre-merge. The ''only'' reason they lose Jack and Lexi is because they got swapped over. Otherwise, Fire came out unscathed.



-> '''Original Members''': Blessing, Fooya, John, Lindsey, Michael, Meg

to:

[[quoteright:745:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_12_092345.png]]
-> '''Original Members''': Blessing, Fooya, John, Lindsey, Michael, MegMeg, Michael



* [[FailureHero Failure Team]]: Arguably even ''worse'' than the Blue Team in this respect! Across the ''entire'' group, the ''only'' ones with any Minecraft experience to speak of were Lindsey and Michael, and the latter self-admits to not even considering himself that good! Compare that against the Fire Team, who only have a ''single'' player who doesn't play the game, and their downfall was guaranteed out the gate. Expectedly, they don't win a ''single'' challenge across the entire pre-merge, including post-team swap.



->'''Occupation(s):''' Kinda Funny

to:

->'''Occupation(s):''' Kinda FunnyNeeds Salt



* HorribleJudgeOfCharacter: Believes the Ice Team is overall ''strong''. Not only do they got on to lose the first challenge, they never win a ''single'' challenge.



->'''Occupation(s):''' Reality Show Newbie

to:

->'''Occupation(s):''' Reality Show NewbieNewbie; Meg Stan



* {{Fangirl}}: Of Meg. She admits up front that she'll never betray her and won't vote her out.



* RightForTheWrongReasons: Ultimately made a smart decision in allying herself with Meg and Michael, as they quickly prove themselves the strategic backbone of the Ice Team. ''But'' she only actually did so due to how much she admires Meg.



[[folder:Michael]]
!!Michael Jones
[[quoteright:527:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_123759.png]]
[[caption-width-right:527:''"...That's how the game is played."'']]
[[quoteright:484:[[labelnote:Click here to see him irl.]]https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_124219.png]][[/labelnote]]

to:

[[folder:Michael]]
!!Michael Jones
[[quoteright:527:https://static.
[[folder:Meg]]
!!Meg Turney
[[quoteright:396:https://static.
tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_123759.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_123725.png]]
[[caption-width-right:527:''"...That's how the game is played."'']]
[[quoteright:484:[[labelnote:Click
[[caption-width-right:396:''"Boom! Go, baby! All gas, no breaks!"'']]
[[quoteright:337:[[labelnote:Click
here to see him her irl.]]https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_124219.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_124334.png]][[/labelnote]]



->'''Occupation(s):''' Trying to Be Nice

to:

->'''Occupation(s):''' Trying to Be NiceGavin's Much, ''Much'' Better Half



->'''Votes Received:''' 11 [[note]]1 vote in Episode 3; 2 votes (1 vote frozen) in Episode 4; 2 votes (1 vote burned) in Episode 5; 2 votes (nullified by Immunity Totem) in Episode 6; 1 vote in Episode 7; 3 votes in Episode 8[[/note]]
->'''Episode Eliminated:''' Episode 8: You Say it’s Your Birthday
->'''Placement:''' 5th place

to:

->'''Votes Received:''' 11 [[note]]1 vote 5 [[note]]2 votes in Episode 3; 2 votes (1 vote frozen) in Episode 4; 2 votes (1 vote burned) in Episode 5; 7; 2 votes (nullified by Immunity Totem) in Episode 6; 8; 1 vote in Episode 7; 3 votes in Episode 8[[/note]]
9[[/note]]
->'''Episode Eliminated:''' Episode 8: You Say it’s Your Birthday
9: It All Comes Down to Dis
->'''Placement:''' 5th Runner-Up (2 jury votes to win); 2nd place



* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: ''Nobody'' wanted Michael to win. It's saying something that after Episode 2, he receives a vote at ''every Chopping Block'' he attends.
* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 2. Blatantly and openly antagonizes those around him, team and alliance alike, uses intimidation and unpredictability to keep people guessing, and happily galavants across the chaos he spurs for no other reason than for a good laugh.
* BornUnlucky: Never managed to win a ''single'' challenge across ''both'' stages of the game. He has the dubious honor of attending the ''most'' Chopping Blocks of any player across ''both'' seasons with ''8'' total ceremonies attended, ''9'' if you count him attending the jury.
* BreakoutVillain: If you come out of season 2 knowing ''anyone'', it's gonna be Michael. Simply compare the sheer number of tropes he has compared to the rest of the cast if you're not convinced.
* ContrastingSequelAntagonist: Whereas Alfredo was a strategic manipulator and challenge beast who more or less controlled the game from beginning to end with the help of a strong majority alliance, Michael is a chaotic wildcard who had little to no power in the game, was frankly terrible in challenges, and completely lacked in loyal allies, but managed to hang around by the skin of his teeth through sheer willpower and focusing in on bigger threats.
* EarlyBirdCameo: First debuted in the season 1 finale alongside Gavin as a teaser for the next season.
* HeterosexualLifePartners: With Gavin, to the surprise of nobody familiar with Achievement Hunter.
* ThisIsGonnaSuck: Not long after getting put into their teams, Michael comes to the realization he's one of the only people on it that knows how to play Minecraft...And he's of the opinion he ''doesn't'' know what he's doing. [[DeadpanSnarker So...High expectations out the gate]].
* WrongGenreSavvy: When initially told about the Immunity Totems hidden around the island, Michael's immediate instinct was to check under the podium Trevor was speaking from. It doesn't work, but was worth a shot.

to:

* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: ''Nobody'' wanted Michael to win. It's saying something that after Episode 2, he receives a vote at ''every Chopping Block'' he attends.
* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 2. Blatantly and openly antagonizes those around him, team and alliance alike, uses intimidation and unpredictability to keep people guessing, and happily galavants across the chaos he spurs
OfficialCouple: With Gavin. They had been together for no other reason than for a good laugh.
* BornUnlucky: Never managed to win a ''single'' challenge across ''both'' stages of the game. He has the dubious honor of attending the ''most'' Chopping Blocks of any player across ''both'' seasons with ''8'' total ceremonies attended, ''9'' if you count him attending the jury.
* BreakoutVillain: If you come out of season 2 knowing ''anyone'', it's gonna be Michael. Simply compare the sheer number of tropes he has compared to the rest of the cast if you're not convinced.
* ContrastingSequelAntagonist: Whereas Alfredo was a strategic manipulator and challenge beast who more or less controlled the game from beginning to end with the help of a strong majority alliance, Michael is a chaotic wildcard who had little to no power in the game, was frankly terrible in challenges, and completely lacked in loyal allies, but managed to hang around
9-years by the skin time of his teeth through sheer willpower and focusing in on bigger threats.
* EarlyBirdCameo: First debuted in the season 1 finale alongside Gavin as a teaser for the next season.
* HeterosexualLifePartners:
recording.
** LoveIsAWeakness:
With Gavin, to the surprise of nobody familiar with Achievement Hunter.
* ThisIsGonnaSuck: Not long after getting put into their teams, Michael comes to the realization he's one of the only people on it
that said, she also knows how couples tend to play Minecraft...And he's get targeted in these sorts of the opinion he ''doesn't'' know what he's doing. [[DeadpanSnarker So...High expectations out the gate]].
* WrongGenreSavvy: When initially told about the Immunity Totems hidden around the island, Michael's immediate instinct was to check under the podium Trevor was speaking from. It doesn't work, but was worth a shot.
shows, which is why she's glad they got separated onto different teams.



[[folder:Meg]]
!!Meg Turney
[[quoteright:396:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_123725.png]]
[[caption-width-right:396:''"Boom! Go, baby! All gas, no breaks!"'']]
[[quoteright:337:[[labelnote:Click here to see her irl.]]https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_124334.png]][[/labelnote]]

to:

[[folder:Meg]]
!!Meg Turney
[[quoteright:396:https://static.
[[folder:Michael]]
!!Michael Jones
[[quoteright:527:https://static.
tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_123725.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_123759.png]]
[[caption-width-right:396:''"Boom! Go, baby! All gas, no breaks!"'']]
[[quoteright:337:[[labelnote:Click
[[caption-width-right:527:''"...That's how the game is played."'']]
[[quoteright:484:[[labelnote:Click
here to see her him irl.]]https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_124334.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_08_124219.png]][[/labelnote]]



->'''Occupation(s):''' Gavin's Much, ''Much'' Better Half

to:

->'''Occupation(s):''' Gavin's Much, ''Much'' Better HalfTrying to Be Nice; A United



->'''Votes Received:''' 5 [[note]]2 votes in Episode 7; 2 votes (nullified by Immunity Totem) in Episode 8; 1 vote in Episode 9[[/note]]
->'''Episode Eliminated:''' Episode 9: It All Comes Down to Dis
->'''Placement:''' Runner-Up (2 jury votes to win); 2nd place

to:

->'''Votes Received:''' 5 [[note]]2 votes 11 [[note]]1 vote in Episode 7; 3; 2 votes (1 vote frozen) in Episode 4; 2 votes (1 vote burned) in Episode 5; 2 votes (nullified by Immunity Totem) in Episode 8; 6; 1 vote in Episode 9[[/note]]
7; 3 votes in Episode 8[[/note]]
->'''Episode Eliminated:''' Episode 9: It All Comes Down to Dis
8: You Say it’s Your Birthday
->'''Placement:''' Runner-Up (2 jury votes to win); 2nd 5th place



* OfficialCouple: With Gavin. They had been together for 9-years by the time of recording.
** LoveIsAWeakness: With that said, she also knows couples tend to get targeted in these sorts of shows, which is why she's glad they got separated onto different teams.

to:

* OfficialCouple: With Gavin. They ZeroPercentApprovalRating: ''Nobody'' wanted Michael to win. It's saying something that after Episode 2, he receives a vote at ''every Chopping Block'' he attends.
* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 2. Blatantly and openly antagonizes those around him, team and alliance alike, uses intimidation and unpredictability to keep people guessing, and happily galavants across the chaos he spurs for no other reason than for a good laugh.
* BornUnlucky: Never managed to win a ''single'' challenge across ''both'' stages of the game. He has the dubious honor of attending the ''most'' Chopping Blocks of any player across ''both'' seasons with ''8'' total ceremonies attended, ''9'' if you count him attending the jury.
* BreakoutVillain: If you come out of season 2 knowing ''anyone'', it's gonna be Michael. Simply compare the sheer number of tropes he has compared to the rest of the cast if you're not convinced.
* ContrastingSequelAntagonist: Whereas Alfredo was a strategic manipulator and challenge beast who more or less controlled the game from beginning to end with the help of a strong majority alliance, Michael is a chaotic wildcard who
had been together for 9-years little to no power in the game, was frankly terrible in challenges, and completely lacked in loyal allies, but managed to hang around by the time skin of recording.
** LoveIsAWeakness:
his teeth through sheer willpower and focusing in on bigger threats.
* EarlyBirdCameo: First debuted in the season 1 finale alongside Gavin as a teaser for the next season.
* HeterosexualLifePartners:
With Gavin, to the surprise of nobody familiar with Achievement Hunter.
* ItAmusedMe: Decides to ally with Fooya because he "delights in her ignorance".
* ThisIsGonnaSuck: Not long after getting put into their teams, Michael comes to the realization he's one of the only people on it
that said, she also knows couples tend how to get targeted in these sorts play Minecraft...And he's of shows, which is why she's glad they got separated onto different teams.the opinion he ''doesn't'' know what he's doing. [[DeadpanSnarker So...High expectations out the gate]].
* WrongGenreSavvy: When initially told about the Immunity Totems hidden around the island, Michael's immediate instinct was to check under the podium Trevor was speaking from. It doesn't work, but was worth a shot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BreakoutVillain: If you come out of season 2 knowing ''anyone'', it's gonna be Michael. Simply compare the sheer number of tropes he has compared to the rest of the cast if you're not convinced.

Added: 2839

Changed: 455

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:545:''"Hello, hello, blockheads! Welcome to your first challenge!"'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:545:''"Hello, hello, blockheads! Welcome to your first challenge!"'']]blockheads!"'']]



* {{Expy}}: Rather obviously of Survivor's own Jeff Probst, down to wearing a skin of him.



!!Original Red Team

to:

!!Original Red !!Red Team



!!Original Blue Team

to:

!!Original Blue !!Blue Team



!!Original Team Fire

[[folder:Team Fire]]

to:

!!Original Team Fire

[[folder:Team Fire]]
!!Fire Team

[[folder:In General]]
[[quoteright:698:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_11_155702.png]]



->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team FireFire Team



* AscendedExtra: To the greater Rooster Teeth company at large; he was hired for the podcast, "[= F**kFace =]" after the season.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team FireFire Team



->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire
->'''Occupation(s):''' Producer

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire
Fire Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' ProducerStacked Team Fan



* AscendedExtra: To the greater Rooster Teeth company at large; he was hired as a producer after the season.
* MyFriendsAndZoidberg: The rare time where the person ''in question'' thinks they're the Zoidberg. On a team full of what he perceives as stacked players, he can't help but notice he's the odd one out.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team FireFire Team



* HeterosexualLifePartners: With Michael, to the surprise of nobody familiar with Achievement Hunter.
* OfficialCouple: With Meg. [[{{Polyamory}} And maybe Michael]].



->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire
->'''Occupation(s):''' Achievement Hunter

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire
Fire Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' Achievement HunterLied on His Application



* HonorBeforeReason: Doesn't want to backstab anyone or betray the interest of those around him...In a game where only ''one'' person can win with a heavy strategic element. {{Lampshaded}} when he explains himself he doesn't think this game is designed around his particularly skillset.
* NiceGuy: Arguably ''the'' nicest guy across ''both'' seasons. Jack doesn't have a single mean bone in his body.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Fire

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team FireFire Team



!!Original Team Ice

[[folder:Team Ice]]

to:

!!Original Team Ice

[[folder:Team Ice]]
!!Ice Team

[[folder:In General]]



->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team IceIce Team



->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
->'''Occupation(s):''' Unassociated with Rooster Teeth (Streamer)

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
Ice Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' Unassociated with Rooster Teeth (Streamer)Reality Show Newbie



->'''Placement:''' [7th place

to:

->'''Placement:''' [7th 7th place



* NoHealthcareInTheApocalypse: Told her Canadian healthcare will not apply if she gets injured on the show.
* RealityShowGenreBlindness: Has never seen Survivor ''or'' the first season of Survive Block Island, meaning she went into the show ''completely'' blind. Predictably, this causes her some issues.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
->'''Occupation(s):''' Funhaus

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
Ice Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' FunhausBig Intern Energy



* AscendedExtra: To the greater Rooster Teeth company at large; he was hired at Funhaus after the season.
* NaiveNewcomer: Had never played Minecraft prior to the show. He doesn't even know how to get into a boat.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
->'''Occupation(s):''' Funhaus

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
Ice Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' FunhausHere for the Right Reasons



* AscendedExtra: To the greater Rooster Teeth company at large; she was hired at Funhaus after the season.
* RealityShowGenreBlindness: She ''does'' watch reality tv...But near exclusively love shows. She even questions if Survive Block Island is the type of place to ''find'' love.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
->'''Occupation(s):''' Achievement Hunter

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
Ice Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' Achievement HunterTrying to Be Nice



* HeterosexualLifePartners: With Gavin, to the surprise of nobody familiar with Achievement Hunter.
* ThisIsGonnaSuck: Not long after getting put into their teams, Michael comes to the realization he's one of the only people on it that knows how to play Minecraft...And he's of the opinion he ''doesn't'' know what he's doing. [[DeadpanSnarker So...High expectations out the gate]].
* WrongGenreSavvy: When initially told about the Immunity Totems hidden around the island, Michael's immediate instinct was to check under the podium Trevor was speaking from. It doesn't work, but was worth a shot.



->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
->'''Occupation(s):''' Unassociated with Rooster Teeth (Streamer)

to:

->'''Team(s):''' Team Ice
Ice Team
->'''Occupation(s):''' Unassociated with Rooster Teeth (Streamer)Gavin's Much, ''Much'' Better Half


Added DiffLines:

* OfficialCouple: With Gavin. They had been together for 9-years by the time of recording.
** LoveIsAWeakness: With that said, she also knows couples tend to get targeted in these sorts of shows, which is why she's glad they got separated onto different teams.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EarlyBirdCameo: First debuted in the season 1 finale alongside Michael as a teaser for the next season.


Added DiffLines:

* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: ''Nobody'' wanted Michael to win. It's saying something that after Episode 2, he receives a vote at ''every Chopping Block'' he attends.
* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 2. Blatantly and openly antagonizes those around him, team and alliance alike, uses intimidation and unpredictability to keep people guessing, and happily galavants across the chaos he spurs for no other reason than for a good laugh.
* BornUnlucky: Never managed to win a ''single'' challenge across ''both'' stages of the game. He has the dubious honor of attending the ''most'' Chopping Blocks of any player across ''both'' seasons with ''8'' total ceremonies attended, ''9'' if you count him attending the jury.
* ContrastingSequelAntagonist: Whereas Alfredo was a strategic manipulator and challenge beast who more or less controlled the game from beginning to end with the help of a strong majority alliance, Michael is a chaotic wildcard who had little to no power in the game, was frankly terrible in challenges, and completely lacked in loyal allies, but managed to hang around by the skin of his teeth through sheer willpower and focusing in on bigger threats.
* EarlyBirdCameo: First debuted in the season 1 finale alongside Gavin as a teaser for the next season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:555:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_11_110100.png]]

Added: 2469

Changed: 60

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DownerEnding: In the end, Alfredo received nothing in the way of compensation for backstabbing his closest allies and making enemies of the entire jury, leaving one to wonder if it was worth it.



* FatalFlaw: His own overconfidence in his gameplay. Not only was he left oblivious to just how bitter the jury ultimately was toward him for his cruel gameplay, but he completely underestimated Barbara's own contributions to his gameplay, leaving him little in the way of convincing the jury, and only receiving 2 jury votes to win, ending the game in second.



->'''Placement:''' Winner (5 jury votes to win)

to:

->'''Placement:''' Winner [[SoleSurvivor Winner]] (5 jury votes to win)



* SoleSurvivor: Manage to convince the jury with her gameplay and strategy that she deserved to win, earning a majority of 5 jury votes and walking away the victor of the season.



* FatalFlaw: Her not taking the game very seriously lead to her frequently being on the bottom and just outside the alliance's plans. Come the endgame, there was effectively nothing she could do to rebound.



* AlasPoorVillain: One can't help but feel heartbroken when Joe is finally shown Alfredo's true colors and is betrayed. Sure, most could see it coming from a mile away, but Joe sounds genuinely ''devestated'' through the whole thing.



* BigNo: Let's one out in horror as he realizes Alfredo betrayed him.



* CassandraTruth: Refuses to believe Barbara's claims that Alfredo and her were originally going to vote him off in Episode 8. He's simply too loyal to Alfredo to budge.

to:

* CassandraTruth: Refuses to believe Barbara's claims that Alfredo and her were originally going to vote him off in Episode 8. He's simply too loyal to Alfredo to budge. This ultimately leads to his own downfall.


Added DiffLines:

* FatalFlaw: His own loyalty to Alfredo. Sure, it helped him get far through a strong alliance, but in the end, Alfredo was never as loyal to him as Joe was toward him, which spelled his doom.


Added DiffLines:

* VotedOffTheIsland: Eliminated in Episode 9, ending the game in 4th place overall.
** LastWords: "No! How could you! How could you do this to me! After all this time! French fries and mayonaise!"
** EliminationStatement: "I believe if I didn't blindly miss the papers, I probably would have won that challenge. You know what the funny thing is? If I had won, I would have given it to Alfredo. What it really all came down to was...Betrayal..."


Added DiffLines:

* BittersweetEnding: Sure, he didn't win, but as he admitted himself, he didn't see himself getting this far in the first place, and ends the game ultimately proud of his gameplay.


Added DiffLines:

* FatalFlaw: His own insecurity. He was unable to properly plead his case to the jury due to heavily downplaying his own accomplishments, leading to him only securing jury votes and ending the game in second.


Added DiffLines:

* FatalFlaw: After an entire game of trying to play the game logically, his decision to play with his heart in Episode 7 lead to him growing too arrogant about his place in the game, and he suffers for it.

Added: 1037

Changed: 133

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Repays Joe's constant loyalty to him since day one by openly attempting to blindside him in Episode 8 and Episode 9. While both Barbara and Jon are hesitant to do so due to the alliance, Alfredo shows no such sympathy.

to:

** Repays Joe's constant loyalty to him since day one by openly attempting to blindside him in Episode 8 and Episode 9.8. While both Barbara and Jon are hesitant to do so due to the alliance, Alfredo shows no such sympathy.



* JustOneLittleMistake: Very nearly played straight; in a state of panic, Barbara tells Joe about the original plan to eliminate him in Episode 8. Had he not been subsequantly eliminated, this could have gone bad for her...



** Tells Joe about Alfredo's plan to vote him out in Episode 8 after the challenge in Episode 9. Once again, {{Downplayed}}, as there is a clear strategic edge to it, but it was a genuine showing of good will.



* CassandraTruth: Refuses to believe Barbara's claims that Alfredo and her were originally going to vote him off in Episode 8. He's simply too loyal to Alfredo to budge.



* DavidVersusGoliath: The Goliath to Jon's David in the final challenge. And just like the tale of myth, he ultimately loses out.



* DrivenByEnvy: An easy assumption to come to as the game goes on; between winning a challenge just to spite Alfredo and targetting Barbara in Episode 9 after a season of working with her, Joe's last few episodes are very easy to interpret as him lashing out over what he ''doesn't'' have.

to:

* DrivenByEnvy: An easy assumption to come to as the game goes on; between winning a challenge just to spite Alfredo and targetting targeting Barbara in Episode 9 after a season of working with her, Joe's last few episodes are very easy to interpret as him lashing out over what he ''doesn't'' have.



* TheRival: A one-sided example, but it becomes clear over the course of the game that Joe has begun to hold a grudge against Barbara in their mutual alliance with Alfredo.

to:

* TheRival: A one-sided example, but it becomes clear over the course of the game that Joe has begun to hold a grudge against Barbara in their mutual alliance with Alfredo. He openly targets her in Episode 9, and attempts to not even hear her out after the challenge.



* SelectiveObliviousness: Refuses to believe that Alfredo was actually going to betray him in Episode 8 when told by Barbara, instead only doubling down on his distrust of her and saying he's voting for her.



** He even helps Alfredo through the challenge in Episode 9, despite supposedly wanting the final immunity. He defends as much that they're all still on the same team, and yet he ''doesn't'' help Barbara and Jon. Any form of subtely of his allegiance is thrown out the window when it's made clear he'd give his immunity to Alfredo if he won.

to:

** He even helps Alfredo through the challenge in Episode 9, despite supposedly wanting the final immunity. He defends as much that they're all still on the same team, and yet he ''doesn't'' help Barbara and Jon. Any form of subtely subtlety of his allegiance is thrown out the window when it's made clear he'd give his immunity to Alfredo if he won.



->'''Challenge Wins:''' 5 [[note]]5 team wins[[/note]]

to:

->'''Challenge Wins:''' 5 6 [[note]]5 team wins[[/note]]wins, 1 individual win[[/note]]


Added DiffLines:

* DavidVersusGoliath: The David against Joe's Goliath in the final challenge. Miraculously, he wins!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He even helps Alfredo through the challenge in Episode 9, despite supposedly wanting the final immunity. He defends as much that they're all still on the same team, and yet he ''doesn't'' help Barbara and Jon...

to:

** He even helps Alfredo through the challenge in Episode 9, despite supposedly wanting the final immunity. He defends as much that they're all still on the same team, and yet he ''doesn't'' help Barbara and Jon...Jon. Any form of subtely of his allegiance is thrown out the window when it's made clear he'd give his immunity to Alfredo if he won.

Added: 2012

Changed: 577

Removed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmugSnake: For all his confidence that he was running the game, he was ultimately little more than a shield for the actual schemer between the two, Barbara.

to:

* SmugSnake: For Is confident he has the game in the bag by the last few episodes, stating that he played a perfect game and that the others don't have anywhere near as good of a resume compared to what he accomplished.
** TooCleverByHalf: Unfortunately, for
all his confidence that he was running the game, he was ultimately little more than a shield for the actual schemer between the two, Barbara.



* SympatheticPOV: While she and Alfredo both arguably played sinister, antagonistic games, this is where they distinctly separate. Namely, while Alfredo is a CardCarryingVillain and SmugSnake who twists the knife on the regular, Barbara is given more genuinely sweet moments with her team, Charlotte especially.
** Best shown off in Episode 9. Whereas Alfredo uses his first confessional to talk big game about how he's guaranteed to win and played things perfectly, Barbara's is spent with her talking about how proud she is to have gotten this far in spite of her lack of skill.



* SmallRoleBigImpact
* TokenGoodTeammate: Of the largely morally gray Red Team, Charlotte sticks out as the most openly kind and friendly member.



* CrazyJealousGuy: {{Implied}} toward Alfredo; specifically, he's noticeably distrusting and against Barbara as the game goes on, despite being in the same alliance.

to:

* CrazyJealousGuy: {{Implied}} toward Alfredo; specifically, he's noticeably distrusting and against Barbara as the game goes on, despite being in the same alliance. It's especially noticeable when he's targetting her over her supposed lack of challenge skill while ignoring that Jon hasn't won a single one.



* MightMakesRight: Decides to target Barbara as the final elimination pre-jury because she had never won a challenge or come close during the merge. [[CrazyJealousGuy Oddly, he ignores that Jon hasn't either...]]

to:

* MightMakesRight: Decides to target Barbara as the final elimination pre-jury because she had never won a of her abysmal challenge or come close during the merge. performances. [[CrazyJealousGuy Oddly, he ignores that Jon hasn't either...]]won a challenge yet while she has...]]
** Hell, Jon [[{{Lampshaded}} lampshdades]] as much, defending that he arguably has done even worse than Barbara, considering she at least won the memory game in Episode 6.
* MistreatmentInducedBetrayal: Begins considering doing this to Alfredo, though ultimately decides not to go through with it.



* PseudoRomanticFriendship: [[CaptainObvious He's very close to Alfredo]].

to:

* PseudoRomanticFriendship: [[CaptainObvious He's very close to Alfredo]]. Or at least, he thinks he is.



* UndyingLoyalty: Toward Alfredo, in spite of the developing issues between them, and once they're over those, Joe trusts him more than ever! It comes back to bite him in the end, as turns out, Alfredo wasn't so trustworthy after all.

to:

* UndyingLoyalty: Toward Alfredo, in spite of the developing issues between them, and once they're over those, Joe trusts him more than ever! It comes back to bite him in the end, as turns out, ever!
** He even helps
Alfredo wasn't so trustworthy after all.through the challenge in Episode 9, despite supposedly wanting the final immunity. He defends as much that they're all still on the same team, and yet he ''doesn't'' help Barbara and Jon...


Added DiffLines:

* HeroicSelfDeprecation: The sweetest member of the Red Alliance, and Red Team as a whole. He's also rarely not insulting himself.


Added DiffLines:

* NiceGuy: A genuinely kind-hearted, well-meaning guy. This especially sticks out came the last few episodes where he's still going out of his way to try and treat his competition well, including those outside his alliance.


Added DiffLines:

* PetTheDog:
** Defends Barbara's supposed lack of challenge skill by bringing up she won Episode 6. This does nothing to help him, and arguably it'd be a good thing for him to let her take pressure off himself considering his lack of power, and yet he does so regardless.


Added DiffLines:

* TokenGoodTeammate: Of the largely morally gray Red Team, Jon sticks out as the most openly kind and friendly member.

Added: 212

Changed: 99

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyJealousGuy: {{Implied}} toward Alfredo; specifically, he's noticeably distrusting and against Barbara as the game goes on, despite being in the same alliance. Considering the implications surrounding as much, its very easy to interpret as such at least.

to:

* CrazyJealousGuy: {{Implied}} toward Alfredo; specifically, he's noticeably distrusting and against Barbara as the game goes on, despite being in the same alliance. Considering the implications surrounding as much, its very easy to interpret as such at least.



* MightMakesRight: Decides to target Barbara as the final elimination pre-jury because she had never won a challenge or come close during the merge. [[CrazyJealousGuy Oddly, he ignores that Jon hasn't either...]]



* PseudoRomanticFriendship: [[CaptainObvious He's ''very'' close to Alfredo]].

to:

* PseudoRomanticFriendship: [[CaptainObvious He's ''very'' very close to Alfredo]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBigGuy: The single most talented contestant of the season in terms of raw challenge performance, winning a vast majority of episodes. To put into perspective, he was ''only'' eligible to be voted for in ''2 episodes'' out of the total 9.

to:

* TheBigGuy: The single most talented contestant of the season in terms of raw challenge performance, winning a vast majority of episodes. To put into perspective, he was ''only'' eligible to be voted for in ''2 ''3 episodes'' out of the total 9.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrazyJealousGuy: {{Implied}} toward Alfredo; specifically, he's noticeably distrusting and against Barbara as the game goes on, despite being in the same alliance. Considering the implications surrounding as much, its very easy to interpret as such at least.


Added DiffLines:

* DrivenByEnvy: An easy assumption to come to as the game goes on; between winning a challenge just to spite Alfredo and targetting Barbara in Episode 9 after a season of working with her, Joe's last few episodes are very easy to interpret as him lashing out over what he ''doesn't'' have.


Added DiffLines:

* PseudoRomanticFriendship: [[CaptainObvious He's ''very'' close to Alfredo]].
* TheRival: A one-sided example, but it becomes clear over the course of the game that Joe has begun to hold a grudge against Barbara in their mutual alliance with Alfredo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:641:"I feel like the only person I can trust right now is Alfredo."]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:641:"I [[caption-width-right:641:''"I feel like the only person I can trust right now is Alfredo."]]"'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:641:some caption text]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:641:some caption text]][[caption-width-right:641:"I feel like the only person I can trust right now is Alfredo."]]

Added: 1629

Changed: 892

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CardCarryingVillain: Openly admits himself to be a manipulator more than willing to lie and screw over anyone in his way to come out on top.

to:

* CardCarryingVillain: Openly admits himself to be a manipulator more than willing to lie and screw over anyone in his way to come out on top. He only takes this to another level come Episode 8, where backstabbing his allies and stirring the pot becomes his priority.



* VillainousFriendship: With Joe and Barbara, ultimately forming the Red Alliance with them.
** Slowly {{Averted}} over the course of the game as power goes to his head. By the last few episodes he's noticed how much of a threat Joe is and decides to throw him under the bus, and only keeps Barbara around because he feels he has a better chance with the jury over her.



* HazyFeelTurn: While she still very much is in it to win it in the last two episodes, Barbara's game noticeably shifts come to final five, as by that point she had formed genuine bonds with the rest of the players since she's known them since day one. Notably, this is the first time the whole game where Barbara doesn't immediately back up Alfredo's idea of who should go next.

to:

* HazyFeelTurn: While she still very much is in it to win it in the last two episodes, Barbara's game noticeably shifts come to the final five, as by that point she had formed genuine bonds with the rest of the players since she's known them since day one. Notably, this is the first time the whole game where Barbara doesn't immediately back up Alfredo's idea of who should go next.



* LesserOfTwoEvils: While she may have worked with Alfredo throughout the game, between the two she was much more openly friendly to rest of the cast. These stronger bonds were part of what allowed her to win over the jury. This is only reinforced by the final five, where the two's differences come fully to light in how they handle the last few eliminations.

to:

* LesserOfTwoEvils: While she may have worked with Alfredo throughout the game, between the two she was much more openly friendly to rest of the cast. These stronger bonds were part of what allowed her to win over the jury. This is only reinforced by the final five, where the two's differences come fully to light in how they handle the last few eliminations.



* SmallRoleBigImpact



* VotedOffTheIsland: Eliminated in Episode 8, ending the game in 5th place overall.
** LastWords: "Hey listen, we all have our time in the sun. Can I drop a tiny little bomb? I'll just say in the last round, I didn't vote for Fredo- but I was not willing to burn a bridge, so I just allowed everyone to think that it was the same playbook I was playing. So, you guys figure that out, and also, took you long enough, Goddamn! Take me, Lord!"
** EliminationStatement: "The Charlotte "Kiss of Death" is widely known in Minecraft circles in that- you don't wanna hang out with me. You gotta stay away, cause people close to me die. And who's closer to you then yourself? And unfortunately that made me a recipient of the kiss of death myself. Who woulda thought? I hadn't consider my "Kiss of Death" being anything but a coincidence. Thanks for the melons!"



* FlatCharacter: Doesn't get much in terms of characterization beyond being Alfredo's loyal ally and being very good at challenges.

to:

* FlatCharacter: Doesn't get much in terms of characterization beyond being Alfredo's loyal ally and being very good at challenges. He starts to grow out of this come the last few episodes, as his own pent up issues toward Alfredo slowly grow more and more.



** He finally gets over it come the end of Episode 8, deciding that he fully trusts Alfredo and that he has his back. [[TemptingFate Little did he know...]]



* ThoseTwoGuys: With Alfredo; they're rarely seen apart after the first episode. He's left feeling heartbroken and betrayed when Alfredo betrays him.
* UndyingLoyalty: Toward Alfredo, in spite of the developing issues between them. It comes back to bite him.

to:

* TemptingFate: Decides he's over his distrust of Alfredo at the end of Episode 8. Guess who is eliminated ''just'' before the jury in Episode 9?
* ThoseTwoGuys: With Alfredo; they're rarely seen apart after the first episode. Even as the two come to bump heads a couple times, they remain in the same alliance and frequently talk things out strategy-wise. He's left feeling heartbroken and betrayed when Alfredo betrays him.
* UndyingLoyalty: Toward Alfredo, in spite of the developing issues between them. them, and once they're over those, Joe trusts him more than ever! It comes back to bite him.him in the end, as turns out, Alfredo wasn't so trustworthy after all.

Added: 650

Changed: 372

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KickTheDog: Repays Joe's constant loyalty to him since day one by openly attempting to blindside him in Episode 8 and Episode 9. While both Barbara and Jon are hesistant to do so due to the alliance, Alfredo shows no such sympathy.

to:

* KickTheDog: KickTheDog:
**
Repays Joe's constant loyalty to him since day one by openly attempting to blindside him in Episode 8 and Episode 9. While both Barbara and Jon are hesistant hesitant to do so due to the alliance, Alfredo shows no such sympathy.sympathy.
** Holds a meeting in Episode 8 to "air things out" for no other reason to spark drama and distrust between the other contestants. He openly admits to only doing so because he knows he's safe.



* HazyFaceTurn: While she still very much is in it to win it in the last two episodes, Barbara's game noticeably shifts come to final five, as by that point she had formed genuine bonds with the rest of the players since she's known them since day one. Notably, this is the first time the whole game where Barbara doesn't immediately back up Alfredo's idea of who should go next.

to:

* HazyFaceTurn: HazyFeelTurn: While she still very much is in it to win it in the last two episodes, Barbara's game noticeably shifts come to final five, as by that point she had formed genuine bonds with the rest of the players since she's known them since day one. Notably, this is the first time the whole game where Barbara doesn't immediately back up Alfredo's idea of who should go next.



** She's 100% loyal to the Red Alliance. Sure, she's down for manipulating and eliminating people outside of it, but she noticeably sounds hesistant to backstab Joe and Jon come the endgame.

to:

** She's 100% loyal to the Red Alliance. Sure, she's down for manipulating and eliminating people outside of it, but she noticeably sounds hesistant hesitant to backstab Joe and Jon come the endgame.endgame once Alfredo suggests it. {{Downplayed}} in that she still agrees to his plans as long as she's able to stay in the game.



* TheBrute: Serves as the primary muscle of the Red Alliance.



* UnwittingPawn: What his role in the Red Alliance ultimately came down to; for all his loyalty, Joe was little more than a number.

to:

* UnwittingPawn: What his role in the Red Alliance ultimately came down to; to in Alfredo's eyes; for all his loyalty, Joe was little more than a number.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Mook}}: Pulled into the Red Alliance as little more than a number to add to their ranks. Jon's more than aware of this fact, but feels he lacks any options to do otherwise.

Added: 1384

Changed: 382

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->'''Challenge Wins:''' 3 [[note]]3 team wins[[/note]]

to:

->'''Challenge Wins:''' 3 4 [[note]]3 team wins[[/note]]wins, 1 individual win[[/note]]



** In Episode 8, whereas Barbara proves a little unwilling to betray anyone in the Red Alliance come the endgame, Alfredo is openly interested in throwing Joe under the bus in spite of his longterm loyalty.



* GeniusBruiser: One of the biggest manipulators of the season, and only second to Joe in terms of raw challenge performance.



* KickTheDog: Repays Joe's constant loyalty to him since day one by openly attempting to blindside him in Episode 8 and Episode 9. While both Barbara and Jon are hesistant to do so due to the alliance, Alfredo shows no such sympathy.



* HazyFaceTurn: While she still very much is in it to win it in the last two episodes, Barbara's game noticeably shifts come to final five, as by that point she had formed genuine bonds with the rest of the players since she's known them since day one. Notably, this is the first time the whole game where Barbara doesn't immediately back up Alfredo's idea of who should go next.



* LesserOfTwoEvils: While she may have worked with Alfredo throughout the game, between the two she was much more openly friendly to rest of the cast. These stronger bonds were part of what allowed her to win over the jury.

to:

* LesserOfTwoEvils: While she may have worked with Alfredo throughout the game, between the two she was much more openly friendly to rest of the cast. These stronger bonds were part of what allowed her to win over the jury. This is only reinforced by the final five, where the two's differences come fully to light in how they handle the last few eliminations.



* PetTheDog:
** Forms a genuine friendship with Charlotte throughout the game, and while they may not be in the same alliance and Barbara does frequently use her for their strategies, she honestly attempts to keep in her in the game as long as she can.
** She's 100% loyal to the Red Alliance. Sure, she's down for manipulating and eliminating people outside of it, but she noticeably sounds hesistant to backstab Joe and Jon come the endgame.



* TheJinx: Comes to the conclusion she may be one in Episode 7, because both people she had personal conversations with (Matt and BK) were eliminated in the episodes she did so.

to:

* TheJinx: Comes to the conclusion she may be one in Episode 7, because both people she had personal conversations with (Matt and BK) were eliminated in the episodes she did so. Gus' subsequant elimination ''right after'' she hung out with them only confirms this in her mind.



* HiddenDepths: For all his supposed cowardice, he actually proves himself a fairly resourceful competitor, consistently performing very well in challenges.

to:

* HiddenDepths: For all his supposed cowardice, he actually proves himself a fairly resourceful competitor, consistently performing very well in challenges. This gets noticed by the rest of the Red Alliance come Episode 8, as Jon managed to keep up with Alfredo and Joe fairly well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:737:[[labelnote:Click here to see them post-team swap.]]https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_10_040417.png]][[/labelnote]]

to:

[[quoteright:737:[[labelnote:Click here to see them post-team swap.]]https://static.[[quoteright:737:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/screenshot_2024_03_10_040417.png]][[/labelnote]]png]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 1. Orchestrates (or attempts a much) the eliminations of several players, openly backstabs and burns bridges with the rest of the cast (including Joe, his number one ally), and generally being quite the thorn in everyone's side.

to:

* BigBad: The main antagonist of Season 1. Orchestrates (or attempts a as much) the eliminations of several players, openly backstabs and burns bridges with the rest of the cast (including Joe, his number one ally), and generally being quite the thorn in everyone's side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilerThanThou: Repeatedly proves himself far more conniving and cruel than the rest of the Red Alliance through just how cutthroat he's willing to play in order to gain any ground in the game.


Added DiffLines:

* PaperTiger: By the end of the season, for all of Alfredo's supposed big moves and spectacle, his resume falls flat and he's unable to convince the jury ''he'' pissed off to vote for him, causing him to lose just before the finish line.


Added DiffLines:

* SitcomArchNemesis: Gets ''really'' caught up on how frequently Charlotte votes for him, to a point where he directly confronts her about it in multiple episodes.
* SmugSnake: For all his confidence that he was running the game, he was ultimately little more than a shield for the actual schemer between the two, Barbara.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrueNeutral: Come the merge and the loss of his closest ally, Matt, Jon more or less commits to an "anyone but me" mentality with the votes. He even openly agrees to work with Alfredo and Joe, in spite of obviously not trusting them, as long as it keeps him in the game.

to:

* TrueNeutral: Come {{Invoked}}; come the merge and the loss of his closest ally, Matt, Jon more or less commits to an "anyone but me" mentality with the votes. He even openly agrees to work with Alfredo and Joe, in spite of obviously not trusting them, as long as it keeps him in the game.

Added: 3281

Changed: 1429

Removed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArchEnemy: To Charlotte. She ''constantly'' votes for and targets him, to a point of genuine annoyance from him.



** BigBadWannabe: At the same time though, while he may have been more ''openly'' villainous, ultimately every decision he made in the game was as a result of Barbara's excellent social navigation, and nearly all their best strategies came from her. Arguably, had he not made an alliance with her, its unlikely he'd have been as effective as he was.



* TheChessmaster: With help from Barbara, he's able to get votes from the entire Green Team, then use his Immunity Totem to nullify their votes, giving him the sole power over who went home. He chooses Matt, a challenge beast he wanted out before the merge.
** He'd go on to repeat the same strategy in the merge, using another Immunity Totem to get BK eliminated, the biggest threat to Red Team's power over the game.
* HatedByAll: Finds himself targeted early on through the merge

to:

* TheChessmaster: With help from Barbara, TheFace: Takes credit for every action the Red Alliance takes throughout the game, including everyone they voted out and screwed over. This comes back to bite him come the finale, as he's able to get votes from left with a very bitter jury.
* HatedByAll: By
the entire Green Team, then merge, Alfredo's reputation is thoroughly in the toilet. Nobody trusts him and half the cast are actively gunning for him, forcing him to use his an Immunity Totem two episodes in a row to nullify their votes, giving him avoid elimination. By the sole power over who went home. He chooses Matt, a challenge beast he wanted out before end of the merge.
** He'd go on to repeat
season, he's tied for the same strategy in most votes of the merge, using another Immunity Totem to get BK eliminated, the biggest threat to Red Team's power over the game.
* HatedByAll: Finds himself targeted early on through the merge
cast.



* ObviousVillainSecretVillain: The Obvious Villain to Barbara's Secret Villain.



* HiddenDepths: For all her lack of experience, Barbara proved herself a rather resourceful and perceptive player. Notably, on day one she was immediately able to identify Alfredo as a threat, which would go on to [[BigBad prove itself true]].

to:

* TheChessmaster: Arguably the single best strategist of the season.
** With help from Alfredo, she manages to get Matt eliminated ''just'' before the merge by convincing him and Charlotte to vote for Alfredo. When they do so, Alfredo plays his Immunity Totem, and thus has the only eligible vote, eliminating Matt from the game while she comes out looking loyal.
** Once again, she uses BK confiding in her about her want to vote Alfredo out against her, telling the Red Alliance about her plans and once again giving Alfredo the chance to use an Immunity Totem, nullifying the alliance's votes and allowing them to get out the biggest threat in the game.
** She's able to convince Gus that Red Team is dysfunctional and unorganized, giving him a false sense of confidence- so much so that he gives his Immunity Totem away to Charlotte, unknowingly causing his own elimination as a result of the Red Alliance splitting their votes between him and Charlotte.
* ChessmasterSidekick: Sure, Alfredo may be the leader of the alliance, but Barbara is clearly the brains.
* HiddenDepths: For all her lack of experience, Barbara proved herself a rather resourceful and perceptive player. Notably, on day one she was immediately able to identify Alfredo as a threat, which would go on to [[BigBad prove itself true]]. This allowed her to form an alliance with him early, leading to the two's future takeover of the game.



* TheManBehindTheMan: While Alfredo may have been TheFace of all their conspiring, she was in all reality the brains between the two of them, being responsible for the two's biggest moves.
* ObviousVillainSecretVillain: The Secret Villain to Alfredo's Obvious Villain.



* ArchEnemy: To Alfredo. She votes for him at every Chopping Block she attends, which ''constantly'' ends up frustrating him.
* BornLucky: Spared from elimination in Episode 7 when Gus gave her his Immunity Totem. This ultimately got him eliminated, meaning she didn't even have to pay him back for it afterward.



* BigBadDuumvirate: {{Subverted}}; Joe ''thinks'' he and Alfredo are this, but time slowly proves that he's little more than Alfredo's pawn and lacks much power in the game outside their alliance.

to:

* BigBadDuumvirate: {{Subverted}}; Joe ''thinks'' he and Alfredo are this, but time slowly proves that he's little more than Alfredo's pawn and lacks much power in the game outside their alliance. In all reality, ''Barbara'' is the real brains of the alliance and Alfredo's ''actual'' number two.



* UnwittingPawn: What his role in the Red Alliance ultimately came down to; for all his loyalty, Joe was little more than a number.



* OutOfFocus: In Episode 5.

to:

* OutOfFocus: In Episode 5.5 and Episode 7.



* AssholeVictim: With how mean-spirited his last few moments on the island were, the Red Alliance can't help but take the piss out of and laugh at his ego, especially considering he was his ''own'' biggest reason he got eliminated and not Charlotte.



* IdiotBall: The sheer number of ''terrible'' decisions he made during the Episode 7 Chopping Block is unbelievable.

to:

* IdiotBall: The sheer number of ''terrible'' decisions he made during the Episode 7 Chopping Block is unbelievable.



* KickTheDog: When questioned at the Episode 7 Chopping Block, he uses it as a chance to insult and condescend to the Red Team about how terribly they're playing the game. Naturally, they don't exactly take it well.



* SoreLoser: Arguably the single most spiteful, ''angry'' exit of the entire game.



* TookALevelInJerkass: Becomes outright ''nasty'' over the course of Episode 7.
** LaserGuidedKarma: And is rewarded in turn with his elimination.



** LastWords: "TBA"
** EliminationStatement: "TBA"

to:

** LastWords: "TBA"
"Sic semper tyrannis!" [[note]]Translated: "Thus always to tyrants!"[[/note]]
** EliminationStatement: "TBA""I gotta say- I'm shocked! I thought these losers who were left in the game had no gull, no gumption; I think they had no idea how to play the game! I blame my big fat mouth. I was getting so frustrated watching this team not play the game! These idiots were playing Minecraft. We're not here to play Minecraft, this is Survive Block Island!"

Top