Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Blog / DasSporking

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving this to the Trivia tab.


* NamesTheSame: Das Sporking has come across two sues named Rose Potter, from stories that are otherwise unrelated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammar


** A fic's thinking UsefulNotes/OdaNobunaga and UsefulNotes/DateMasamune fought each other in the ''Edo'' period received a lengthy comment pointing out the blatant ArtisticLicenseHistory, which should have no place in the ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' fandom, that is capped off with…

to:

** A fic's fic thinking UsefulNotes/OdaNobunaga and UsefulNotes/DateMasamune fought each other in the ''Edo'' period received a lengthy comment pointing out the blatant ArtisticLicenseHistory, which should have no place in the ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' fandom, that is capped off with…

Added: 846

Changed: 514

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawmanHasAPoint: [[invoked]] In his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, he's actually entirely justified in being suspicious, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.

to:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: [[invoked]] In [[invoked]]
**In
his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, he's actually entirely justified in being suspicious, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.Hornburg.
** In her sporking of [=TDOMCM=] Libraryseraph points out that Harry is a conqueror who is unifying the wildlings into a fighting force and who possesses magical powers like nothing seen in Westeros before, and therefore all the characters treated as in the wrong for mistrusting and fearing him are the only IC and sensible ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** szaleniec is normally a [[DeadpanSnarker dead calm]] MeanBrit, but is ticked off whenever a fic calls Hermione "Mione".

Added: 504

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Astra flipped her shit over the scene in ''Pawn of Prophecy'' where Polgara laughs upon realising that [[spoiler: Merel is pregnant by rape for the third time.]]

to:

** Astra flipped flips her shit over the scene in ''Pawn of Prophecy'' where Polgara laughs upon realising that [[spoiler: Merel is pregnant by rape for the third time.]]


Added DiffLines:

** Ki no Shirayuki completely blows her lid and rants in ALLCAPS for several paragraphs at a Sue's horribly abusing a sword, up to and including putting him into solitary confinement for ''2 weeks'', one day shy of qualifying as ''psychological torture'' by the UN's standards, just because he refuses to be an ExtremeDoormat and kiss the ground she walks on, that is treated like ''comedy'' by the narrative and viewed by other swords as {{Tsundere}} behavior and her way of confessing her love for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ki no Shirayuki's translation-sporking of the ''Nobunaga-sensei'' anime cast commentary is the first sporking of foreign language material whose translation is provided by the sporker themself.

to:

* ** Ki no Shirayuki's translation-sporking of the ''Nobunaga-sensei'' anime cast commentary is the first sporking of foreign language material whose translation is provided by the sporker themself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ki no Shirayuki's translation-sporking of the ''Nobunaga-sensei'' anime cast commentary is the first sporking of foreign language material whose translation is provided by the sporker themself.

Added: 253

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneHasStandards: All of he sporkers have their limits on what they will and won't spork. Usually it's because a work is unspeakably horrific (Mervin even added the "''Hogwarts Exposed'' line" to the comm rules, stating that anything that manages to [[UpToEleven be worse than that fanfiction]] is banned from being sporked there), although some sporkers refuse to do works on the grounds of them simply being ''boring'' (for example, this is why Mervin stopped sporking ''Child of Grace'' and ''Standing My Ground''). Mervin herself holds the comm at large to several ironclad rules, including certain types of fics that are ''not'' allowed, namelyl the aforementioned "squick-fics", troll fics (on the grounds that they basically spork themselves), things that run the risk of breaking the "no politics" rule (such as ''Literature/TheTurnerDiaries''), and real person fics. She also forbids making personal attacks/death threats towards the Suethors or their families. The only exception is Neil, who wrote the aforementioned ''Hogwarts Exposed'' and is hands-down the most hated Stuthor on the comm (though Creator/MarionZimmerBradley is quickly giving him a run for his money).

to:

* EveryoneHasStandards: All of he sporkers have their limits on what they will and won't spork. Usually it's because a work is unspeakably horrific (Mervin even added the "''Hogwarts Exposed'' line" to the comm rules, stating that anything that manages to [[UpToEleven be worse than that fanfiction]] is banned from being sporked there), although some sporkers refuse to do works on the grounds of them simply being ''boring'' (for example, this is why Mervin stopped sporking ''Child of Grace'' and ''Standing My Ground''). Mervin herself holds the comm at large to several ironclad rules, including certain types of fics that are ''not'' allowed, namelyl namely the aforementioned "squick-fics", troll fics (on the grounds that they basically spork themselves), things that run the risk of breaking the "no politics" rule (such as ''Literature/TheTurnerDiaries''), and real person fics. She also forbids making personal attacks/death threats towards the Suethors or their families. The only exception is Neil, who wrote the aforementioned ''Hogwarts Exposed'' and is hands-down the most hated Stuthor on the comm (though Creator/MarionZimmerBradley is quickly giving him a run for his money).


Added DiffLines:

** During the ''Nobunaga-sensei'' sporking, [[VideoGame/ToukenRanbu Heshikiri Hasebe]] says while he isn't fond of his old master Oda Nobunaga, the latter still doesn't deserve to have his historical impact ignored to be portrayed as a bland harem hero.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The infamous ''Hogwarts Exposed'' has ''multiple'' [[{{Squick}} extremely disturbing themes]] but the last nail in the coffin is its ''[[{{Doorstopper}} length]]''.

Added: 95

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Ki no Shirayuki's is "[[VideoGame/ToukenRanbu Drop your head and die]]" in regards to Sues.



** If Ket Makura is eating food, it's generally rice. She and [=ZeldaQueen=] often end chapters of HushHush by going off for ice cream.

to:

** If Ket Makura is eating food, it's generally rice. She and [=ZeldaQueen=] often end chapters of HushHush ''Literature/HushHush'' by going off for ice cream.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A fic's thinking UsefulNotes/OdaNobunaga and UsefulNotes/DateMasamune fought each other in the ''Edo'' period received a lengthy comment pointing out the blatant ArtisticLicenseHistory that is capped off with…

to:

** A fic's thinking UsefulNotes/OdaNobunaga and UsefulNotes/DateMasamune fought each other in the ''Edo'' period received a lengthy comment pointing out the blatant ArtisticLicenseHistory ArtisticLicenseHistory, which should have no place in the ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' fandom, that is capped off with…
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A fic's thinking UsefulNotes/OdaNobunaga and UsefulNotes/DateMasamune fought each other in the ''Edo'' period received a lengthy comment pointing out the blatant ArtisticLicenseHistory that is capped off with…
-->'''Ki no Shirayuki:''' Aside from that, why are you referring to Oda Nobunaga by last name and Date Masamune by first name?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawmanHasAPoint: [[invoked]] In his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, they're actually entirely justified, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.

to:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: [[invoked]] In his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, they're he's actually entirely justified, justified in being suspicious, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawmanHasAPoint: In his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, they're actually entirely justified, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.

to:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: [[invoked]] In his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, they're actually entirely justified, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: In his sporking of ''Identities'', Master Ghandalf points out that despite Legolas' suspicion of Morwen/Rana being portrayed as a flaw with him, they're actually entirely justified, since he knows for a fact that she's an agent of the Enemy. It doesn't help that she spends more time whining about Legolas not trusting her than she does showing that she can be trusted, and she apparently doesn't fully turn against Sauron until after she gets caught in an explosion at the Battle of the Hornburg.

Added: 785

Changed: 235

Removed: 547

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationInducedPlotHole: In "Identities," MG points out that since [[SparedByTheAdaptation Boromir survived]], Denethor's actions and characterization (which were more or less copied from Peter Jackson's ''Return of the King'' adaptation) don't make any sense.

to:

* AdaptationInducedPlotHole: AdaptationInducedPlotHole:
**
In "Identities," MG points out that since [[SparedByTheAdaptation Boromir survived]], Denethor's actions and characterization (which were more or less copied from Peter Jackson's ''Return of the King'' adaptation) don't make any sense.



* TheManBehindTheMan: In [=RiffingAcademy=]'s sporking of ''Pretty Cure Perfume Preppy'', he makes reference a couple of times to an unnamed collaborator, whom he accuses of having [[EvilMentor suggested to the fourteen-year-old primary author]] to have included [[CorruptTheCutie several story elements that are not appropriate for children]]. Because the collaborator is never named, it is impossible to be certain, but [=RiffingAcademy=] has strong suspicions that the collaborator was a pedophile, and just using [[UnwittingPawn the Suethor]].



* TheManBehindTheMan: In [=RiffingAcademy=]'s sporking of ''Pretty Cure Perfume Preppy'', he makes reference a couple of times to an unnamed collaborator, whom he accuses of having [[EvilMentor suggested to the fourteen-year-old primary author]] to have included [[CorruptTheCutie several story elements that are not appropriate for children]]. Because the collaborator is never named, it is impossible to be certain, but [=RiffingAcademy=] has strong suspicions that the collaborator was a pedophile, and just using [[UnwittingPawn the Suethor]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While sporking "To Rule Them All", Master Ghandalf notes that while Sauron isn't being [[DracoInLeatherPants portrayed as a good guy]], the author doesn't seem to grasp the true scope of his weight and presence, so he comes off as more like Azra's somewhat cranky but otherwise generic boss rather than one of the most monstrous individuals in the history of Middle-earth. This makes him an unusual example of this trope being caused by combination of bad writing and a lack of understanding of the source material.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainProtagonist: Azra from "To Rule Them All" is considered a very poor example of one by Master Ghandalf. As he points out, she's not [[AntiVillain sympathetic]] enough for the audience to feel for her, nor is she [[EvilIsCool impressive]] enough for them to want to she how she'll pull of her schemes.

Changed: 630

Removed: 256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* ShipperOnDeck:
%%** Sporkers often make their preferred ships known throughout their sporkings, although not so much that the sporking becomes a [[AuthorFilibuster Sporker Filibuster]].
%%** ng55snarkings is particularly vehement about Sues that come between [[OfficialCouple Jack and Sally's]] relationship in WesternAnimation/TheNightmareBeforeChristmas fanfics she sporks. It's hard not to see why, considering how badly written they were.

to:

%%* ShipperOnDeck:
%%**
* ShipperOnDeck: Sporkers often make their preferred ships known throughout their sporkings, although not so much that the sporking becomes a [[AuthorFilibuster Sporker Filibuster]].
%%** ** ng55snarkings is particularly vehement about Sues that come between [[OfficialCouple Jack and Sally's]] relationship in WesternAnimation/TheNightmareBeforeChristmas ''WesternAnimation/TheNightmareBeforeChristmas'' fanfics she sporks. It's hard not to see why, considering how badly written they were.



** Ki no Shirayuki ends her posts with ''waka'' poems except tables of contents.

to:

** Gratuitous classical Japanese poetry is a staple of Ki no Shirayuki – she ends every of her posts with ''waka'' poems except (except tables of contents.contents) with one and {{angst nuke}}s into them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{invoked}} InNameOnly: The crew considers ''VideoGame/ChronoCross'' this.

to:

* {{invoked}} InNameOnly: The crew considers ''VideoGame/ChronoCross'' this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*{{invoked}} InNameOnly: The crew considers ''VideoGame/ChronoCross'' this.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InsistentTerminology: Riffing Academy is a die-hard [[Series/MysteryScienceTheater3000 MSTie,]] and to that end calls his sporkings "riffings." [[CaptainObvious His username may have something to do with him sticking to it, too.]]

to:

* InsistentTerminology: Riffing Academy is a die-hard [[Series/MysteryScienceTheater3000 MSTie,]] and to that end calls his sporkings "riffings." [[CaptainObvious His username may have something to do with him sticking to it, too.]]

Added: 111

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GratuitousJapanese: Some sporkers use this in their usernames and/or sporks, like ryina chan and Raxistaicho.



'''Mervin:''' '''[+OH, FUCK YOU!!!+]''' *slams down the phone furiously with a loud bang*

to:

'''Mervin:''' '''[+OH, '''OH, FUCK YOU!!!+]''' YOU!!!''' *slams down the phone furiously with a loud bang*

Added: 90

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Several of the sporkers, but azralibrarian stands out most. Her knowledge of Franchise/FinalFantasy is well shown during one of her sporks of a self-insert Dissidia fanfic. She also displays a good deal of knowledge of VideoGame/RuneScape during her sporking of a sloppy crossover fic.
** Nix has made a habit of sporking almost nothing but things from VideoGame/TheWorldEndsWithYou.

to:

** Several of the sporkers, but azralibrarian stands out most. Her knowledge of Franchise/FinalFantasy ''Franchise/FinalFantasy'' is well shown during one of her sporks of a self-insert Dissidia fanfic. She also displays a good deal of knowledge of VideoGame/RuneScape ''VideoGame/RuneScape'' during her sporking of a sloppy crossover fic.
** Nix has made a habit of sporking almost nothing but things from VideoGame/TheWorldEndsWithYou.''VideoGame/TheWorldEndsWithYou''.
** Ki no Shirayuki specializes in ''VideoGame/{{Onmyoji}}'' and ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu''.

Added: 58

Changed: 102

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ki no Shirayuki does the same, but into ''waka poems''.



** [[Main/ArtisticLicenseBiology Science]] [[Main/ArtisticLicenseChemistry failure]] [[Main/ArtisticLicensePharmacology sets]] [[Main/ArtisticLicensePhysics off]] Mrs. Hyde. The eight-pointed snowflake in ''[[Literature/{{Twilight}} Breaking Dawn]]'' was a pretty major one.

to:

** [[Main/ArtisticLicenseBiology [[ArtisticLicenseBiology Science]] [[Main/ArtisticLicenseChemistry [[ArtisticLicenseChemistry failure]] [[Main/ArtisticLicensePharmacology [[ArtisticLicensePharmacology sets]] [[Main/ArtisticLicensePhysics [[ArtisticLicensePhysics off]] Mrs. Hyde. The eight-pointed snowflake in ''[[Literature/{{Twilight}} Breaking Dawn]]'' was a pretty major one.



** [[Main/RomanticizedAbuse Romanticized Abuse]]--physical abuse, emotional abuse and/or rape--''enrages'' Gehayi. So does [[CriticalResearchFailure Critical Research Failure]].
** [[Main/MoralMyopia Callous]] [[Main/LackOfEmpathy disregard]] [[Main/AMillionIsAStatistic for]] [[Main/TheRightOfASuperiorSpecies human]] [[Main/TautologicalTemplar life]] will make Mervin [[WesternAnimation/AquaTeenHungerForce Paul]] out. So will getting anything related to [[Main/ArtisticLicenseMedicine medicine]] wrong.

to:

** [[Main/RomanticizedAbuse Romanticized Abuse]]--physical RomanticizedAbuse --physical abuse, emotional abuse and/or rape--''enrages'' Gehayi. So does [[CriticalResearchFailure Critical Research Failure]].CriticalResearchFailure.
** [[Main/MoralMyopia Callous]] [[Main/LackOfEmpathy [[LackOfEmpathy disregard]] [[Main/AMillionIsAStatistic [[AMillionIsAStatistic for]] [[Main/TheRightOfASuperiorSpecies [[TheRightOfASuperiorSpecies human]] [[Main/TautologicalTemplar [[TautologicalTemplar life]] will make Mervin [[WesternAnimation/AquaTeenHungerForce Paul]] out. So will getting anything related to [[Main/ArtisticLicenseMedicine [[ArtisticLicenseMedicine medicine]] wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Libraryseraph hates {{Designated Hero}}es, ProtagonistCenteredMorality, and poor grammar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Gekkou", it's pointed out that since the government recruited the saniwa and depends on them to lead the protection of history in ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' canon, their ''[[RonTheDeathEater actively harming the saniwa]]'' in the fic doesn't make any sense either.

to:

** In "Gekkou", it's pointed out that since the government recruited the saniwa and depends on them to lead the protection of history in ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' canon, their ''[[RonTheDeathEater actively actively]] [[StupidEvil harming the saniwa]]'' in the fic doesn't make any sense either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ki no Shirayuki ends her posts with ''waka'' poems.

to:

** Ki no Shirayuki ends her posts with ''waka'' poems.poems except tables of contents.

Added: 271

Changed: 40

Removed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Gekkou", it's pointed out that since the government recruited the saniwa and depends on them to lead the protection of history in ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' canon, their ''[[RonTheDeathEater actively harming the saniwa]]'' in the fic doesn't make any sense either.



--> GEHAYI: I'm not going to say what it took to persuade the queen and princess of Arendelle except that it involved kittens, the Hubble Telescope, and Ket karaoke.

-->KET: And a really bad clam. *shudders*

to:

--> GEHAYI: I'm not going to say what it took to persuade the queen and princess of Arendelle except that it involved kittens, the Hubble Telescope, and Ket karaoke.

-->KET:
karaoke.\\
KET:
And a really bad clam. *shudders*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
“Gwen” is just a nickname the sporkers call her.


* FixFic: A bit rarer than the RevengeFic, but still there when they feel the rare sympathetic character deserves something better. When the sporkers get tired of watching [[Literature/TheMistsOfAvalon Gwen]] being repeatedly tortured by the narrative, they wrote a new ending where all [[Series/DoctorWho thirteen Doctors]] rescue her and bring her to a hospital in the future, and that Gwen in the rest of the book is just Kamelion pretending to be her.

to:

* FixFic: A bit rarer than the RevengeFic, but still there when they feel the rare sympathetic character deserves something better. When the sporkers get tired of watching [[Literature/TheMistsOfAvalon Gwen]] Gwenhwyfar]] being repeatedly tortured by the narrative, they wrote a new ending where all [[Series/DoctorWho thirteen Doctors]] rescue her and bring her to a hospital in the future, and that Gwen in the rest of the book is just Kamelion pretending to be her.

Top