What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/ChewbaccaDefense

Knight9910
topic
04:24:24 PM Jul 7th 2013
Cut the following:

  • Miracle on 34th Street this man had the post office send him letters addressed to Santa Claus so clearly ladies and gentlemen he must be Santa Claus because the post office is so awesome. Also shame on you for trying to have him committed into an asylum!
    • Not so much that the post office is awesome, as the argument that the post office is part of the US government, and if they recognize the man as Santa, it must be true (at least as far as the courts are concerned).

Where, exactly, is the Chewbacca Defense here? I'm really not seeing it. Really, this seems more like a case of the troper simply disagreeing with the movie's decision, rather than any sort of indiscretion on the part of the movie lawyers.
Knight9910
topic
04:23:26 PM Jul 7th 2013
Another ZCE:

Knight9910
topic
04:06:59 PM Jul 7th 2013

Removed for being Zero-Context Example.
Knight9910
topic
02:22:34 PM Jul 6th 2013
Removed for the moment.

Remember Fan Myopia. When someone can expand on and explain how this is an example then they should do so before putting this back up.
Telcontar
moderator
02:11:19 AM Jul 7th 2013
Done.
MithrandirOlorin
topic
09:23:31 PM Jul 8th 2012
"It makes even less sense if you consider the Chewbacca doesn't live on Endor" Originally the Wookeis where supposed to play the Ewoks role. And why is Endor called a Moon anyway? We don't see it orbiting a Planet?
Fireblood
09:15:34 PM Jul 3rd 2013
It's confusing. Supposedly it's like Yavin 4, a moon of a larger planet (which we don't see in the films). They do call it the "sanctuary moon of Endor". It's being the moon of Endor apparently got mixed up with being Endor itself.
GreyAngel
topic
12:11:18 AM Sep 23rd 2011
This can get really interesting in real life, often overlapping with Insane Troll Logic. I used to be a debater and ran into a team who said things like, "Statistically, black men have been shown to jump higher." It was a Curb Stomp Battle.

Any other people actually run into people who use this?
captainsandwich
06:39:56 PM Feb 28th 2012
Sometimes this works not because the person that hears that chewbaka defense gets confused, but because they think its Insane Troll Logic, and that any attempt to convince the user (or audience) otherwise is a waste of time.
TheGunheart
topic
03:50:23 PM Jun 15th 2011
Could someone add the whole speech to our Quotes page?
Adrenfreak
topic
01:58:47 PM Oct 21st 2010
The comment I just added may be natter (on the electricity point on the bottom). However, I haven't slept in awhile and I'm not really all here. If so, please remove and smack me.
118.208.220.83
topic
07:21:49 AM May 18th 2010
The Nifty: Cut this:

  • That whole "Swiftboat" debacle in the 2004 could also count as well. Basically, a conservative group managed to make John Kerry, a war hero, look unpatriotic compared to George W. Bush, who very well may have used his family's connections and wealth to get a cushy assignment during the Vietnam War. The flip flopping controversy, where John Kerry was made to look indecisive because he changed his mind, again might count.
    • Um, the point of the "debacle" as you call it, is the claim, supported by eyewitness testimony, that Kerry got his purple heart by exaggerating his accomplishments. Then when the war became unpopular, he started making, probably false, accusations of war crimes since being seen as pro-war would not be good for his career. Later still, when the country was again pro-military he dusted up his old medals so he could run as a war hero.
      • I don't think My Lai is an exaggeration.
    • Also on that note, liberals' habit of screaming "Swiftboating" whenever an independent conservatives group presents evidence that disputes their statements or criticize their policies also counts.
      • If you're a conservative group, by definition, you're not independent. QED.
        • That's not really the case; you can be conservative, but not Republican, and thus Independent; there are actually quite a few conservatives dissatisfied with the Republican party.
      • I have a toy frog, so my political views are more valid than anyone elses.
      • Hitler also had a toy frog, your views are therefore invalid.

For reasons of natter. Seriously people, is it really so goddamned hard to avoid this crap? if you don't like an example, either cut it or ignore it. This Justifying Edit crap has got to stop.
blackcat
moderator
topic
06:14:12 PM Mar 12th 2010
Why is the trope called Chewbacca Defense? Is this a pre-existing term or is it from the picture on the page from South Park?
mikekearn
01:41:05 PM Jan 31st 2011
The trope name stems entirely from the South Park episode. It is, however, notable enough of an example that even the Other Wiki has it as an article.
back to Main/ChewbaccaDefense

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy