Discussion Film / Thechroniclesofnarnia

Removed:

• Five-Man Band:

  • The Hero - Peter
  • The Lancer / The Antihero - Edmund
  • The Smart Girl - Susan/Lucy interchangeable
  • The Chick - Lucy/Susan interchangeable
  • The Big Hero - Aslan

  • In Prince Caspian it becomes
    • The Hero - Peter, and Caspian at certain points
    • The Lancer - Susan
    • The Smart Guy - Edmund
    • The Heart - Lucy
    • The Big Hero - Aslan
  • And then in the third movie it becomes
    • The Hero - Caspian
    • The Lancer - Edmund
    • The Smart Girl - Lucy
    • The Chick - Eustace
    • The Big Hero - Aslan

There are several things wrong with this entry. First, bands nearly always must have five members (excepting the Sixth Ranger) and no doubling up. Second, The Chick must be a girl and The Heart won't do. Third, Big Damn Heroes is not a role in a Five-Man Band, and Aslan is never part of the band directly; he's a lone figure who drops in occasionally. Fourth, none of these have The Big Guy.

That was the amazing part. Things just keep going. Hide / Show Replies