Suggestion: Elemental Powers

I was looking around and this pic seems kinda meh to me. Anybody like these? [1]◊[2]◊ [3]◊ [4]◊

2 kicks up an error message. The others are a little better than current as they show more of the elements rather than being only colour-coded. Current, by the way:

I like the 4 the best; it has a decent composition, clearly shows each one with their individual powers, and contrasts the characters most by said powers.

The current picture is kinda muddy, and the blue sphere thing takes up much more prominence than the actual powers.

edited 3rd Feb '13 2:47:34 AM by Scardoll

Huh, that's weird. Here's another link for 2.◊

Keep Until Better Image Suggested on the current, but 1.1 and 1.2 (aka 4) are better. I prefer 1.1 because the characters are closer together — it's a very fun image and easy to resize. At 300:

I like that one better too, since it's from the comic and I like the comic better than the show.

Buuut, for the sake of those who asked, here's 4, cropped and resized at 350:

I think that's the best so far.

That's good.

I think it's a bit tacky, but it's better than the current.

I vote for 4 or 5.

To reiterate, I like the image in post 6, primarily because it's cleaner and the characters are all wearing the same outfits so that the main thing distinguishing them is the elemental powers.

edited 3rd Feb '13 1:50:00 PM by Scardoll

All of them but 6 and current look disgusting to me. I'd rather keep the current, but when I try to think of a reason I realize that I don't actually have one, so I'm perfectly okay with 6.

A vote for 6.

One or two more votes for 6 and we can run with it.

I like 6

I started to run with 6, but turns out it's essentially the same image as is on the series page (that one has a colored background). Shouldn't be hard to find a new pic for that page, but I'm not putting 6 up until the issue's resolved.

This one?◊

Where are the elements?

That proposal was about replacing the W.I.T.C.H. article, not the elements one.

That looks good. If someone will upload that, put it on W.I.T.C.H., and tag the page, I'll put 6 up on Elemental Powers. Caption or no for that one in the meantime?

I prefer no caption for elegance.

Looks like someone else got the show, so I updated Elemental Powers.

I'm good with no caption, myself.

I really can't think of anything that needs to be said that can clarify or improve the image, so consider the following a joke:

"What The Witch Hunter sees: bad hair days, arson, witchcraft, flooding and razor petals."

Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking needs to have the jaywalking at the end, not at the beginning of the triple.

edited 5th Feb '13 11:38:56 AM by SeptimusHeap