PINNACLE OF MAN
Well, there's Zero, Yoshikage Kira, Saitama, Satsockings, Beerus, Vegeta, Blake, Blue-Haired Dio, Freeza and Diego Brand- HOLY SHIT IS THAT ORO
My gallery is a wee bit bigger, they have Yellow Diamond, Cro-Maine, whose club can throw you off a cliff, Pet Shop, Bolbox, Iggy, Bird-King, and Chargeman Ken with his ray-gun.
I'd put it at 50/50, but let's face it: the Triumvirate of Jimmies always wins.
I am the most suitable partner for Gaia. I have some bad news. You will not make it to Eden. This is the end of your journey.
Divine Burden
My gallery is a fairly larger than yours, with the usual DBZ hax characters and stuff.
Even if we put the Beyonder out of all these fights, for fairness's sake, there are way too many planet/solar system/universe busters for the powerful guys in your gallery to stand a chance. My gallery will certainly take loose but the sisters (red-headed OCs), DBZ and the likes ftw.
edited 10th Apr '16 3:29:50 AM by Bolded1
Fallout 2? More like Fallout 2 bad.
Don't Try It
You have multiple Gokus, Vegetas and a Frieza. I have a couple of Force-Users and some using guns.
You might win because you have greater numbers.
It's Over Anakin, I have the high ground!
PINNACLE OF MAN
You have a few force users. I think my gallery will be able to pull through!
I am the most suitable partner for Gaia. I have some bad news. You will not make it to Eden. This is the end of your journey.
Mine would probably win. Having the Anthropomorphic Personification of the ocean on your side is good, but won't really help against another embodiment of the ocean, the embodiment of magma and volcanic destruction and a Planet Eater. Most everything else in my gallery is pretty overpowered, too.
edited 10th Apr '16 7:53:48 PM by Ghostninja109
Dread Pirate Captain
A long, grueling war in favor of your (![[up]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]"){kind=icon}
) gallery.
The weaker ones of both of our galleries would be eliminated pretty much immediately, but I doubt even the amount of Saiyans you have in your gallery can defeat Nyarlathotep, Yog-Sothoth, Azathoth, and SCP-682 at the same time.
I don't have anything that can stand up against Outer Gods, so it's all over when they show up.
Your gallery wins. I'm clearly outnumbered, and many of your avatars look pretty powerful. 
The man behind the slaughter
Mine win rather easily.
"Take your weapon; strike me down with all of your hatred, and your journey towards the Dark Side will be complete."
But does your gallery have anything capable of killing an Outer God? I think not.
Into Oblivion
Would Batman, Deadpool and a black hole do the trick?
please call me "XionKuriyama" or some variation, thanks! | What is the good deed that you can do right now?
All depends of if Zodiark's Limit Break of punching a hole in reality works against a black hole. Otherwise, the characters in my gallery my gallery defeat all of the characters in yours on account of sheer numbers, but die to the black hole, which would be your win.
edited 21st Apr '16 6:16:11 PM by Ghostninja109
The Vagrant
I have deities of all kinds, and a huge avatar gallery. Looks like this will be mine.
Creator of the Avatar Arena and its Discord server.
The Silence That Speaks Volumes
Funny you'd mention that; my gallery has 2 godslayers, a nigh-invulnerable suit of Animated Armor with a weapon that can also kill deities, the goddess Izanami, the immortal dragon embodiment of destruction, and a demented vampire who can literally destroy anything.
edited 21st Apr '16 11:56:04 PM by TrulyDeceptive
The truth can oft be more misleading... I'm driven by greed, guilt, rage, and despair, but I'll never try to justify haughtiness.
You'd probably win this on sheer numbers.
straight up just a bear
I don't have a very combat-orientented gallery so yours would probably win. Taking down Pucci would be pretty tough, though.
edited 22nd Apr '16 3:23:18 PM by Sedmikrasky
The man behind the slaughter
Pucci could win it if he has Stairway to Heaven.
"Take your weapon; strike me down with all of your hatred, and your journey towards the Dark Side will be complete."
The Vagrant
Hmm... probably mine because of the numbers.
Creator of the Avatar Arena and its Discord server.
PINNACLE OF MAN
Above guy wins.
I am the most suitable partner for Gaia. I have some bad news. You will not make it to Eden. This is the end of your journey.
I lose.
When life gives you lemons, burn life's house down with the lemons.
Red Like Santa
Mine. I have a ton of powerful bastards.
Now known as Cyber Controller
straight up just a bear
Tough call. I feel like Pucci and Giorno at their strongest could wipe the floor with most of your guys, but Bill Cipher is a problem. I'd just call it a tie.
edited 30th Apr '16 4:22:43 PM by Sedmikrasky
I have doubts that even Pucci and Giorno at their strongest could stand a fighting chance against Nyarlathotep or Yog-Sothoth.
Your gallery.