YMMV / Son of the Mask

  • Critical Backlash: As stated in the main description, a number of viewers don't think the movie's as bad as the reviews said, and think it works best as an Actually Pretty Funny love-letter to The Golden Age of Animation.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Loki and Dr. Neuman.
  • Evil Is Sexy: Alan Cumming as Human!Loki. We even get to see him in a speedo at one point!
  • Fridge Horror: One might wonder what Alvey is gonna do once he's a grown up. Hopefully his parents will teach him right and wrong enough to avoid this!
  • Fridge Logic:
    • Wasn't Loki trapped inside the Mask before? As a half-assed answer to this, the sequel declares the source of this plot point (Dr. Neuman) to be unreliable, and retcons the Mask's history in the first scene, so as to get it out of the way and get right to the new stuff. In The Mask, it's Neuman who delivers the exposition regarding the Mask's connection to Loki. In the beginning of the sequel, Neuman returns to relate Loki's back-story to a museum tour group, ending it with Loki's binding. The actual Loki happens to be in the group, disproving (and loudly objecting to) Neuman's mythology.
      • But even that was a massive retcon. There was a scene filmed for the first movie, though cut for time, showing vikings carrying the wooden mask across the ocean and burying it because it had Loki himself trapped inside. The comic adaptation of the film also includes this same scene with enough exposition to confirm that, yes, Loki himself was sealed away.
    • So the mask removes all inhibitions and self-control. Why is it that until now no one, throughout the entire history of man, got the mask, got laid, and made a God-Baby?
      • Because up until that point, everyone who had gotten the Mask either became insanely greedy, violent or lustful for the sake of lust; Tim was the first one whose biggest hang-up wasn't any of that but specifically having a baby.
    • For someone who is really pissed about Loki's mask causing so much trouble for humans, why doesn't Odin just possess Tim and grab the mask from his home at... well, any point he likes?
    • Why does Alvey use his powers to make references to things he couldn't possibly know about? note 
  • Heartwarming Moments:
    • The scene of Tim bonding with Alvey, set to a cover of "What a Wonderful World".
    • Loki patching things up with his father Odin and the two of them going home together.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Alan Cumming, a veteran of a Marvel movie adaptation, playing Loki.
  • Just Here for Godzilla: Loki. Arguably the only reason people watch this movie at all.
  • Nausea Fuel: When Alvey pees on Tim. And his peeing turns into a fountain.
    The Nostalgia Critic: Why are you making me think about a baby with three penises?! What twisted pigshit does that?!
  • Sequelitis: One of the more prominent 21st century examples.
  • Signature Scene: Other than Loki, the most memorable scene is the remix of "Can't Take My Eyes of You", despite all of its cheesiness.
  • Special Effects Failure: Most, if not all, of Alvey's effects. Depressingly, the movie's lead FX house was Industrial Light and Magic!
    • Otis also looks way too "cartoonish" when masked, but that was more than likely intentional.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: A boy with Mask powers, a dog that wears the Mask, and the maker of the Mask; all Reality Warpers and all mischievous. This had the making of a wild Crazy Awesome comedy; one scene even had the first and third play Super Twister ending with Loki planning to be a Big Brother Mentor, but only at the end. The potential here is just not exploited.
  • The Scrappy: Almost everybody (except arguably Loki and Dr. Neuman)! But Alvey is the most prominent example.
  • Took the Bad Film Seriously: Everyone.note 
  • Uncanny Valley: Alvey. You can always tell when he's about to use his powers, because he'll morph from a regular baby into some CGI abomination right before using any special effects.
    • Tim Avery is also pretty unsettling when he's wearing the mask, with his fake-looking green face and obviously plastic hair. The fact that the camera is often zoomed in on it does not help.
  • Unintentionally Unsympathetic: Alvey.
  • Vindicated by History: Not a perfect example. The film got a massive backlash upon its release, but 10 years after its release its response has escalated to moderately mixed, and a lot of viewers find at least one scene genuinely funny.
  • What Do You Mean, It's for Kids?: There's a sperm fertilization scene in some DVD copies of this PG movie.
    • Mercilessly lampshaded by the Nostalgia Critic at every one of the film's more horrifying moments:
    The Nostalgia Critic: Kids, see Son of the Mask! A FAMILY picture!
  • What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs?: Almost all the sequences that attempt to be funny or which show the Mask's powers. Especially the subplot about Otis and Alvey, with its length and Uncanny Valley.