These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
"(Don't Go Back To) Rockville" almost qualifies, were it not for "and waste another year".
"The One I Love" is an inversion: more people know the verses ("This one goes out to the one I love...") instead of the chorus (Michael Stipe holding the word "fire" for an entire bar while Mike Mills sings "She's comin' down on her own" repeatedly in the background).
Covered Up: Their version of "Superman" has become better known than the Clique's original.
So much so that when the song appeared, re-recorded, in a 1999 commercial, some parts of their fandom were shocked that the band had supposedly sold themselves out in such a manner. The group responded with the fact that, simply, it wasn't their song to begin with, so they basically had no control over what was done with it.
Also, "Strange" is often thought of as a song they originally performed. You'd think the fact that it's credited to a different set of writers would tip off people that it was originally performed by another band.
Crowning Moment of Heartwarming: During "Let Me In" live performances, the bandmembers form a closed circle and perform an acoustic version of the song as a tribute to Kurt Cobain, to whom the song is dedicated.
Epic Riff: Many. The most famous one is "Losing My Religion" for obvious reasons, but others include "Man on the Moon," "Drive," and "What's the Frequency, Kenneth?". Some of their more recent material, such as "Supernatural Superserious" and "Discoverer," also applies.
Face of the Band: Michael Stipe, although he isn't the main creative force as every member contributes to the final product.
Fanon Discontinuity: Changes from person to person. For some fans, it's after Fables of the Reconstruction, when the band cleaned up their sound; for others, after they signed on Warner Bros.. For most, it's after Bill Berry left.
While their appeal varies, the first three albums without Berry (Up, Reveal, and Around the Sun) are often considered a Dork Age that was ended by Accelerate.
First Installment Wins: Most people feel that debut album Murmur is their best album. Reckoning, their second, occasionally gets this as well.
Somewhat averted by the popularity of Green and Document.
Automatic for the People, although markedly different to their earlier material in many ways, has frequently been strongly-received too. Some British polls have even ranked it alongside critical favourites such as OK Computer and Revolver in the past.
"Welcome To The Occupation" is deliberately written in such a manner that it can either be about an 'occupation' as in a job, or it can be about an 'occupation' as in a country in war. Both meanings imply that the people involved had hoped for better things but have no real choice in the matter. Being screwed over by the government is the main theme of the Document album.
Also, the political subtext of "The Flowers of Guatemala" is more obvious to anyone who knows that Amanita is actually the name of a genus of very poisonous fungi.
Germans Love David Hasselhoff: When their popularity dropped off in America, they remained popular in the UK and Ireland, mostly because the genre of music the band performs remains extremely popular in those countries. Indeed, Around the Sun (their only studio album never to have had a song place even on the Bubbling Under chart in the U.S.) produced a #5 hit in the UK.
Also inverted: their first album, Murmur, was a hit in the US but did not chart anywhere else (except New Zealand, where it was only a minor hit). They did not even hit the top 10 in any other country besides the US until they signed with Warner Bros.
Hilarious in Hindsight: The opening lyrics of "It's the End of the World As We Know It (And I Feel Fine)": "That's great, it starts with an earthquake, birds and snakes, an aeroplane..." Made even funnier by the Mondegreen where people hear it as "snakes in airplanes".
Vindicated by History: Monster is probably the band's most dramatic example of this, but this applies to some extent to almost all of the band's post-Automatic output, which was ignored or reviled until the band broke up, at which point people went back and began reconsidering.