A Nightingale sang in Berkeley Square subtext. What do you make of it?At the end of the book: a nightingale sang in Berkeley square. As said on the YMMV page, it's a very old and sappy love song but, don't you notice somethings very interesting about the lyrics?
- That certain night, the night we met,There was magic abroad in the air.
- There were angels dining at the ritz,
- And a nightingale sang in berkeley square.
- I may be right, I may be wrong,
But I'm perfectly willing to swear
That when you turned and smiled at me,
A nightingale sang in berkeley square.The moon that lingered over london'town
Poor puzzled moon, he wore a frown.
How could he know that we two were so in love?The whole darn world seemed upside down.
- The streets of town were paved with stars,
It was such a romantic affair.
And as we kissed and said goodnight,
A nightingale sang in berkeley square.
- When dawn came stealing up, all gold and blue
- To interrupt our rendez-vous,
I still remember how you smiled and said,
"was that a dream? or was it true? "
- Our homeward step was just as light
As the dancing of Fred Astaire,
And like an echo far away
A nightingale sang in Berkeley square.
Who could play the different characters?Not that much of a WMG, but it fits here better than on the main page.
- Summer Glau could play Anathema Device really well... A pretty pale skinned brunette with touches of cuckoocloudlander-ness.
- There's growing support for Tom Hiddleston as Crowley and, by virtue of the fact that they have established rapport (Wallander, Thor, etc.), Kenneth Branagh as Aziraphale. It's an understatement to say this would be ALL KINDS OF AWESOME.
- I second Tom as Crowley. He was literally the first thing that popped into mind when I read his description. I can't quite see Kenneth Branagh as Aziraphale though. I keep seeing Martin Freeman.
- Stephen Fry is Aziraphale—gay, intelligent, extremely English, well-read, middle-aged, even has a habit of calling people "dear" ...
- Which means that Hugh Laurie is Crowley.
- These two could be put to far better use as minor characters. Creative cameos!
- Mark Gatiss is Aziraphale. Martin Freeman is Aziraphale. Benedict Cumberbatch is Aziraphale.
- Too much Sherlock baggage on all of them at this point, although Freeman could've done Newt ten years ago.
- Colin Farrell is Crowley. I'd even say Paul Bettany is Aziraphale.
- For my money, Colin Farrell might make a good Newt, and Paul Bettany would make a perfect Metatron.
- David Tennant...oh, bugger it for a lark, he could play either of them. Brilliantly.
- Actually, I'd love to see him as the Delivery Man. It's a minor role, but a crucial one, and he'd play it with appropriate whimsy!
- Tennant playing Crowley with Benedict Cumberbatch as Aziraphale.
- Mark Sheppard is Crowley. (He's already played a demon named Crowley...)
- From what this troper's seen so far, that particular name match-up has provided a great excuse for crossover fic.
- Really not sure I could see him as Crowley (his manner's not quite right), but what about as Hastur or Ligur?
- Noel Fielding as Crowley and Julian Barratt as Aziraphale. That is all.
- Tom Hardy as Aziraphale. I don't know why, it just works.
- Imelda Stauton as Sister Mary Loquacious.
- Simon Pegg and Nick Frost as Hastur and Ligur.
- Andy Serkis as Shadwell.
- Matt Gordon as Crowley, appearance-wise. He's the Paco Rabanne model for 1 Million. This troper's not so sure about his acting skils, but that's what he should look like. It's the cheekbones, what can I say?
- Suranne Jones (played Idris in Doctor Who) as Anathema.
- Steve Buscemi is Crowley, Stephen Fry as Aziraphale. That would be utterly perfect in my opinion.
- Vinette Robinson (yes from Sherlock) as Anathelma Device. Just think about it. It works, in my opinion!
- Thomas Sangster as Adam. Scarlet Johansson as War. (See what I did there?) James Earl Jones as the voice of Death. Hey, it could happen... in a quantum sense, anyway.
- This trope is always going to be disappointed that she'll never get to see young Kyle Mac Lachlan as the delivery man. Or Aziraphale.
- Cillian Murphy as Famine. It works.
- Richard Ayoade as Azirphale, Sendhil Ramurphy as Crowley, Oona Chaplin as Anathema, and Dev Patel as Newt. Think about it.
The 4-part TV adaptation of Good Omens will have a soundtrack consisting entirely of music from Queen.Search your feelings, you know it to be true.
- God I hope so.
- Yes, but... but... Bat out of Hell!
- And "Under Pressure," and "Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy," come to it.
- But you can't forget "A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square."
- Additionally, Brian May and/or Roger Taylor will make a cameo. And the world will collapse because of the overload of pure epicness.
When the REAL Judgement Day comes, God will make Crowley and Aziraphale honorary humans.Angels are either good or evil. Humans come in shades of grey. Crowley and Aziraphale are basically humans with special powers. Therefore, on the real Judgement Day, God will judge them as if they had been humans all along and not slowly become that way.
BEST POSSIBLY UNINTENTIONAL PAYING-WAY-TOO-MUCH-ATTENTION-WHEN-YOU-READ-IT-FOR-THE-THIRD-TIME FORESHADOWING EVER:Crowley's musings on page 93 about good and evil end in 'where you found the real McCoy...was right inside the human mind.' On page 275, War describes herself and the horsepeople to a biker as 'the real McCoy'. On page 359, DEATH states that the other horsepeople have gone back 'WHERE THEY BELONG'...right inside the human mind. This troper squee'd when she noticed. Yes, I'm a loser.
- That is awesome. Thank you. Might this belong in Fridge Brilliance?
The Them grow up to become Sex Bob-Omb.Or, at least, they are each other's AU equivalents. Adam is Scott (warping reality to fit his ideal, which has now become video games), Pepper is Kim (redhead, irritable, heart of gold), Brian is Stephen Stills (relaxed and more fun-loving), and Wensleydale is Young Neil (um... process of elimination?)
- Alternatively, Adam went on to become Owl City.
The Them will grow up to be the next Horsepersons/Bikers of the ApocalypseAlternatively, they would - but because they're human, they don't fulfill the roles properly and the apocalypse never actually comes to pass. Pepper is War. She's always getting into fights. Brian is Pollution - he's constantly dirty and crisp packets apparently accumulate on the ground wherever he goes. Wensleydale is Famine. He's very fastidious and therefore is probably very careful about what he eats, just as he's very careful about everything else. Adam is Death. He's everywhere, all the time, and you can't really get rid of him.
- I noticed the parallel on my last re-read and assumed it was deliberate. Adam was supposed to be the Antichrist, but instead he grew up human. So instead of changing the world with the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, he gathered his own horsemen (well, horseboys and -girl) and turned the world over to human control, rather than starting a war that would end in either Heaven or Hell controlling the Earth.
Shadwell is an angel/demon gone rogue (and native).Probably an old-fashioned angel, considering the witch-hunting thing and his constant condemning of Madame Tracy's, ahem, profession. It could be inferred that he has some kind of supernatural ability, considering his ability to apparently produce cigarettes from nowhere, light them without a match or lighter and make them disappear when he's finished with them, plus the fact that he manages to subsist on nothing but condensed milk, sweet tea and the aformentioned cigarettes, which no human could do.
- Problem: It's mentioned Madame Tracy cooks meals for him and leaves them at the door. Shadwell waits just long enough for her to leave before opening the door and taking the food.
- Who says he actually eats the food though? He could just take it because of the sheer inconvenience of leaving it outside the door to pile up and start smelling a bit.
God is the unnamed postal service worker who delivers the Horsepersons' artifactsBecause He is the only character who is listed among the dramatis personae but is not explicitly introduced in the text. Also, we all know that God loves playing janitors, postal workers, and such.
- This sounds like a brilliant WMG, but how would you explain Him getting killed?
- He doesn't actually get killed though. Even after meeting Death, He appears at the end of the last battle.
- He IS ineffable.
- Or he could be Jesus, since the Seals are meant to be broken by 'The Lamb of God'.
Tadfield stands on the same spot where the Garden of Eden once wasThere are many hints throughout the book lampshading its "paradise"-like properties. Also, makes sense for it to be in the middle of everything.
- That's because Adam lives there. He wants it to be nice, so it is.
- At the end of the book, Adam climbs up an apple tree and reflects on how "there never was an apple... that wasn't worth the trouble you got into for eating it". Based on that alone, I'd say the above WMG is completely true, if never explicitly stated.
Agnes' second book only had empty pages in itBecause she has, of course, foreseen that Anathema will not read it.
Ligur was resurrected along with the humans killed in the Armageddon't.Thus, Hell no longer has a reason to let Hastur harm Crowley. Doesn't mean he might not try, but Hell may step in. Or Adam may.
- I don't know if you invented the Armageddon't, but it is magnificent.
Hastur bought H.P. Lovecraft's soul.Hence his inclusion in the Cthulhu Mythos.
The original four Horsemen are the first four biblical humans.Eve got the flaming sword; This is Red's sword sword. As far as I can recall, it's never said that Aziraphale tracked down his original sword, and he could have been given a replacement after going through the proper bureaucratic channels. If it does say that that's the sword he gave away, then Red's sword is just a different, less warm sword that exemplifies her personification. Cain got Kicked Upstairs into the role of Famine, as part of his eternal, highly unpleasant punishment for killing Abel. Abel, the first human to die, provides a filter through which Azrael can communicate with living humans and the world of the living without them dying (prescriptively or proscriptively). Adam was Conquest, who followed his wife; everntually, in his role as both the first human and what follows in the wake of War, he became Pestilence. I'm not sure who Pollution is; He may be practically anyone, depending on when Pollution stepped into the job and how long someone can be around (in whatever form) before taking on the mantle. This is not quite incompatible with the highly significant plot point that eating the fruit of The Tree of Knowledge (of Good and Evil) gave humans mortality. Humans have been shown in The Bible to be able to attain immortality (through divine intervention, or after death, but still). If having eaten of the fruit personally made Adam, Eve, and their unborn child/children exceptionally human, they could easily have become some of the Anthropomorphic Personifications of humanity, and the ones who happened to be tasked to ride out (by God or fate or a poorly addressed package) in the event of an apocalypse.
The reason that Aziraphale & Crowley are now living together in a cottage on the South Downs is that they were Reassigned to AntarcticaIt was quite embarrassing for both Heaven and Hell to have prepared so extensively for an Apocalypse that never came to be, so they needed to find someone to blame. Thankfully neither Aziraphale nor Crowley had directly contributed to the averting of the Apocalypse, so they couldn't be charged with any crime in particular except perhaps not obeying orders or murdering another demon in cold blood in Crowley's case. But from Hastur's attitude, demons probably kill each other all the time with little to no repercussions, so Hell couldn't pin that one on Crowley. And anyways, it would be even more embarrassing to admit that two agents were fraternizing with each other, so to cover up the whole mess Aziraphale and Crowley were demoted and sent to a quiet village where they would be able to do very little harm and keep out of sight. Of course, since both are very fond of each other and actually like living with humans, they probably egged on their superiors in an attempt to stay together on Earth. So now Aziraphale and Crowley are essentially retired and living comfortably with each other while their superiors consider this a punishment for the Saturday That Never Was (an Arrangement that works out for EVERYBODY, fangirls/-boys included, if I ever saw one).
To go with the above, Aziraphale's position on Earth was also Reassigned to AntarcticaAfter all, Aziraphale is a Principality and used to the Guardian of the East Gate of Eden, and it should be noted that Aziraphale is the only angel we meet that is seen on Earth. Perhaps God wasn't pleased about Aziraphale giving his flaming sword to humans and banished him to Earth, where he adapted and learned to like living among humans. Or was it a punishment after all...?
Pestilence is going to come out of retirementDue to antibiotic resistant disease strains.
- Or to make zombies.
- Pestilence spread the idea that vaccines caused Autism.
War was once known as Helen of Troy.Daughter of Zeus my left foot. Now Shrouded in Myth, War is in no way associated with that gorgeous redhead that used to hang around Menelaus and Paris a lot. Alternately, War had a daughter, who turned out to be Helen.
How Adam's powers workAdam altered reality to fit his view of the world. But where would he get a view of the world? From books. Adam probably read books with eleven year old protagonists when he was a child, and he thought that he would grow up like that. So he did.
Crowley doesn't just drink because he likes the taste...
- He doesn't seem to be all that happy about what happened during the Spanish Inquisition. It's at least vaguely hinted that he drinks to forget.