The finale of The Walking Dead, where Clementine shoots Lee upon request of him to avoid him coming back as a zombie. It made him cry, for God's sake.
The killing of Ben and Kenny also made him cry, despite the characters being right assholes for the long while. Though also a tear jerker, it doesn't compare to the above example, as it didn't just make him cry but made him right out bawl.
"You can be Robin next time. You can be Robin."
His reaction to the end of The Witch's House, especially considering that it was right after he had gone through the above. Viola's dad shoots Viola without even realizing that he shot his own daughter.
Pewdiepie: Not again...
Froggy 2012. Never forget.explanation In part 3 of his Let's Play series of The Witch's House, Pewds ended up having to sacrifice his frog to a snake. He was understandably heartbroken.
Sometimes it's hard to laugh at his horror or sympathize with him.
His expression while listening to the homeless peoples' stories in part 6 of his Beyond: Two Souls playthrough. While he doesn't cry, it's rather sombering, especially for fans who have been used to his comedic exaggerated sobbing.
And as a double-sombering moment for Canadian fans, that episode went up on their Thanksgiving. Ouch.
For a real life example, his "I'm Sorry" video, addressing the Retsupurae controversy.
Somewhat depressing was how the whole thing spiraled out of control to begin with; with Felix's Fan Dumb taking things WAY too far in response. You know, the exact same thing Felix himself has repeatedly criticized them for doing? The fact that the Fan Dumb aids many people's hatred for Pewds makes it worse.
"I deleted most of my early videos. People were all like, 'Wow, he sounds so fucking stupid here.' They still comment that."
The Saddest Story Ever video. A heartwrenching cover set to footage of Pewdie crying and looking depressed, and we see him dropping something that turns out to be a picture of Marzia. Millions of hearts shattered.
His entire reaction to the game. He is noticeably calm. His face throughout the playthrough can be described as shock.
The ending of episode four of his Journey LP, where his accomplice Bengtdiesin the snow. What makes it worse is that you had no idea that it was coming—you only had a hint from the episode title ("SADDEST ENDING!") that a Tear Jerker was going to drop. But after tagging alongside Pewdie for the entirety of the game up until that point, Bengt's death was rather jarring for most bros.