Recap / Tarrytown

Tarrytown

• From New York to Nowhere
• Location Song
• Setting Introduction Song

Katrina’s Welcome Song

• Motor Mouth: Katrina barely lets Ichabod get a word in edgewise.
• The Something Song
• Welcoming Song

My New Gay Best Friend

• Friendship Song
• Gay Best Friend: What Katrina seeks from Ichabod
• Awful Wedded Life: Katrina slips in small references to her resentment towards Brom

Four Downs To The Ten-Yard Line

• Counterpoint Duet
• Eating the Eye Candy: How Ichabod gets through the football game. Brom makes some references implying a similar reaction to football.
• Hopeless Suitor: Ichabod expresses that the guys he likes are always either straight, unavailable, or uninterested when bemoaning his attraction to Brom.
• Instant Seduction: Ichabod is wildly interested in Brom within minutes of meeting him.

Dinner For Three - Part 1

• Dinner and a Show: A very passive aggressive fight bubbles under the surface between Brom and Katrina.
• Small Town Boredom: Katrina in spades. Averted with Brom, who is happy with his life in Tarrytown.

Back Home

• Homesickness Hymn: Averted, as Ichabod explains why he is glad to have left New York.
• The Big Rotten Apple: Ichabod had bad experiences in New York that drove him to Tarrytown.

Dinner For Three - Part 2

What Do You Do?

• "I Am" Song: for Katrina
• Shotgun Wedding: Katrina reveals the only reason she married Brom was because of an unplanned pregnancy.

• Melancholy Musical Number

History

• "I Want" Song: for Brom
• Job Song

Goes Away

• From New York to Nowhere: Ichabod finally explains his reasons for leaving.
• Tropaholics Anonymous: Bram sings this at his NA meeting.

Down the Stairs

• "Gaining Confidence" Song: Katrina finds the strength to leave Bram during this song.
• Wanderlust Song

Apple-Picking Song

• Descent into Darkness Song: Brom begins lighthearted but grows sad when he realizes Katrina is leaving him.
• I Want My Beloved to Be Happy: Brom is acting on advice from Ichabod, who is in love with Brom but still helps him try to win Katrina back.
• The Something Song

The Man in the Middle

• Imagine Spot: Ichabod admits he exaggerates Bram's flirtations
• Love Triangle
• Patter Song: Bram and Katrina's verses are like this
• Tropaholics Anonymous: Bram sings this at his NA meeting

The Legend of Sleepy Hollow

• Ghost Song
• Villain Song

When You're Near

• Anguished Declaration of Love
• Love Confession
  " I love you, Brom I love you, I'm in love"
• Official Kiss: or so Ichabod thinks.
• Torch Song

Ichabod

• Dark Reprise: Some sections share a melody with Katrina's Welcome Song.
• Death Song
• Honey Trap: Brom got Ichabod to go to the bridge under the guise of a sexual encounter.
• Imagine Spot: Ichabod imagines a future with Brom
  "And he'll teach me about football and I'll teach him how to be free. Free from himself. Free from his fear! And together we'll weather wherever we steer."
  "He will protect you He's meeting you here That's what he said Any minute now He'll come And we'll go On our way And he'll hold me and I'll Kiss him and cry And he'll know why And he won't say a word Neither will I He'll just lay me down and-"
• Maybe Magic, Maybe Mundane: did Ichabod get pushed off the bridge by Brom or did the Headless Horseman really kill him?
• Sanity Slippage Song
• Song of Many Emotions

Another Halloween

• Downer Ending