Witchy Simone searches the Fickle Sea for an eye of newt with the warriors, but Man Fish the Fish Man is against the quest.
- By the Eyes of the Blind: It is revealed that Zombie Pumpkin Magisword (And anyone who has been given his eyes) can see ghostly apparitions. The newt is oddly okay with this.
- Description Cut: Witchy Simone talks about how humble and responsible the Warriors are. Cut to Prohyas saying "Nothing like a day of being self-absorbed and irresponsible"
- Department of Redundancy Department: Man Fish the Fish man.
- Didn't Think This Through: Simone had very little information to go on, something that irks Vambre.
- Eye of Newt: The last ingredient of Witchy Simone's potion, with her pointing out how cliché it is.
- How Is That Even Possible?: Prohyas' reaction to Simone setting Mummy Magisword's bandages on fire, underwater.
- Leeroy Jenkins: As Prohyas lampshades, Simone doesn't seem to know what subtlety is.
- The Load: Simone insists on going with Prohyas and Vambre, making the mission harder with her impulsiveness.
- Older Than They Think: Kyle reveals that Man Fish is one of the oldest characters in Mighty Magiswords as he originally created him in 1992 as an entry to Nintendo Power’s contest seeking ideas for Mega Man Robot Masters.
- Shamu Fu: Man Fish can summon fish to aid him, including when he slaps Simone with one.
- We Are Not Going Through That Again: After their mission, the Warrior's father calls on the phone and asks for eyes of newt. They respond by throwing the phone out the window.
