Nightmare Fuel / Baman Piderman
- The Basement Monsters (now known as Those Guys) can be rather unsettling.
- Where did they get the blood for the cookie pie?
- How did they get in the basement in the first place?
- Why did the cookie pie grow a face?!
- The end of the Season 3 Opener. Whatever passes for a status quo on this show is screwed.
- Wanda undergoing Undercrank, where she rapidly flickers between several versions of her best Nightmare Face and seems to be growing towards the camera. That girl ain't right.