This bite-sized Rock Opera
is a Recursive Fanfiction
based on the infamously terrifying My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic
. It takes place during and after a few
episodes. It expands
upon several ideas that weren't in the original fic, like how Pinkie's father abused her as a filly
It can be found on Bandcamp here,
and on Soundcloud here.
According to creator George DesRoches (better known as Tarby), the story of Something Broke
is far from over. A redux of the song is planned as the opening track of his upcoming Rock Opera Forever Broken,
which will expand on the original story even more.
Something Broke contains examples of:
- Adaptation Expansion: The song weaves two episodes from the actual show into its storyline, and it works surprisingly well.
- Abusive Parents: Pinkie's father, assuming her cutie mark story wasn't all true.
- Book Ends / Dark Reprise: The first and last songs (after "Let's Begin, which was a preface) have the same beginnings and middles, with similar titles.
- Careful With That Axe: The ending is a textbook example (see Last Note Nightmare below for details).
- Creator Backlash: Tarby doesn't hate the song, but he's somewhat annoyed that it overshadows his other work.
- Dark Reprise: "Hide the Body" is a slow, melancholy version of "Art of the Dress" whose ending reprises "Cupcakes". The album's final track combines this with Lyrical Dissonance.
- Freudian Excuse: Pinkie has one now, in that her dad took advantage of her when she was young.
- Last Note Nightmare: At the end of the final track, Tarby goes from singing to screaming on a dime and the music suddenly becomes loud, dissonant, and abrasive, before cutting into a series of dissonant, lonely guitar notes.
- In The Style Of: The third part ("Young Fliers' Competition) sounds a lot like the Red Hot Chili Peppers, complete with funky guitar, informal, slang-filled lyrics, and gratuitous swearing.
- I'm a Humanitarian: In this adaptation, Pinkie sells the cupcakes.
- Mood Whiplash: Once again, the ending.
- Sampling: The Skull Kid's scream can be heard towards the end of "Late-Night Accident."
- Spiritual Successor: It's like The Wall written for ponies.
- Split Personality Takeover: Pinkamena takes over, starting during Awakening, and finishing during Hide The Body.