Puzzles in Adventure Games
and Adventure-hybrids tend to fall into one of two categories: the Lock and Key Puzzle
, wherein the player must collect and use objects from around the model world to effect changes to the state of the game, and the Set Piece Puzzle
, which consists of a single object to be manipulated.
A Set Piece Puzzle is typically some sort of device, usually a complicated machine, whose controls must be operated in a particular way to solve the puzzle. Most often, interacting with the puzzle will bring up a new user interface, distinct from the one used for playing most of the game.
There are many possible sorts of set piece puzzles, often based on traditional non-computer puzzle toys. For many years, the most popular of these was the Fifteen Puzzle
or sliding-tile puzzle. The Towers of Hanoi
(with a small number of disks) is another favorite. A single round of a Puzzle Game
can often be found built into the mechanism.
Adventure games have long used a combination of the two types of puzzle, though the Set Piece Puzzle became overwhelmingly popular to the point of excluding all others during the dominance of Myst
-clones. These puzzles were popular with designers because, isolated as they were from the rest of the model world, they were technically easier to design and avoided the problem of Combinatorial Explosion
. A game consisting of only this sort of puzzle need not, for example, provide a player inventory at all.
To the player, a mix of both puzzle types adds variety, though overuse of the Set Piece Puzzle makes the puzzles feel disconnected from the narrative, and can lead him to feel that he's dealing with a Solve the Soup Cans
On occasion, the player may be faced with a broken
Set Piece Puzzle, and would have to find an item that repairs the puzzle before it can be played. Examples of this are sporadic, but games that feature both Set-Piece and Lock-And-Key will usually have at least one.
The Set Piece Puzzle
usually features Puzzle Reset
- The illustrated Interactive Fiction adventures of Legend Entertainment typically threw in a handful of these each.
- The 7th Guest begat the genre of basing games around a collection of set piece puzzles.
- Myst, as noted, popularized the format, and many other games of the era followed suit: Shivers, Amber, The Lighthouse, etc.
- Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time included a puzzle sequence to activate the castle's security systems, consisting of a platform that could rotate and move up and down, which you had to use to pick up rods in the correct order and then slot them into the right holes. It's much harder to describe than it is to solve.
- Prince of Persia: Warrior Within has two: One where you have to open a sluice gate to fill a couple of garden fountains with water, and one where you had to trick a boss into helping you get an old clockwork started.
- Every Pokémon game had several of these, involving the Strength HM and Boulders in a cavern, all of which could be reset by leaving the cavern or room and reentering.
- Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver features some puzzles involving putting a stone block on the right slot on the wall to complete the illustration. The fact that the blocks can be turned over adds some smooth difficulty to its solving.
- The Lufia games for the Super Nintendo had a great many of these.
- Each level of 3 in Three is of this form.
- Resident Evil was fond of these in addition to Lock And Key Puzzles. One notable example occurred in "Outbreak," when you would have to turn on power to an elevator by solving one of these puzzles while zombies smacked in the door in real-time.
- Resident Evil 4 has a few of these, including a sliding tile puzzle used to unlock a mechanism
- Any Zelda game ever contains loads of these, mostly involving pushing blocks around.
- The Xenosaga series has a lot of these. From stacking/exploding block puzzles, to audio puzzles, to balancing puzzles. Some were good, some went right into guide dang it.
- LucasArts' Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis contains several of them, often involving inventory, so it's a mix of the two puzzle types.
- Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow contains the 15-tile puzzle in the middle of the Demon Guest House.
- Chrono Cross contains a bunch of these, mainly in Fort Dragonia.
- Hotel Dusk: Room 215 is full of these; they tend to be pretty simple though.
- BioWare's very fond of the Tower of Hanoi. They also frequently use the "press the lit button and the buttons surrounding it light up" puzzle.