History YMMV / OneMomentInTime

* FridgeLogic: If the story changed almost nothing and Peter still exposed his identity to the world...what? Wasn't there even a ''Brand New Day'' story where not even NormanOsborn or Venom even knew who he was, despite knowing his identity even ''before'' he told the world?

* RunningTheAsylum: ''Again''.

* CharacterDerailment: Just as many fans saw ''OneMoreDay'' as arguably Peter's biggest derailment ever, just as many consider ''One Moment In Time'' the biggest one for Mary Jane. If her reasons regarding her own safety aren't inconsistent with her character enough for you (she was always more concerned about Peter than about herself), the whole "the reason I wanted to get married was to have kids" nonsense will be.

* UnfortunateImplications: "Without kids, marriage is just a piece of paper." So marriage only counts if you have kids? Where does that leave all the couples who can't have children or who choose not to have children, or who even ''get married just for the sake of love'' and either decide to not HAVE children, or discuss having kids later?

* HilariousInHindsight[=/=]HarsherInHindsight: Depends on the reader, but the famous page image of of MJ [[SkywardScream skyward screaming]] seemed to be made to mimic (or to mock) the reaction the fans would have.

* CharacterDerailment: Just as many fans saw ''OneMoreDay'' as arguably the biggest example of this for Peter ever, just as many consider ''One Moment In Time'' the biggest example for Mary Jane. If her reasons regarding her own safety aren't inconsistent with her character enough, the whole "the reason I wanted to get married was to have kids" nonsense will.

* UnfortunateImplications: "Without kids, marriage is just a piece of paper." So marriage only counts if you have kids? Where does that leave all the couples who can't have children ([[SarcasmMode Good news, gays who have been campaigning for decades to be married legally! You can't have kids biologically so it doesn't matter anyway!]]) or who choose not to have children, or who even ''get married just for the sake of love'' and either decide to not HAVE children, or discuss having kids later?

* UnfortunateImplications: "Without kids, marriage is just a piece of paper." So marriage only counts if you have kids? Where does that leave all the couples who can't have children ([[SarcasmMode Good news, gays who have been campaigning for decades to be married legally! You can't have kids biologically so it doesn't matter anyway!]]) or who choose not to have children, or who even ''get married just for the sake of love'' and discuss having kids later?

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Quesada finally answers all the fans' unanswered questions about One More Day. Results definitely weren't satisfactory.

* BileFascination - Played with, as you don't initially read it because it's bad, but then Quesada's writing shows up pretty quickly.

* UnfortunateImplications: "Without kids, marriage is just a piece of paper." So marriage only counts if you have kids? Where does that leave all the couples who can't have children([[SarcasmMode Good news, gays who have been campaigning for decades to be married legally! You can't have kids biologically so it doesn't matter anyway!]]) or who choose not to have children, or who even ''get married just for the sake of love'' and discuss having kids later?

* KickThemWhileTheyAreDown: Quesada to the readers.

* BrokenBase: Just as the fandom was finally getting over OneMoreDay this story reopened old wounds.

* RunningTheAsylum: ''Again''.

* AndTheFandomRejoiced: Subverted. Yes, the fandom ''did'' rejoice upon hearing Peter and MJ not only ''talking'' at last, but talking about the events of OMD. The premise was promising... [[ItGotWorse until Mary-Jane said the infamous page quote]].

* NeverLiveItDown: perhaps intentionally, since MJ's page quote is basically ''begging'' for this to happen [[SelfDemonstratingArticle (and giving how much it got referenced in this page already... it seems the quote fullfilled its purpose)]], but the fandom will only remember this [[FanonDiscontinuity "as a memorable quote by the Quesada-verse Mary-Jane Watson"]].
* RunningTheAsylum

* DerailingLoveInterests: Mary Jane, see the page quote.

* CharacterDerailment: Mary Jane, see the page quote.
** DerailingLoveInterests

** DerailingLoveInterests
* {{Narm}}: The revelation of how Peter missed his wedding. [[DropTheCow A fat guy fell on him.]]
** Let's just remember that one of Peter's powers is ''super strength'', and he has, in the past, been seen throwing ''entire cars'' across a city block. And he's out of commission because a fat guy falls on him.
* DarthWiki/WallBanger:... Oh, ''where'' to begin? [[{{WallBangers/OneMomentInTime}} A whole page should be enough.]]

* WallBanger:... Oh, ''where'' to begin? [[{{WallBangers/OneMomentInTime}} A whole page should be enough.]]

* WallBanger:... Oh, ''where'' to begin?

** Let's just remember that one of Peter's powers is ''super strength'', and he has, in the past, been seen throwing ''entire cars'' across a city block. And he's out of commission because a fat guy falls on him.

* {{Narm}}: The revelation of how Peter missed his wedding. [[DropTheCow A fat guy fell on him.]]