Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / ShanghaiNoon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DirtyCop: Sheriff Van Cleef. He was a collaborator of Lo Fong's plan to ransom Princess Pei Pei, likely in exchange for a cut of the gold.


Added DiffLines:

* EpicFail: The fact that Roy loses control of his gang to Wallace -a buffoonish idiot who had ''just joined it.''


Added DiffLines:

* VillainHasAPoint: Van Cleef asking how Roy [[ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy with his horrendous gunplay]] can survive in the Old West which isn't an invalid question. Especially considering Roy [[Lame Comeback doesn't have much of a response]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CatchAndReturn: When protecting the Sioux Chief's daughter against a pair of angry rival braves, Chon catches their thrown tomahawks in midair and chucks them back, [[SubvertedTrope both catch them with ease.]]

to:

* CatchAndReturn: When protecting the Sioux Chief's daughter against a pair of angry rival braves, Chon catches their thrown tomahawks in midair and chucks them back, [[SubvertedTrope both catch them with ease.right into their waiting hands.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CatchAndReturn: Unexpected, because it's done by a random Indian warrior to Chon Wang, the Chinese martial artist.

to:

* CatchAndReturn: Unexpected, because it's done by When protecting the Sioux Chief's daughter against a random Indian warrior to pair of angry rival braves, Chon Wang, the Chinese martial artist.catches their thrown tomahawks in midair and chucks them back, [[SubvertedTrope both catch them with ease.]]

Added: 398

Changed: 174

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImprovisedWeapon: Chon Wang employs them in every fight scene.

to:

* ImprovisedWeapon: In typical Jackie Chan movie fashion Chon Wang employs them in every fight scene.scene. Whether it's tree branches, a giant bear statue or a pair of moose antlers, if it can be picked up it's a lethal weapon in Chon's hands.


Added DiffLines:

* MadeOfIron: Chon and Roy take a ton of punishment over the course of the movie and neither of them seem seriously or permanently hurt. Chon takes a twenty foot fall down church bell tower hitting multiple ropes on the way down and is able to get back up relatively quickly. Roy is shoved across the entire length of a bar into a giant table full of sharp glass and pretty much just walks it off.

Added: 477

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IndianMaiden: While lost in the woods, Chon rescues a young indian boy from a rival tribe, and finds himself married to his older sister as a reward.

to:

* IndianMaiden: While lost in the woods, Chon rescues a young indian Native American boy from a rival tribe, and finds himself married to his older sister as a reward.


Added DiffLines:

* InformedFlaw: It's never really made clear how Chon is considered such an inept embarrassment in China. When he gets to the United States he rampages through most of his opponents, only having trouble with two other highly trained martial artists, one of whom (Lo Fong) fought dirty at every opportunity.


Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: The circumstances that caused Lo Fong to become a traitor. It's mentioned that he "ran away from the Forbidden City" but that's all the audience is told.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassHasAPoint: Played with since Chon isn't a {{Jerkass}}. [[spoiler: In Shanghai Knights, Roy asks Chon to speak to Lin and put in a good word with her. Instead, Chon tells Lin of Roy's bad habits, including drinking, smoking, gambling, womanizing and tendency to lie. While this is undoubtedly stabbing Roy in the back, Chon does have a point. Despite being friends, Roy has often lied to Chon and has indulged in habits that make him unsuitable for marriage. What can caused this trope to be played straight is that Roy is genuinely in love with Lin.]]

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Played with since Chon isn't a {{Jerkass}}. [[spoiler: In Shanghai Knights, Roy asks Chon to speak to Lin and put in a good word with her. Instead, Chon tells Lin of Roy's bad habits, including drinking, smoking, gambling, womanizing and tendency to lie. While this is undoubtedly stabbing Roy in the back, Chon does have a point. Despite being friends, Roy has often lied to Chon and has indulged in habits that make him unsuitable for marriage. What can caused lead this trope to be played straight is that Roy is genuinely in love with Lin.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GivenNameReveal: At the end of the film, Roy reveals that his name isn't really Roy O'Bannon but [[spoiler:Wyatt Earp]], much to Chon's amusement.

Changed: 303

Removed: 716

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
People, including Roy, are racist to Wang many times throughout the first film.


* PoliticallyCorrectHistory: Despite the fact that both films are set in the 1890's, both films avoid the widespread racism of the era.
** In Shanghai Noon, none of the public ever once makes a racist comment about Chon, and they allow him to sit on a train despite the fact that racial segregation was fiercely enforced. Similarly, the Chinese railroad workers are treated fairly, despite the fact that many of the bosses in the actual were vicious racists who had a fierce WeHaveReserves mentality regarding the workers.
** In Shanghai Knights, with the sole exception of Chon, nobody ever seems surprised to see Roy showing romantic interest in Lin. In the 1890's in London, interracial marriage was explicitly seen as horrific, and the effects of British colonialism are largely unaddressed in the film, and is actually used for comedy at one point.

to:

* PoliticallyCorrectHistory: Despite the fact that both films are set in the 1890's, both films avoid the widespread racism of the era.
**
In Shanghai Noon, none of the public ever once makes a racist comment about Chon, and they allow him to sit on a train despite the fact that racial segregation was fiercely enforced. Similarly, the Chinese railroad workers are treated fairly, despite the fact that many of the bosses in the actual were vicious racists who had a fierce WeHaveReserves mentality regarding the workers.
** In Shanghai Knights,
''Shanghai Knights'', with the sole exception of Chon, nobody ever seems surprised to see Roy showing romantic interest in Lin. In the 1890's in London, interracial marriage was explicitly seen as horrific, and the effects of British colonialism are largely unaddressed in the film, and is actually used for comedy at one point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Played with since Chon isn't a {{Jerkass}}. [[spoiler: In Shanghai Knights, Roy asks Chon to speak to Lin and put in a good word with her. Instead, Chon tells Lin of Roy's bad habits, including drinking, smoking, gambling, womanizing and tendency to lie. While this is undoubtedly stabbing Roy in the back, Chon does have a point. Despite being friends, Roy has often lied to Chon and has indulged in habits that make him unsuitable for marriage. What can caused this trope to be played straight is that Roy is genuinely in love with Lin.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigDamnHeroes: Chon and Roy fail at this whenever the RuleOfFunny calls for it, but succeed whenever the RuleOfDrama is in play.

to:

* BigDamnHeroes: Chon and Roy fail at this whenever the RuleOfFunny calls for it, but succeed whenever the RuleOfDrama is in play. There's also all the times Falling Leaves shows up to pull them out of trouble such as when they're in prison or about to be executed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InsistentTerminology: When Chon confronts Roy in the saloon after following Roy's directions to Carson City got him badly lost, he accuses Roy of giving him "bad directions". Roy, who Chon left buried up to his neck in sand with only a pair of chopsticks in his mouth to dig himself out with, calmly corrects Chon that he gave him ''wrong'' directions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Shanghai Noon'' is a comedy {{Western}} film starring Creator/JackieChan and Creator/OwenWilson. Chan plays a Chinese guardsman, Chon Wang, who travels to America to rescue the kidnapped Imperial princess Pei-Pei (Creator/LucyLiu), teaming up along the way with disreputable gunslinger Roy O'Bannon (played by Owen), a small time robber with delusions of grandeur. Together, the two forge through one misadventure after another. Directed by Tom Dey, it was written by [[Series/{{Smallville}} Alfred Gough and Miles Millar]]. The movie, set in Nevada and other parts of the west in the 19th century, is a juxtaposition of a western with a Creator/JackieChan MartialArtsMovie. It also has elements of comedy and the "Buddy Cop" film genre, as it involves two men of different personalities and ethnicities (a Chinese imperial guard and a Western outlaw) [[TheyFightCrime who team up to stop a crime]].

to:

''Shanghai Noon'' is a martial arts/{{Western}} comedy {{Western}} film starring Creator/JackieChan and Creator/OwenWilson. Chan plays a Chinese guardsman, Chon Wang, who travels to America to rescue the kidnapped Imperial princess Pei-Pei (Creator/LucyLiu), teaming up along the way with disreputable gunslinger Roy O'Bannon (played by Owen), a small time robber with delusions of grandeur. Together, the two forge through one misadventure after another. Directed by Tom Dey, it was written by [[Series/{{Smallville}} Alfred Gough and Miles Millar]]. The movie, set in Nevada and other parts of the west in the 19th century, is a juxtaposition of a western with a Creator/JackieChan MartialArtsMovie. It also has elements of comedy and the "Buddy Cop" film genre, as it involves two men of different personalities and ethnicities (a Chinese imperial guard and a Western outlaw) [[TheyFightCrime who team up to stop a crime]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 631

Removed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%** Lin, in the sequel.

to:

%%** ** Lin, is a very capable martial artist in the sequel.



* BuriedAlive: At least from the neck down.
%%* CaliforniaDoubling

to:

* BuriedAlive: At least Roy is left stranded in a desert buried from the neck down.
%%* CaliforniaDoubling
down. Chon Wang comes across him, interrogates him, and gives him a pair of chop sticks to excavate himself with... by using his mouth.



%%* EternallyPearlyWhiteTeeth: Wallace.

to:

%%* * EternallyPearlyWhiteTeeth: Wallace.Wallace has unusually white teeth even though he is often covered in an expected amount of grime.



%%* EvilBrit: Lord Rathbone in ''Knights''.

to:

%%* * EvilBrit: Lord Rathbone is a Brit noble who murders and steals from China in ''Knights''.



%%* HandsomeLech: Roy O'Bannon.

to:

%%* * HandsomeLech: Roy O'Bannon.O'Bannon is always being adored by ladies and he is constantly frequenting brothels.



* IHaveNoSon: At the start of the second movie, Chon's father has disowned him for abandoning the family for America. Chon does not take this very well when Lin informs him of this, especially since [[spoiler: his father said it shortly before he was murdered by Rathbone.]] However, [[spoiler: Chon is given a puzzle box containing a message from his father that he was indeed proud of him.]]

to:

* IHaveNoSon: At the start of the second movie, Chon's father has disowned him for abandoning the family for America. Chon does not take this very well when Lin informs him of this, especially since [[spoiler: his [[spoiler:his father said it shortly before he was murdered by Rathbone.]] However, [[spoiler: Chon [[spoiler:Chon is given a puzzle box containing a message from his father that he was indeed proud of him.]]



%%* StockYuck



%%* UnwillingSuspension: ''Shanghai Knights''.

to:

%%* * UnwillingSuspension: ''Shanghai Knights''.Chon and Roy are left hanging from the clock face of Big Ben in the finale of ''Knights''.



--> ''(with a big smile on his face)'' She's going to fight my battles for me.
%%* VitriolicBestBuds: Chon and Roy.

to:

--> ''(with -->'''Roy:''' ''[with a big smile on his face)'' face]'' She's going to fight my battles for me.
%%* * VitriolicBestBuds: Chon and Roy.Roy are at each other's throats throughout ''Noon'' due to their initial conflict but become good friends by the end..



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LineOfSightAlias: In ''Shanghai Knights'', Roy comes up with the pseudonym "Literature/SherlockHolmes" in this manner. No, not from seeing anything written by Creator/ArthurConanDoyle: In fact, he's the one who inspires Sir Arthur to use that name. Mangling "sure" and "clock" together, Roy ends up with "Sherlock" for a first name; he then notices the manufacturer's nameplate on the Grandfather Clock, "Holmes." He's put on the guest list as "Literature/SherlockHolmes." [[BeenThereShapedHistory Doyle was also in attendance, and asks Roy if he can use that name once things clear up.]]

to:

* LineOfSightAlias: In ''Shanghai Knights'', Roy comes up with the pseudonym "Literature/SherlockHolmes" in this manner. No, not from seeing anything written by Creator/ArthurConanDoyle: In fact, he's the one who inspires Sir Arthur to use that name. Mangling "sure" and "clock" together, Roy ends up with "Sherlock" for a first name; he then He notices the manufacturer's nameplate on the Grandfather Clock, "Holmes." Clock reading, "Sherlock Watchmakers Holmes County Ireland". He's put on the guest list as "Literature/SherlockHolmes." [[BeenThereShapedHistory Doyle was also in attendance, and asks Roy if he can use that name once things clear up.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PoliticallyCorrectHistory: Despite the fact that both films are set in the 1890's, both films avoid the widespread racism of the era.
** In Shanghai Noon, none of the public ever once makes a racist comment about Chon, and they allow him to sit on a train despite the fact that racial segregation was fiercely enforced. Similarly, the Chinese railroad workers are treated fairly, despite the fact that many of the bosses in the actual were vicious racists who had a fierce WeHaveReserves mentality regarding the workers.
** In Shanghai Knights, with the sole exception of Chon, nobody ever seems surprised to see Roy showing romantic interest in Lin. In the 1890's in London, interracial marriage was explicitly seen as horrific, and the effects of British colonialism are largely unaddressed in the film, and is actually used for comedy at one point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MickeyMousing: In Shanghai Knights, part of the market fight scene is choreographed to Film/SingingInTheRain, an homage to one of Jackie Chan's favorite scenes in film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Pei-Pei does not wish to return to the Forbidden City, as she feels she can be a more involved ambassador in the States. She ends up burning the scroll that contains the Imperial Guard's orders to bring her back as an act of finality.

to:

* RebelliousPrincess / ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Pei-Pei does not wish to return to the Forbidden City, as she feels she can be a more involved ambassador in the States.States, and her initial intent in going to the States was to escape an arranged marriage to a barely adolescent boy. She ends up burning the scroll that contains the Imperial Guard's orders to bring her back as an act of finality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LineOfSightName: In ''Shanghai Knights'', Roy comes up with the pseudonym "Literature/SherlockHolmes" in this manner. No, not from seeing anything written by Creator/ArthurConanDoyle: In fact, he's the one who inspires Sir Arthur to use that name.

to:

* LineOfSightName: LineOfSightAlias: In ''Shanghai Knights'', Roy comes up with the pseudonym "Literature/SherlockHolmes" in this manner. No, not from seeing anything written by Creator/ArthurConanDoyle: In fact, he's the one who inspires Sir Arthur to use that name. Mangling "sure" and "clock" together, Roy ends up with "Sherlock" for a first name; he then notices the manufacturer's nameplate on the Grandfather Clock, "Holmes." He's put on the guest list as "Literature/SherlockHolmes." [[BeenThereShapedHistory Doyle was also in attendance, and asks Roy if he can use that name once things clear up.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope


* EverythingsBetterWithPrincesses: Princess Pei-Pei (played by Creator/LucyLiu) in the first movie.

Added: 278

Changed: 211

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lin, in the sequel.

to:

** %%** Lin, in the sequel.



* AllThereInTheManual: Although she's never properly identified and is credited as "Indian Wife", Chon's Indian wife is called Falling Leaves, as noted by the title of the Deleted Scene "Falling Leaves Takes A Dip".
* AnachronismStew: A major source of comedy.
* TheArtfulDodger: Creator/CharlieChaplin
* AuthorityEqualsAsskicking: [[spoiler:Rathbone basically hands Chon his head.]]

to:

* AllThereInTheManual: Although she's never properly identified and is credited as "Indian Wife", Chon's Indian wife is called Falling Leaves, as noted by the title of the Deleted Scene DeletedScene "Falling Leaves Takes A Dip".
* %%* AnachronismStew: A major source of comedy.
* %%* TheArtfulDodger: Creator/CharlieChaplin
* AuthorityEqualsAsskicking: AuthorityEqualsAsskicking:
**
[[spoiler:Rathbone basically hands Chon his head.]]



-->'''Van Cleef:''' What the hell is going on in there?
-->''[Roy is thrown through the front window out into the street]''

to:

-->'''Van Cleef:''' What the hell is going on in there?
-->''[Roy
there?\\
''[Roy
is thrown through the front window out into the street]''



-->'''Roy:''' ''[missing wildly]'' Did I hit you?!
-->'''Van Cleef:''' No. But you're getting ''really'' close.

to:

-->'''Roy:''' ''[missing wildly]'' Did I hit you?!
-->'''Van
you?!\\
'''Van
Cleef:''' No. But you're getting ''really'' close.



* EternallyPearlyWhiteTeeth: Wallace.

to:

* %%* EternallyPearlyWhiteTeeth: Wallace.



* EvilBrit: Lord Rathbone in ''Knights''.

to:

* %%* EvilBrit: Lord Rathbone in ''Knights''.



* HandsomeLech: Roy O'Bannon.

to:

* %%* HandsomeLech: Roy O'Bannon.



* ShamelessFanserviceGirl: In the DeletedScene where Roy walks in on Falling Leaves SkinnyDipping, she's not bothered by his presence and doesn't hesitate to [[SexySurfacingShot emerge from the water]] naked in front of him.



* StoclClockHandHang: In ''Shanghai Knights'', the heroes find themselves in Victorian London. While Chon fights inside the Great Clock of the Palace of Westminster, Roy spends the time crawling on the giant hand of the tower clock. Chon and his opponent fall off the window. Roy manages to catch Chon's hand and they both hang for their lives.

to:

* StoclClockHandHang: StockClockHandHang: In ''Shanghai Knights'', the heroes find themselves in Victorian London. While Chon fights inside the Great Clock of the Palace of Westminster, Roy spends the time crawling on the giant hand of the tower clock. Chon and his opponent fall off the window. Roy manages to catch Chon's hand and they both hang for their lives.



* ToplessnessFromTheBack: When Roy catches Falling Leaves bathing in a Deleted Scene.

to:

* ToplessnessFromTheBack: When Roy catches What the audience sees of Falling Leaves bathing when Roy [[AccidentalPervert accidentaly]] catches her [[ShowerOfAwkward bathing]] in a Deleted Scene.DeletedScene, along with ShouldersUpNudity.



* VitriolicBestBuds: Chon and Roy.

to:

* %%* VitriolicBestBuds: Chon and Roy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BritishTeeth: Roy bumps into a pretty young English girl, and begins flirting, only for her to smile, revealing a set of truly atrocious dirty chompers, causing Roy to recoil in fear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IfYouEverDoAnythingToHurtHer: In the second movie, while [[spoiler: being captured by Rathbone]], after initially objecting to the idea of a relationship between his sister Lin and Roy, Chon accepts it, but adds, "Break her heart, I break your legs," to which Roy replies, "That's fair."

to:

* IfYouEverDoAnythingToHurtHer: In the second movie, while [[spoiler: being captured by Rathbone]], after initially objecting to the idea of a relationship between his sister Lin and Roy, Chon accepts it, but adds, "Break "if you break her heart, I break your legs," to which Roy replies, "That's fair."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GroinAttack: Roy taunting a royal guard in the sequel, who stands there as expected, until he leaves off ''by'' reaching over physically brushing him on the way out, ends with a rifle butt to the groin. ("You're not allowed to do that!")
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Shanghai Knights'', Chon and Roy jump from Big Ben, ripping the middle of the Union Jack hanging on the tower to slow their descent, like Film/JamesBond and Wai Lin jump from Elliot Carver's building, slowing their descent by ripping the middle of a wall photo of Carver. Wai Lin was played by Creator/JackieChan's friend and ''Film/{{Supercop}}'' costar Creator/MichelleYeoh.

to:

** In ''Shanghai Knights'', Chon and Roy jump from Big Ben, ripping the middle of the Union Jack hanging on the tower to slow their descent, like how in ''Film/TomorrowNeverDies'', Film/JamesBond and Wai Lin jump from Elliot Carver's building, slowing their descent by ripping the middle of a wall photo of Carver. Wai Lin was played by Creator/JackieChan's friend and ''Film/{{Supercop}}'' costar Creator/MichelleYeoh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''Shanghai Knights'', Chon and Roy jump from Big Ben, ripping the middle of the Union Jack hanging on the tower to slow their descent, like Film/JamesBond and Wai Lin jump from Elliot Carver's building, slowing their descent by ripping the middle of a wall photo of Carver. Wai Lin was played by Creator/JackieChan's friend and ''Film/{{Supercop}}'' costar Creator/MichelleYeoh.

Added: 344

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StoclClockHandHang: In ''Shanghai Knights'', the heroes find themselves in Victorian London. While Chon fights inside the Great Clock of the Palace of Westminster, Roy spends the time crawling on the giant hand of the tower clock. Chon and his opponent fall off the window. Roy manages to catch Chon's hand and they both hang for their lives.



* SwordFight: At the climax of Shanghai Knights.

to:

* SwordFight: At the climax of Shanghai Knights.''Shanghai Knights''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NormalFishInATinyPond: Chon Wang is considered incompetent and embarrassing in China and was sent to America to keep his uncle company and to get rid off him, in America and Britain he's a OneManArmy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Chon is their family name.


In the sequel directed by David Dobkin, ''Shanghai Knights'', they travel to Victorian London to foil a plot against [[UsefulNotes/QueenVictoria the Queen]]. Also starring Singaporean actress [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fann_Wong Fann Wong]] as Chon Wang's sister, Chon Lin. In the 1880's, Chon Wang's father and keeper of the Imperial Seal has been murdered by Parliament and royal family member Rathbone, who steals the Imperial Seal, with Chon Wang's sister, Chon Lin, witnessing the murder. Chon Lin follows Rathbone to London to kill him, while sending Chon a letter telling him of the murder. Chon then travels to New York for Roy O'Bannon. Together they travel to England and meet up with Chon Lin to defeat Rathbone and get the Imperial Seal back.

to:

In the sequel directed by David Dobkin, ''Shanghai Knights'', they travel to Victorian London to foil a plot against [[UsefulNotes/QueenVictoria the Queen]]. Also starring Singaporean actress [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fann_Wong Fann Wong]] as Chon Wang's sister, Chon Lin. In the 1880's, Chon Wang's father and keeper of the Imperial Seal has been murdered by Parliament and royal family member Lord Rathbone, who steals the Imperial Seal, with Chon Wang's sister, Chon Lin, witnessing the murder. Chon Lin follows Rathbone to London to kill him, while sending Chon Wang a letter telling him of the murder. Chon Wang then travels to New York for Roy O'Bannon. Together they travel to England and meet up with Chon Lin to defeat Rathbone and get the Imperial Seal back.

Top