Follow TV Tropes

Reviews Fanfic / Trials And Tribulations Of The Oathkeeper

Go To

koook160 Since: Jun, 2010
07/25/2019 14:55:01 •••

Bafflingly bad

I cannot believe this has over a thousand bookmarks and reviews. I cannot believe this bloated, flavorless self-insert is popular by any stretch of the imagination. Everything about this is represents the worst qualities of a Fix Fic, where everything is hunky dory, yet things STILL play out like canon. I lost count of how many of the show’s best speeches were given to this personality-devoid protagonist, no matter what the context. For example, Daveth is given Tyrion’s “vicious kings” speech... despite Daveth being king already instead of Joffrey. It’s just consistently and aggressively sloppy throughout its insane length. Avoid this like the plague. Read something better like Robb Returns or Life and Honor.


Leave a Comment:

Top