What the Hell, Hero?: Andy's affair with the stroke patient's wife in Season 3. Not only was it out of character, but the guilt over the first time they slept together caused him to develop an ulcer and cough up blood...and THAT was when he decided to make a go of the relationship as more than just a one-off? Really? It was like the story was written backwards, somehow making the logical endpoint the catalyst.
As it's written, it doesn't look in-universe. I don't remember if anyone called him on it in the series.
As it's written, it doesn't look in-universe. I don't remember if anyone called him on it in the series.