Does the Super Paper Mario example really count? All the information the Mario Bros. had was that Peach went missing after the castle got raided. Luigi assumed Bowser kidnapped Peach because Bowser raids the castle and kidnaps Peach all the time. And when Bowser says that he couldn't've done it, since he was just about to kidnap Peach, Count Bleck shows up, with Peach, before Luigi can even react.
Does the Super Paper Mario example really count? All the information the Mario Bros. had was that Peach went missing after the castle got raided. Luigi assumed Bowser kidnapped Peach because Bowser raids the castle and kidnaps Peach all the time. And when Bowser says that he couldn't've done it, since he was just about to kidnap Peach, Count Bleck shows up, with Peach, before Luigi can even react.
Edited by MathematicalVoid