Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History PlayingWith / WouldHitAGirl

Go To

[003] Wyldchyld Current Version
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
On the issue of girly-ness, while I\'m aware a couple of anime filler episodes have made him girly (I remember one filler practically turned Yumichika into Ikkaku\'s wife), that\'s not the case in the manga. A volume 55 omake has him describe himself as the \
to:
On the issue of girly-ness, while I\\\'m aware a couple of anime filler episodes have made him girly (I remember one filler practically turned Yumichika into Ikkaku\\\'s wife), that\\\'s not the case in the manga. A volume 55 omake has him describe himself as the \\\"supreme king of fashion\\\". Fashion-obsessed isn\\\'t automatically girly, although ValuesDissonance can creep in on this point: high fashion in Japan (especially Tokyo) can look quite feminised compared to western fashion (and western fashion can make men look more feminised as well). For example, some perfumes that are marketed for women in the west are marketed for men in Japan. In terms of girly-ness, I tend to view Charlotte Cuulhorne as closer to this trope than Yumichika.

I\\\'m not sure what you\\\'re looking for on this point, however. Could you tell me how you see Yumichika meeting the girly-ness the trope is looking for? (Bear in mind I am not disagreeing that he\\\'s an officer, vain, pretty, effective in combat or fabulous.) That might give me a better idea of how you see the trope.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
On the issue of girly-ness, while I\'m aware a couple of anime filler episodes have made him girly (I remember one filler effectively turned Yumichika into Ikkaku\'s wife), that\'s not the case in the manga. A volume 55 omake has him describe himself as the \
to:
On the issue of girly-ness, while I\\\'m aware a couple of anime filler episodes have made him girly (I remember one filler practically turned Yumichika into Ikkaku\\\'s wife), that\\\'s not the case in the manga. A volume 55 omake has him describe himself as the \\\"supreme king of fashion\\\". Fashion-obsessed isn\\\'t automatically girly, although ValuesDissonance can creep in on this point: high fashion in Japan (especially Tokyo) can look quite feminised compared to western fashion (and western fashion can make men look more feminised as well). For example, some perfumes that are marketed for women in the west are marketed for men in Japan. In terms of girly-ness, I tend to view Charlotte Cuulhorne as closer to this trope than Yumichika.

I\\\'m not sure what you\\\'re looking for on this point, however. Could you tell me how you see Yumichika meeting the girly-ness the trope is looking for? (Bear in mind I am not disagreeing that he\\\'s an officer, vain, pretty, effective in combat or fabulous.)
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Well, I\'m not going to disagree he\'s a highly seated officer, but he\'s still been kicked down to size by lieutenants (Kira, specifically), so he\'s definitely not viewed as being on a par (position-wise) with the actual leadership positions (captain and lieutenant).
to:
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
On the issue of girly-ness, while I\'m aware a couple of anime filler episodes have made him girly (I remember one filler effectively turned Yumichika into Ikkaku\'s wife), that\'s not the case in the manga. A volume 55 omake has him describe himself as the \
to:
On the issue of girly-ness, while I\\\'m aware a couple of anime filler episodes have made him girly (I remember one filler effectively turned Yumichika into Ikkaku\\\'s wife), that\\\'s not the case in the manga. A volume 55 omake has him describe himself as the \\\"supreme king of fashion\\\". Fashion-obsessed isn\\\'t automatically girly, although ValuesDissonance can creep in on this point: high fashion in Japan (especially Tokyo) can look quite feminised compared to western fashion (and western fashion can make men look more feminised as well). For example, some perfumes that are marketed for women in the west are marketed for men in Japan. In terms of girly-ness, I tend to view Charlotte Cuulhorne as closer to this trope than Yumichika.

I\\\'m not sure what you\\\'re looking for on this point, however. Could you tell me how you see Yumichika meeting the girly-ness the trope is looking for? (Bear in mind I am not disagreeing that he\\\'s an officer, vain, pretty, effective in combat or fabulous.)
Top