[003]
Alucard
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Sentinel: You dodged the issue: I\'ve pointed out that the page deals in references to the roster\'s home series at many points and I stated that this particular trope was written with the home series powers in mind. Secondly, the fact that the Sentinel\'s mutant-detecting abilities could just barely be called a \
to:
Sentinel: You dodged the issue: I\\\'ve pointed out that the page deals in references to the roster\\\'s home series at many points and I stated that this particular trope was written with the home series powers in mind. Secondly, the fact that the Sentinel\\\'s mutant-detecting abilities could just barely be called a \\\"sense\\\" by a wide stretch proves how badly tech-themed characters fit in this scale.
Morrigan: You haven\\\'t given me any reason to think this trope shouldn\\\'t be dealing exclusively in the character\\\'s own universe. Obviously, the in-universe rules become sketchy when these non-fighting game characters are converted for a fighting game. The fact that crossover fighting games run into this problem so often is what the trope is poking fun at in this particular case; based on the crowner, the trope itself is most likely going to be labeled \\\"Just For Fun\\\", thus its purpose on this page. If you decide to start inserting arguments like \\\"Thor can\\\'t SpeedBlitz his opponent in 2 seconds therefore he should have his class lowered\\\", you start to lose the point of the trope.
I don\\\'t think the other editors are going to be too happy with Phoenix being a class 3 or Akuma being a Class 2 just because they never do anything on-screen to suggest otherwise. That\\\'s grade-A nerdrage-bait right there. Just by the limits of the game mechanics the whole cast becomes a Class 3 or lower (technically we don\\\'t see any of the upper limits of Galactus\\\' ability either). If you want this scale to rigidly go by in-game feats, keep in mind that you\\\'ll piss off a lot of fans and make the trope a lot less useful (especially to people who aren\\\'t familiar with the franchises these characters come from).
I\\\'ll ask you a simple question: give me a good reason why this scale \\\'\\\'shouldn\\\'t\\\'\\\' be dealing in the roster\\\'s home-universe feats and power-levels?
Morrigan: You haven\\\'t given me any reason to think this trope shouldn\\\'t be dealing exclusively in the character\\\'s own universe. Obviously, the in-universe rules become sketchy when these non-fighting game characters are converted for a fighting game. The fact that crossover fighting games run into this problem so often is what the trope is poking fun at in this particular case; based on the crowner, the trope itself is most likely going to be labeled \\\"Just For Fun\\\", thus its purpose on this page. If you decide to start inserting arguments like \\\"Thor can\\\'t SpeedBlitz his opponent in 2 seconds therefore he should have his class lowered\\\", you start to lose the point of the trope.
I don\\\'t think the other editors are going to be too happy with Phoenix being a class 3 or Akuma being a Class 2 just because they never do anything on-screen to suggest otherwise. That\\\'s grade-A nerdrage-bait right there. Just by the limits of the game mechanics the whole cast becomes a Class 3 or lower (technically we don\\\'t see any of the upper limits of Galactus\\\' ability either). If you want this scale to rigidly go by in-game feats, keep in mind that you\\\'ll piss off a lot of fans and make the trope a lot less useful (especially to people who aren\\\'t familiar with the franchises these characters come from).
I\\\'ll ask you a simple question: give me a good reason why this scale \\\'\\\'shouldn\\\'t\\\'\\\' be dealing in the roster\\\'s home-universe feats and power-levels?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Sentinel: You dodged the issue: I\'ve pointed out that the page deals in references to the roster\'s home series at many points and I stated that this particular trope was written with the home series powers in mind. Secondly, the fact that the Sentinel\'s mutant-detecting abilities could just barely be called a \
to:
Sentinel: You dodged the issue: I\\\'ve pointed out that the page deals in references to the roster\\\'s home series at many points and I stated that this particular trope was written with the home series powers in mind. Secondly, the fact that the Sentinel\\\'s mutant-detecting abilities could just barely be called a \\\"sense\\\" by a wide stretch proves how badly tech-themed characters fit in this scale.
Morrigan: You haven\\\'t given me any reason to think this trope shouldn\\\'t be dealing exclusively in the character\\\'s own universe. Obviously, the in-universe rules become sketchy when these non-fighting game characters are converted for a fighting game. The fact that crossover fighting games run into this problem so often is what the trope is poking fun at in this particular case; based on the crowner, the trope itself is most likely going to be labeled \\\"Just For Fun\\\", thus its purpose on this page. If you decide to start inserting arguments like \\\"Thor can\\\'t SpeedBlitz his opponent in 2 seconds therefore he should have his class lowered\\\", you start to lose the point of the trope.
I don\\\'t think the other editors are going to be too happy with Phoenix being a class 3 or Akuma being a Class 2 just because they never do anything on-screen to suggest otherwise. That\\\'s grade-A nerdrage-bait right there. Just by the limits of the game mechanics the whole cast becomes a Class 3 or lower (technically we don\\\'t see any of the upper limits of Galactus\\\' ability either). If you want this scale to rigidly go by in-game feats, keep in mind that you\\\'ll piss off a lot of fans and the trope will become a lot less useful (especially to people who aren\\\'t familiar with the franchises these characters come from).
I\\\'ll ask you a simple question: give me a good reason why this scale \\\'\\\'shouldn\\\'t\\\'\\\' be dealing in the roster\\\'s home-universe feats and power-levels?
Morrigan: You haven\\\'t given me any reason to think this trope shouldn\\\'t be dealing exclusively in the character\\\'s own universe. Obviously, the in-universe rules become sketchy when these non-fighting game characters are converted for a fighting game. The fact that crossover fighting games run into this problem so often is what the trope is poking fun at in this particular case; based on the crowner, the trope itself is most likely going to be labeled \\\"Just For Fun\\\", thus its purpose on this page. If you decide to start inserting arguments like \\\"Thor can\\\'t SpeedBlitz his opponent in 2 seconds therefore he should have his class lowered\\\", you start to lose the point of the trope.
I don\\\'t think the other editors are going to be too happy with Phoenix being a class 3 or Akuma being a Class 2 just because they never do anything on-screen to suggest otherwise. That\\\'s grade-A nerdrage-bait right there. Just by the limits of the game mechanics the whole cast becomes a Class 3 or lower (technically we don\\\'t see any of the upper limits of Galactus\\\' ability either). If you want this scale to rigidly go by in-game feats, keep in mind that you\\\'ll piss off a lot of fans and the trope will become a lot less useful (especially to people who aren\\\'t familiar with the franchises these characters come from).
I\\\'ll ask you a simple question: give me a good reason why this scale \\\'\\\'shouldn\\\'t\\\'\\\' be dealing in the roster\\\'s home-universe feats and power-levels?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Sentinel: You dodged the issue: I\'ve pointed out that the page deals in references to the roster\'s home series at many points and I stated that this particular trope was written with the home series powers in mind. Secondly, the fact that the Sentinel\'s mutant-detecting abilities could just barely be called a \
to:
Sentinel: You dodged the issue: I\\\'ve pointed out that the page deals in references to the roster\\\'s home series at many points and I stated that this particular trope was written with the home series powers in mind. Secondly, the fact that the Sentinel\\\'s mutant-detecting abilities could just barely be called a \\\"sense\\\" by a wide stretch proves how badly tech-themed characters fit in this scale.
Morrigan: You haven\\\'t given me any reason to think this trope shouldn\\\'t be dealing exclusively in the character\\\'s own universe. Obviously, the in-universe rules become sketchy when these non-fighting game characters are converted for a fighting game. The fact that crossover fighting games run into this problem so often is what the trope is poking fun at in this particular case; based on the crowner, the trope itself is most likely going to be labeled \\\"Just For Fun\\\", thus its purpose on this page. If you decide to start inserting arguments like \\\"Thor can\\\'t SpeedBlitz his opponent in 2 seconds therefore he should have his class lowered\\\", you start to lose the point of the trope.
I don\\\'t think the other editors are going to be too happy with Phoenix being a class 3 or Akume being a Class 2 just because they never do anything on-screen to suggest otherwise. That\\\'s grade-A nerdrage-bait right there. Just by the limits of the game mechanics the whole cast becomes a Class 3 or lower (technically we don\\\'t see any of the upper limits of Galactus\\\' ability either). If you want this scale to rigidly go by in-game feats, keep in mind that you\\\'ll piss off a lot of fans and the trope will become a lot less useful (especially to people who aren\\\'t familiar with the franchises these characters come from).
I\\\'ll ask you a simple question: give me a good reason why this scale \\\'\\\'shouldn\\\'t\\\'\\\' be dealing in the roster\\\'s home-universe feats and power-levels?
Morrigan: You haven\\\'t given me any reason to think this trope shouldn\\\'t be dealing exclusively in the character\\\'s own universe. Obviously, the in-universe rules become sketchy when these non-fighting game characters are converted for a fighting game. The fact that crossover fighting games run into this problem so often is what the trope is poking fun at in this particular case; based on the crowner, the trope itself is most likely going to be labeled \\\"Just For Fun\\\", thus its purpose on this page. If you decide to start inserting arguments like \\\"Thor can\\\'t SpeedBlitz his opponent in 2 seconds therefore he should have his class lowered\\\", you start to lose the point of the trope.
I don\\\'t think the other editors are going to be too happy with Phoenix being a class 3 or Akume being a Class 2 just because they never do anything on-screen to suggest otherwise. That\\\'s grade-A nerdrage-bait right there. Just by the limits of the game mechanics the whole cast becomes a Class 3 or lower (technically we don\\\'t see any of the upper limits of Galactus\\\' ability either). If you want this scale to rigidly go by in-game feats, keep in mind that you\\\'ll piss off a lot of fans and the trope will become a lot less useful (especially to people who aren\\\'t familiar with the franchises these characters come from).
I\\\'ll ask you a simple question: give me a good reason why this scale \\\'\\\'shouldn\\\'t\\\'\\\' be dealing in the roster\\\'s home-universe feats and power-levels?
