[006]
Torfindra
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\'t actually know who she really is; they don\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \
to:
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\\\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\\\'t actually know who she really is; they don\\\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E7AGoodManGoesToWar A Good Man Goes to War]],\\\" [[spoiler: Melody had just been taken. While she isn\\\'t a \\\"long-lost\\\" child she is still \\\"lost;\\\" Rory and Amy have no idea where she is or if they will ever see her again. In light of this fact it is a big shock when River reveals herself as their daughter from the future]].
What\\\'s the consensus on this issue, then? Does anyone else agree/disagree with either of us?
What\\\'s the consensus on this issue, then? Does anyone else agree/disagree with either of us?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\'t actually know who she really is; they don\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \
to:
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\\\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\\\'t actually know who she really is; they don\\\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E7AGoodManGoesToWar A Good Man Goes to War]],\\\" [[spoiler: Melody had just been taken. While she isn\\\'t a \\\"long-lost\\\" child she is still \\\"lost;\\\" Rory and Amy have no idea where she is or if they will ever see her again. In light of this fact it is a big shock when River reveals herself as their daughter from the future]].
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\'t actually know who she really is; they don\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \
to:
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\\\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\\\'t actually know who she really is; they don\\\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E7AGoodManGoesToWar A Good Man Goes to War]],\\\" [[spoiler: Melody had just been taken. While she isn\\\'t a \\\"long-lost\\\" child she is still \\\"lost;\\\" Rory and Amy have no idea where she is or if they will ever see her again. In light of this fact it is a big shock when River reveals herself as their daughter from the future]].
Does anyone else agree/disagree with this?
Does anyone else agree/disagree with this?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\'t actually know who she really is; they don\'t know her *real* identity.]] Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \
to:
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\\\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\\\'t actually know who she really is; they don\\\'t know her *real* identity]]. Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E7AGoodManGoesToWar A Good Man Goes to War]],\\\" [[spoiler: Melody had just been taken. While she isn\\\'t a \\\"long-lost\\\" child she is still \\\"lost;\\\" Rory and Amy have no idea where she is or if they will ever see her again. In light of this fact it is a big shock when River reveals herself as their daughter from the future]].
Does anyone agree/disagree with this?
Does anyone agree/disagree with this?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\'t actually know who she really is; they don\'t know her *real* identity.]] Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \
to:
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\\\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\\\'t actually know who she really is; they don\\\'t know her *real* identity.]] Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E7AGoodManGoesToWar A Good Man Goes to War]],\\\" [[spoiler: Melody had just been taken. While she isn\\\'t a \\\"long-lost\\\" child she is still \\\"lost;\\\" Rory and Amy have no idea where she is or if they will ever see her again. In light of this fact it is a big shock when River reveals herself as their daughter from the future]].
Does anyone agree/disagree with this?
Does anyone agree/disagree with this?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\'t actually know who she really is; they don\'t know her *real* identity.]] Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \
to:
Here is my reasoning why it should be LukeYouAreMyFather: This isn\\\'t a situation where someone is revealing their maternity/paternity to someone but is the *other* way around. [[spoiler: Yes, River has been known to Rory and Amy for two series but they don\\\'t actually know who she really is; they don\\\'t know her *real* identity.]] Therefore this should be considered a SubvertedTrope of LukeYouAreMyFather because, further on in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E7AGoodManGoesToWar A Good Man Goes to War]],\\\" [[spoiler: Melody had just been taken. While she isn\\\'t a \\\"long-lost\\\" child she is still \\\"lost;\\\" Rory and Amy have no idea where she is or if they will ever see her again. In light of this fact it is a big shock when River reveals herself as their daughter from the future.]]
Does anyone agree/disagree with this?
Does anyone agree/disagree with this?
