Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / Arthur

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That is a matter of personal opinion. I personally see D.W. as irredeemably bad, so anything bad that happens to her is deserved in my eyes. Also, just because the Tibbles are worse than her doesn\'t mean she didn\'t deserve it. Sometimes bad people in the real world are victims of even worse people than themselves too, and while others might think the victimized person had it coming, they would still want the other person to be punished if they\'ve victimized the innocent as well. And the example you gave of her causing trouble (threatening Kate with physical violence) is actually a pretty big deal since she is only a baby whereas D.W. is four. And then there\'s the fact that she also attempted to SELL Kate as if she were property just because she was jealous of her, which I would say crosses the line into straight-up heinous. And if the troper who added those entries also felt that way, then don\'t they have the right to add it here? Aren\'t YMMV sections meant to be for sharing opinions? And even if it\'s meant to be about the common opinion and not one person\'s individual one, if you look up a list of hated cartoon characters online, chances are that D.W. will be pretty high up on the list, and some people in the comments will outright wish she\'d get into some kind of \'\'fatal\'\' accident.
to:
That is a matter of personal opinion. I personally see D.W. as irredeemably bad and a completely heartless and selfish monster, so anything bad that happens to her is deserved in my eyes. Also, just because the Tibbles are worse than her doesn\\\'t mean she didn\\\'t deserve it. Sometimes bad people in the real world are victims of even worse people than themselves too, and while others might think the victimized person had it coming, they would still want the other person to be punished if they\\\'ve victimized the innocent as well. And the example you gave of her causing trouble (threatening Kate with physical violence) is actually a pretty big deal since she is only a baby whereas D.W. is four. And then there\\\'s the fact that she also attempted to SELL Kate as if she were property just because she was jealous of her, which I would say crosses the line into straight-up heinous. And if the troper who added those entries also felt that way, then don\\\'t they have the right to add it here? Aren\\\'t YMMV sections meant to be for sharing opinions? And even if it\\\'s meant to be about the common opinion and not one person\\\'s individual one, if you look up a list of hated cartoon characters online, chances are that D.W. will be pretty high up on the list, and some people in the comments will outright wish she\\\'d get into some kind of \\\'\\\'fatal\\\'\\\' accident.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That is a matter of personal opinion. I personally see D.W. as irredeemably bad, so anything bad that happens to her is deserved in my eyes. Also, just because the Tibbles are worse than her doesn\'t mean she didn\'t deserve it. Sometimes bad people in the real world are victims of even worse people than themselves too, and while others might think the victimized person had it coming, they would still want the other person to be punished if they\'ve victimized the innocent as well. And the example you gave of her causing trouble (threatening Kate with physical violence) is actually a pretty big deal since she is only a baby whereas D.W. is four. And then there\'s the fact that she also attempted to SELL Kate as if she were property just because she was jealous of her, which I would say crosses the line into straight-up heinous. And if the troper who added those entries also felt that way, then don\'t they have the right to add it here? Aren\'t YMMV sections meant to be for sharing opinions?
to:
That is a matter of personal opinion. I personally see D.W. as irredeemably bad, so anything bad that happens to her is deserved in my eyes. Also, just because the Tibbles are worse than her doesn\\\'t mean she didn\\\'t deserve it. Sometimes bad people in the real world are victims of even worse people than themselves too, and while others might think the victimized person had it coming, they would still want the other person to be punished if they\\\'ve victimized the innocent as well. And the example you gave of her causing trouble (threatening Kate with physical violence) is actually a pretty big deal since she is only a baby whereas D.W. is four. And then there\\\'s the fact that she also attempted to SELL Kate as if she were property just because she was jealous of her, which I would say crosses the line into straight-up heinous. And if the troper who added those entries also felt that way, then don\\\'t they have the right to add it here? Aren\\\'t YMMV sections meant to be for sharing opinions? And even if it\\\'s meant to be about the common opinion and not one person\\\'s individual one, if you look up a list of hated cartoon characters online, chances are that D.W. will be pretty high up on the list, and some people in the comments will outright wish she\\\'d get into some kind of \\\'\\\'fatal\\\'\\\' accident.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
That is a matter of personal opinion. I personally see D.W. as irredeemably bad, so anything bad that happens to her is deserved in my eyes. Also, just because the Tibbles are worse than her doesn\'t mean she didn\'t deserve it. Sometimes bad people in the real world are victims of even worse people than themselves too, and while others might think the victimized person had it coming, they would still want the other person to be punished if they\'ve victimized the innocent as well. And the example you gave of her causing trouble (threatening Kate with physical violence) is actually a pretty big deal since she is only a baby whereas D.W. is four. And if the troper who added those entries also felt that way, then don\'t they have the right to add it here? Aren\'t YMMV sections meant to be for sharing opinions?
to:
That is a matter of personal opinion. I personally see D.W. as irredeemably bad, so anything bad that happens to her is deserved in my eyes. Also, just because the Tibbles are worse than her doesn\\\'t mean she didn\\\'t deserve it. Sometimes bad people in the real world are victims of even worse people than themselves too, and while others might think the victimized person had it coming, they would still want the other person to be punished if they\\\'ve victimized the innocent as well. And the example you gave of her causing trouble (threatening Kate with physical violence) is actually a pretty big deal since she is only a baby whereas D.W. is four. And then there\\\'s the fact that she also attempted to SELL Kate as if she were property just because she was jealous of her, which I would say crosses the line into straight-up heinous. And if the troper who added those entries also felt that way, then don\\\'t they have the right to add it here? Aren\\\'t YMMV sections meant to be for sharing opinions?
Top