Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / TheLastJedi

Go To

[002] Apocrypha Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Right, and I agree with that. What I mean is, why do people assume Poe's way was the right way because it ''turned out'' to have good results? Results that no one, least of all him, foresaw, expected, or planned for?
to:
Right, and I agree with that. What I mean is, why do people assume Poe\'s way was the right way because it \'\'turned out\'\' to have good results? Results that no one, least of all him, foresaw, expected, or planned for?
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
I'm asking this mostly because the entry under InformedWrongness doesn't sit right with me. Yes, he saved the day. But ''nobody knows it at the time'', and the message the film presents is that he saved the day at a high cost and as secondary goal (his primary one being
to:
I\'m asking this mostly because the entry under InformedWrongness doesn\'t sit right with me. Yes, he saved the day. But \'\'nobody knows it at the time\'\', and the message the film presents is that he saved the day at a high cost and as secondary goal (his primary one being \"heroism\"). And then tries to repeat the gesture with Holdo, with far more disastrous consequences. That kind of attitude definitely seems like something that is rightfully wrong.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Right, and I agree with that. What I mean is, why do people assume Poe's way was the right because it ''turned out'' to have good results, that no one in the film foresaw?
to:
Right, and I agree with that. What I mean is, why do people assume Poe\'s way was the right way because it \'\'turned out\'\' to have good results? Results that no one, least of all him, foresaw, expected, or planned for?
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
I'm asking this mostly because the entry under InformedWrongness doesn't sit right with me. Yes, he saved the day. But ''nobody knows it at the time'', and the message the film presents is that he saved the day at a high cost and as secondary goal (his primary one being
to:
I\'m asking this mostly because the entry under InformedWrongness doesn\'t sit right with me. Yes, he saved the day. But \'\'nobody knows it at the time\'\', and the message the film presents is that he saved the day at a high cost and as secondary goal (his primary one being \"heroism\"). And then tries to repeat the gesture with Holdo, with far more disastrous consequences. That definitely seems like something that is rightfully wrong.
Top