We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
to:
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don't know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
to:
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don\'t know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Are you saying that because we don't see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
to:
Are you saying that because we don\'t see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz's reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn't know that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you really entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
to:
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz\'s reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn\'t know that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you really entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
Changed line(s) 13 from:
n
'''Edit:'''
to:
\'\'\'Edit:\'\'\'
Changed line(s) 15 from:
n
We have instances wherein Elizabeth states she feels nostalgic being around Meliodas aka an obvious ReincarnationRomance confirmed by that chapter with Zaneli. We were given hints that maybe Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation before the reveal.
to:
We have instances wherein Elizabeth states she feels nostalgic being around Meliodas aka an obvious ReincarnationRomance confirmed by that chapter with Zaneli. We were given hints that maybe Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation before the reveal.
Changed line(s) 19 from:
n
'''Edit:'''
to:
\'\'\'Edit:\'\'\'
Changed line(s) 21 from:
n
I readded the edit because there was no consensus between us. I modified the line originally to make it more neutral. You kept taking out what can be considered giving context based on manga chapters to explain the scene more in question. You kept taking it partly on an assumption that you have not provided support for and clearly partly on your bias on certain aspects in the series.
to:
I readded the edit because there was no consensus between us. I modified the line originally to make it more neutral. You kept taking out what can be considered giving context based on manga chapters to explain the scene more in question. You kept taking it partly on an assumption that you have not provided support as in chapters for and clearly partly on your bias on certain aspects in the series.
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
to:
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don't know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
to:
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don\'t know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Are you saying that because we don't see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
to:
Are you saying that because we don\'t see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz's reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn't know that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you really entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
to:
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz\'s reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn\'t know that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you really entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
Changed line(s) 13 from:
n
'''Edit:'''
to:
\'\'\'Edit:\'\'\'
Changed line(s) 15 from:
n
We have instances wherein Elizabeth states she feels nostalgic being around Meliodas aka an obvious ReincarnationRomance confirmed by that chapter with Zaneli. We were given hints that maybe Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation before the reveal.
to:
We have instances wherein Elizabeth states she feels nostalgic being around Meliodas aka an obvious ReincarnationRomance confirmed by that chapter with Zaneli. We were given hints that maybe Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation before the reveal.
Changed line(s) 17 from:
to:
\'\'\'Edit:\'\'\'
I readded the edit because there was no consensus between us. I modified the line originally to make it more neutral. You kept taking out what can be considered giving context based on manga chapters to explain the scene more in question. You kept taking it partly on an assumption that you have not provided support for and clearly partly on your bias on certain aspects in the series.
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
to:
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don't know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
to:
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don\'t know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Are you saying that because we don't see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
to:
Are you saying that because we don\'t see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz's reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn't know that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
to:
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz\'s reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn\'t know that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you really entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
Changed line(s) 13 from:
n
to:
\'\'\'Edit:\'\'\'
We have instances wherein Elizabeth states she feels nostalgic being around Meliodas aka an obvious ReincarnationRomance confirmed by that chapter with Zaneli. We were given hints that maybe Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation before the reveal.
You say that Nakaba failed ShowDontTell yet you kept wanting outright statements about whether Meliodas knows to accept Meliodas knows rather accept those instances that show that he knows something.
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
to:
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don't know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
to:
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don\'t know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Are you saying that because we don't see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
to:
Are you saying that because we don\'t see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz's reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn't know that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
to:
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz\'s reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn\'t know that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
Changed line(s) 11 from:
n
The edit gave context as to why Meliodas called baby Elizabeth. You are clearly motivated to condemn this instance based on your UnfortunateImplications edits, FlameBait review, and our PM discussions together to a point that giving some context to what some would find squicky is out of a question in order to make it more neutral.
to:
The edit gave context as to why Meliodas called baby Elizabeth. You are clearly motivated to condemn this instance based on your UnfortunateImplications edits, FlameBait review, and our PM discussions together to a point that giving some context to what some would find squicky in order to make it more neutral is out of a question.
\"\'Edit:\'\'\'
We have instances wherein Elizabeth states she feels nostalgic being around Meliodas aka an obvious ReincarnationRomance confirmed by that chapter with Zaneli. We were given hints that maybe Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation before the reveal.
You say that Nakaba failed ShowDontTell yet you kept wanting outright statements about whether Meliodas knows to accept Meliodas knows rather accept those instances that show that he knows something.
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
to:
We have confirmed reincarnation when Zaneli stated that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation. This was stated before the chapter that revealed Meliodas called baby Elizabeth his woman.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don't know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
to:
We have seen what happened when Hawk was hit with an otherwise fatal attack. We don\'t know what happened but it leads some credence to what may have happened with Liz.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Are you saying that because we don't see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
to:
Are you saying that because we don\'t see the reincarnation, we must doubt that Meliodas knows it happened. He was there in the epicenter when it happened.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz's reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn't know that Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
to:
His motivation to protect Elizabeth is because she is Liz\'s reincarnation. It was stated outright. If he doesn\'t know that Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation then would he protect her. Are you entertaining the idea that Meliodas found a random baby in a battlezone that his lover died, decided she was his dead lover without knowing for sure, and got lucky because she really was her reincarnation?
Changed line(s) 11 from:
n
The edit gave context as to why Meliodas called baby Elizabeth. You are clearly motivated to condemn this instance based on your UnfortunateImplications edits, FlameBait review, and our discussions together to a point that giving some context to what some would find squicky is out of a question in order to make it more neutral.
to:
The edit gave context as to why Meliodas called baby Elizabeth. You are clearly motivated to condemn this instance based on your UnfortunateImplications edits, FlameBait review, and our PM discussions together to a point that giving some context to what some would find squicky is out of a question in order to make it more neutral.
