Poor Image: Characters.MCU Peggy Carter

As part of the plan to phase out Character Images With Black Borders, I’d suggest we pull these images instead of replacing them because Peggy only appears once in these ages and isn’t as prominent when she got older.

EDIT: I accidentally pressed the publish button before fixing the title, can the mods fix it.

Edited by MaxyGregoryyyy on Sep 16th 2023 at 7:04:13 PM

Title fixed.

They are pretty impactful scenes though and I think there's no problem them being there. I'd just remove the black borders myself.

Peggy wasn’t really important in that Ant-Man scene though because that scene was mainly about Hank Pym. I don’t think we need it because we don’t really use elder appearances if it’s brief (even if it’s impactful). It’s why there’s no old Steve Rogers or old Edwin Jarvis pics but there is an old Howard Stark pic because it’s a different actor and Howard does make multiple appearances as an older man but Peggy at different stages of life seems redundant because she’s at her most prominent when she was at her 20s-30s.

Edited by MaxyGregoryyyy on Sep 16th 2023 at 7:43:30 PM

Fair, it's more the elderly one than the middle aged one that springs to mind for me if only because it's so goddamn sad so it may be making me feel a bit preservationist of it for that reason but I suppose it doesn't really hit without the dialog in the scene. I can just picture people ignoring tags though and readding it in future though as well and us ending up with edit wars but that might be me just worrying about something that might not happen.

Keep only middle-aged Peggy image + quality upgrade

Keep only elderly Peggy + quality upgrade

Cause middle-aged peggy isn't that important

The black border images must be removed as they’re being phased out. It’s either by replacing them or removing them.

Votes bump, one in green.