Complaining NEW CROWNER: Alt Titles 12-28-12: Gannon Banned

Complaining NEW CROWNER: AltTitles 12-28-12: Gannon Banned

Go To

Ironeye Cutmaster-san from SoCal Since: Jan, 2001 Relationship Status: Falling within your bell curve

Cutmaster-san

#126: Mar 3rd 2013 at 11:45:23 PM

Yeah, clear victor and it's been open long enough. Calling in favor of the merged title overwhelmingly being Fandom Berserk Button, with Gannon-Banned and Pedantic Fan Rage as redirects.

Make it so, cleanup crew!

I'm bad, and that's good. I will never be good, and that's not bad. There's no one I'd rather be than me.

SeptimusHeap from Switzerland (Edited uphill both ways) Relationship Status: Mu

#127: Mar 4th 2013 at 12:50:19 AM

Did the initial merge and tagging. Will do wicks ASAP.

Wicks done, except for ghosts and those where an edit request is necessary.

edited 4th Mar '13 9:25:55 AM by SeptimusHeap

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman

Add Post

PageAction: GannonBanned

8th Dec '12 6:09:55 PM

Crown Description:

What should be done with the page Gannon Banned?

Note that these are not all mutually exclusive. All winning actions that are compatible with the top winner can be done together.

17 (Yeas:18 Nays:1) 18.00 : 1

Merge with Nerd Rage. Name to be determined in another crowner.

2 (Yeas:9 Nays:7) 1.29 : 1

Clarify the description. (Possible wording written here

2 (Yeas:8 Nays:6) 1.33 : 1

Clean out hyperbole, complaining, Fan Myopia, natter, and misuse. Allow examples but put in a warning comment.

2 (Yeas:9 Nays:7) 1.29 : 1

Delete all examples. Keep the page as a definition of the phenomenon.

1 (Yeas:7 Nays:6) 1.17 : 1

Rename.

-4 (Yeas:3 Nays:7)

Delete all examples, merge with Internet Backdraft.

-4 (Yeas:4 Nays:8)

Cut the whole page.

Pro: The examples aren't worth saving, and the page is useless without them.
Con: The phenomenon is worth documenting even if the examples aren't worth saving. This also has 647 inbound links.

-7 (Yeas:1 Nays:8)

Move to Trivia. This isn't a trope.

Pro: The things fans get mad over are little pieces of Trivia.
Con: The page is about the Audience Reaction to those things, so it isn't Trivia.

-8 (Yeas:0 Nays:8)

Delete only the out-of-universe examples.

-8 (Yeas:1 Nays:9)

Remove the examples to another, new page. Create the new page through YKTTW. Somebody will have to do the YKTTW.

-9 (Yeas:0 Nays:9)

Do nothing.

Back Top

Total posts: 127