The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Reviewed the picture, and those subtitles are grammatically incorrect.

It's hard to see something as sexualized when I have such a hard time figuring out what the hell I am looking at.

You're looking at a bunch of magical girls made of Conspicuous CG, dressed in skimpy outfits.

That may be, but I looked this stuff up, and it's basically an acid trip of epic proportions.

I frankly wouldn't call it pedo pandering, if only because I can't make sense of what the whole point to the show is in the first place.

In all seriousness, the only way I can see this being pedo pandering is if the aforementioned pedophiles are high as a kite.

I think we should just give this the Arcade Gamer Fubuki treatment and move on.

Darn those pedos! Getting high so they can be pandered to!

So not only do they pander to the loli-maniacs by giving them this piece of lolishit, they expect them to Watch It Stoned?

Good Flying Spaghetti Monster... Maybe the fact that it is so obscure is a warning for those who would think about watching it. The series avoids breaking our brains by not letting itself be watched.

Yea, it's this that divides those who like cute things and the total pervos.

If this is really the line, that doesn't talk very highly of my own mind, which keeps pressing me to watch it at least once.

Maybe I should distract myself playing some Freeware Games. It would help me fight the temptation.

Okay, let's take a slight detour from that...

Netorare Genre... whoa. A whole genre of Japanese!Cuckold Porn? What should we do with this? Does this even have non-porn examples?

A few, like the School Days example.

No idea. I don't pay attention to that crap. But from the list of examples there, I'm willing to bet that any example that is not blatant porn is obscure as hell.

EDIT: Oh, yeah, School Days. Hadn't thought of that.

edited 11th Jun '12 3:22:36 PM by Sachiko

In this case, I advice (also because of the 8000+ inbounds) to delete the porn-y works (and there are a lot of them that fell to 5P on there) and add a big %% Do not add porn here. We don't want a Netorare Porn index warning.

Definitely needs some major cleanup, to say the least. The outright porn examples will need to go, but there are definitely non-porn examples (such as the film Indecent Proposal, which I think most of us are familiar with) that should be kept.

edited 11th Jun '12 3:23:59 PM by TwoGunAngel

If I knew what examples can be kept and which have to be eliminated, I would be willing to jump in right now and rev the chainsaw, but... Yeah, I don't pay attention to works of that kind, as I said, so I have no idea. Someone who knows better should do it.

edited 11th Jun '12 3:24:28 PM by Sachiko

Easy. Just eliminate anything without an article and let non-porn entries percolate back in.

edited 11th Jun '12 3:25:46 PM by Ramidel

Most of the anime examples don't even have works pages, locked or not.

Re: Netorare Genre

Easiest solution: give it the fanspeak treatment (i.e. chainsaw everything and leave it as a locked definition)

Talking about locks: There has been some trouble on Locked Pages over page locks under the new policies, so I have to request that no more "example lockouts" (which rely on cherry-picking) be added there - "filter locks", maybe, if you get what I mean.

Speaking of locks, is anything being done to unlock restored pages?

Call me dense, but I'm not getting it. c.c

edited 11th Jun '12 3:42:15 PM by Sachiko

I'm guessing you would ask about unlocking a restored page here or here.

As for the Netorare Genre, we should at least give it a definition page, if nothing else.

Like I argued for "Naughty Tentacles" (have we reconstituted that yet?), it's too well known as a trope/genre term to be easily ignored, so it deserves a definition if nothing else.

If we can't gather any SFW examples to populate the page, fine, but a locked stub describing it should probably suffice.

Okay, that CGI...thing...may be some of the worst character design/artwork I've seen in a long time. My gut reaction, based on everything so far and the costume designs, is that this is just far enough over the line that it can be cut.

As far as the netorare page, my vote's to only cut the porn examples.

edited 11th Jun '12 3:45:27 PM by Willbyr

Or just a stub with a big (commented out or not) DO NOT ADD EXAMPLES OR YOU'LL GET BANNED (or something less direct) note, since examples to Example Sectionectomized pages get restored once every blue moon.

Makes sense as well.

edited 11th Jun '12 3:46:35 PM by SeptimusHeap

Naughty Tentacles is planned to be restored under a different name. That's on the "later stuff to work on" part, though.

Also, I'd say any work page restored can be locked for a while because of how much drama these decisions have honestly caused. Like maybe a month? There are exceptions, of course.