Originally aired November 11, 2013
Written by Heather V. Regnier
Directed by Doug Aarniokoski
Ichabod discovers that the Freemasons in Sleepy Hollow have been beheaded by the Horseman, and realizes that the Horseman is seeking its own head. Irving recovers the Horseman's head from the lab before the Horseman comes for it, barely escaping with his life. Ichabod and Abbie cannot destroy the head by normal means, so they use it to lure and trap the Horseman using both science and magic.
Tropes present in the episode:
- Skeptic No Longer: Irving, after he sees for himself that the Horseman is real.
