Barry Berkman is a Marine Corps veteran and a hitman based in Cleveland. Returning home after completing a job, Barry is approached by Fuches, his handler and mentor. He gives Barry an assignment for the Chechen mob out in Los Angeles, hoping a change of scenery will cheer up the burnt-out Barry. Barry flies to Los Angeles and meets Chechen mob boss Goran Pazar and his right-hand man "No Ho" Hank, who tell him the target is Ryan Madison, a personal trainer whom Goran's wife Oksana is having an affair with.
Barry follows Ryan to a community center and waits outside. Moments later, Barry approaches the building and hears a woman yelling. He approaches her and discovers she is rehearsing lines from a script. She chastises him and runs into the building. Barry follows her and enters a theater where a man and the woman he just interrupted are on stage performing. The theater teacher, Gene M. Cousineau (Henry Winkler) insults Sally Reed (Sarah Goldberg), the female student, then encourages her to finish the scene, which she does with fervor. As Barry watches Sally, he is approached from behind by Ryan, who asks him to do a scene with him. They perform a scene from the movie True Romance, with Barry blankly reading his lines from the script.
After Cousineau dismisses the class, Sally invites Barry to join the students at a bar, where she and the acting students brainstorm a monologue Barry can prepare for class. As Sally and her classmates dance, Barry becomes infatuated with her from afar. Afterward, Barry drives an inebriated Ryan home, and he hugs Barry in response while No Ho Hank and his henchman secretly watch from afar. The next morning, Fuches tells Barry what No Ho Hank saw. Barry explains that he wants to pursue acting, but Fuches says that Barry must complete the job and forget acting, or else the Chechens will kill them.
At night, Barry approaches Cousineau outside the community center. Barry confesses he is a hitman and tells Cousineau that he is depressed about his life. However, Cousineau assumes that Barry was performing a monologue and tells him that he can be in the class. Barry tells Cousineau his last name is Block, an idea proposed by Ryan a day earlier. Barry then follows Ryan to his apartment and approaches Ryan's car preparing to kill him. However, Barry discovers that Ryan had already been shot dead, and discovers No Ho Hank and two henchmen in a car across the street. No Ho Hank orders a henchman to shoot Barry, but Barry retaliates by shooting at the three, killing the two henchmen while No Ho Hank escapes. As police rush to the scene, Barry hides in a nearby diner. Served by a waitress learning lines for an audition, Barry declares he, too, is an actor.
