Round 1
- The host's decomposing body, still hanging from a noose. It definitely unnerves a large chunk of the cast.
- Finding Princess Anna's headless bloody corpse in the attic. In the dark. Where it fell onto the first person to walk in.
- Case Five, in which the group finds not just the pelt of Kiara without the rest of her body, but Tip's severed head floating in the air. It's all the worse when they discover that The gruesome deaths were all an accident.
Round 2
Round 3
- At the end of the first trial, Kiara's missing innards and Princess Anna's severed head fall out of the air all the way from Round 1 thanks to a badly-worded attempt at magic. Needless to say everyone is deeply disturbed.
- The execution for Case 2... possibly one of the most graphic ones in the game. Jane is sprinkled with pixie dust and forced to slowly float upward into a Deadly Rotary Fan, unable to stop herself until she's essentially mulched.
- Case 3 continues the trend of horrifying executions with Pinocchio being Eaten Alive by clockwork whales, piece by piece. Extra bad with the knowledge that Negaduck, the one who made up the plans that would kill Mister Arrow, gets off scott-free.
- The motive for week 5, everyone is tormented by Pink Elephants on Parade that induce a Mushroom Samba if touched.
- Kim's execution, at the fourth trial, is gruesome for such a kind character. Pulled limb from limb by imitations of the Zords and her friends, left to finally bleed out as a limbless torso on the floor. A shocking fate for someone that Randall frequently called his "friend".
