Headscratchers / Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell

• ....Why exactly is someone like Gary in Hell to begin with?
  • He says he committed "some horrible sin."
  • When Gary escapes to Earth in season two, his stepbrother asks him if he'll be religious this time around, knowing what he does now. In a world where not believing in Jesus gets you sent to Hell, even if you've never heard of Christianity before, I think Gary's religious apathy may have majorly counted against him.