Follow TV Tropes


Fanfic Recs / Monster Prom

Go To

Proof that the remaining 10% is worth getting rejected by your crush here:

These are recommendations made by Tropers for Fanfics, all of which have been signed. After a few samples, you will be able to judge whether you might be interested in the 'fic, based on who recommended it. No-name recommendations will be Zapped!. Nobody would back up the rec. Discussion of the recommendation is welcome on the discussion page. As such discussion is important, do remember to add the discussion page to the watchlist, if need be.


    open/close all folders 

    Authors and Sites 

    General Fics 
Stories focused on the familial and the friendly relationships of the cast. Plot-focused stories or light day-in-the-life stories. Pretty much anything that isn't focused on romance.

Finding Phobias by Veggie Guru

  • Recommended by Roseblackwood
  • Status: Completed
  • Synopsis: What exactly does it mean to be made of fear? Polly, Vera, Damien, Liam, and Miranda want to find out and are ready to do what it takes to get answers. Oz is a good friend, but they don't know much about Oz's life outside of school—when they take it into their own hands to investigate, their discoveries were a little unexpected...

A Friendship That Lasts a Lifetime by LaLlorona

  • Recommended by SEGASister
  • Status: Ongoing
  • Synopsis: Vicky and Oz have been friends for years. They’ve been through so much together.

This is the story of the two and the bond that grew between them. Starting from the day they met, this will be the many highlights of their friendship as it grew though the years.

Not going to school today by Veggie Guru

  • Recommended by Roseblackwood
  • Status: Completed
  • Synopsis:"Are you guys in a cuddle pile instead of going to school?" A nice, cozy fic about buds being best buds.

    Shipping Fics 
Stories focused on the romantic relationships between the cast.

Trauma Stitched With Love by Rinichey

  • Recommended by SEGASister
  • Status: Completed
  • Pairings: Vicky/Scott, Liam/Oz, Amira/Damien, Brian/Polly
  • Synopsis: After begging for so long, Vicky finally gets a shot at public education for her last year of high school. She feels prepared and excited for anything that stands in her way, until she meets the lovable Scott that brings back haunting memories from her childhood. With fear and stubbornness fighting for her emotions, Vicky tries to overcome these fears by becoming friends with the one thing that she's scared of the most. Will she overcome her past and find a future with more than just a friend, or let her past consume her and chain her to her trauma permanently? The full moon draws near ...

Amira Moves In by The3ookNook

  • Recommended by Rinichey
  • Status: Dormant; last updated September 2018
  • Pairings: Scott & Amira, Liam & Vicky
  • Synopsis: As paranoia about the supernatural rises, so does violence. Wards against monsters are increasing in the human world. Amira finds herself on the brutal end of an eviction that lands her with a broken arm and a pretty bad infection. Her on-again, off-again boyfriend Scott invites her to stay with him, but Amira's feelings about the werewolf have always been cautious at best. Amira likes to think she's passionate; her heart runs wild and unrestrained. But her werewolf beau radiates a different kind of passion that makes her more than a little scared. Scott's deep, unadulterated affection for her and everything he sees challenges the shallow extremes she lives her life in. Being with Scott forces her to think about things deeply in a way she usually doesn't like to consider. So as soon as Scott helps her settle in with him, she starts looking for a way out. But her recovery takes longer than she expected, and she's forced to spend more time with Scott outside sex on the full moon. Amira knows she likes Scott, but is it possible she might love him? It would be easier to figure out the answer if Liam wasn’t fucking around with Vicky.

Monster Manhunt by The3ookNook

  • Recommended by Rinichey
  • Status: Completed
  • Pairings: Oz & Vera & Damien, Amira & Scott, Vicky & Liam
  • Synopsis:Vera Oberlin runs a tight ship and Oz knows — they helped him start it. Monsters say high school relationships never last, but Oz's role as his adviser is more than that. In their twisted world, Vera's "businesses" make them notorious. They've just about damned all the competition, so deciding to move to Hell was pretty apt. Damien LaVey, their closest friend, opened his arms and his ring of Hell to them eagerly. Forming a terrifying Triumvirate, the three expanded his kingdom. The only thing more hellish than their personalities is their empire. But when Oz's body begins to change, they find themselves leaving their sinful paradise for answers. They didn't exactly leave a note of absence from their life of crime and despotism. Oz's relationship with Vera and Damien is formal, no more no less, and built on strength. They're pretty sure two of the most dominating people in existence won't appreciate hearing Oz is getting weaker by the day. They definitely won't like hearing that Oz has run away. It's a race against the clock, the illness growing inside them and the two strongest people to rule Hell. If Oz is caught, the repercussions will be dire, and it's not like they're working at 100% either.

All According to Plan by LaLlorona

  • Recommended by SEGASister
  • Status: Completed
  • Pairings: Vicky & Liam, Oz & Damien
  • Synopsis: For years Vicky has been trying, and failing, to win over Polly’s heart. Liam seems to have a similar problem with a certain demon. With prom right around the corner Vicky grows desperate. She strikes a deal with the vampire, and the two help each out serving as wingmen. Seems simple enough. That is until Vicky develops feelings for her partner.

Zoe the Matchmaker by Greenhand, SEGASister

  • Recommended by Snowy_Mass
  • Status: Completed
  • Pairings: Vicky & Damien, Oz & Polly, Amira & Vera, Brian & Scott,Zoe & Calculester
  • Synopsis: Zoe is very meticulous when it comes to her fanfictions and OTPs. She's even written up ships for her fellow classmates at Spooky High.

What if she could make them... real?

Three Weeks is a Lifetime by PhantomDreamshade

  • Recommended by Arruruerie
  • Status: In-Progress
  • Pairings: Brian/Damien, Oz/Zoe, Vicky/Scott, Amira/Vera, Miranda/Dahlia, Liam/Joy, and Aaravi/Hope, with Calculester & Blobert & Kale and quadruple player character friendship also tagged on the platonic front
  • Synopsis: It’s finally Senior Prom, and the school’s most charismatic personalities are actually graduating this time—rules for how long monsters stay in school vary by species and are ridiculously strange and convoluted. Seriously, it’s like they’ve been stuck in a time loop or something. How many times have they actually gone to prom? No one really knows.

ANYWAY—after chasing after love interests for so long, everyone’s favorite squad of Player Characters has decided that this year, they’re going to focus on themselves. They have their own problems and aspirations to deal with aside from being way too thirsty for their own good (not that anyone else seems to know or care) and since it seems like whatever they do with their prom dates is more or less forgotten about by the next cycle, they’re skipping prom this year.

Needless to say, everyone is perturbed by this break in routine. With the end of high school on the horizon, the love interests are going to have to decide if they’ve found someone they want to have a real relationship with—and with how things are looking, they’re going to have to do some of the chasing and problem-solving this time around.

  • Comments: A new but ridiculously promising fic that treats the cast as a full ensemble while having the excellent sense of everyone's characterization to pull it off in its use of multiple perspectives. The writer's style also tends toward serious/thoughtful and character-study-ish, but they pay homage to pretty much every facet of the game's appeal, from the silliness and enjoyable absurdity of a lot of what happens in the setting to the self-aware elements of Deconstruction and meta-humor to just plain classic "shipping feels". Definitely worth keeping an eye on and encouraging!

"life is an adventure" by Crazy4U

  • recommended by chris the gamer 72
  • "status": in-progress
  • "parings": Oz/Aaravi, Vicky/Scott, Brian/Miranda, Polly/Amira/Calculester, Valerie/Damien
  • "synopsis": No one expected the concept of fear and a temperamental slayer to get married, let alone have a kid, but stranger things have happened. Now Oz and Aaravi are embracing an adult life together. Hey, it can't be any harder than high school, right? Right???
A loose collection of episodic one shots taking place in the same universe.

  • "comments": a nice rare pair fic with plenty of domestic fluff and cuteness, with a healthy dose of tsundere Aaravi.

    Dark Fics 
Stories focused on making the series darker, and/or exploring the darker aspects of the series.

Fifteen Minutes by Greenhand & SEGASister

  • Recommended by Rinichey
  • Status: Completed
  • Pairings: Brian & Zoe, Liam & Vicky, Oz & Miranda, Amira & Scott & Polly
  • Synopsis: What if I told you that the world was gonna end and you had fifteen minutes to spend with me or your friends? Prom draws near. As the students scramble to find dates, the Prank Masterz (With a Z!) gear up for the prank to end all pranks (as well as life on Earth as we know it)!

How You Lived by SEGASister

  • Recommended by vickylavey
  • Status: Completed
  • Synopsis: Vicky's having nightmares as of late, of herself... dying? No. Her past self. Perhaps her Mother/Creator has some insight as to why...

    Erotic Fics 
Stories focused on the sexual aspects of the series, not necessarily romantic.

    Alternate Universe Fics 
Stories where one or more plot points, settings, or characters are significantly different from canon.

    Crossover Fics 
Crossovers with other franchises.

Monster Prom Plays: Trivia Murder Party by Lord_Tenebros

  • Recommended by Snowy_Mass
  • Status: Complete
  • Pairings: Oz & Zoe, Vera & Amira, Liam & Brian, Vicky & Damien
  • Synopsis: Exactly What It Says on the Tin. Monster Prom has come and gone, and our favorite Color Squad and their love interests decide to all hang out together at the Color Squad’s house. While they are playing some games and generally having a good time, Vicky accidentally lets slip about how Oz is the best roleplayer she has ever seen for the host of a certain game involving trivia and murder. Thoroughly interested, the monsters call for Oz to show them the acting that is being so highly praised by one of his closest friends. Relenting, Oz takes them all over to his home dimension, where his will is law…and shows his best friends’ love interests a whole new side to him that they’ll never forget. All in the name of good fun, of course! And fear, can’t forget the fear.

Featuring Oz as the Trivia Murder Party host.


How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: