Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Pannic Reads Stuff He Hates
Pannic2016-05-28 15:15:07

Go To


I return from my coma. Back to the hippy nudists.

Shit, I've been away from this for way too long. Sorry, I was busy trying to graduate and also getting a bit deep into Pathfinder. But fear not, those of you who still may be here, I return with more Rose Potter! Which I was gonna do months ago but I closed the page I was writing on and lost my work and went "fuck it."

Now, let me see where I left off on the previous page, because I stopped halfway into chapter 2. There is a reason for this.

I was barely back in the Glen when I heard slivers of footfalls approaching, the magical boundary was disrupted. A tall naked woman ran into the clearing, Cerelian the druidess. The clear astonishment on her face was actually the first clear emotion I had ever seen from the druidess. I sat down in lotus again.
You know, sometimes I feel bad about being snarky at fanfiction. Like, one time I left a critical comment on someone's shipfic because of how it handled a canon character, when the story was probably written by a teenager seeking an outlet. I felt like a dick. Or there was Lily's Changes, where I was very rude indeed, so much so that even a friend on Skype told me I was a dick. I don't feel as bad about that one because I found the story itself sufficiently nasty. I mean, context is important. A slash fic might be as badly written as a fixfic, but the slash fic might be the only outlet that some gay teenager has, as opposed to the fixfic, which is written from a perspective of spite and arrogance.

It's easy to be a critic, sometimes, to emulate your Yahtzees or your Plinketts and come up with scathing remarks when you find an error or a plot contrivance and blow it open. And we have a laugh. But we often forget that when people write stories, they're sharing with you a piece of themselves, and even if you're the most gracious accepter of criticism, it can still sting when you see someone tear apart your work. I don't think I fully understood that back when I started this blog. If I were to redo it all I think I might be a little nicer. I don't know. I want to be funny and a good critic, but I also want to be an empathetic and understanding (and, well, good) person. I think that self-inventory is an important thing.

And then I see "lotus position" and I go fuck it I'm going in!

“Why are you here Cerelian? My week is not up?” I said, untying the letters.

“Apprentice,” said Cerelian chastisingly, “even though you are supposed to get by on your own this week, does not mean I stop watching and observing you. And besides, I felt the Glen’s magic being disturbed in a menacing way, I know you couldn’t have the knowledge to do so. And I assumed you were under attack.”

“Well, a house-elf wanted to imprison me within the Glen, but I teleported out of it before the elf could finish, it’s also responsible for preventing all my letters from finding me,” I pointed to the stack of mail.

“Why would a house-elf do that?” asked Cerelian curiously.

“Well, I had a chat with Dobby, before he tried to imprison me; apparently there is a plot to do most terrible things, his words, at Hogwarts this year. He came to warn me. And because he thinks I am too valuable to lose, he stops my mail to make me think my friends don’t like me, so I won’t go back,” I explained shaking my head.

“Oh,” said Cerelian frowning, “it has nothing to do with Voldemort?”

“Apparently not,” I answered.

“You said you teleported?” asked Cerelian uncertainly.

“That’s what I call it, yes, it first happened when I was at Muggle school and being chased by my cousin, I jumped behind the dumpster to hide, and the next thing I know, I’m on the school roof,” I laughed at the memory. “I had a physical defence teacher who helped me harness the ability, even though he clearly was not magical and couldn’t do it himself, he helped to remember what was going through my mind at the time, and to reproduce the effects reliably.”

“There is an ability called Apparition, that wizards learn, that transports them from one place instantly to another in the blink of an eye, it should not be possible to perform it in the Glen,” said Cerelian. “Can you do it again?”

I nodded from my seated position and concentrated again, the world shifted and warped and I was now ten meters away from my previous spot. I teleported back and ripped open a letter from Hermione.

“Well,” said Cerelian obviously impressed, “I see you have the ability down pat. Then again, if you can teleport in the Glen, you can certainly teleport in any warded area, even Hogwarts itself.”

“I have thought of giving it a try,” I said, “but I do not want to advertise the ability, Professor Dumbledore is rather all knowing in Hogwarts, and knows most everything that happens.”

“If that is your decision, I will respect it,” said Cerelian, “and your mother?”

“I trust my mother,” I said, “but not Professor Mc Gonagall; she is a stickler for rules and would report it to the Headmaster.”

“They are one and the same person, Apprentice,” said Cerelian, “if you approach your mother as such, she will keep your confidence I believe.”

“I suppose you are right, Cerelian,” I said, “I will tell her then.”

“Good,” nodded the druidess, “I shall let you get back to your solitude. I shall however be close, in case the house-elf has second thoughts.”

Cerelian turned and disappeared into the trees. I sighed and started reading.

You know how I mentioned Plinkett before? If you don't recognize that name, you might remember that years ago someone did these big long video reviews of the Star Wars prequels, which combined dark humor with some very eye-opening filmmaking analysis. I won't go into that, but there's one thing we're going to use here. We're going to talk about characters!

Here's what I call "The Plinkett Test."

"Describe the following Star Wars character WITHOUT saying what they look like, what kind of costume they wore, or what their profession or role in the movie was."

Except instead of Star Wars it's just gonna be, like, various characters from fanfiction and also media. Including Cerelian here from Rose Potter.

Here

Note a few things. First, notice how they seem to like Brother White, and therefore you should read The Book of Friendship. Second, notice that Snipehamster, who was about as critical of Fallout: Equestria as I was and who clearly doesn't like Monterey Jack, can describe Monterey Jack's personality enough that he can say what he doesn't like about him. That, dumb children, is what separates stories that have problems from stories that are legit shit.

The only person here who can actually give something of a run-down for Cerelian in terms of character and shit is Sereg, who once did a fuckheug blog post about fucking Flash Sentry from Equestria Girls. So yeah. Cerelian is not a good character. In fact, the author of Rose Potter, whenever he brings in an OC, never really manages to give them, like... characterization.

Also, Rose has a new superpower. Teleportation. It's like apparation, except better.

The rest of the week of solitude passed uneventfully. I continued practicing my druidic magic, exercising, tracking magical creatures and so forth. I felt immeasurably better now that I knew my friends had not suddenly deserted me, and the solitude had passed more quickly. It even got to the point where I was getting pangs of longing to live such an uncomplicated life in such a beautiful setting; it was a scene of paradise.
Maybe it's because I'm trying to hurry so I can get to doing other things, like writing my fanfiction or starting a new liveblog where I talk about an analyze the best animated show ever or playing pony pathfinder (I swear playing the party's token tragic pseudo-pacifist has really helped me empathize more with Velvet Remedy), but that last sentence just makes no sense to me. Pangs of longing? Longing for what? Longing because it's passing so quickly? Whatever, moving on to other things.

Soon enough, I was being led out of the forest by Cerelian. It was late at night and because I knew what to look for, I figured we were heading south. Cerelian stopped just inside the Forest boundary. I looked out and saw that it was exactly where I had entered the forest with her six weeks ago.

“This is where your training ends for this summer Apprentice,” said Cerelian, “you are far from finished and I guess that after another four summers you will be ready to be called a druidess among us and have your true name.”

And have public sex on Stonehenge.

That's not a joke. That happens.

“It has been an honour to learn from you, Cerelian,” I said with slight bow of the head.

“It has been an honour to teach you my Apprentice,” said Cerelian,

How do you learn an apprentice? If I were a lazy hack I'd make a "You're Fired!" joke, but I will instead make the marginally less lazy hack joke of "making a joke about making a joke about 'You're Fired!'"

Do I still got it? Probably not.

So Cerelian tells her she has to practice because Malcolm Gladwell says you needs ten thousand hours to get good at something and gives her her amulet.

“Here is your amulet,” she handed it back to me and I instantly slipped it around my waist and fitted it tight. Cerelian looked up at the sky. “Your mother has owled me and said that the Weasley’s will be picking you up right there on the road. She apologized that she could not meet you personally, but she has been unexpectedly busy at Hogwarts. She will visit you at the Weasley’s home as soon as she can.” I sighed a bit in sadness but nodded.
It's the little things that make this story fun. Like how the author misuses apostrophes twice. "Weasley's" is used twice, and both instances are wrong! It should just be "Weasleys" the first time (because it's a plural and not a possessive) and "Weasleys'" the second time (because it's plural and also a possessive)!

I forgot how much fun it was to be petty. Also, remember how in Chamber of Secrets we had that fun break-out of the barred window? Not going to happen! This is a mature rewrite of the story for discerning adults, and discerning adults hate things like "fun" and "suspense" and "action" and "things that aren't totally fucking boring."

“Goodbye, Cerelian,” I said, the naked druidess nodded and disappeared into the woods.
In case you forgot they were naked. Because they're naked.

The impression I got from Cerelian was that they would be here at any moment. It was then that I heard it, an odd whine and something that distinctly sounded like a car engine. I looked up and down both ends of the road but saw nothing, yet the sound was distinctly coming closer. Two bright spots of light caught the upward corner of my eye. I looked up and saw that something with two headlights was distinctly coming closer, but out of mid-air. Did the Wealey’s own an aeroplane?
No more buttered scones for me, maître d', I'm off to play the grand piano. Pardon me while I fly my aero-

... ... ... ... ...

Whew. Sorry about that. My Monty Python penalty wristband just put me into a brief coma.

But that was impossible, they were a wizarding family.
I'd more go with "they're dirt poor and those fucking things are expensive," but eh, I guess that train of logic also, um... kinda works?

It did not sound like an aeroplane. The pair of headlights was rapidly but evenly descending to the surface of the road not a hundred meters away from me.

It touched down, with a loud thump! And tires were screeching and not a few moments later I was staring through the passenger window of a turquoise car. And someone was goggling through the window at me: a freckle-faced, red-haired, long-nosed someone.

Ron Weasley.

Ohhhh, Ron Weasley. I feel bad for you. You're gonna be in for a miserable time this book. We're in for some

Good to be back. Hopefully I'll be able to update a bit regularly now. I'm gonna be continuing with this as well as with Fallout Equestria: Memories. That is, assuming I can stick with my goals. I don't really have an excuse, but when has that ever stopped me?

Anyway, I may also be starting some other liveblogs for stuff. I'll keep you posted. As long as I'm actually posting.

Comments

Valiona Since: Dec, 1969
May 28th 2016 at 7:09:14 PM
It is good to see you posting again. At times, the liveblogging section seems almost dead, with hardly anyone else updating.

Do not worry too much about being overly critical of fan fiction. While some writers become defensive, others thank me for pointing out their flaws. In any case, I agree that fix fics are born out of arrogance, specifically the belief that the fanfic author is better than the original creators.

Of course, as a writer myself, while I welcome constructive criticism, I also agree that I am sharing a bit of myself when I write. Perhaps my advice to critics would be to write their own works, if only to understand the perspectives of other writers.

Apologies for the lack of apostrophes, but as far as I know, the system error is still there.
IcyShake Since: Dec, 1969
May 28th 2016 at 11:56:18 PM
A system error that kills comments with apostrophes, Valiona? Looks like it to me. Anyway, great to see you are back, Pannic. And I see it is this again. Joy.

  • I was barely back in the Glen when I heard slivers of footfalls approaching,

What does that even mean? What is a sliver of a footfall? Does the concept even make sense? Mr. Orwell, take it up:

XXX A newly invented metaphor assists thought by evoking a visual image . . . Many of these are used without knowledge of their meaning (what is a rift, for instance?) . . . a sure sign that the writer is not interested in what he is saying.

(I see now Sereg caught on to this too. On which note I should add a character point, if it was not already there or I forgot it: Cerelian speaks in a very stilted fashion, eschewing the use of contractions, among other issues. Probably because being a druid means being a crappy mid-20th century sci-fi robot or computer. )

  • Does this person just have some kind of irrational hatred of periods? There are soooo many comma splices in the parts you excerpted.

  • I see you have the ability down pat. Then again, if you can teleport in the Glen, you can certainly teleport in any warded area, even Hogwarts itself.

God. Dammit.

  • you are far from finished and I guess that after another four summers you will be ready to be called a druidess among us and have your true name.

Well, small wonder it will take another four summers, if you are not even going to describe any of the stuff you are doing. Yes, large parts of Harrys studies were glossed over, but they were puncuated by him using things he learned in class context as well as in adventures/schenanigans, throughout the time he was learning them rather than separately, if at all.

  • Two bright spots of light caught the upward corner of my eye.

Was her head tilted or something? I do not think that is how that phrase is normally used.

  • It touched down, with a loud thump! And tires were screeching and not a few moments later I was staring through the passenger window of a turquoise car.

Drop the comma and make the And lowercase and you actually have a really good sentence there, using a breathless structure to convey the speed with which the landing and approach happened. And, dare I say it, even a sense of excitement.
Valikdu Since: Dec, 1969
Jul 17th 2016 at 5:18:36 AM
  • If I were to redo it all I think I might be a little nicer.

You can (not) redo.
Top