Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Umineko Visual Novels : the Live But Delayed Blogination
Jhiday2011-01-26 13:23:20

Go To


Episode #7 : Part 6 - Love

"Chapter 5, a new element"

Again, the years pass. Then, one night, in what looks a lot like a dream, Beatrice invites Shannon to join her and party forever in her rose garden. Shannon politely declines, to Beatrice's bewilderment and anger. A servant's live is hard and will little reward : why doesn't Shannon want to leave it ?

The answer becomes clear the next day, at the annual Ushiromiya family reunion : Jessica has secretly become friends with Shannon (despite Natsuhi's best efforts), and the maid enjoys the company of the three cousins while the adults are too busy to care. (Maria's too young to count ; Asumu's presence suggests this is at least "six years ago"... and I'm already pretty sure it's exactly that point in time.)

[LOL at the reveal that Battler and George spent the night talking about Shannon's breasts. And, er... Jessica and Shannon were also there for at least part of the discussion, and the maid wasn't the least interested in all this flowers and bees talk...]

But moreover, what Shannon found was... love. It all started with Battler lending her a mystery book (smooth, man !)... and then their shared passion for those became something more, and an excuse for them to meet alone together. By now, he even gets enough nerve to suggest that, if she ever quits her job as a maid, he'd welcome her happily... But he leaves her time to think it over, and she decides to give it a year. If he still comes for her next year... Oh dear. I already know he'll break his promise and won't be coming.

Beato watches all this from afar... and becomes very interested in this "love" thing.

Cut to Lion (watching all this with Will), who's quite unnerved by this parallel version of her... but still has no clue why she'd commit murder. Beato states that she herself didn't know then she'd commit mass murder six years later... and really it was bad luck that Battler came back exactly six years later. So the timing of his return's important, hum ? Oh, and will has guessed that one of the root causes for the whole thing is that Beato solved the epitaph... which gave her leverage to gain allies. Well, EP 2 strongly hinted at that, and it supports my "round robin of allies" pet theory.

But why does Battler coming back exactly six years later matter so much ?


And I'm tired, so that's it for today.

Comments

76.175.202.223 Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 26th 2011 at 2:19:26 PM
Jeremy-

The internal psychology of Yasu is hurting my head.

Perhaps the reason is the Love Trial? If Battler returned later, Yasu would be already happily married and if earlier the other relationships would be weak and easy to break. 1986 Yasu might be an emotional timebomb waiting to be set off from the conflicting desires.

Wait. Battler's broken promise was conditional? It seems unfair to me to blame a 12 year old boy for not keeping a conditional promise if she didn't keep her part first.
Jhiday Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 26th 2011 at 2:35:40 PM
Battler promises here that he'd be back the next year to hear her answer. But he wasn't, due to all the Asumu stuff. I'd understand her being a bit angry. (And her narration here does express regret at not accepting there and then.)

What baffles me in those flashbacks is the bizarre insistence that Yasu and Shannon are different people, despite not making a lick of sense internally (even discounting everything we already know about Shannon, we get a gradual transfer of Yasu's background onto Shannon... and this was already happening before the "retcon").
76.175.202.223 Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 26th 2011 at 8:49:01 PM
Ah, Battler did make an actual promise that he then broke. Sorry, I did not understand. He really should have at least written a letter explaining what happened and why he did not come back.

Oh, that also explains why the not remembering was the main part of the sin. It comes off as him not caring and maybe never caring about her at all.

The Yasu Shannon relationship is the head hurting element. Beatrice was Gaap and then Yasu took the name and title. This somehow left Shannon behind. Though, Beatrice does seem to believe that Shannon and Kannon are seperate people. It still makes my head hurt.
Top