Line #15 Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS2E5LoudAsAWhisper


1	[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/picard_calming_riva.jpg]]
2	[[caption-width-right:350:Picard talking to Riva.]]
3
4	'''Original air date:''' January 9, 1989
5
6	The ''Enterprise'' gets orders to transport a renowned mediator named Riva to Solais V to bring an end to a bitter war. Upon meeting him, the crew learns that he is deaf and speaks through three interpreters who communicate with him telepathically. Riva immediately finds himself taken with Counselor Troi and bonds with her over dinner.
7
8	Upon reaching Solais V, Riva beams down to settle the dispute with only Riker and Worf as security, reasoning that bringing anyone else will only increase tensions. But only moments after arriving (before they even have the table set up) one of the natives becomes angry and fires at Riva, somehow killing all three of his interpreters with one shot when Riker pulls him out of the way. After beaming out, Riva becomes despondent and loses faith in his ability to mediate a peace. Even after Data learns his sign language, he insists that he cannot be an effective mediator without his interpreters.
9
10	Counselor Troi tells Riva that she will handle the negotiations herself and asks his advice. He tells her that he didn’t have a secret trick to negotiating; he merely found something in common between the two sides and worked from there. He also says that he liked to turn a disadvantage into an advantage. Troi asks why he can’t do that now, and it gives him an idea. He beams down to the planet again to renew the negotiations. When Riker asks him how the natives will understand him without his interpreters, he explains that he intends to begin the negotiations by teaching the natives his sign language. As they learn to communicate with him, they will learn to communicate with each other, giving them common ground to start from. He gives the ''Enterprise'' permission to leave him behind, stating that the peace talks will be a long process, but he believes they will be successful.
11	----
12	!! This episode provides examples of:
13	* TenMinuteRetirement: Riva's refusal to return to the negotiations lasts a few hours.
14	* AbortedArc: One scene features Dr. Pulaski offering to grow new human eyes for Geordi, who leaves saying he'll think about it. This is never brought up again. The reason for this was to allow for the possibility of removing Geordi's need of the visor, which was due to a request from Levar Burton to be allowed to use his expressive eyes in the series. The plot point was dropped after the episode, however.
15	* AliensSpeakingEnglish: Despite him being from another planet, Riva's sign language is seemingly identical to American Sign Language -- which is understandable, as it's Howie Seago's native language, but doesn't make much sense in-universe. Since the Universal Translator doesn't really work as an explanation,[[labelnote:*]] it ''might'' be designed to work on sign languages, but why translate a language the user doesn't understand into ''another'' one they don't understand?[[/labelnote]] we can only guess that TranslationConvention may be in effect.
16	* ArmorPiercingQuestion: When Troi asks Riva why he can't do what he does in his negotiations with himself - turn a disadvantage into an advantage.
17	* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Riva, talking about deafness in his family, says "it is similar to [[UsefulNotes/TheHouseOfHanover the House of Hanover]] of your planet Earth, all who had haemophilia". However:
18	** The royal house status [[LineageComesFromTheFather goes by male line only]]; haemophilia, being a recessive X chromosome gene, almost always goes only by female line (but only affects males), the exception being that a male haemophiliac who has children (which was rare until the mid 1900s) pass the gene to all his daughters and none of his sons.[[note]]The above explanation of the genetics of Haemophilia doesn't apply to type C, the rarest type. However, the family tree indicating who had Haemophilia '''does''' match the genetic information above.[[/note]] So haemophilia could not possibly go down a royal house.
19	** There actually were several haemophiliacs in European royalty. The source was a mutated gene in UsefulNotes/QueenVictoria, who was from the House of Hanover. It did not affect her; however, it did affect one of her sons (even he wasn't a Hanover), one of the sons of his daughter, and 7 grandsons and great grandsons of Queen Victoria through 2 of her daughters. None of them were from the House of Hanover.
20	** Although it can't be proven that the mutation was new with her, no members of her extended family, except her matrilinial descendants, had the disease.
21	** Queen Victoria wasn't even the first British monarch from the House of Hanover. She came after George I, George II, her grandfather UsefulNotes/GeorgeIII, and her uncles George IV and William IV.
22	* BilingualBonus: Riva's signing is all genuine ASL. This unfortunately causes some issues during the scenes of Data's translating, as the differences in sentence structure mean he occasionally says a word before Riva makes the sign for it.
23	* BreakTheHaughty: Riva isn't a bad guy at all and likes the entire crew, but he was pretty overconfident in his abilities to defuse a war (especially considering the warring factions in question had been at it for '''fifteen centuries'''). Either way, once his entire chorus gets wiped out right in front of him, his confidence and cool veneer is completely shattered.
24	* TheCharmer: Riva turns on the ol' charm immediately upon seeing Troi.
25	* DespairEventHorizon: Riva is ''horrified'' after his chorus gets killed, pacing around the briefing room like a madman. Troi and Picard try desperately to calm him, but of course, that's not happening.
26	* DisabilitySuperpower: Riva, who's deaf, is also telepathic. This is apparently a trait of his family, and possibly linked to their deafness (both are hereditary among them).
27	* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: The mention of Riva negotiating peace treaties between the Klingons and the Federation was an early attempt to explain how those former enemies became allies. Season 3's "Yesterday's Enterprise" later explained that the two sides became allies after the ''Enterprise''-C heroically sacrificed itself defending Klingons at Narenda III, and ''Film/StarTrekVITheUndiscoveredCountry'' would show that peace was first established after the destruction of Praxis left the Klingon Empire unable to sustain their military might against the Federation.
28	* FeeFiFauxPas: When meeting Riva, Picard attempts to address the chorus instead of Riva, offending him. He later explains to Riker to treat the chorus as interpreters and thus address Riva directly.
29	* ForeverWar: The Solari factions has been fighting for fifteen centuries, leading both of them to the brink of extinction.
30	* FreudianTrio: Riva's psychic chorus literally represent parts of his mind.
31	-->'''Superego Interpreter:''' I am the scholar. I represent the intellect, and speak in matters of judgement, philosophy, logic. Also, I am the dreamer, the part that longs to see beauty beyond the truth, which is the first duty of art. I am the poet who...
32	-->'''Id Interpreter:''' Artists, they tend to ramble, neglect the moment. I am passion, the libido, I am the anarchy of lust, the romantic, and the lover. I am also the warrior, the perfect line which never wavers.
33	-->'''Ego Interpreter:''' I am that which binds all the others together. I am harmony, wisdom, balance.
34	* GetAholdOfYourselfMan: Picard to Riva, by grabbing his head so Riva can read his lips and tell him he's not alone, after Riva's chorus is killed. With a bit of TranslationByVolume with Picard shouting "''LISTEN TO ME!!''" to a deaf guy.
35	* HiveMind: Consisting of only four people. Riva's chorus represent his [[FreudianTrio Ego, Superego and Id]], with each speaking Riva's thoughts that most closely correspond to those aspects of his mind. It can also be turned off and on at will--Riva brings only the Id voice to his dinner date with Troi, then dismisses him to communicate alone.
36	* ItsAllMyFault: Riva blames himself for his chorus' untimely deaths.
37	* ItsPersonal: Riva tells the ''Enterprise'' crew not to even bother investigating the reasons for the war provided in the background they've been given. It'll say that it's about some piece of land, or wealth, or something, but it doesn't matter. After fifteen centuries of fighting, nobody really cares about the original reason anymore. It's just personal now.
38	* JustThinkOfThePotential: Worf is intrigued by the concept of sign language, observing that a form of communication which is both silent and covert could have other uses. (Of course, he's hardly the first person to have this thought.)
39	* LanguageEqualsThought: Before Riva negotiated several treaties with the Klingons, the Klingon language had no word for peacemaker.
40	* MoodWhiplash: The episode takes a deliberately slow pace in the first half to build up the mystique around Riva and his chorus. The result is that the tragedy that happens in the first negotiation attempt becomes that much more of a shock.
41	* NeverLearnedToTalk: Riva is deaf due to a congenital defect among the nobles of his planet. He has a group of interpreters who are telepathically linked to him, but otherwise can only communicate through sign language.
42	* RayOfHopeEnding: Riva isn't the same after his chorus is gone, but he does decide to give the peace negotiations one more try - by teaching the two factions sign language. The theory is, while they learn to speak to him, they'll learn to speak to each other. It's clearly going to be a process, but that's fine with Riva.
43	* ReadingLips: Riva certainly has no problem with this.
44	* ReconcileTheBitterFoes: After fifteen centuries of war, the Solari calls for Riva to lead the peace negotiations. The episode ends with Riva intending to teach both sides his sign language to communicate with him, and hopefully with each other.
45	* RenegadeSplinterFaction: The representative that shoots at Riva to try and prevent peace is apparently from one of these. He is immediately shot dead as a traitor by the other representative of his supposed faction.
46	* RoyalsWhoActuallyDoSomething: Riva is a member of the ruling family of Ramatis, and is also a renowned and experienced peace mediator.
47	* TheSpeechless: Riva's deafness is hereditary, and having grown up with his chorus, he doesn't speak. In the script it's said he doesn't even know how to read or write either, which is why he ignores Picard's suggestion that he write his thoughts down.
48	* SuperSpeedReading: Basically how Data learns all known sign language for Riva.
49	* VoiceForTheVoiceless: Riva's chorus telepathically conveys his thoughts. It's a hereditary position for them, corresponding to the equally hereditary condition of Riva's family.
50	* WhamShot: When one of the tribesmen suddenly goes AWOL and shoots, instantly killing Riva's entire chorus.
51	* WhatCouldPossiblyGoWrong: Averted. Riker expressed some concern about allowing Picard to beam down to the planet to meet Riva. Picard points out that he's just going to greet a dignitary and there's no danger. It seems like the perfect set up for something to go horribly wrong. But other than a minor faux pas that was immediately forgiven, nothing went wrong at all.

Context Recap / StarTrekTheNextGenerationS2E5LoudAsAWhisper