Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / YuunaAndTheHauntedHotSprings

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingEnding: A fair amount of fans were upset that [[spoiler:the MarryThemAll that the final arc seemed to be building up towards instead ends with Kogarashi solely picking Yuuna while the other girls merely get to live with their false memories of the future where he picks them instead, and several do not take this well, with him losing contact with all of them and [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding only Kogarashi and Yuuna getting any sort of happy ending]]]].

to:

* AudienceAlienatingEnding: A fair amount of fans were upset that [[spoiler:the MarryThemAll that the final arc seemed to be building up towards instead ends with Kogarashi solely picking Yuuna while the other girls merely get to live with their false memories of the future where he picks them instead, and several do not take this well, with him losing contact with all of them the girls drifting apart from Kogarashi over time and [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding only Kogarashi and Yuuna getting any sort of a completely happy ending]]]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanPreferredCouple: There are many strong supporters over who Kogarashi should end up with, but many fans agree that a MarryThemAll scenario is preferable, especially to the girls who've showed explicit interest in him (Yuuna, Chisaki, Sagiri, Hibari, Oboro, and Karura), all of whom are supportive of each other and that Kogarashi treats each of them with kindess and makes an effort to make them happy.

to:

* FanPreferredCouple: There are many strong supporters over who Kogarashi should end up with, but While Kogarashi/[[spoiler:Yuuna]] is by no means unpopular in the fanbase, many fans agree that a MarryThemAll scenario is preferable, preferable over picking just one, especially to the girls who've showed explicit interest in him (Yuuna, Chisaki, Sagiri, Hibari, Oboro, and Karura), all of whom are supportive of each other and that Kogarashi treats each of them with kindess and makes an effort to make them happy.happy. [[spoiler:The ending breaking all but Yuuna's hearts through their false futures with Kogarashi only strengthened the sentiment.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Shipping Goggles TRS cleanup, out-of-universe examples are to be removed as it's now just Fan Speak (only wicks in descriptions).


* ShippingGoggles: Kogarashi's fellow classmates Satoshi Hyodo and Seri Yanazawa are often seen interacting with one another, which is more than enough for readers to pair them together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WriterCopOut: The ending is viewed as this by some readers for not going through with the [[spoiler:MarryThemAll scenario]] that seemed to be building up throughout the final arc.

to:

* WriterCopOut: The ending is [[AudienceAlienatingEnding viewed as this by some readers readers]] for not going through with the [[spoiler:MarryThemAll scenario]] that seemed to be building up throughout the final arc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AudienceAlienatingEnding: A fair amount of fans were upset that [[spoiler:the MarryThemAll that the final arc seemed to be building up towards instead ends with Kogarashi solely picking Yuuna while the other girls merely get to live with their false memories of the future where he picks them instead, and several do not take this well, with him losing contact with all of them and [[OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding only Kogarashi and Yuuna getting any sort of happy ending]]]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EsotericHappyEnding: [[spoiler:Yuuna gets an emotional return to the semi-mortal plane due to the efforts of her love interest and friends, and a just-as-emotional confession from Kogarashi with the harem's implicit blessing. However, it comes hot off the heels of the harem gaining false memories of futures where they're the ones he picked instead of Yuuna, ''keeping'' those memories after being given the chance to erase them, and Kogarashi also having access to those memories but explicitly saying that all of those realities were lesser because Yuuna wasn't there--and this is ''during'' the emotional confession and in front of the harem to boot. A few of the main six don't take this well at all according to the epilogue illustrations, but regardless the story depicts the ending as completely happy.]]

to:

* EsotericHappyEnding: [[spoiler:Yuuna gets an emotional return to the semi-mortal plane due to the efforts of her love interest and friends, and a just-as-emotional confession from Kogarashi with the harem's implicit blessing. However, it comes hot off the heels of the harem gaining false memories of futures where they're the ones he picked instead of Yuuna, ''keeping'' those memories after being given the chance to erase them, and Kogarashi also having access to those memories but explicitly saying that all of those realities were lesser because Yuuna wasn't there--and this is ''during'' the emotional confession and in front of the harem to boot. A few of the main six don't take this well at all according to the epilogue illustrations, least of all [[WomanScorned Karura]], but regardless the story depicts the ending as completely happy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EsotericHappyEnding: [[spoiler:Yuuna gets an emotional return to the semi-mortal plane due to the efforts of her love interest and friends, and a just-as-emotional confession from Kogarashi with the harem's implicit blessing. However, it comes hot off the heels of the harem gaining false memories of futures where they're the ones he picked instead of Yuuna, ''keeping'' those memories after being given the chance to erase them, and Kogarashi also having access to those memories but explicitly saying that all of those realities were lesser because Yuuna wasn't there--and this is ''during'' the emotional confession and in front of the harem to boot. A few of the main six don't take this well at all according to the epilogue illustrations, but regardless the story depicts the ending as completely happy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Although she ranked fourth in the first poll, but dropped to sixth for the second, Nonko remains popular despite not being a major character of the harem due to her party-loving, CoolBigSister personality. It also helps that she accentuates the MsFanservice BuxomIsBetter philosophy.

to:

** Although she ranked fourth in the first poll, but dropped to sixth for the second, Nonko remains popular despite not being a major character of the harem due to her party-loving, CoolBigSister personality. It also helps that she accentuates the MsFanservice BuxomIsBetter BuxomBeautyStandard philosophy.

Changed: 925

Removed: 1977

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* WhatAnIdiot: Readers were not impressed with Sagiri and Yaya's attempt to get Kogarashi kicked out of the inn over a simple misunderstanding in Chapter 3.\\
'''What Happened''': Kogarashi finds a cat walking around in the inn and reaches out to cuddle it, not knowing that it's Yaya in animal form. To his embarrassment, Yaya transforms back butt-naked while Sagiri appears behind him and pissed off; violence ensues.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Since it's a first offense and one of complete accident, the girls would hear him out.\\
'''Instead''': He gets forced into a ping pong game against Sagiri and Yaya - if he loses, he's forced to leave the inn. Making this more ridiculous is Yuuna protests the whole thing - that Kogarashi wasn't at fault and it was just a misunderstanding. With everyone ignoring her, Yuuna is forced to embarrass herself to keep him from leaving.\\
'''Result''': The incident makes it look like Sagiri and Yaya was looking for an excuse to get rid of Kogarashi; while they were unsuccessful, the way the chapter ends leaves a bad taste in readers' mouths, especially with the [[DoesNotLikeMen man-hater]] stereotype fans are getting tired of for this genre.
* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: This series runs into the same problems as ''To-Love-Ru'' when the latter had its run in ''Shonen Jump'', except the {{Fanservice}} in ''Yuuna'' is more explicit compared to not just the former, but also the average {{Seinen}} work. In fact, the first popularity [[http://goboiano.com/shonen-jump-faces-controversy-after-due-to-a-sexy-manga/ poll]] became controversial with MoralGuardians due to the girls in the color spread being practically nude with minimal CensorSteam; not even ''To-Love-Ru'' dared to go that far until SpinOff {{Sequel}} ''To-Love-Ru Darkness''[[note]]''Darkness'' was released in the monthly {{Shonen}} magazine ''Jump Square'' instead, which allowed it to be more explicit, but not without scrutiny either, when it was reviewed by the Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly to see if it violated a bill restriction with regards to material that could be sold to minors; they ultimate decided it did not[[/note]].

to:

* WhatAnIdiot: Readers were not impressed with Sagiri and Yaya's attempt to get Kogarashi kicked out of the inn over a simple misunderstanding in Chapter 3.\\
'''What Happened''': Kogarashi finds a cat walking around in the inn and reaches out to cuddle it, not knowing that it's Yaya in animal form. To his embarrassment, Yaya transforms back butt-naked while Sagiri appears behind him and pissed off; violence ensues.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Since it's a first offense and one of complete accident, the girls would hear him out.\\
'''Instead''': He gets forced into a ping pong game against Sagiri and Yaya - if he loses, he's forced to leave the inn. Making this more ridiculous is Yuuna protests the whole thing - that Kogarashi wasn't at fault and it was just a misunderstanding. With everyone ignoring her, Yuuna is forced to embarrass herself to keep him from leaving.\\
'''Result''': The incident makes it look like Sagiri and Yaya was looking for an excuse to get rid of Kogarashi; while they were unsuccessful, the way the chapter ends leaves a bad taste in readers' mouths, especially with the [[DoesNotLikeMen man-hater]] stereotype fans are getting tired of for this genre.
* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: This series runs into the same problems as ''To-Love-Ru'' ''Manga/ToLoveRu'' when the latter had its run in ''Shonen Jump'', except the {{Fanservice}} in ''Yuuna'' is more explicit compared to not just the former, but also the average {{Seinen}} work. In fact, the first popularity [[http://goboiano.com/shonen-jump-faces-controversy-after-due-to-a-sexy-manga/ poll]] became controversial with MoralGuardians due to the girls in the color spread being practically nude with minimal CensorSteam; not even ''To-Love-Ru'' dared to go that far until SpinOff {{Sequel}} ''To-Love-Ru Darkness''[[note]]''Darkness'' was released in the monthly {{Shonen}} magazine ''Jump Square'' instead, which allowed it to be more explicit, but not without scrutiny either, when it was reviewed by the Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly to see if it violated a bill restriction with regards to material that could be sold to minors; they ultimate decided it did not[[/note]].

Top