Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / WalkingWithDinosaurs

Go To

OR

Added: 1158

Removed: 1158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later lowered those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies".


Added DiffLines:

** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later lowered those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies".

Added: 1158

Removed: 1159

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later lowered those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",


Added DiffLines:

** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later lowered those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The series features quite a few controversial ([[ScienceMarchesOn and since debunked]]) ideas that were based on rather obscure and fragmentary evidence and certain theories that have largely been forgotten since 1999. The tie-in books ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs the Evidence'' (2000) [[AllThereInTheManual explain some of it]]:

to:

** The series features quite a few controversial ([[ScienceMarchesOn and since debunked]]) ideas that were based on rather obscure and fragmentary evidence and certain theories that have largely been forgotten since 1999. The tie-in books ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs the Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' (2000) [[AllThereInTheManual explain some of it]]:



*** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",

to:

*** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized lowered those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The series features quite a few controversial ([[ScienceMarchesOn and since debunked]]) ideas that were based on rather obscure and fragmentary evidence and certain theories that have largely been forgotten since 1999, and the 2000 tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs the Evidence'' [[AllThereInTheManual explains some of it]]:

to:

** The series features quite a few controversial ([[ScienceMarchesOn and since debunked]]) ideas that were based on rather obscure and fragmentary evidence and certain theories that have largely been forgotten since 1999, and the 2000 1999. The tie-in book books ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs the Evidence'' (2000) [[AllThereInTheManual explains explain some of it]]:



*** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' (2000), the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",

to:

*** Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' (2000), Evidence'', the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** 'Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' (2000), the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",

to:

*** 'Regarding Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' (2000), the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** 'Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence" (2000), the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",

to:

*** 'Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence" Evidence'' (2000), the 12-meter wingspan was actually based on much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Santana Group of Brazil, as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the Vectis Formation on the Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** ''Ornithocheirus'' (or rather ''Tropeognathus'') having a 12-meter wingspan was legitimately taken seriously by some workers back in the '90s, based on the preliminary description of a very large, partial specimen found in the Romualdo Formation of Brazil, which is what WWD also cited, and it has been cited in other paleontological media from the time (like 1999's ''Series/WhenDinosaursRuled''), but once the specimen got a proper description in 2013, its wingspan was downsized to a more likely 8.2-8.7 meters.

to:

*** ''Ornithocheirus'' (or rather ''Tropeognathus'') having 'Regarding the huge size of WWD's ''Ornithocheirus'', it's often claimed that it was based on MN 6594-1, a partial skull and skeleton now assigned to ''Tropeognathus''. While that specimen has been known since the '80s, according to both ''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History'' (1999) and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence" (2000), the 12-meter wingspan was legitimately taken seriously by some workers back in the '90s, actually based on the preliminary description of a very large, partial specimen much more fragmentary fossils, mainly isolated wing bones found in the Romualdo Formation Santana Group of Brazil, which is what WWD also cited, and it has been cited in other paleontological media as well as similar fragmentary fossils from the time (like 1999's ''Series/WhenDinosaursRuled''), but once Vectis Formation on the specimen got a proper description Isle of Wight, which David Martill (the series main consultant) attributed to [[https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287549358_Giant_pterosaurs_from_the_Lower_Cretaceous_of_the_Isle_of_Wight_UK gigantic pterosaurs with wingspans in 2013, its wingspan was excess of 9 meters back in 1996]] ([[https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/14288452/Additional_evidence_for_very_large_wing_span.pdf though he later downsized those estimates to a more likely 8.2-8.7 meters.less than 6 meters]]), which also provided apparent evidence of giant ornithocheirids in both Brazil and England, further supporting the intercontinental migration shown in "Giant of the Skies",

Changed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The female ''Postosuchus'' does not start this way, as she's seen in her prime when we first see her, but as soon she gets injured in her leg things start to go downhill from there with her injury being a handicap that will make hunting difficult for her, then when she arrives to her territory she finds a male individual has invaded it and she's driven away from her house due to being to weak to defend it as result of her injury, and it eventually her injury gets worse as it reaches the point where she loses the ability to use her back legs and her's been gravely injured at that point that she became blind from her left eye, the mighty predator lays there dying being surrounded by a flock of ''Coelophysis'' eager to make a quick meal out of her before she finally succumbs to her injury and the lack of food.

to:

** The female ''Postosuchus'' does not start this way, as she's seen in her prime when we first see her, but as soon she gets injured in her leg things start to go downhill from there with her injury being a handicap that will make hunting difficult for her, then when she arrives to her territory she finds a male individual has invaded it and she's driven away from her house due to being to weak to defend it as result of her injury, it, and it eventually her injury gets worse as it reaches the point where she loses the ability to use her back legs and her's been gravely injured at that point that she became blind from looking worse than before having lost sight on her left eye, the mighty predator lays there dying being surrounded by a flock of ''Coelophysis'' eager to make a quick meal out of her before she finally succumbs to her injury and the lack of food.

Changed: 821

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The female ''Postosuchus'' does not start this way, as she's seen in her prime when we first see her, but as soon she gets injured in her leg things start to go downhill from there with her injury being a handicap that will make hunting difficult for her, then when she arrives to her territory she finds a male individual has invaded it and she's driven away from her house due to being to weak to defend it as result of her injury, and it eventually her injury gets worse as it reaches the point where she loses the ability to use her back legs and her's been gravely injured at that point that she became blind from her left eye, the mighty predator lays there dying being surrounded by a flock of ''Coelophysis'' eager to make a quick meal out of her before she finally succumbs to her injury and the lack of food.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* UnintentionallySympathetic: Scowler is meant to be seen as a jerk and an antagonist, but ultimately somewhat sympathetic given he has a HeelFaceTurn. Since Scowler spends most of the film being an emotionally and at times physically abusive bully to Patchi for no real reason, culminating in him [[spoiler:leaving his brother to die out of petty spite]], many viewers found his redemption unearned and felt he had crossed the MoralEventHorizon with [[spoiler:his attempted familicide.]]

to:

* UnintentionallySympathetic: UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Scowler is meant to be seen as a jerk and an antagonist, but ultimately somewhat sympathetic given he has a HeelFaceTurn. Since Scowler spends most of the film being an emotionally and at times physically abusive bully to Patchi for no real reason, culminating in him [[spoiler:leaving his brother to die out of petty spite]], many viewers found his redemption unearned and felt he had crossed the MoralEventHorizon with [[spoiler:his attempted familicide.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* UnintentionallySympathetic: Scowler is meant to be seen as a jerk and an antagonist, but ultimately somewhat sympathetic given he has a HeelFaceTurn. Since Scowler spends most of the film being an emotionally and at times physically abusive bully to Patchi for no real reason, culminating in him [[spoiler:leaving his brother to die out of petty spite]], many viewers found his redemption unearned and felt he had crossed the MoralEventHorizon with [[spoiler:his attempted familicide.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The ''Brachiosaurus'' in the second episode. While it doesn't do much other than walk and eat, it's presence accompanied by the soundtrack playing quickly shows the magnificence of the giant sauropod.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's often claimed that the little ornithopod from "Death of a Dynasty" is just the ''Othnielia'' from "Time of Titans", [[PropRecycling without even being given a new coat of paint]]. While they are the same model ([[PaletteSwap the same one as all the "hypsilophodonts" in the series]]), ''Othnielia'' [[MandelaEffect never actually appeared]] in "Time of Titans", we only see a small background ornithopod with a green body and red head. The brightly colored ''Othnielia'' (along with ''Dryosaurus'') showed up a year later in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl'' and [[EarlyBirdCameo repurposed the striking color scheme of the unnamed ornithopod]] from ''Death of a Dynasty".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommonKnowledge: It's sometimes claimed that in the tie-in book (''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History''), the ''Plateosaurus'' fights the ''Postosuchus''. In actuality, it just ''scares it off'' and the encounter is summarized in one sentence.

to:

* CommonKnowledge: It's sometimes claimed that in the tie-in book (''Walking with Dinosaurs: A Natural History''), the ''Plateosaurus'' fights the ''Postosuchus''.''Postosuchus'' in the book. In actuality, it just ''scares it off'' and the encounter is summarized in one sentence.

Top