History YMMV / UncannyXMen2018

** Cyclops are also less than pleased over him saying he was wrong in his actions since ''House of M'', or that characters like Chamber (who sided with Cyclops during Schism) are now calling him out.
* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: Hey, did you want another retread of Warren and Archangel? Well, here you go! In the most forced way possible! The series overall seems to really like retreading the 90s. Also, ''Disassembled'' leads into yet ''another'' Extinction barely two years [[Comicbook/InhumansVsXMen after the last one]], while also setting up rehashes of both ''Comicbook/AgeOfApocalypse'' and ''Comicbook/HouseOfM''.

* InternetBackdraft: As you might have gathered by now, fans of New X-Men are ''pissed'' at this book's treatment of these characters. And a lot of Cyclops fans, too, for him saying he was wrong in his actions since ''House of M''.

** The younger students, with the exception of Pixie, being so pissed at their perceived sidelining by the senior X-Men. Partially because the situation they complain about is ''very'' forced (and requires ignoring their histories in order to push them into a resentful sidekick role; most of them have long since been depicted as young adults equal to the senior X-Men, so they should have no reason to still be considered students). However, the fact they ''don't shut up'' about the perceived sidelining gets very grating, and ends up coming off as petty and even quite selfish when they start complaining about not getting 'cool' missions and complaining about the very idea of doing clean-up, making it feel less like they're being abandoned and more that they only want to do ''cool'' superhero stuff and not the equally important roles. They also complain when they're given ''any'' order, no matter how much it makes sense, simply because they're being told what to do. Not only that, but they seem to be actively ''looking'' for reasons to rebel against the adult X-Men, such as lambasting the adults for imprisoning Legion despite how much trouble he's caused both recently and in the past, as well Armor implying it's Kitty Pryde's fault that two of her team got hurt when she disappeared, when Kitty was ''kidnapped''.
*** What's worse is that the complaining youths are Rockslide, Armor, Pixie and Glob Herman; characters who, while rarely given starring roles, have been getting a lot of use on teams, made a lot of appearances, and have been pushed in one way or another. Their complaints ''are'' valid, given that X-students post-2000 are NotAllowedToGrowUp and are ''always'' DemotedToExtra, but the characters complaining about this are the ones who often get the attention and cool missions. Compare them to the other New X-Men-era students, who spent most of their time forced to grow up and take care of themselves after the failure of the adult X-Men, but end up being treated as children and mostly left out of stories. They're acknowledging the fans' complaints, but they chose the absolute worst characters for it.

* {{Narm}}

** Marvel seems to have learned from the complains about its predecessor, ComicBook/AvengersNoSurrender's length, as ''Disassembled'' arc is only 10 issues long, as opposed to a whopping ''16.''

** Annual #1 is a Saving Throw towards Cyclops, resetting him to how he was before events such as ''Avengers vs. X-Men''.
* ClicheStorm: With exception of the Phoenix, if you can name a popular X-Men plotline, this book probably tried to rehash it.
* InternetBackdraft: As you might have gathered by now, fans of New X-Men are ''pissed'' at this book's treatment of these characters. And a lot of Cyclops fans, too.

** Pretty much any of the adults calling the students kids or children or insisting they're too young to take a part in real missions.Jean was previously okay with having two of their peers, Gentle and X-23, and an even younger character, Honey Badger, on her team in ''X-Men: Red''.Jubilee started as a TagAlongKid herself and Laura was with those very kids on a team, meaning she is similar age to them. So they all come off as colossal hypocrites. And in ''X-men: Legacy'' Legion was ''dating'' one of the students so him constantly calling Blindfold's peers children makes him look like a total creep.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: For one of the first times in this history of the franchise Apocalypse is in a comic with both his favorite horseman, Archangel (who also temporally served as his successor), ''and'' Genesis, his teenaged clone who has been fighting all his existence to not become whom he was intended to be. Yet not one word of dialogue passes between the three.
** Legion returns in the same story that tries to bring more spotlight to X-men students and their plotlines are strongly intertwined. Yet Blindfold, the student he formed a romantic connection with [[spoiler: and the only person to remember him after he UnPerson himself]] is nowhere to be found. Made even more infuriating when she shows up right after the story involving Legion ends and he is no longer in the book.

* InternetBackdraft: As you might have gathered by now, fans of New X-Men are ''pissed'' at this book's treatment of these characters.

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The treatment of the New X-Men era cast has gotten a lot of scrutiny for the ContinuitySnarl and [[TheResenter one-note characterisation they're given]]. Fans of their characters are really annoyed at them being de-aged and derailed back into students, despite many having graduated on-panel, as well as the book treating them as if they're inexperienced idiots who hate that the older X-Men don't treat them as equals all the while acting in a way that would directly inspire them to be treated as such. Normally this would make them all TheScrappy, except that since its such a dissonance from their previous characterisation, the anger is aimed at the writers instead of the characters.

** The younger students, with the exception of Pixie, being so pissed at their perceived sidelining by the senior X-Men. Partially because the situation they complain about is ''very'' forced (and requires ignoring their histories in order to push them into a resentful sidekick role; most of them have long since been depicted as young adults equal to the senior X-Men, so they should have no reason to still be considered students). However, the fact they ''don't shut up'' about the perceived sidelining gets very grating, and ends up coming off as petty and even quite selfish when they start complaining about not getting 'cool' missions and complaining about the very idea of doing clean-up, making it feel less like they're being abandoned and more that they only want to do ''cool'' superhero stuff and not the equally important roles. They also complain when they're given ''any'' order, no matter how much it makes sense, simply because they're being told what to do. Not only that, but they seem to be actively ''looking'' for reasons to rebel against the adult X-Men, such as lambasting the adults for imprisoning Legion despite how much trouble he's caused both recently and in the past, as well Armor implying it's Kitty Pryde's fault that two of her team got hurt when she disappeared, when Kitty was ''kidnapped''.
*** What's worse is that the complaining youths are Rockslide, Armor, Pixie and Glob Herman; characters who, while rarely given starring roles, have been getting a lot of use on teams, made a lot of appearances, and have been pushed in one way or another. Their complaints ''are'' valid, given that X-students post-2000 are NotAllowedToGrowUp and are ''always'' DemotedToExtra, but the characters complaining about this are the ones who often get the attention and cool missions. Compare them to the other New X-Men-era students, who spent most of their time forced to grow up and take care of themselves after the failure of the adult X-Men, but end up being treated as children and mostly left out of stories. They're acknowledging the fans' complaints, but they chose the absolute worst characters for it.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: The ''Disassembled'' event was advertised as a massive crossover with tons of different X-Men, from all the different eras. Outside of the core cast, most X-Men just made wordless cameos in two crowd shots. And of the core X-Men, only Jean, Psylocke, Bishop and the X-kids had any importance.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel seems to have learned from the complains about its predecessor, ComicBook/AvengersNoSurrender's length, as ''Disassembled'' arc is only 10 issues long, as opposed to a whopping ''16.''

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: For one of the first times in this history of the franchise Apocalypse is in a comic with both his favorite horseman, Archangel (who also temporally served as his sucesor), ''and'' Genesis, his teenaged clone who has been fighting all his existence to not become whom he was intended to be. Yet not one word of dialogue passes between the three.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: For one of the first times in this history of the franchise Apocalypse is in a comic with both his favorite horseman, Archangel, ''and'' Genesis, his teenaged clone who has been fighting all his existence to not become whom he was intended to be. Yet not one word of dialogue passes between the three.

* UnfortunateImplications: With the X-Men and mutants long being used as an allegory for minority struggles, (the Civil Rights movement of the 60s, while often using them as stand-ins for the LGBTQ rights in TheNewTens) the fact that Anole — one of the few prominent gay characters in the franchise — handed over the Mutant Cure, which the government made into a mandatory vaccination, becomes this since the vaccine might be viewed as a metaphor for government-mandated [[CureYourGays Conversion Therapy]].

* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: Hey, did you want another retread of Warren and Archangel? Well, here you go! In the most forced way possible! The series overall seems to really like retreading the 90s.

** Psylocke. Everyone stands by her decision to turn Angel into Archangel, and we're probably supposed to feel bad for her. That doesn't change that ''he's got a point''. She inflicted on him his worst fear, one he'd finalyl gotten free of, all to take away X-Man's Horseman of Salvation that... flies.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: The younger students, with the exception of Pixie, being so pissed at their perceived sidelining by the senior X-Men. Partially because the situation they complain about is ''very'' forced (and requires ignoring their histories in order to push them into a resentful sidekick role; most of them have long since been depicted as young adults equal to the senior X-Men, so they should have no reason to still be considered students). However, the fact they ''don't shut up'' about the perceived sidelining gets very grating, and ends up coming off as petty and even quite selfish when they start complaining about not getting 'cool' missions and complaining about the very idea of doing clean-up, making it feel less like they're being abandoned and more that they only want to do ''cool'' superhero stuff and not the equally important roles. They also complain when they're given ''any'' order, no matter how much it makes sense, simply because they're being told what to do. Not only that, but they seem to be actively ''looking'' for reasons to rebel against the adult X-Men, such as lambasting the adults for imprisoning Legion despite how much trouble he's caused both recently and in the past, as well Armor implying it's Kitty Pryde's fault that two of her team got hurt when she disappeared, when Kitty was ''kidnapped''.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel have not been subtle about promoting Cyclops' resurrection after his unceremonious and disliked death in ''ComicBook/DeathOfX''.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: The younger students, with the exception of Pixie, being so pissed at their perceived sidelining by the senior X-Men. Partially because the situation they complain about is ''very'' forced (and requires ignoring their histories in order to push them into a resentful sidekick role; most of them have long since been depicted as young adults equal to the senior X-Men, so they should have no reason to still be considered students). However, the fact they ''don't shut up'' about the perceived sidelining gets very grating, and ends up coming off as petty and even quite selfish when they start complaining about not getting 'cool' missions and complaining about the very idea of doing clean-up, making it feel less like they're being abandoned and more that they only want to do ''cool'' superhero stuff and not the equally important roles. They also complain when they're given ''any'' order, no matter how much it makes sense, simply because they're being told what to do. Not only that, but they seem to be actively ''looking'' for reasons to rebel against the adult X-Men, such as lambasting the adults for imprisoning Legion despite how much trouble he's caused both recently and in the past, as well Armor implying it's Kitty Pryde's fault that two of her team got hurt when she disappeared, when Kitty was ''kidnapped''.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel have mot been subtle about promoting Cyclops' resurrection after his unceremonious and disliked death in ''ComicBook/DeathOfX''.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: The younger students, with the exception of Pixie, being so pissed at their perceived sidelining by the senior X-Men. Partially because the situation they complain about is ''very'' forced (and requires ignoring their histories in order to push them into a resentful sidekick role; most of them have long since been depicted as young adults equal to the senior X-Men, so they should have no reason to still be considered students). However, the fact they ''don't shut up'' about the perceived sidelining gets very grating, and ends up coming off as petty and even quite selfish when they start complaining about not getting 'cool' missions, making it feel less like they're being abandoned and more that they only want to do ''cool'' superhero stuff and not the equally important roles. They also complain when they're given ''any'' order, no matter how much it makes sense, simply because they're being told what to do.

* InternetBackdraft: The treatment of the New X-Men era cast has gotten a lot of scrutiny for the ContinuitySnarl and [[TheResenter one-note characterisation they're given]]. Fans of their characters are really annoyed at them being de-aged and derailed back into students, despite many having graduated on-panel, as well as the book treating them as if they're inexperienced idiots who hate that the older X-Men don't treat them as equals all the while acting in a way that would directly inspire them to be treated as such. Normally this would make them all TheScrappy, except that since its such a dissonance from their previous characterisation, the anger is aimed at the writers instead of the characters.