Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheDearSweetieBelleContinuity

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooBleakStoppedCaring: The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife stories, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series' [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the series. While later works were better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows that a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] went largely without notice.

to:

* TooBleakStoppedCaring: The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife stories, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series' [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the series. While later works were better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows that a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] cancellation]] went largely without notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooBleakStoppedCaring: The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife stories, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the series. While later works were much better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] went largely without notice.

to:

* TooBleakStoppedCaring: The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife stories, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series series' [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the series. While later works were much better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows that a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] went largely without notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders'': [[ArcVillain Former Captain Feather Duster]] was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

** ''Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders'': [[ArcVillain Former Captain Feather Duster]] was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, Wrap-Up and went about taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.



* TooBleakStoppedCaring The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict is being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the seres. While later works were much better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] went largely without notice.

to:

* TooBleakStoppedCaring TooBleakStoppedCaring: The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife, SliceOfLife stories, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict is being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the seres.series. While later works were much better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] went largely without notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors" showing Luna help the CMC fight back against their nightmares, since as of season 5 all three Crusaders [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS3E6SleeplessInPonyville have received aid]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E20ForWhomTheSweetieBelleToils from the night princess]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E4BloomAndGloom within their dreams]].

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors" showing Luna help the CMC fight back against their nightmares, since as of season 5 all three Crusaders [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS3E6SleeplessInPonyville have received aid]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E20ForWhomTheSweetieBelleToils from the night princess]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E4BloomAndGloom within their dreams]].dreams]].
* TooBleakStoppedCaring The series shifting to foreshadowing/setting up an [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt apocalyptic conflict]] has put off many who enjoyed the series character-driven SliceOfLife, especially since the characters it made them so attached to are now at high risk of getting unhappy endings. Not helping is said conflict is being caused in part by the [[BrokenBase controversial actions]] of the series [[BaseBreakingCharacter more controversial characters]] while likable characters are denied agency, most notoriously [[ShooOutTheClowns Pinkie Pie dying of unspecified causes prior]]. The first story fully set in this darker direction, ''The Changelings Have a King'', had a high body count and higher ratio of dislikes to likes than any other work in the seres. While later works were much better received, their having only one-fifth the likes shows a large majority, all save the most dedicated fans, stopped caring about the series to the point its [[DeadFic cancelation]] went largely without notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS. Now about the original work having a tendency for fanworks to do so. Specific works doing it are Adaptational tropes.


* HilariousInHindsight: "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors" showing Luna help the CMC fight back against their nightmares, since as of season 5 all three Crusaders [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS3E6SleeplessInPonyville have received aid]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E20ForWhomTheSweetieBelleToils from the night princess]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E4BloomAndGloom within their dreams]].
* RonTheDeathEater:
** While she is still portrayed as a well-meaning ruler, Princess Celestia displays a disturbing pattern of arrogance and [[LackOfEmpathy belittling of others' concerns]] when dealing with individual ponies, from brushing off her sister's pre-Nightmare Moon insecurities, to subsequently blaming Luna's [[TeacherStudentRomance pupil/lover]] for her fall into madness (when if anything he was the victim of [[ClingyJealousGirl Luna's jealous rage]]) and trying to have him arrested, to talking down to and ''slapping'' Cadance when the latter is upset after [[spoiler:learning of Shining Armor and Luna's affair (admittedly Cadance had [[DisproportionateRetribution gone off the deep end in response]] but Celestia didn't know that yet)]] to [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking getting Twilight drunk at Fluttershy and Big Mac's wedding reception]]. Most egregiously, in "Apple Family Secrets", she reacts to Applejack [[spoiler:[[CallingTheOldManOut calling her out for seducing a random stallion and abandoning the resulting daughter]] -- ''Applejack's biological grandmother'' --]] by calling her a "bumpkin" and blaming earth ponies for "saddl[ing] the rest of us with your feeble moral code" [[spoiler:(i.e. monogamy)]], and even briefly considering [[spoiler:''[[TakenForGranite turning AJ into stone]]'']] after AJ [[spoiler:threatens to blackmail her with the knowledge of the affair]]. This is portrayed as a temporary, stress-induced relapse into the darker mindset she had during Luna's banishment, but seeing this undertone of racism and arrogance is jarring all the same. Her next appearance has her back to the caring, well-meaning monarch we know, but considering she starts by [[spoiler:[[{{Hypocrite}} castigating Luna for doing the same damn thing that she did and shows no regrets for]]]]....
** Applejack herself verges on this when [[spoiler:blackmailing Celestia.]]
** [[EarlyInstallmentWeirdness "Lost in the Night"]] outright states that Shining Armor is a domineering ControlFreak. He gets much more sympathetic in later installments, but WordOfGod still expresses disgust at his affair with Luna.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors" showing Luna help the CMC fight back against their nightmares, since as of season 5 all three Crusaders [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS3E6SleeplessInPonyville have received aid]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E20ForWhomTheSweetieBelleToils from the night princess]] [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E4BloomAndGloom within their dreams]].
* RonTheDeathEater:
** While she is still portrayed as a well-meaning ruler, Princess Celestia displays a disturbing pattern of arrogance and [[LackOfEmpathy belittling of others' concerns]] when dealing with individual ponies, from brushing off her sister's pre-Nightmare Moon insecurities, to subsequently blaming Luna's [[TeacherStudentRomance pupil/lover]] for her fall into madness (when if anything he was the victim of [[ClingyJealousGirl Luna's jealous rage]]) and trying to have him arrested, to talking down to and ''slapping'' Cadance when the latter is upset after [[spoiler:learning of Shining Armor and Luna's affair (admittedly Cadance had [[DisproportionateRetribution gone off the deep end in response]] but Celestia didn't know that yet)]] to [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking getting Twilight drunk at Fluttershy and Big Mac's wedding reception]]. Most egregiously, in "Apple Family Secrets", she reacts to Applejack [[spoiler:[[CallingTheOldManOut calling her out for seducing a random stallion and abandoning the resulting daughter]] -- ''Applejack's biological grandmother'' --]] by calling her a "bumpkin" and blaming earth ponies for "saddl[ing] the rest of us with your feeble moral code" [[spoiler:(i.e. monogamy)]], and even briefly considering [[spoiler:''[[TakenForGranite turning AJ into stone]]'']] after AJ [[spoiler:threatens to blackmail her with the knowledge of the affair]]. This is portrayed as a temporary, stress-induced relapse into the darker mindset she had during Luna's banishment, but seeing this undertone of racism and arrogance is jarring all the same. Her next appearance has her back to the caring, well-meaning monarch we know, but considering she starts by [[spoiler:[[{{Hypocrite}} castigating Luna for doing the same damn thing that she did and shows no regrets for]]]]....
** Applejack herself verges on this when [[spoiler:blackmailing Celestia.]]
** [[EarlyInstallmentWeirdness "Lost in the Night"]] outright states that Shining Armor is a domineering ControlFreak. He gets much more sympathetic in later installments, but WordOfGod still expresses disgust at his affair with Luna.
dreams]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Applejack herself verges on this when [[spoiler:blackmailing Celestia. InTheBlood, perhaps]]?

to:

** Applejack herself verges on this when [[spoiler:blackmailing Celestia. InTheBlood, perhaps]]?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
DIAA now requires proof audiences were apathetic.


* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: The increasing focus on foreshadowing/setting up a coming cataclysmic conflict which portends doom for Equestria, and the distinct possibility of unhappy endings for most characters involved, has [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere driven off a few readers]] (though many more are still hooked). Some also find the behavior of the royals who receive much of the focus to be extremely unpleasant, especially considering that their divisive behavior is implied to be at least partially responsible for said conflict.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''[[https://www.fimfiction.net/story/209182/the-changelings-have-a-king The Changelings Have a King]]'': [[TheEvilPrince Prince Blueblood]] is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After [[UnholyMatrimony he and Chrysalis marry]], he begins making plans to take over Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end, he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him. After moving to Ponyville, he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn and stirs drama between Spike and Crescendo--Rarity's former lover--to the point that Spike nearly kills him. After being found out, he unleashes his horde of flesh-hungry Changelings on Ponyville, watching with a smile as innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed, he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity outright, only for Spike to [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TakingTheBullet take the shot]]. He then attempts to [[EvilNephew kill his aunts]] in an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor, and then drains a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated, he [[IRegretNothing shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets]]; he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.

to:

** ''[[https://www.fimfiction.net/story/209182/the-changelings-have-a-king The Changelings Have a King]]'': [[TheEvilPrince Prince Blueblood]] is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After [[UnholyMatrimony he and Chrysalis marry]], he begins making plans to take over Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end, he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him. After moving to Ponyville, he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn and stirs drama between Spike and Crescendo--Rarity's former lover--to the point that Spike nearly kills him. After being found out, he unleashes his horde of flesh-hungry Changelings on Ponyville, watching with a smile as innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed, he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity outright, only for Spike to [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TakingTheBullet [[TakingTheBullet take the shot]]. He then attempts to [[EvilNephew kill his aunts]] in an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor, and then drains a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated, he [[IRegretNothing shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets]]; he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

** "Dear ''Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Crusaders'': [[ArcVillain Former Captain Feather Duster, Duster]] was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

Added: 2099

Changed: 776

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear CompleteMonster:
**"Dear
Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.Dash.
** ''[[https://www.fimfiction.net/story/209182/the-changelings-have-a-king The Changelings Have a King]]'': [[TheEvilPrince Prince Blueblood]] is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After [[UnholyMatrimony he and Chrysalis marry]], he begins making plans to take over Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end, he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him. After moving to Ponyville, he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn and stirs drama between Spike and Crescendo--Rarity's former lover--to the point that Spike nearly kills him. After being found out, he unleashes his horde of flesh-hungry Changelings on Ponyville, watching with a smile as innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed, he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity outright, only for Spike to [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TakingTheBullet take the shot]]. He then attempts to [[EvilNephew kill his aunts]] in an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor, and then drains a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated, he [[IRegretNothing shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets]]; he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.

Removed: 1094

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not properly approved by the thread and incorrect indentation.



** "The Changelings have a King":Prince blueblood is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After he and Chrysalis marry he begins making plans to takeover Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him . after moving to Ponyville he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn, stirs drama between Spike and Cresecendo raritys former lover to the point Spike nearly kills him. After being found out he unleashes his horde of flesh hungry Changeling on ponyville watching with a smile has innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity out right only for Spike to take the shot. He then attempts to kill his aunts In an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor and then draining a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated he shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "The Changelings have a King":Prince blueblood is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After he and Chrysalis marry he begins making plans to takeover Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him . after moving to Ponyville he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn, stirs drama between Spike and Cresecendo raritys former lover to the point Spike nearly kills him. After being found out he unleashes his horde of flesh hungry Changeling on ponyville watching with a smile has innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity out right only for Spike to take the shot. He then attempts to kill his aunts In an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor and then draining a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated he shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.

to:

* "The **"The Changelings have a King":Prince blueblood is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After he and Chrysalis marry he begins making plans to takeover Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him . after moving to Ponyville he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn, stirs drama between Spike and Cresecendo raritys former lover to the point Spike nearly kills him. After being found out he unleashes his horde of flesh hungry Changeling on ponyville watching with a smile has innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity out right only for Spike to take the shot. He then attempts to kill his aunts In an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor and then draining a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated he shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's
body to murder Dash.
* The Changelings have a King:Prince blueblood is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After he and Chrysalis marry he begins making plans to takeover Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him . after moving to Ponyville he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn, stirs drama between Spike and Cresecendo raritys former lover to the point Spike nearly kills him. After being found out he unleashes his horde of flesh hungry Changeling on ponyville watching with a smile has innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity out right only for Spike to take the shot. He then attempts to kill his aunts In an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor and then draining a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated he shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's
Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.
Dash.

* The "The Changelings have a King:Prince King":Prince blueblood is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After he and Chrysalis marry he begins making plans to takeover Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him . after moving to Ponyville he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn, stirs drama between Spike and Cresecendo raritys former lover to the point Spike nearly kills him. After being found out he unleashes his horde of flesh hungry Changeling on ponyville watching with a smile has innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity out right only for Spike to take the shot. He then attempts to kill his aunts In an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor and then draining a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated he shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.

Added: 1111

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, taking revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster would have happily let Rainbow Dash, his replacement, face the wrath of Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster [[SadisticChoice forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm. After seemingly being stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's Scootaloo's
body to murder Dash.Dash.
* The Changelings have a King:Prince blueblood is the spoiled nephew of Celestia who becomes king of the Changelings. After he and Chrysalis marry he begins making plans to takeover Equestria and gain revenge on Rarity. To that end he starts isolating her in order to make her dependent on him . after moving to Ponyville he kidnaps ponies to feed to his monstrous spawn, stirs drama between Spike and Cresecendo raritys former lover to the point Spike nearly kills him. After being found out he unleashes his horde of flesh hungry Changeling on ponyville watching with a smile has innocent ponies get violently ripped apart. After his offspring are killed he brushes off their deaths and simply tries to kill Rarity out right only for Spike to take the shot. He then attempts to kill his aunts In an attack that ends up killing Trixie and Shining Armor and then draining a mortally wounded Chrysalis of all the love he gave her before leaving her to die. Even after being defeated he shows no remorse when asked if he has any regrets he simply states he regrets not killing everyone sooner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changing back via thread consensus


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of taking responsibility for what he did, Feather Duster [[NeverMyFault takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash]], his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]] and face the wrath of a furious Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, Feather Duster swears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of taking responsibility for what he did, revenge by causing a catastrophic storm, killing Applejack's parents. Feather Duster [[NeverMyFault takes out his anger on would have happily let Rainbow Dash]], Dash, his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]] and replacement, face the wrath of a furious Ponyville, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, Feather Duster swears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] storm. After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, stopped, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of taking responsibility for what he did, Feather Duster [[NeverMyFault takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash]], his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, Feather Duster swears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of taking responsibility for what he did, Feather Duster [[NeverMyFault takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash]], his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], blame]] and face the wrath of a furious Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, Feather Duster swears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of [[NeverMyFault taking responsibility]] for what he did, Feather Duster takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash, his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, Feather Duster swears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of [[NeverMyFault taking responsibility]] responsibility for what he did, Feather Duster [[NeverMyFault takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash, Dash]], his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, Feather Duster swears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of [[NeverMyFault taking responsibility]] for what he did, Feather Duster takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash, his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take to jail, he swears that he sears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of [[NeverMyFault taking responsibility]] for what he did, Feather Duster takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash, his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take him to jail, he Feather Duster swears that he sears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

Changed: 274

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of [[NeverMyFault taking responsibility]] for what he did, Feather Duster takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash, his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

to:

* CompleteMonster: "Dear Cutie Mark Crusaders" ArcVillain, former Captain Feather Duster, was fired for drunkenly flooding rabbit holes during Winter Wrap-Up, but instead of [[NeverMyFault taking responsibility]] for what he did, Feather Duster takes out his anger on Rainbow Dash, his replacement as captain and a mare he had a previous beef with do to her graduating from training at the top of her class, despite him trying to pull his DrillSergeantNasty routine on her. After pretending to take his leave and replacement professionally for a while, he tries to take his vengeance on her by intentionally causing a massive storm to hit Ponyville, indirectly killing the parents of Applejack and her siblings in the process, with full intention of leaving Rainbow Dash to [[FrameUp take the blame]], face the wrath of Ponyville, and leave her thinking the death of two innocent ponies was on her hooves, had he not drunkenly passed out at the scene of his crime. Lashing out at Dash again, Feather Duster attacks Firefly, the elderly caretaker of the Cloudsdale orphanage and Rainbow's [[ParentalSubstitute surrogate mother figure]], before leaving a mortally injured Firefly and '''setting the orphanage on fire''', [[WouldHurtAChild killing three foals]] and two rescue ponies through smoke inhalation, after he finds papers [[spoiler: revealing Scootaloo is Rainbow's sister and kidnaps her]]. Then when Rainbow Dash confronts him, [[SadisticChoice he forces her to choose]] between saving Scootaloo and stopping him from unleashing another, even more destructive storm that would endanger countless lives, counting on her choosing to save Scoots, so she'll be blamed for [[TheNeedsOfTheMany choosing one foal, over the many that would die when he unleashed the storm]]. When Rainbow Dash defeats him and is going take to jail, he swears that he sears that he'll get out one way or another and kill both her and [[spoiler: her sister]] in the end, [[spoiler: causing Rainbow Dash to realize she has kill him, our else he'll just keep coming.]] After seemingly being KilledOffForReal, Feather Duster returns in "Cutie Mark Crusaders Dream Warriors", where his disembodied spirit returns to feed off the nightmares of ponies and tries to possess Scootaloo's body to murder Dash.

Top