Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / StarWarsRebels

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: Although Ezra and Sabine's relationship is officially as step-siblings (and sometimes they don't even come close to that), many of the moments they share in the second and third seasons can be interpreted as romantic. Especially on Ezra's side

to:

* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: Although Ezra and Sabine's relationship is officially as step-siblings (and sometimes they don't even come close to that), many of the moments they share in the second and third seasons series can be interpreted as romantic. Especially on Ezra's side
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Back when [[WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars "The Lost Missions"]] came to Creator/{{Netflix}}, not everyone was particularly happy about the revelation of Order 66 being a result of [[ManchurianAgent brain-implanted microchips]] instead of a [[JustFollowingOrders contingency order]]. Barring the usual FandomRivalry between ''The Clone Wars'' and Creator/KarenTraviss's [[Literature/RepublicCommando novels]] (and other parts of the ''[[Franchise/StarWarsLegends Legends]]'' continuity), some of those against the revelation saw this as diminishing the likelihood of any clones refusing to follow Order 66. With Season 2 revealing that Rex, Wolffe and Gregor had removed their chips and are now allies to ''Ghost'' crew, the show retains the possibility of other clones having faulty chips, or growing suspicious and likewise having their chips removed, thus also refusing to follow the order to turn on their Jedi companions.

to:

** Back when [[WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars "The Lost Missions"]] came to Creator/{{Netflix}}, not everyone was particularly happy about the revelation of Order 66 being a result of [[ManchurianAgent brain-implanted microchips]] instead of a [[JustFollowingOrders contingency order]]. Barring the usual FandomRivalry between ''The Clone Wars'' and Creator/KarenTraviss's [[Literature/RepublicCommando [[Literature/RepublicCommandoSeries novels]] (and other parts of the ''[[Franchise/StarWarsLegends Legends]]'' continuity), some of those against the revelation saw this as diminishing the likelihood of any clones refusing to follow Order 66. With Season 2 revealing that Rex, Wolffe and Gregor had removed their chips and are now allies to ''Ghost'' crew, the show retains the possibility of other clones having faulty chips, or growing suspicious and likewise having their chips removed, thus also refusing to follow the order to turn on their Jedi companions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: Although Ezra and Sabine's relationship is officially as step-siblings (and sometimes they don't even come close to that), many of the moments they share in the third and fourth seasons can be interpreted as romantic. Especially on Ezra's side

to:

* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: Although Ezra and Sabine's relationship is officially as step-siblings (and sometimes they don't even come close to that), many of the moments they share in the second and third and fourth seasons can be interpreted as romantic. Especially on Ezra's side
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Did Maul really go to Tatooine to kill Kenobi as he claimed, [[spoiler:or did he expect that Kenobi might kill him and was he really just a DeathSeeker by this point -- his life was a catalogue of ''de facto'' slavery and TrainingFromHell followed by decades of loneliness, loss and pain, so possibly by this point he just wanted to go out on his own terms. Telling Ezra that he will see him again suggests the former, while his ({{Downplayed}} VillainsDyingGrace of having a moment of camaradrie with Kenobi (acknowledging that they are both victims of the Emperor and hoping that Luke will avenge them) leans towards the latter; quite possibly, Maul didn't know himself, and would have been content with either outcome.]]

to:

** Did Maul really go to Tatooine to kill Kenobi as he claimed, [[spoiler:or did he expect that Kenobi might kill him and was he really just a DeathSeeker by this point -- his life was a catalogue of ''de facto'' slavery and TrainingFromHell followed by decades of loneliness, loss and pain, so possibly by this point he just wanted to go out on his own terms. Telling Ezra that he will see him again suggests the former, while his ({{Downplayed}} {{Downplayed}} VillainsDyingGrace of having a moment of camaradrie with Kenobi (acknowledging that they are both victims of the Emperor and hoping that Luke will avenge them) leans towards the latter; quite possibly, Maul didn't know himself, and would have been content with either outcome.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OlderThanTheyThink: The idea of the Inquisitors as dark Jedi used by the Empire to hunt Jedi Knights and other Force-sensitives who evaded ThePurge originated in ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' with characters like [[https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Antinnis_Tremayne Antinnis Tremayne]].

Changed: 215

Removed: 846

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It doesn't qualify, since they had enough interactions.


** Some people had Agent Kallus and Maketh Tua as this back in Season 1. [[spoiler:"The Siege of Lothal" [[AbandonShipping completely destroys the pairing]], [[AbandonShip due to how weird it is to ship a victim and her assassin]], [[TeethClenchedTeamwork as well as the two making it clear they were tired of each other by that episode]].]]



** As of "The Honorable Ones", Zeb/Kallus is now being considered. However, it did become controversial as a romance pairing for obvious reasons similar to Mallus (and was also poked at as a joke by other parts of the Internet), and the fact that it is almost vocal enough as the Sabezra fanbase has begun to gain fatigue in fans of the characters due to {{Flanderization}} by the shippers.



* FanonDiscontinuity: Of a sort. A few detractors of the Sequel Trilogy or generally those who [[spoiler:don't like the theory of Jacen being [[DoomedByCanon one of Luke's students and a Knight of Ren]]]] prefer [[spoiler:the theory that Jacen will be trained by Ahsoka and/or Ezra in isolation from the events of the Sequel Trilogy]].

to:

* FanonDiscontinuity: Of a sort. A few detractors of the Sequel Trilogy or generally those who [[spoiler:don't like the theory of Jacen being [[DoomedByCanon one of Luke's students and a Knight of Ren]]]] students]]]] prefer [[spoiler:the theory that Jacen will be trained by Ahsoka and/or Ezra in isolation from the events of the Sequel Trilogy]].



** The mere idea of suggesting that Sabine and Ezra are in love, the fandom will make it clear that it is platonic.



* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: Although Ezra and Sabine's relationship is officially platonic (and sometimes they don't even come close to that), many of the moments they share in the third and fourth seasons can be interpreted as romantic.

to:

* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: Although Ezra and Sabine's relationship is officially platonic as step-siblings (and sometimes they don't even come close to that), many of the moments they share in the third and fourth seasons can be interpreted as romantic.romantic. Especially on Ezra's side



** "Mallus" for [[CrackPairing Maketh Tua/Kallus]]. Becomes an [[HarsherInHindsight aptro]][[HilariousInHindsight nym]] when it turns out Kallus actually ''disliked'' her enough that [[spoiler:he was willing to help assassinate her]].

to:

** "Mallus" for [[CrackPairing Maketh Tua/Kallus]].Tua/Kallus. Becomes an [[HarsherInHindsight aptro]][[HilariousInHindsight nym]] when it turns out Kallus actually ''disliked'' her enough that [[spoiler:he was willing to help assassinate her]].



* ShipsThatPassInTheNight: Sabine and Ahsoka never with each other interacted one-on-one throughout the entire run of the show but the pairing ''exploded'' in popularity following [[spoiler: the last scene of the finale, where the two meet up to search for Ezra.]] Sabine's new, [[ButchLesbian much shorter and masculine]] haircut didn't help matters.

to:

* ShipsThatPassInTheNight: Sabine and Ahsoka never with each other interacted one-on-one throughout the entire run of the show but the pairing ''exploded'' in popularity following [[spoiler: the last scene of the finale, where the two meet up to search for Ezra.]] Sabine's new, [[ButchLesbian much shorter and masculine]] haircut didn't help matters.



* SoOkayItsAverage: Very much so amongst older EU fans, as the Y7 rating (or whatever equivalent overseas) does not really allow for gory violence like in the movies or ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars''. A lot of the flack is directed towards the younger characters (Ezra and Sabine), mostly because there wasn't a lot of CharacterDevelopment due to the episodic nature of the show (barring a few mini-arcs in season 3).

to:

* SoOkayItsAverage: Very much so amongst older EU fans, as the Y7 rating (or whatever equivalent overseas) does not really allow for gory violence like in the movies or ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars''. A lot of the flack is directed towards the younger characters (Ezra and Sabine), mostly because there wasn't a lot of CharacterDevelopment due to the episodic nature of the show (barring a few mini-arcs in season 3).(At least until the third season).

Added: 4614

Removed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
After the removal of some invalid entries on the subpage, the latter was deemed too short on the forum.


* [[BrokenBase/StarWarsRebels Broken Base]]


Added DiffLines:

* BrokenBase:
** Whether or not [[spoiler: Maul's death]] in "Twin Suns" actually works. [[spoiler:Some fans believe it was a fitting end for the character, dying in the arms of his old foe while believing that "the Chosen One" would avenge everything that the Sith had done to him and those he loved -- and possibly what had been done to Obi-Wan, finally making some sort of peace with him. Others felt that his death was a waste and a cop out, making most of his inclusion in ''Rebels,'' or at least its third season, pretty pointless. Still others accept that Maul dying was clearly foreshadowed and inevitable, but wish that he could have gone out with more of a bang than a duel ''that only lasted a few seconds'', especially when his final confrontation with Obi-Wan had been hyped up so much in the marketing. There are also quite a few fans who originally didn't like the battle due to its brevity, but began to appreciate it more after understanding the symbolism and FridgeBrilliance behind it.]] [[note]]Explanation: The exchange breaks down like this. First Darth Maul taunts Obi-Wan while Obi counters everything Maul says to him. Maul gets frustrated, but then realizes that Obi-Wan is protecting someone on the planet. Obi-Wan ignites his saber in response knowing that he can't let Maul leave alive. Obi-Wan takes his first stance with his Saber above his head and his free hand pointing two fingers at Maul. Maul takes a preliminary stance by holding his lightsaber out in front of him and igniting the other end of his saber and them he spins his saber around and holds it behind him with one hand. Finally, Maul switches to the stance he fought Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon with. Obi-Wan, seeing this, switches to his stance that he would fight Darth Vader with on the Death Star. The first stance Obi-Wan took was a common one that he used in his youth while the second was the one he used in his wiser and quieter days. Finally, Obi-Wan switches to Qui-Gon's preferred stance. Maul, seeing this, tries to kill Obi-Wan by stunning him with a strike to the face with the shaft of his lightsaber. This is the same move that let him kill Qui-Gon. Obi-Wan switched to Qui-Gon's stance because he knew that Maul would try the same trick and when Maul goes for it, Obi-Wan slices his saber right down the middle, cutting Maul's blade in half and killing him. Not only did Obi-Wan score poetic justice by defeating Maul with Qui-Gon's stance while also surpassing his master, he also proved to have grown much wiser and stronger while Maul has fallen into stagnancy and despair. For the fans who love the exchange, the amount of detail, thought, and [[CallBack call backs]] included in the scene is what sells it. All of this happens in just a few dozens of seconds. [[https://youtu.be/A-Fx94bdGrQ This video does a good job of explaining it.]] Also, this symbolism and strategizing by Obi-Wan is mirrored in an [[https://youtu.be/HrkFj6iepMs explanation of the scene by Darth Maul's voice actor.]][[/note]]
** The Season 4 episode "A World Between Worlds" is possibly the most divisive episode in the show if not the franchise. [[spoiler:People either love the episode for resolving Ahsoka's ambiguous fate, bringing Palpatine in to the show, and expanding the franchise's lore. Detractors however feel that Ahsoka should've died in her fight against Vader, feeling that bringing her back through such a convoluted method turns her into a CreatorsPet. Detractors also feel that bringing time travel into the mythos will lead to the [[OpeningACanOfClones Can of Clones trope]] and will inevitably result in the franchise's lore rules being broken.]]
** The revelation during the series finale that [[spoiler:Hera and Kanan had a son, Jacen. Some fans were happy that the pair had at least consummated their relationship and that Hera had SomeoneToRememberHimBy, while others disliked how Hera had only told Kanan she loved him at the last minute, and that Jacen looks ''nothing'' like the previous Twi-Lek hybrids we've seen in the ''Star Wars'' canon.]]
*** His very name has set off flame wars, even between Legends fans themselves. Some of whom think it's a nice MythologyGag and others who think it's akin to a slap in the face.
** While some appreciate the storylines and resolution of many of WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars arcs in Rebels, it is common to see the phrase "God, I miss The Clone Wars" in Rebels' scenes uploaded on [=YouTube=]. In general, Rebels' inclusion in the new EU is hotly debated as to whether or not it is inferior to The Clone Wars or if it should be judged by its own merits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evil Is Sexy has been dewicked.


* EvilIsSexy:
** The Grand Inquisitor, thanks to Creator/JasonIsaacs' voice.
** Kallus. His [[EvilSoundsDeep voice]], cunning, and [[HotBloodedSideburns sideburns]] are definitely contributing factors. Some people (including most of the team behind ''Rebels'') also thought he looked attractive after he got beat up in "Zero Hour" (which, mind you, [[spoiler:is after his HeelFaceTurn]]), which lead to the '[=#HotKallus=]' [[MemeticMutation meme]].
** The Seventh Sister is a beautiful, positively deadly villainess who's overly touchy-feel-y with her prey, helped by Creator/SarahMichelleGellar's performance.
** [[spoiler:Darth Maul]] gets to show off his muscular body and battle scars in a ShirtlessScene while fighting multiple Jedi and Inquisitors.
** Thrawn already had fangirls thanks to his ''Legends'' portrayal as a CulturedBadass who was [[AffablyEvil Affably Imperial]]. Adding Lars Mikkelsen's voice is not doing anything to deter this. The mid-season trailer showing him in training clothes that expose his (surprisingly muscular) arms has only added fuel to the fire.
** Arihnda Pryce for her cold demeanor, being modeled after [[Film/IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrystalSkull Colonel]] [[TheBaroness Irina Spalko]], and [[MaleGaze having not-so-disappointing size of racks]] which are accentuated by her rather [[FormFittingWardrobe form fitting]] [[PuttingOnTheReich Imperial Officer Uniform]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ezra lost the crush he had on Sabine, or still has it, but he just stopped being quite so obvious and annoying about it.

to:

** Ezra lost the crush he had on Sabine, or still has it, but he just stopped being quite so obvious and annoying about it. Especially considering that most of the episodes, where he shows some interest in her, are usually in the third and fourth seasons.

Top