Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / OnceUponATimeS4E19Lily

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Of course, such a plot would require, at the very least, Robin to be holding a huge IdiotBall so getting it out of the way is probably for the best.

to:

** Of course, such a plot would require, at the very least, Robin to be holding a huge IdiotBall so getting it out of the way is probably for the best.best.
** One also has to wonder if, InUniverse, Zelena herself realized how lame or impossible such a plot would have been, and so dispensed with it to try something much more direct (and, as stated above, mean).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these tropes likely applies. Which one depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]IntendedAudienceReaction: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these tropes likely applies. Which one depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch {{Manipulative B|astard}}itch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue Villain Sue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these tropes likely applies. Which one depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these tropes likely applies. Which one depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.Author.
** Of course, such a plot would require, at the very least, Robin to be holding a huge IdiotBall so getting it out of the way is probably for the best.

Changed: 658

Removed: 658

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these tropes likely applies.
Which one depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these tropes likely applies. \n Which one depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.

Added: 658

Changed: 1005

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: Which of these applies to Zelena dispensing with her Marian disguise (and possibly continuing the LoveTriangle, playing the helpless DamselInDistress, claiming Regina wanted to MurderTheHypotenuse, or just plain leading Robin on as to her true nature) depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: Which What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the '[[DamselInDistress helpless]]' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit ([[MurderTheHypotenuse or kill]]) her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, one of these applies to Zelena dispensing with her Marian disguise (and possibly continuing the LoveTriangle, playing the helpless DamselInDistress, claiming Regina wanted to MurderTheHypotenuse, or just plain leading Robin on as to her true nature) tropes likely applies.
Which one
depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot[=/=]TheyPlottedAPerfectlyGoodWaste: Which of these applies to Zelena dispensing with her Marian disguise (and possibly continuing the LoveTriangle, playing the helpless DamselInDistress, claiming Regina wanted to MurderTheHypotenuse, or just plain leading Robin on as to her true nature) depends on whether a) you love ManipulativeBitch Zelena being back and think her an awesome villain, or you hate her as a VillainSue and want her gone; and b) you think the second half of the season has been dragged on and padded out long enough with too many characters and plotlines, so dispensing with this (or the LoveTriangle in particular) is good, especially this close to the end...or that if less focus had been given to flashbacks, side characters, and other issues there would have been more time for such a plot--one which would have served as a great distraction to keep Emma and Regina from doing anything to stop Gold and the Author.

Top